May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DI… 0:41
Speaker 6 presented Arkansas’s gender-wage-gap data, estimating a $3.6 billion economic gain from pay equity and noting that the bill would permit wage-discussion without retaliation and align Arkansas with a California model.
[10:02][10:05][10:37][11:07][11:38][12:09][12:40][13:14]
After further public testimony-including Paul Calvert’s objection that the employer-burden shift contradicts traditional justice principles-the committee voted against the measure, resulting in its failure.
[36:55][37:27][37:58][38:30][39:03][50:36]
HB2108 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING WORKERS' COMPENSATION COVERAGE REQUIRED FOR A CONTRACTOR. 52:01
Chair Rep. Bob Johnson explained that HB 2108 would require residential contractors to carry workers’ compensation insurance only when they meet Arkansas eligibility criteria, rather than mandating coverage for all licensees.
[52:03]
With no audience testimony, the committee moved the motion to pass and approved the bill unanimously.
[52:36][52:54]
HB2109 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING FINANCIAL STATEMENTS REQUIRED TO BE SUBMITTED BY A LICENSEE OF THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD. 53:08
Chair Representative Bob Johnson explained that HB2109 would change the financial-statement requirement for contractors earning less than $750,000 a year, shifting CPA work from an audit to a compilation to protect small contractors and CPAs.
[53:09][53:43]
Representative Stephen Meeks asked how many contractors fall below that threshold, and Chair Johnson estimated about 30 licenses per year, noting most small contractors are well under the $750,000 level.
[53:53][54:11][54:16]
Representative Bentley moved to pass the bill and the committee approved it without opposition.
[54:46][54:59]
HB1775 Johnson TO MANDATE THAT THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN A SUICIDE PREVENTION HOTLINE. 55:13
Chair Representative Bob Johnson introduced HB1775, stating Arkansas ranks 10th nationally in suicide rates, lacks an in-state hotline, and that the bill would fund a hotline at $250,000-$500,000 annually with up to $2.3 million available from the health department and related appropriations.
[55:23][55:53][56:25][57:04][57:07][57:29][57:43]
Representative Meeks sought clarification on the fiscal impact, and witnesses including Tyler West explained that the health department already receives federal Garrett Lee Smith funds and would lose $1.4 million if 70 % of calls are not answered in-state, underscoring the need for a local call center.
[56:37][56:56][57:04][57:07][57:29][57:43][57:51][58:00]
HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES WHO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS; AND TO AMEND TH… 1:14:05
Representative Karilyn Brown introduced HB 1186, arguing that mandatory collaborative practice agreements add unnecessary cost, do not improve patient safety, and that advanced practice registered nurses (APRNs) already provide high-quality, cost-effective care supported by national research and organizations such as the National Governors Association and the Institute of Medicine.
[1:14:55][1:15:31][1:16:04][1:16:40][1:17:14]
The committee adopted a motion to limit debate to two minutes per speaker (motion by Speaker 249) and subsequently voted on the bill, with eight yeas and ten nays, causing HB 1186 to fail.
[1:37:05][1:37:10][1:37:17][1:59:20][1:59:38]
HB1160 A. Mayberry TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF A "SPECIALIST SIGN ELECTRICIAN". 2:02:04
After a brief question period, Chair Jeff Wardlaw called for a vote and the committee unanimously approved the bill as amended.
[2:05:33][2:05:58]
HB2177 McCollum TO CLARIFY THE PROPER ADMINISTRATION BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES OF THE FEDERAL REGULATIONS PERTAINING TO POST-ELIGIBILITY TREATMENT OF… 2:06:33
Representative Austin McCollum introduced HB 2177, explaining that it would clarify the Department of Human Services’ administration of federal Medicaid regulations concerning post-eligibility treatment of institutionalized individuals and would protect the state budget.
[2:06:38][2:07:03][2:07:06][2:07:08]
No committee members or public speakers offered questions or opposition, and Chair Wardlaw moved to pass the measure, which was adopted without dissent.
[2:07:17]
HB1953 Collins TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948. 2:08:40
Representative Stephen Meeks presented HB 1953, outlining three major changes: (1) it prevents workers’-comp claims for lost wages when an employee is terminated for cause during transitional work; (2) it bars double payment of medical bills when a settlement overlaps with workers’-comp benefits; and (3) it requires a “major cause” finding for treatment eligibility, while also shifting the “made-whole” provision to favor insurance carriers over injured workers.
[2:08:45][2:09:23][2:09:59][2:10:38][2:11:15][2:11:46][2:12:21][2:12:57]
HB2216 McCollum TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS OF CURRENT AND PROSPECTIVE EMPLOYEES. 2:45:40
Representative Austin McCollum introduced HB 2216 to amend Arkansas law governing social-media accounts of current and prospective employees, arguing the change would clarify permissible employer inquiries on platforms such as Facebook and LinkedIn.
[2:45:59][2:46:18][2:46:23][2:46:29]
No questions or objections were raised, and Chair Wardlaw moved to pass the measure, which was approved unanimously.
[2:46:37]
HB1771 S. Meeks TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS NIGHTTIME ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION ACT. 2:47:31
Representative Stephen Meeks introduced HB 1771, explaining that it would encourage municipalities to replace existing street-lighting fixtures with energy-efficient, downward-directed units to cut electricity costs and reduce light pollution, noting potential savings of up to 50 % for cities like Little Rock.
[2:47:48][2:48:14][2:48:17][2:48:20][2:48:55][2:49:03][2:49:25][2:49:58]
Committee members raised several concerns: Chair Jeff Wardlaw questioned whether the bill created an unfunded mandate for cities; Representative Mary Bentley asked if public safety lighting would be maintained; Bill Phillips of the Arkansas Municipal Power Association testified that many cities are already installing shielded fixtures and saw no need for legislation; and Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson of the Highway Department warned that the bill would impose unenforced lighting-enforcement duties on the department without funding.
[2:50:32][2:51:03][2:51:10][2:52:36][2:52:39][2:52:50][2:53:11][2:57:08][2:57:34][2:58:08][3:00:23][3:00:57][3:01:28]
During the closing, Rep. Meeks moved to pass the bill while Rep. John Payton opposed it, citing the bill’s expansive provisions on light trespass and commercial signage and requesting a no-vote.
[3:05:35][3:05:42][3:05:51][3:06:09][3:06:29]
The chair ruled the motion failed, and the bill did not pass.
[3:06:29]
are recognized thank you mr. chair thank you committee i'm here to present house bill 1021 and if you look at the subtitle you know exactly what i want to do to provide pay equity for women and to amend the wage discrimination laws concerning prohibited conduct and remedies for violations of the wage and discrimination act laws excuse me and so So if I was to begin to talk to you about this bill, because what I want to do is I'm going to walk through this bill, basically point out the highlights, and then I'm going to turn it over to Dr. Estes to provide the importance to the state. And so if we begin on page one, we begin to talk about the definitions of employee and employer. Now, what we want to do is we want to define exactly what employee is not. And the three things that an employee is not is an individual employed by his or her parent, excuse me, or spouse or child, an individual participating in a specialized employment training program conducted by a nonprofit shelter workshop or rehabilitational facility, or an individual employed outside the state of Arkansas. So this bill does not cover any of those employees. However, what we did was, and this was on advice from the Department of Labor, is throughout the bill we're going to show how we're bringing everything in line with what is in Arkansas state law. So the Arkansas civil rights, we use that just as a definition of employer. here. Now we clarified moving down to line 22 on the penalties, excuse me, on penalties for violation. And what we wanted to do is clarify, we're not changing any of the penalties under violation. But what we did do is just for clarification is we stated that this is This is an unclassified misdemeanor. And what that means is it's no greater than a citation. The most, I guess the most identifiable unclassified misdemeanor would be a speeding ticket. So there is no criminal intent on this at all. Moving down to the administration part of line 34, it's just stating that the director for the Department of Labor will be charged with handling everything within the bill. Moving to page three, this begins the crux of the bill. We stated this is a sex-based wage discrimination piece. Now, I worked with Arkansas Family Council because if you saw the initial draft that I turned in, uh the the word sex was uh exchanged for gender what we did was working with family council i moved it back to sex because that is basically what we're talking about male and female i had an article that was written about this bill and stating that i was going to be changing you know the laws to you know do other things but it was outside the scope of the bill and i was It's like, okay, family council, we'll work with you. So sex is back in here. So if you read the initial and you wanted to try to jump on me about that, guess what? You won't get your chance today. All right. Now, moving on, and just in a more serious note, though, we do define what discrimination is in here. And this is just a clarification for stating that an employer shall not do this if shall not do these things. And you can't discriminate based on a substantially if a woman is substantially doing similar work as a man and also when it's viewed on a composite of skills, efforts, and responsibilities. Moving down to line 15. This is where the bill really is the crux of the bill. When an employer can demonstrate these things, we will say that this is not wage-based discrimination. And as you can see, the language stricken, what we did was we just clarified this so the employees and employers will know without a doubt, if they're not doing these things, it is not wage-based discrimination. And these are things that, you know, we do on a daily basis if you're an employer, but just without thinking. So if the compensation differential is based on one or two of these things, then it's not wage-based discrimination. If there's a seniority system, if there's a merit system, a system that measures earnings by the quantity and quality of work. Now, this is an interesting conversation I just had. Is Paul in the room? There's Paul. Paul was like, well, Representative Love, if I'm splitting wood and I do more wood than what a woman can do, are you going to say if I get paid more, is that wage-based discrimination? I said no, because the quantity and the quality of work may be such that he may demand a higher wage. So we're not changing anything in the law that anybody can prove is a bona fide factor of why wages can be different. Moving on to page four, and it just, like I said, it clarifies the system on if someone was to say it was voyage-based, it just clarifies in the law. All right, so actions that can be taken to collect unpaid, and I'm on line eight on page four. Actions that can be taken. We brought this in line with what's in the Arkansas Civil Rights Act. I think yesterday on the floor when Representative Charlie Collins ran a bill, he had to go back and fix this piece. Line two is where he fixed it. You cannot bring a federal action and a state action at the same time. And if that does occur, then one of two things would happen. And this is what it states. It says, however, if an employee recovers any monies under federal law for the same violation, the employee shall return to the employer the lesser of the amount recovered under this section or the amount recovered under federal law. So you cannot use both to recover wages. Moving on down to line 36, this is going to pick up to where the Department of Labor takes over and executing a case if a case is bought. I work with the Arkansas Department of Labor to actually clarify what they will be doing, what they couldn't do. They had some concerns with the initial bill, and so they pretty much said, Representative Love, this will bring us in line with law, with current law. And so pretty much I work with them to change that. But it outlines the procedures and the process. Moving on to page 5, I think a point of note and clarification is that section 2 on line 19, these are the protections that are going to be afforded to women when they do think that they want to bring a case. And this is just basically protecting them from any type of retaliation. And in this, it says an employer shall not discharge an employee or discriminate or retaliate against an employee for an action taken by the employee under this code, except it prohibits an employee from doing these things. So when a woman wants to bring a case like this, we must protect her. We must make sure that she has some protection so that it doesn't produce a chilling effect and that they will not bring cases. And so with that being said, the last piece is just the rules promulgation piece. The Department of Labor said they needed this piece so they can promulgate rules to implement and administer this subchapter of the law. And with that, Mr. Chair, what I would like to do is turn it over to Dr. Estes. That's the highlights of the bill. I will entertain any questions after Dr. Estes does her presentation,
unless you want to open up for questions now. We've already started getting questions, so if you just want to answer questions and let Doc kind of do her presentation through the questions, that would be fine with me. Well,
Thanks for the opportunity to speak with you all today about this bill. I'm just going to give some statistics here, and then we'll be glad to talk about this further. Census data shows that in 2015, median earnings for men in Arkansas were $40,570 compared to $32,003 for women. This is an earnings ratio of 79%, which puts Arkansas 28th out of all states in the District of Columbia in terms of the size of the wage gap. The gap is larger for women of color. Compared to white men's wages in Arkansas, Asian American women are paid 73%, African American women 65%, Native American women 71%, and Hispanic and Latino women 53%. and these figures are for full-time, full-year employed men and women. Analysis by the Institute for Women's Policy Research shows that were comparable men and women paid equitably in Arkansas, this would raise women's pay in Arkansas on average by $5,699 annually. This would result in a 16.7% pay increase for women in Arkansas. What this would mean for poverty in the state is that the rate among women would fall by half, from 8.2 percent to 4 percent. Among employed single mothers, the poverty rate would decline by almost half as well, going from 29.3 percent to 15.8 percent. Such a change would mean Arkansas would move from the fifth highest rate of poverty among women in the nation to 12th. Taken altogether, raising women's pay to equitable levels would result in $3.6 billion returning to Arkansas families for consuming and asset building. Research on the gender gap in pay shows that when all the factors we know are related to wages are taken into account, including occupation type, industry, education level, years of experience, years in a job, work hours, and the list goes on and on, there is still a 10 to 20 percent pay gap that is unexplained by what we would call these productivity factors. Women and their families bear the cost of this unexplained differential. While this differential obviously impacts annual salary, it of course accumulates across the life course. In Arkansas, this differential comes to $350,000 across a 40-year career. In turn, that differential reduces women's social security and other retirement savings, leading women to higher rates of poverty in older age. The current bill amends a previous state bill designed to address shortcomings in the Federal Equal Pay Act, which hasn't been amended since 1963. This bill is modeled after a California law, one that has now been passed in many states. It would mean that Arkansas would join other states in including provisions allowing employees to discuss pay rates without retaliation and to not allow previous rates of pay to affect salary setting. Those provisions would send a message to families in Arkansas that their labor matters, and so too does their economic well-being. Across the country, stronger equal pay laws are associated with more positive well-being among women, and that means more positive outcomes for children and the larger community. Even though the pay gap is invisible, we all bear the cost of it. Arkansas would be a stronger and healthier state were we to adopt the provisions in this bill. Thank you again for the opportunity to speak. Thank you, Mr.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for your presentation, Representative Love. My question is this. We have a wage discrimination law. I mean, it's on page three. Current law says that wage discrimination is prohibited, that no employer shall discriminate in the payment of wages on the basis of sex. So my question is, why do we need this bill? What are the changes that you're actually making to make this current law? stronger because we're already accounting for the possibility of, you know, merit and time and job and all these other factors. Again, that's in current law. I mean, I think you've maybe spelled it out a little clearer. So please help me to understand what is different about this bill. Why is it stronger than what our current law is? Thank you for the question. And representing Meeks, I will say, first of all, it just brings clarification. Number one, there is just clarity in this bill that wasn't in the previous state law. But number two, most importantly, is that in one of the larger changes overall is the burden of proof that the employer has in this bill versus the employee. And when you outline this and you define it in such a way, I believe once the employee brings suit and it's carried out by the Department of Labor, then the employer must say, hey, we fit within these parameters and so there should not be or there was not any discrimination taking place. And so I think the bigger question is where the burden of proof lies. And so that's what makes this a stronger piece of legislation for the state. Representative Love, I got a question Sure My co-chair brought
than the lady? Well, you know what? I was ready for that question Well, here's the thing I don't want to get into the weeds because there may be an issue in which may arise if a man gets paid less than a woman, but I believe that the same laws would apply. The same laws would apply. An employer, whether it's male or female, cannot discriminate based on sex. Representative
Yeah, I was just wondering if you had any statistics that don't deal with medians as was given because I think what I heard was a median comparing full-time workers for females, full-time workers for males, but the problem with comparing medians with full-times is full-times is officially measured as 35 hours or more. So you could be comparing 35 hours of female work to 45-plus hours of male work. So to me, the median statistic doesn't really show me much in inequality. So I'm curious if you have any other types of measurements. I don't with me, but with respect
to that question, right, because that is indeed the case. And as we know, I mean, none of our statistics are perfect. We can't account for everything. And so that one that is full-time, full-year, that's exactly right. It's adult workers in the labor market. There is no occupation in there. We know men and women are in different occupations. It doesn't account for that, right? So in those statistics, when we talk about the median annual earnings, there's a lot that is not covered there. So on the other side, I cited studies that showed even when we control for everything we know that affects wages, including actual hours, years of experience, actual occupation, actual industry, we still end up with a between, and this goes across studies, 10 to 20 percent of unexplained difference, meaning the difference that we see in these models is attributed to sex not to anything else we understand affects productivity so that is why I talked about both of those things and we can cut the data in various ways you know I know in Arkansas in 2011 in the occupation the broad occupational category of computer science and mathematics the pay ratio was 91 percent so women are doing relatively well in that sector at the same time when we look at things like food service, we see that the ratio is about 50 percent, okay? But those numbers don't include these things like work hours or those sorts of things. That's just looking in occupational categories. So there's lots of different ways to look at the issue, and looking with taking all of this into account is the best way we have to do it. And in that way, we still have an unexplained differential. That's what parts of this bill, including, you know, making things more clear, but looking at how wages are set. That's really what this bill is talking about, is trying to move wage setting as much into setting it on what's required in a job versus attached to individual demographic factors.
Yeah, so this is something I've been pretty curious about for a while now as well, the unexplained differential. So some of those other statistics that you mentioned, studies, do you have with you? I can give you the citations.
Thanks. Representative Meeks, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Kind of as a follow-up, so based on those statistics, you believe that, or you seem to believe, that wage discrimination is going on. So with that said, how many lawsuits have been brought in the last few years based on our current law, based on the fact that there probably is wage discrimination going on? Well, at this point in time, I'm not sure how many lawsuits we actually didn't look at this. But, well, no, I'm not going to say we didn't look at that. We've had a lot of women come and testify that they felt like they were being discriminated against, but due to the fact that they were scared that their employer may retaliate, they did not want to pursue the lawsuit. So you have a lot of that going on, Representative Meeks, and I think I have some people sign up to testify to that fact. Representative Ladyman, are
you, Mr. Chair. I just have a question on line, see, I guess this is first page. First page? I think it is. No, page two, sorry. Page two, okay. Page two, line two through six there. What do you mean, you said line two through six? Yeah, on page two. Part D there, however it shall not include. If we're talking about discrimination, I mean, why are you taking these occupations out? Why does that come into
play? here well those are the those were occupations that were exempt and so what we did was we brought it in line with what's in the arkansas civil rights act and so what we're stating is that any employer that with with uh less than you know nine employees they're going to be exempt anyway so we just brought that in line with what's what's already common practice in arkansas
Okay, thank you. Co-Chair Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. Do employees have a legal right to the wages of every other employer? Let me say that again. Well, I mean, how would you know you're being discriminated against if you don't have a
right to the salaries of everyone else in the company? Is that an employee's legal right? Yes, if you go to page 6 under Section 2, Line 19, this is what's going to be covered. Now, this still does not compel an employer to give any salary information regarding employees. But these are the protections that we have. So say, for instance, if an employee, if a couple of employees want to get together and discuss their wages, it gives protections to employees so that they may do so. But it doesn't compel, this law does not compel an employer to turn over and disclose any wage information. So first the employee must be protected so that they can discuss the differentials in wages. And then once that happens, if they feel like they're being discriminated against, then they can begin to proceed in an action. But this does not compel any employer to disclose any information. I believe that's either caught there or I believe that that's where that is captured. Let me look through here. But that's how they would bring a case. Representative Bentley, you're recognized for
somebody from the Department of Labor here to discuss the employer's burden of proof. As an employer myself, I'd like to discuss what we need to do as an employer to prove this. Is Mr. Jones in the room? I've seen him here earlier. I thought I did as well or I wouldn't ask the question. I
in the room, we'll be gathering him up for you. Thank you. All right. Seeing no more questions, I'll go ahead and go to the people speaking for the bill I have find my list here I have Chelsea Miller to speak for the
I'm Neal Matthews. I'm a member of AAUW, that's American Association of University Women, and the League of Women Voters of Arkansas, and I'm a woman, so I want to speak to this bill. I'm going to speak about it personally. my grandmother and great aunt were suffragettes they fought for the right to women to have a vote and my mother when she graduated college the only job open to her was as a school teacher you had to be single and it was a job almost exclusively of young women in fact she was living in a small country county in Texas where she had a cold water flat so she'd go home on the weekends to wash her hair at her parents house where she could have hot water and she had to speak before the school board because they assumed she was going home to a husband and you had to be single at that time. Then after mother married and had four children she didn't work for a while until economic forces forced her back to teach. She was a fabulous teacher and she was able to work then because despite being married they needed teachers and so society changed again. And so here's an opportunity for society to catch up with reality and allow women to earn the same amount as men working in jobs. I'm a feminist, right? I'm a child. I graduated in 67 from high school and 71 in college. And it never occurred to me for one second that I could not apply for jobs and get education the same as any other person, male or female. And so that's been the life that I've lived all this time and it's always a huge shock to run into a barrier where I'm suddenly told I can't do that because I'm a woman. I don't qualify because I'm a woman. I get less pay because I'm a woman. It's time to bring Arkansas into the 21st century and give people what they deserve based on their merits, their work, their qualifications. This is a reasonable bill to clarify and make the way clear for women who are not being treated fairly to be treated fairly. You've heard the statistics. African American women don't reach equality until July. Latino women don't reach equality until November. Come on. It's time to do this. It will help Arkansas. It will move us out of the middle of the pack into a much better position, and that's good for Arkansas. Thank you. Any questions? Representative Hammer,
Correct. I am retired, more or less. Okay. So follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Thank you. So in your experience when you worked, and it sounds like you ran into this issue, and that's why you're here speaking in favor of it today, you did not have recourses under the current federal laws in order to be able to bring suit or to seek justice under the current
federal or state laws? You know, that's a very interesting question. When you are a professional and you decide to sue your employer, it makes it a very, very difficult future. Yes, you may win your case in court, but whether you will be allowed to successfully complete your professional career in that same place is a whole different question. think about if you were working for you know Stevens and you decided to sue how likely are you going to be even if you're successful to go on and continue to work in the financial industry in Little Rock so my profession was in medical research I was a research scientist I saw my boss Betty Sue Masters who had a Ph.D. in biochemistry was promoted, and another faculty member was not promoted. She deserved it on every level. He insisted that she got it because she was a woman. It was a huge battle, and there was tons of political fallout over it. So, yeah, you do have the recourses, but then you have to live with the results of that. I'd like to go to the bottom of the queue, or one
And first of all, I'm all for a level in the playing field. I don't care if you're a man, woman, white, black, whatever, who does the best job and given the opportunity to do it. I just want that out there before I ask this question. But based on what you just said as the argument for this bill, and that is no matter what law we have in place, there's going to be that kind of retaliation, that kind of discrimination. What do you see in the merits of this bill that's going to address and put that kind of situation in check so it's not going to be any different
moving forward with this bill? I think the fact that the bill would exist, employers would look at it and see that there are specific things that they should and should not do, it would give them pause. If you know that you can be held accountable for your actions and that it's very clear and written out, as it is here in Section 2 on this page 6, that you're going to think twice before you cavalierly say, I'm not going to give this person the same amount because she's a woman. She doesn't need it. Forty percent of the families are headed by a single woman here in Arkansas. Let's move those women out of poverty. Let's give those women fair treatment. And let's make employers know that they need to do that. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
coming today. I appreciate your testimony. You stated in your testimony that some things were prohibited for me to do because you're a woman. Could you give me, or you knew of some, could you give some examples to that here in Arkansas? Or because you're a woman, you weren't allowed to
do something. I'd like to hear about that. Well, I grew up in Texas. And so, you know, in Texas, at the time that I was coming out, there was a big women's movement. We were feminists, and we said, we are not going to be denied an opportunity to, for instance, major in physics. At one point, fields like engineering, science, and math were given to men. At the time, going to medical school, it was over... If you were an applicant for medical school and you were a woman, and you were at a disadvantage relative to a man. So they actually put in place those equalization rules that said, no, you've got to be blinded, or you have to bring actually more women into the fields. So, yeah, there's lots of examples from our past, and you're going to hear later from a whole bunch of women that are talking about medical health care. We need to have equal playing field because we all have equal opportunities to bring our particular skill sets and our abilities and our talents to the workplace. Don't handicap us by making us take less money. Representative McCullough, you're
participate in? Well, as you know, even out in California and Silicon Valley, Silicon Valley, my kids keep telling me I say it wrong, Silicon Valley, where they're about as liberal as you can get, there's like a 10% discrepancy of women going into computer science that is not explained by education or anything else. they don't get hired into the jobs companies have to the companies that are formed that are just strictly for women just in order to enrich the field because when you expand to include men and women minorities of any race different ethnicities and so forth you bring in an enrichment to your industry. And by discriminating against women, you're discriminating against half the population. So yeah, there exists problems with women being able to get in, and equal pay
would help. So overwhelmingly, men enter into the computer science and computer engineering studies. So my question is, in Arkansas, what do you see as the educational barrier? Because you mentioned educational job opportunities that women don't have the ability to participate in. I'm asking if you see that today. I think
you have to go all the way back into school where girls are discriminated against in math and STEM classes. There's giant efforts. There's going to be a Girl of Promise program that AAUW works on that young girls in the eighth grade are brought in to listen to women in the fields of STEM in order to encourage them. The discrimination and the turning them away from the field can be so subtle that sometimes you have to have either, you know, I had three brothers. I was, by goodness, I was going to do everything they did. But some girls need more than that. They need encouragement. We don't need to discriminate based on sex. Seeing no further
please. Proper motion, non-debatable. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Ayes have it. Your motion has passed. Representative Love, would you like to reserve any of that time for closing? One minute. Thank you. Mr. Paul Calvert, you recognize to speak against the bill. Mr. Price will keep the time, and if you watch him, he'll give you every minute that passes by. Is there anyone
else signed up to speak against the bill after me? Okay, so I can have it the whole time. One of the things that, first off, that I have a problem with this bill is that employers must prove their innocence. I think that's pretty much in conflict with the idea of justice in our justice system, if you will, that when you're guilty of something, I think you need to be proven guilty, and you don't have any obligation to prove your innocence. The proof of guilt needs to be on the side of the person bringing the charges if you will otherwise this is not a criminal case well actually I guess it sort of is and there's kind of a it's a misdemeanor isn't it I thought you said there's a misdemeanor possible unclassified mr. he would address the committee sorry sorry he's it's his fault I heard an issue I I think it was brought up about the difference in wages between men and women. I think one of the things that we don't often think about is the negotiation factor. I think, statistically speaking, men are much more likely to negotiate their wages and be more aggressive in that regards. And so from a market standpoint, I know people that will go off and buy a car, and they will just offer to pay the car salesman full price. And I think that's just crazy. But they do that way. And I think statistically speaking, you'll see that females are less likely to negotiate than men are. And so I think that's a factor that needs to be considered as well from a market standpoint. If one particular group of people are less likely to negotiate, then they're going to get a worse deal. That's just the way things are. and so the difference could be that you could look at statistics and see that women pay more for cars than men do and we would say well that's discrimination, well no it's not, it's just the fact that we negotiate differently and that's just a fact of life another issue I have with the bill is that employers would, it looks like employers would lose the right to require secrecy about their wages between employees, I think that Employers should have the right to tell their employees that, you know, this is secret information. I think that they can require that as terms of employment. I think that's reasonable. It may be a dumb rule on the part of the employer, but I think employers should have the right to make dumb rules that would require their employees to be secret about their wages. little anecdotal evidence about my father he was an RN he worked at Fort Roots VA hospital he worked in the psych ward and he was kind of an oddball among nurses he was a man and the other female nurses there liked that about him because on a on a psych ward with Behind locked doors, we had a lot of the people who were there were men, and some of them were big guys, and they liked having my dad there because him being a man made it safer for everybody because some of these guys were pretty hard cases. They would fight sometimes, but him being a man I think would calm them down. He didn't get paid extra for being a man, but I think it should have been legal for his employer to pay him extra for that added security that you can't really necessarily account for a whole lot, but it's worth something, and I think it would have been reasonable for his employer to pay extra for that, and it's just natural psychology on some level, but it's just the difference between males and females, and he wasn't a big man. He's not big like me. He was 5'8 or 9, and so he wasn't all that large, but just being male, I think, helped him in that regard and helped the whole floor and it was good and the female nurses around there liked him and he had a good relationship with him I think. One other thing, a couple different things. There was some testimony that there were companies developed only for women. I think that would be illegal for some of these technology positions, I don't know, but it sounds like it would be illegal under this, maybe not under this legislation, but under some of its related. One other thing, there were some testimony made about how girls are kind of maybe herded into different fields of work that are less profitable. And I think it's unfair to say that they're herded that way. I think God made
men and differently and so Mr. Coward that's the time your testimony I'm sorry that's all the time we have we have a Caroline Morgan speak for the bill you have four minutes Miss Caroline you want to introduce yourself for the committee and recognized for
I'm a woman but that's about the only qualifications I have to speak with y'all today so thank you so much for listening again my name is Caroline Morgan and I'm an Arkansas native and a mom and I'm speaking very briefly in favor of House Bill 1021 my 18 year old daughter is about to graduate from Central High School. I am for this bill because I want clarification for my daughter, Jessica, all daughters, and all women that they need to receive equal pay for equal work and to be able to discuss and negotiate any discrepancies without retaliation. So I would appreciate if they would be approved. Thank you. any questions from the committee see you none thank you for
your testimony sure thank you anyone else in the audience speak for the bill see you none representative love you're recognized for your bill how many minutes
do i have you have about four thank you mr chair committee thank you all for just allowing me to bring this as you can see there there are many people that this bill will impact Not only women, it impacts families. And I want to address just a couple of things. When we talked about the disclosure of salary information, it is covered on page 6, line 31. This section does not create an obligation to disclose salaries or wages. That is a protection in the bill for the employer. Number two, I believe our friend Paul talked about the employer burden in his testimony. No, these states have equal pay protection laws and the burden is on the employer. California, Colorado, Illinois, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New Jersey, Vermont, New York, Massachusetts, the District of Columbia, Iowa, Washington, and West Virginia all have those burdens on the employer. So we were just catching up with these other states. Last but not least, I noticed Paul did talk about kind of a bona fide issue with his dad. And the thing about it is this does not, this law does not prohibit any bona fide factors from being incorporated into wage discrimination. And it says this on page 3, page 3, lines 23. A bona fide factor other than sex, including without limitation, education, training, experience, ability, differences in duty, which that would probably be qualified as a difference in duties, and services performed, and differences in the ability in the shift or time of the day worked. These are all protections that are in this bill. So when you want to factor in these factors, take into account these factors, they're already clarified in this bill. And so I would say I would ask this committee to very carefully look. I did amend this bill in the last two or three days. And so I think some of the frustrations came or some of the pause came when the bill was initially sent. But I've taken into account what the Arkansas State Chamber sent to me. I've taken into account what the Arkansas Department of Labor has sent to me. I've taken into account the issues that Family Council had. I have worked with a lot of different people, including the AAUW, on this bill to try to address everyone's concerns. And so I will ask for a favorable vote on House Bill 1021. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I am closed. What's the pleasure of the committee?
Well, first of all, I'll say I am for the bill. I was one of six women in my dental class back when the other lady talked. I'm really old, so. But because I think that there are groups of women, and particularly minority women who don't do a good job of advocating for themselves. But the gentleman who testified against it does have a good point, and I want this to be a message to all the women here and to take it home to all your daughters. I'm a huge fan of Sheryl Sandberg's Lean In book, and I hope you've all read it, because I do think it's a good point that women do not advocate for themselves well enough. she says you know if a guy looks at a job posting and he goes oh well you know I'm 90% qualified for that I'm going to apply I mean I'm 60% qualified for that I'm going to apply but the woman looks at it and she goes oh well I'm not 100% qualified so I'm not even going to apply for that job so there is a difference in how men and women perceive jobs in the workplace but I do think there are a good number of women, particularly poor women and minority women, who aren't in a position to advocate for themselves, and I think this bill helps do that for
for us. This bill kind of makes it really difficult for an employer for the fact that on page three you have all these bona fide factors that you would have to keep a record-keeping on and write those factors in order to justify your pay scale and then when you come down to line 35 these factors do not apply if the employee can demonstrate an alternative business practice where all you have to do is do a different rating on the factors that you have done so I I think it would be an impossible situation for keeping with all of these records, rating them, and then they would work against you. So thank you. Thank you for your
Committee, I just want to give you a little bit of my life experience, you know, running several businesses. Number one, growing up in my dad's car lot, we had a lady salesperson that was just top-notch, And she got paid the same as the men, one of the best salespeople we ever had. In my Chevrolet dealership in Hebrew Springs, I had a lady that was a general manager for eight or ten years. I didn't research that. I just decided to share that with you. But it was eight or ten years that she was general manager there. The man that replaced her got paid the same as she did. However, in my auto auction, I have five auctioneers employed. and haven't had any women ask for that job. But to give you an example of how hard it is to determine pay disparity, I mean I have five auctioneers employed and not two of the five get the same pay. They all do the identical same job, same amount of time, almost always a very near same number of cars. And some of the ones that get paid the most have been there the shortest time. I'm one of the auctioneers. My son is one of the auctioneers, and we don't get paid the same. He actually gets more than I do. The bottom line is, I mean, there are some jobs that are negotiated. There are some jobs where you can't put a pencil to determining why there is a pay disparity. And then there are others that are very simple to define. I think this bill is unnecessary, but I also think it's unenforceable, and I'm voting against it. Any further discussion
from the committee? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. Your bill has failed, Representative Love. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Thank you. Representative Carolyn Brown. Is she in the room? She was in the room. I guess we'll pass over it. Representative Meeks. we'll go to representative johnson you want to run house bill 1775 right that'd be fine
very much 2108 was both of these bills were brought to me by the contractor's license board and the second one's a follow-up of a CPA bill this bill just simply says last time they changed the law they said residential home builders had to have workers comp insurance and that's fine unless you don't meet the qualifications under Arkansas law to have workers comp insurance so they were having to get it when they didn't even meet the qualifications to have it and this just changed it to where if they qualified to have workman's comp insurance under Arkansas law, then they must have it for their contractor's residential license. If they don't, then they still get their contractor's residential license. And I'd answer any questions if I could, but I think
it's pretty straightforward. Any questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, what's the pleasure of the committee? Got a motion to do pass. Representative Ladyman, any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed, Congratulations,
your bill passed. House Bill 21-09. Thank you, Chairman. 21-09 is basically really a CPA bill. We passed a couple CPA bills earlier, and one of them was to require CPAs to have a review if they do any sort of a test function. Well, one of our major test functions for small CPAs is doing contractor's license review on the balance sheet of small contractors. And what this bill does is it moves that from a review for small contractors. If you do a job less than $750,000 a year, then it moves that to where it's only a compilation. So this protects the small contractors and the small CPAs. The only reason that I spoke for the bill and was willing to co-sponsor it was that I knew this was coming behind it. This is a sister bill that protects the CPA and contractors behind that. So I'd be happy to answer any questions.
Representative makes you have a question thank you on page two line one it it actually starts on and on page one but it says if it's less than seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars for a single project do we know how many of those fall in that category either less than or if you if you don't
know that number maybe more than I do 30 contractors license a year I have one that will fall will not fall within that $750,000 group. So you're talking about most small contractors are not going to do a $750,000 job. That's a big contractor. So, yeah, it protects the little contractor guy, you know, the strip mall builder, that sort of thing. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions from the committee?
Seeing not anyone in the audience speak for or against the bill. What's the pleasure, committee? Got a motion to do passed. Representative Bentley. And any discussion on that motion? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, congratulations. Your bill had passed. You run
Okay. Thank you, Chair. Thank you, committee. This bill, and I was hoping the health department would be here there down at the Senate end playing with fluoride. I understand. So I just talked to Dr. Smith a few minutes ago. This bill is mandating an in-state suicide hotline. I don't know if you saw in the paper that Arkansas has now hit number 10 per capita. We're one of two states that don't have an in-state hotline. The other one is Wyoming, who was number one. So when this was brought to me by the Veterans Mental Health Council and the Veterans Coalition, I called Dr. Smith and said, what do you think about this? He said, please run it. I would appreciate it. We need it. I just can't solicit you to run a bill. And so he was happy that I did it. And I have an impact statement. And I don't know if 1705 is ever going to run it. $1,705 was moving money from the health department to DHS, but Representative Lemons had agreed to leave whatever we need to run this bill. So it's $250,000 to $500,000 a year. But there's like $2.3 million that would be available to use in this if needed, but it won't be. And I've got some experts with me, so maybe if we have questions, they can answer them. Representative Meeks, you're
recognized for a question. Thank you. Just for clarification, the fiscal impact says $250,000 to $500,000. Is that the initial startup cost, or is that what they figure yearly that they're going to need to be able to operate this thing? Because I don't, for one, don't want to get this thing started and then not have the funds to continue it in the foreseeable future.
got it going. He could answer this better. The Department of Health's Office of Injury Prevention has already started this process. Currently they receive about $750,000 in federal money through the Garrett Lee Smith Act for youth suicide prevention. There's going to be another $450,000 available next year. Arkansas will be disqualified for all of that money if we do not answer at least 70% of these national suicide prevention lifeline calls in Arkansas. So the health department's already been working on this with some trauma system carryover money and some Garrett Lee Smith money. So they've already started this process. So tell me how
the process works. When somebody calls into the National Suicide Prevention Hotline and they see that this call is from Arkansas, it would get routed to our call center versus
the call center out of state? Firstly, it would come to Arkansas. If there is an operator available, then yes, it would be answered in Arkansas and optimally that would happen 100% of the time because those in Arkansas, no Arkansas resources. Currently, calls are being routed as far as Boston. Well, if I call Boston and I've got my brother who is in an actively suicidal crisis, Boston doesn't know where to send me. Boston doesn't know what resources are available here in Arkansas. So, yes, the way the Lifeline Network works is that the calls are routed to the home state first. Representative McCullough, did you have a question?
Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So if currently an individual in Arkansas calls, it could go, to your example, to Boston, Austin, Boston, wherever. Austin, Boston, Memphis are
they know where to send that individual? If it's suicide prevention, shouldn't they have whatever route is possible to prevent suicide? Well, they can de-escalate over the
phone, of course, But they don't know the resources that are available in Neenah, Arkansas, or in Russellville, Arkansas. And because there are workforce changes in those different areas, it's hard to keep up with that. If they are a veteran, if they call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline and Press 1, then they do have those resources, obviously, through the VA here in
was late. Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm kind of like Representative McCollum, I can't imagine why we couldn't inform them of what resources are available, why they wouldn't have that on a computer. If you had an in-state hotline, I mean, they wouldn't just have the knowledge in their head, they'd have to have it, you know, through technology in front of them on a computer or something when
they took that call. Right. Currently the network, the National Suicide Prevention Network is built as just a network of call centers. And because of change that happened throughout the state, the network, that would just be nearly impossible for them to keep up with all of the mental health resources in all 50 states with 159 of all of their call centers, none of which being in Arkansas. But again, going back to the issue, we're going to lose $1.4 million in federal suicide prevention money if we don't answer 70% of these calls in Arkansas. If I could
have a follow-up. Thank you. So where is this hotline going to be housed, and is that expense calculated in this fiscal impact? Are we going to be renting a building or building a building or buying a building or what? We're going to leave that
the building, but to run the program. not the building but to run the program whether they're going to outsource it do themselves it's the cost of running the the program the in line and you know we went from 16th to 10th like I said and also you're going to have training for these people and that's going to be localized training not training in Texas Boston Tennessee somewhere else well it may be if we outsource it you're still going to be trained in in Arkansas places to go and like I said the health department wants this and has the money to do it we'll give you a
lead way okay so if we're going to give the health department the opportunity to outsource this I mean how do we know where that outsourcing is going to be located it's mandated to be in state okay thank you thank you mr. chair thank you any further questions from
at the health department my understanding is they have it right now i mean they they they have funds for uh trauma major health right and this being one of them for health crisis trauma crisis different things and so they have one 2.3 million that that they could use and they're going to use part of that to run this
away from other trauma programs well when i called dr smith i said do you want me to do this and he said yes please and i just talked to him down at the senate end going in to talk about fluoride and he was going to try to get down here before uh we ran this bill but he is very much on board with this and very appreciate it that we would try to get this done anything it's a necessity
currently I have not talked to the governor's office about this I've just talked to the veteran some of the veterans people that work there the governor's office they like it but I think they already have the money in their budget the health department does it's already budget to the health
department I got a follow-up and I have to ask this because I drilled a committee member other day and state agencies on the same line anytime personally that I've ran a bill that costs money I've had an appropriation that followed that bill and I've went and followed up all the way through to make sure that it was within the governor's budget within the budget of rsa because without that assurance representative johnson you when rsa is decided in the next two weeks if if you're you pass this bill you could possibly be passing an unfunded mandate to the health department without without it being in the rsa of the governor so that's concerning
to me okay as a member 1705 is appropriations bill by representative lemons and it's $2.3 million and he's co-sponsored on this bill and he's agreed to amend his bill to make sure the health department has the money to run this. Has that been done yet? I don't know if he's amended it yet or not, but he will. Any further questions from the committee?
want to speak again I just like to make the point I want to thank Representative Johnson and the members of this committee for making suicide a priority this legislative session every year Arkansas loses 571 Arkansans to suicide that's more than motor vehicle accidents That's more than twice the homicides in Arkansas. In the last five years, that number has risen almost 30%. And since we have not been answering calls in Arkansas from the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline, during that one-year period of time, Arkansas has gone from number 16 to number 10. So we believe that a call center is the front line. We believe we can defer costs from the trauma system and keep people out of the ER and out of our jails.
Good morning. I'm Tanya Phillips. I am with the Arkansas Suicide Prevention Network. I have been with them. I helped co-found that in 2009 when there was a functional operational hotline in the state of Arkansas. We were much lower ranked, as you've heard. We are now 10th in the nation, and this has been deemed a public health crisis. We have multiple organizations that are on board with this bill. We've got the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, the Arkansas Association of Chiefs of Police, as they see this as a public safety crisis, Arkansas Psychological Association, Arkansas Suicide Prevention Council, which is the governor's council that was created by House Bill 1887, The Arkansas Suicide Prevention Network, the Arkansas Veterans Coalition, RVETS, Central Arkansas Veterans Mental Health Council, and the Suicide Prevention Allies. We also have 13 co-sponsors and sponsors, excuse me, sponsors and co-sponsors. We have Republicans, Democrats, and also a few veterans that are sponsoring or co-sponsoring this bill. Suicide is two and a half times more likely to be the way of death than homicide. We see homicide in the news every day. We never talk about suicide. But in Arkansas, you are twice as likely to die by suicide than homicide. So I just would like to emphasize the importance of this call center. Thank you. It's okay.
Thank you for your testimony. Taylor LeBrew? LeBow? All these people members are signed up to speak for the bill. I have no one signed up to speak against the bill. Mr. Taylor, you'll recognize me. Introduce yourself
and present your testimony. My name is Taylor LeBell. I'm founder of the Veterans Mental Health Council of Central Arkansas. And I would just like to thank the committee and the chair for hearing us today. This is a very important issue to the veterans in Arkansas because this is the line that answers the phone calls for our family members and not just for veterans. And since there's no one speaking against this today, I actually would like to not take up any more of your time today. I know you're very busy, so you
all have a great day. Thanks. And he's also my stepson. He's a veteran of Afghanistan War, 82nd Airborne. Used to like to jump out of planes. You recognize the close for your bill, having no one else signed up. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is important to our Cansons. It's important to youth. I don't know if you've seen the news that the Garland County paper, Hot Springs paper, whatever it's called, ran on teen suicides. Veteran suicide is high. Just suicide in general is too high. This is important to Arkansas families, and I think it should be important to us, and I'd appreciate a good vote. Thank you, committee. Thank you, Chair. It's a pleasure, committee.
Mr. Chair. Just real quick, I think this is a good bill. I think the concern about it being paid for, I'm trusting Representative Johnson and Representative Lemons to get this all cleared out by the time we do have a short time to try to get these bills both passed through the House and through the Senate. And so I'm going to vote for this this morning, and I hope the other members will. And then, like I said, hopefully we can get any questions on the funding cleared up by the time it gets to the House floor tomorrow.
Representative Boyd, you recognize? I just wanted a little clarification because it looks like, I mean, I realize we're in discussion here, but House Bill 1705 is an appropriation for DHS, not the Department of Health. It's
Representative Johnson, you not being a member of the committee, I can't allow you in the discussion. I'm sorry. Representative Bentley, you're recognized for discussion. I appreciate him bringing this
Meeks, you're recognized for further discussion. Yeah, thank you. Since Representative Johnson is not on the committee, I'll go ahead. 1705 just says it does mention $2.3 million, and it's got special language. It says Suicide Prevention, Department of Human Services shall promulgate rules and regulations for the operation of a statewide comprehensive plan for suicide. So what the bill does is what has been said. So thank you. Thank
you, and thank you for alleviating my concerns of having a method of paying for this. I just hate passing bills that put a mandate on an agency or a county or city that we don't allude funding to as well. Seeing no further discussion, all those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed. No.
Representative Brown, are you ready to run 1186? And I think there's an amendment. Am I right? We'll take up the amendment first, representative. So if you would, explain your amendment first. And the amendment's on the tablet for the committee. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is Stephen here?
If he in here would do McCulloch next. I can't, I'm not worried about that. McCulloch next and then Stephen. and then we'll go to Collins and then Mayberry. I'll stay as long as that takes. Eric, can I present
the amendments. It was done in response to the committee's concern to provide for 3,600 hours for an advanced practice nurse graduate to practice under a collaborative practice agreement under the supervision of either a physician or an APRN. and be classified as an advanced practice, a qualified advanced practice registered nurse.
Am I looking at the right amendment? No, ma'am. I think it's amendment JMB 460. This amendment amends page 3, line 28, practice experience under supervision of A, a physician, B, an advanced practice nurse who has three more years practice. Correct. That's what I was referring
because I've already took the motion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm reading the amendment real quick here, and it would seem that this bill pertains to allowing an advanced practice nurse to come out from under the collaborative agreement. It requires some experience, and now this amendment takes it that that experience does not have to be under a physician. That is correct. Okay. Well, I'm going to vote against the amendment.
You're welcome to vote any way you want to, Representative Payton. All those in favor of the amendment say aye. All those opposed? The ayes have it. Your amendment is passed. you're recognized to
present. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Sharon Stevenson. I am a certified pediatric nurse practitioner and clinical instructor, clinical faculty in the College of Nursing at one of our fine universities here in the state. I am not here as a representative of my employer. Thank you, Mr. Chair. And as
this bill has not run yet, I think it's very important for us to realize that all of Section 1 is do not codify. and everything in Section 1 is the result of an interim study proposal. Advanced practice registered nurses are nationally certified in practice in all 50 states and 21 states authorize advanced practice registered nurses to have full practice authority that includes full prescriptive authority without supervision. Nearly 50 years of research consistently support the high quality and cost-effectiveness of advanced practice registered nurses. Since the 1960s, studies have found no difference in health outcomes, including patient health status, number of prescriptions written, return visits requested, or referral to other providers of care delivered by advanced practice registered nurses or physicians. Collaborative practice agreements do not add patient safety or added value to the health care system, but add to the cost of care for the consumer. Negative impacts of mandatory collaborative practice agreements include, without limitation, potential interruption or closing of an advanced practice registered nurse-operated clinic due to a loss of a collaborative practice physician. Significant added cost to overhead of the practice due to higher fees charged by many collaborative physicians. Added paperwork for the advanced practice registered nurse and the physician, which adds to the cost of care. Decreased health care access by adding a barrier for advanced practice registered nurses who would like to establish a new clinic, and it inhibits the establishment of new health care access points in rural and medically underserved areas of the state, and acts as a disincentive to remain in the state to practice for new graduates of Arkansas advanced practice registered nurse programs. The following major groups and organizations support full practice authority for advanced practice registered nurses. The National Governors Association, the Institute of Medicine, which I'd like to point out, is part of the National Academy of Sciences, Medicine, and Engineering. the American Association of Retired Persons, and the Federal Trade Commission. The state of Arkansas should modernize scope of practice laws for advanced practice registered nurses by removing the mandatory collaborative practice agreement for qualified advanced practice registered nurses. It is the intent of the General Assembly to increase patient access to health care, reduce health care costs, and promote efficient and timely health care in the state of Arkansas, all, and authorize qualified advanced practice registered nurses to have full practice authority without a collaborative practice agreement, and I'll be glad to take questions.
I have a, any questions from the committee? Seeing none, we'll move on to the audience. We have a large list to speak for and against the bill. Just if you guys would, we'll go ahead and move along. And do you have something to add to
Ms. Brown's testimony while you're there? Yes, please. Go ahead. Yes, I know that this bill and the collaborative practice agreement in general has been a tension that has been among everyone who's been involved. I'd like to say, though, that before we move into lots of testimony, I wanted to show you that this is a copy of the collaborative practice agreement that one of the examples that's been pulled from the Arkansas State Board of Nursing. This document is really a formal piece of paper that is signed between an advanced practice registered nurse and a physician, and it basically is a mandatory document, a mandatory piece of paper. This does not tell anyone that I am or any APRN has been educated and certified nationally and licensed by the state of Arkansas to manage the care of patients that we see. If this paper went away, if it's retired, then we continue to work and practice under our scope of practice. This document, if it is retired, does not mean that we will not continue to collaborate as needed for our patients. and that we're not practicing, it does mean that we continue to practice as APRNs as we are educated and certified and licensed by the state of Arkansas.
APRNs and physicians? What this means is that we as APRNs will continue to collaborate on behalf of our patients. This doesn't change our scope of practice. This basically is just a piece of paper, a signed document. If it goes away, we continue to serve the patients under the scope of our practice, under our certification and our licensure, how we've been trained. When we need to refer a patient to a physician, then we continue to do that. That does not change at all. That's a part of patient care. When we are collaborating, we don't need a piece of paper to say that we collaborate. When we signed this, I signed, this document for me was updated in 2014, 2015. It was signed, sent to the board as required, and it's never been brought up again. We continue to practice whether this paper is there or not. Follow up, Mr. Chair.
you have your own clinic, and where would you practice at? My practice hasn't changed. However, for those who have, for instance, I'll give an example. for those patients, in fact, for those APRNs who have completed their documentation and their requirements, then they will practice, we hope that they will practice in their hometowns. where there are areas that are underserved and have no other provider, then we are hoping that those practitioners will continue to stay and serve in the area that they lived.
a question? Thank you Mr. Chair. Going back to Representative Henderson's original question the difference between family practice physicians and nurse practitioners are there things that a family practice physician can do that a registered nurse practitioner cannot form of colonoscopies castings can you name some of those things that specifically that physicians can do that
that nurse practitioners cannot? And it depends, obviously, on the area of specialty and the area that the practitioner has been educated and certified, that population of patients. Practitioners are in an area to, are working in an area or a practice in an area that is where they have been trained to perform diagnostics, testing, only that what they've been certified and what they have been educated and trained to do. They do not practice outside of what they have been trained to do. Representative Meeks do you still have a question? Representative Hammer? Thank you
that you operate under one or you have in the past I'm just curious as to the requirements of what the doctor is expected to do in the reviewing of the charts can you speak to that and also as to how much that either helps hinders
is it a real good quality measure to use or not, would you speak to that, please? Yes, as I understand your question, the collaborative practice agreement in this document, it does not speak to, it primarily speaks to the prescriptive authority. The prescribing of the, it provides guidelines to the medications that APRNs have been allowed through our licensure and through the board to prescribe. And I'm sorry, what was your question again? Did I answer that? Yes, ma'am. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. If I understood you're right,
really the main focus of the collaborative agreement is to make sure that the scripts that are being written by the APRN is being monitored. So if APRN nurses are already prescribing to the PDMP to make sure that they are not over-prescribing, do you think that the 3,600 hours speaks to everything else as far as the quality of an APRN being able to
do his or her duty out there on her own? Yes, and as a matter of fact, the 3,600 hours, it really, by the national certification, it doesn't provide, this would be an extra, an added confirmation that the APRN is prepared or qualified to practice without that binding formal document. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Seeing no further questions, we'll move on to the
My name is Caleb Dixon, I want to thank the chairman in the house for listening to us today. I'm a second-year resident at Jonesboro, Arkansas at one of UAMS's family medicine residencies there, born and raised in Stuttgart, went to school in Conway, med school in Little Rock, been within the state throughout my education. I just want to give you a little bit of insight from my perspective about the differences in education between physicians within the state and other providers in general. eight years of higher education, be that undergrad in medical school, to get a basis of knowledge and thousands and thousands of patient encounters before we ever get our degree, that's followed by residency training, which I feel like sets our degree apart from any other degree out there. And for so long, physicians have been the cornerstone and responsible for the care of Arkansans and patients nationwide, and I think it's an honor to have that privilege, and I think that things were set up in a way to provide the best patient care, to prevent bad outcome, and to treat and diagnose over a long period of time, and the physician's always been the cornerstone. So once we get to that residency training, which I feel like sets us apart from other providers, I know you all have heard the hours and the hours that are different amongst the different providers, but you've heard the 20,000 hours, and I think some insight into what we do in that 20,000 hours and how that's managed may connect a few dots, and we're talking over or around 2,000 patient visits in our outpatient clinic in three years after we've already received our degree. These are not patient visits in which I go in, treat a patient, and that's the end of the encounter. I diagnose, I treat, and then I collaborate with an attending physician that makes every one of those patient encounters an educational opportunity, over a thousand inpatient encounters in the hospital. And throughout our residency program, we have the luxury of rotating with specialists. So if I want to learn gastroenterology, I don't go to a family medicine physician to learn that. I go to a GI doctor to learn that, or pulmonology, I go to a pulmonologist to learn those skills. And I feel like all of that together creates well-rounded family physicians within our state. We have a lot of ill patients in our state, and unfortunately those ill patients are in these areas of need. When we place physicians there, we need physicians that are able to provide a wide scope of care to these patients. When they walk in, when they have an interaction with the physician, we need to offer them every service that we can in order to be efficient and thorough in their care, and I feel like physicians are trained to do that throughout med school and the residency program so that's why I feel like physicians are the cornerstone for treatment of patients within the state and I feel like that's kind of where the buck needs to stop because it's an honor to me to have that privilege and I think our training reflects that on one last note yesterday matched was match day 3300 family or primary care positions in the nation 96% of those were filled there's interest in family medicine by physicians right now like there's never been that only leaves 141 spots left that will likely be filled in the next three days the interest is out there we need well-trained physicians in these areas and I feel like physicians within the state are best served to do that so anybody has any questions I'll be glad to
sorry. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You didn't understand that on this bill, it allows the nurse practitioner only to practice up to their level of scope of practice. Is that correct? Yes,
I do understand that, but that extra training and the amendments that were made, I feel like the physician's training are under these specialists that can provide us the best knowledge in every field. That way, when we step out in the field, we have, you know, the knowledge of a GI doctor, not a family physician. And the knowledge of a pulmonologist, not just a family physician. So I think the scope of a family physician within the state is so broad due to our rigorous training. It sets our education apart from the other degrees at hand here.
Follow up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized for a quick one. Do you plan on going back to Stuttgart, which is a medically underserved area, as in your intent upon graduation to go back to Stuttgart and establish a practice or
to be in a practice? I haven't decided yet. I'm still exploring my options. I can tell you, though, that the rural practice program and loan forgiveness programs are programs that are working within our state in order to get physicians back to these areas. I work with multiple residents right now that are in their third year of residency who are taking advantage of those programs and they're going to these medically underserved areas within
the state. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you. Seeing no questions, thank you, Doc, for your testimony. Thank you. We have Teresa Whited. I hope I pronounced that right. You did. Thank you. If you would introduce yourself for
the committee and you're recognized to share your testimony. Hi, thank you guys for your time. My name is Teresa Whited. I am the director of the master's education program at a large university that educates nurse practitioners within our state in a multitude of clinical specialties, such as family practice, pediatrics primary and acute care, adult Gero primary and acute care, women's health, and family psych mental health. I'm here as president-elect of Arkansas NAPNAP, and I'm also a practicing MP with more than 14 years of experience in both specialty and primary care. I do want to say that I'm not here representing my university. I'm representing myself as an individual. House Bill 1186 is a bill that provides the option to transition for removal of collaborative practice agreement after 3,600 hours with a collaborative practice agreement in place. This will also increase access to care and remove antiquated barriers to MP practice. There is no evidence, I repeat, no evidence that shows that collaborative practice agreements protect the public or promote collaboration in any way. I've been practicing as an MP for over 14 years, and I can tell you that my collaborative practice agreement has never driven me, has never been the driving force to collaborate with other providers within my scope. Appropriate patient care is what drives all providers, MPs and physicians, to collaborate with other professionals. I've cared for a multitude of patients with very complex needs, including congenital heart disease patients and heart transplant patients. And I've collaborated with physicians, other nurse practitioners, physical therapists, speech therapists, and even surgeons to meet their needs. Never once has that been guided by my collaborative practice. Removal of my collaborative practice agreement will not change this, but only will get rid of an unnecessary piece of paperwork. As you've been told before, collaborative practice agreements can be extremely costly, with fees charging between $1,000 to $10,000 a year. This virtually makes it impossible for practices such as those in rural Arkansas that we need desperately to sustain the overhead so high for a simple document. Additionally, collaborative practice agreements do not require the physician to be present or even see the patient in any way. Therefore, they essentially only represent a piece of paper, and therefore no patient safety has been found to be associated with these. Collaborative practice agreements and other restrictions discourage our graduates here in Arkansas from remaining in Arkansas and it makes it difficult to recruit nurse practitioners from out of our state. As Representative Brown was saying, there are approximately 22 states plus the District of Columbia who now have passed full prescriptive authority. In practice states that are similar to Arkansas, rural states. They have shown an increase in licensure of nurse practitioners by 30 to 83 percent. So therefore, they are making a difference in those states to increase access to care. If we want to meet the health care needs of Arkansas, we need to remove unnecessary barriers that are forcing, and I said forcing, our graduates out of our state. Many MPs out at universities across our state are educated in the rural setting and wish to stay there within their home communities. Education was brought up by the last person, and I do want to clarify some things. Nurse practitioners, they have their education beginning at the undergraduate level in a BSN program and then go on to specialize in their population foci in their master's or DNP programs. Most DNPs have practiced as an RN, and most universities require around 2,000 to 4,000 hours practicing as an RN prior to entering clinicals for their very specialized population foci. So across the continuation of education, MPs often come out of their education with over 8,000 direct patient contact hours. And it is absolutely required by our certifying bodies that in our master's or our doctorate education that we have at least 1,000 direct patient care hours. Additionally, our graduates are being educated into all types of specialty care and seeing those providers such as pulmonologists, cardiologists, and others. They're not just educated under family practice. Studies have shown that MPs are more likely to practice in rural settings, and a favorable practice environment for MPs were associated with practitioner-to-population ratios that are significantly higher than the national average. As was stated before, multiple organizations at the national and state levels support removal of barriers to MP practice, so I'm asking that you support House Bill 1186 to allow a transition process for removal of collaborative practice agreements within the state of Arkansas. Again, the 3,600 hours was asked for by members of this committee, and we are therefore trying to meet the needs of Arkansas. I'm happy to answer any
That's a proper motion. that's two minutes per person committee not a certain minutes per side all those in favor say aye all those opposed eyes have it mr. price will keep the time that two minutes will include questions as well mr. hammer
you're recognized for a question one of the earlier presenters made a comment about how that they had sufficient amount of training but also implied that whenever something occurred that was outside of their comfort level that they sought expertise outside Is that not the truth for APRNs that you would be responsible without the collaborative agreement that the liability rests on you? And if you're inside an area that's out of your comfort zone, you would be required to seek guidance outside of yourself. Is that not the same scenario?
That is absolutely true. If it is outside my scope of practice, I don't do surgery as an example. So therefore, if I have a patient who needs surgery, I'm absolutely going to refer outside of my scope of practice. and the liability does rest with me. Whether this piece of paper, whether the collaborative practice agreement is in place or not, the liability rests with me. I have my own liability insurance, and I am not afraid at all, nor will I be afraid if I have my collaborative practice go away to refer outside of my
Ferguson, you recognize for a question? I have a question because this is one of my biggest complaints that I see with APRNs, that they circumvent the collaborating physician and refer straight to specialist instead of referring to their collaborating physician first if they have an issue. Do you refer to your collaborating physician first?
asking, do you always do that and get the physician's opinion first before you send to a specialist? I do not always do that because sometimes my collaborating physician
does not want me to refer to them. I've had physicians say, no, you just take care of that and go ahead and refer them out because that's what I would do. But you talk to him first? Most of the time, yes. That's not been my experience.
that name sounds so familiar. looks familiar too by the way well I apologize for the looks portion of that thank you Mr. Chairman and the members of the committee I'm Dr. Tommy Wagner president of the Academy of Family Physicians to Mr. Chairman's point this is my sixth session here with the Academy started with the Academy as a student and have moved up to the presidency I'm a product of those programs within the state, went back to my hometown, opened a practice, and have been there for the last 12 years. So a couple of things I wanted to point out. You all have heard plenty, and I've only got two minutes. So in a three-hour drive here this morning, I only went through two towns that didn't have a clinic, Cache, Arkansas, McCray. Cache, Arkansas is 300 people, McCray is 600 in population. There is a critical mass that you have to have in order to keep the doors open, unless you guys want to change the reimbursement on a per-patient basis. So the second thing is removing the collaborative practice agreement, its initial intent was that there would be a very good working relationship between the advanced practice nurse and the collaborating physician. And so the intent of that document, which unfortunately is not seen as anything but a piece of paper by some, but its intent was to be much more than that, that there would be a working team relationship, something that has been shown time and time again to be the best approach and show the best outcomes, which is a team approach. And then lastly, I'd like to point out that in this bill, it also allows for the writing of Schedule II prescriptions. And so that's the end of your time, Dr. Wagner.
I understand. Thank you. Thank you. I will have Ms. Karen Reynolds to speak for the bill. if you would introduce yourself for the committee and you recognize speak for the bill
yes i'm karen reynolds and i'm sorry i have a bit of allergies going on um i was the 2015 small business administration's small business woman of the year um and i had a practice in Elkins that had to close in October of this last year. Um, I loved everybody, every one of those patients. Um, my collaborating physician required that I pay a thousand dollars to keep that little piece of paper and, um, my overhead and on top of being nurse practitioners are reimbursed, uh, 70 to 80% of what a physician is reimbursed. So on top of the reimbursement and I has had the same overhead as a physician. On top of that, I was unable to keep my doors open. 39.5% of my patients were Medicaid. Elkins is a rural community. And what was very sad, that collaborating physician, all of my patients had to sign up with them as their PCP because they had to do that at any point in time, if he decided to open up a practice anywhere, which he was an ER physician, so he didn't have a practice, if he was to open up a practice anywhere, they would leave because they had to. They were signed up, and most of them, the time it took to get on the phone and change their PCP, they wouldn't have done. The other thing I'd like to say is many towns need this. There was a nurse practitioner in West Fork who had to do the same thing. She left a hole there in West Fork where they needed physicians, and nobody's been there to fill that hole.
I think it's something Arkansas needs. Is there any questions for the witness? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Ms. Dr. Evans, does it recognize I speak against the bill? Dr. Evans, if you would introduce yourself for the committee
and you're recognized to speak against the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm Laura Evans. I am currently an administrator, educator at an Arkansas university. I have been in nursing for more than 40 years, and all levels of nursing, I've been in LPN, RN, nurse practitioner and as I said currently an educator. I believe that I in every level of nursing that I have worked I have depended a great deal on all members of the health care team nurses physicians physical therapists respiratory therapists every member of the team is important And when I was a practitioner, I was in a rural area. I worked in a very rural area of south Arkansas. I was in the public sector, so I did not have the opportunity to have an on-site physician in the clinic with me. That would have been nice, but my physician was not on site. So I frequently contacted my physician when I encountered problems outside my scope of practice, which was every day. I encountered those types of problems. So to cut the physician out of the equation and say I don't need a collaborating physician to me is very unrealistic. and for the sake of patient safety, I would support voting against House Bill 1186.
Would you or would you not, functioning as an APRN in that environment you just described, have a moral obligation, if not a professional obligation, to seek an opinion of somebody greater than your scope of practice with or without a collaborative agreement? Yes, I would. Thank you,
Hi, thank you. As you said, my name is Sarah Jones. I am the specialty coordinator for the only psychiatric mental health nurse practitioner program in the state of Arkansas, and I feel like we are really neglecting that scope. I hear us speak about family. If you look across Arkansas, 69 out of 77 of the counties are underserved as far as mental health professionals go. We just heard how suicide has raised over 10th in the nation with suicide, and as the only psych NP program in the state, I can assure you I am putting out extremely well-trained, well-qualified nurse practitioners that absolutely could work in our rural areas, the 69 out of 77 counties that are not receiving mental health care like they should be. It's very important that people receive mental health care not from their PCP, but from a mental health professional in order to receive the best evidence-based practice. I am also the president of the Arkansas chapter of the Psychiatric Nurses Association, and we are growing in trying to represent that role. I'm going to jump around. I just saw my one-minute mark. I do want to emphasize 22 states plus D.C. are now allowing nurse practitioners to practice full scope without a collaborative or supervision from a physician. I think that's a trend we're going to see grow. Unfortunately, I don't want to see Arkansas on the back end of that again. And the other thing I wanted to emphasize was when we go into our specialty in a graduate program we choose our specialty and our entire focus during that educational time is in that specialty so my students choose psych mental health from the beginning and they do that from the beginning and that's how specialized they are most of them have two to four thousand hours in mental health care practice as an RN prior to their time of going into graduate school so I just want to put that other side out there because we need mental health providers and the state does not have them and nurse practitioners are an obviously clear amazing choice to help provide evidence-based practice that's
perfect that's the end of your time okay thank you miss karen richardson you recognize speak against the bill Ms. Richardson, if you would introduce yourself for the committee and
you're recognized to speak against the bill I'm Karen Richardson and I'm from rural Arkansas actually southeast Arkansas and I have been practicing as an advanced practice RN for 21 years I'm against abolishing the collaborative practice agreement for many reasons One of which, I have never felt that a collaborative practice agreement was a barrier. I've always felt like it actually enhanced my practice and actually made me a more significant team player in the collaboration of patient care. I have personally called physicians at all hours of the night and day and been well received. Without that little piece of paper, I don't think we're going to be able to have that type of collaborative effort. I have spoken with many physicians. I've spoken with many of my colleagues that are practicing. And even though they're not here today for various reasons, they would be willing to write letters in state. They did not want to abolish the collaborative practice agreement because they felt that it was very important and also would help enhance patient care. Just because these doctors do have more training, they have had more experience than some of us. And quite frankly, it's more cost-effective to go across the hall or call someone on the phone than send the patient to the ER or call a specialist and take up a time that is not necessary. So for those reasons, I am certainly in favor of keeping a collaborative practice with my physician, and I see no need at this point to abolish it. Representative
Hammer, are you recognized for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. In your testimony, you just said that you call physicians plural at all hours of the day and night. I'm under the understanding that the collaborative agreement requires that you call your collaborative agreement. So have you stepped outside of your scope of practice and that you've bypassed your physician in calling other physicians, or would you clarify that, please? I have
So you have four collaborative agreements. That's the end of time. Sorry. Thank you, Ms. Karen, for your testimony. That's the best I've ever seen that time work. Hey, by the way, I don't keep the time. Mr. Anthony Rodriguez is recognized. You want to pass? Thank you. Mr. Frazier Edwards, recognize, speak against the bill.
Frazier Edwards, I'm with the Arkansas Osteopathic Medical Association. I'm the executive director. Many of you are familiar with the osteopathic profession now. There's going to be two new osteopathic medical schools in the state, one starting now that's already started and another one that has started or that will start this August. The osteopathic profession in general is actually unique in the fact that we are separate from MDs in the fact that those are osteopathic medical schools and UAMS is an allopathic medical school, MDs and DOs. We both share unlimited scope of practice rights. We have representation on the state medical board, and our graduate medical education is even merging, in the process of merging right now as we speak. The osteopathic profession went out and earned its rights for scope of practice and did not legislate them. We see this as a way to legislate scope of practice and separating themselves from the collaborative physicians. The two medical schools that will come, that are starting now, are in the process of training their students in the community in Arkansas. We also have a different training model in the fact that it is more community-based. We send physicians to those communities to train there because there has been clear evidence that shows physicians tend to stay where they do their training, clinical rotations in residencies. We are working with community health centers of Arkansas and many other hospitals and institutions around the states in rural underserved areas. The osteopathic philosophy has traditionally been primary care in rural America. Any questions from the committee?
Representative Gonzales, you have 10 seconds. Never mind. Okay. Thank you for your testimony, Mr. Edwards. Seeing no one else signed up to speak for or against the bill, Representative Brown will recognize you to close for your bill. You have two minutes.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. In closing, we've heard lots of testimony from very qualified people. Evidence shows that advanced practice registered nurses provide an outstanding service and that there is no evidence that they are unwilling to collaborate or that the collaborative practice agreement requirement enhances their collaborating with other professionals. With the scope of practice agreement, it really does inhibit the nurses. They don't have the security of knowing that when that physician retires, goes on vacation, or dies, that they will be able to sustain their office. They may not be able to replace that agreement quickly. This is a good deregulation bill that will enhance access to care and especially in our rural areas, and it will enable qualified APRNs to practice their vocation to the full extent of their licensure and certification. And I would ask for a good vote. I don't believe that we need to belabor this issue any longer. I think we need to pass this bill, and I would appreciate your
support. Thank you. It's a pleasure, committee. I got a motion due pass. Representative Meeks, any discussion on that motion? Representative Hammer, you're recognized for discussion.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. In speaking in favor of this, just a couple points I'd like to ask the committee to consider. First of all, when you look at where we are in the scope of practice, debate, and collaborative agreement, we are right in the middle of the pack. But unfortunately, when you look at the overall health rating of the state of Arkansas, we are between 48th and 49th. In fact, it wasn't that many years ago in doing some research that we were number 40. But since that time, several years ago, we haven't moved in the right direction. We're moving in the wrong direction. I can't seem to lay it in my conscience at the feet of all the fried catfish in the state of Arkansas that contributes to why we're moving in the wrong direction. I think perhaps it might be because there's an obstructionist barrier or attitude in this state that wants to limit free market. I'm not foolish enough to think that all APRNs are going to utilize this opportunity. In fact, it will be a very small percentage of APRNs, I think, that are going to utilize this. But I'd like to measure that against the fact also that not all physicians that graduate are going to move to a medically underserved area, which according to federal statistics, we remain a vast majority of medically underserved area. And when you consider that not all physicians are continuing to take Medicaid patients and are turning some of them away, I think it's disturbing that we would limit and continue to keep barriers in place that allow the citizens of Arkansas to be able to have access to good quality care at the most free market rate. So with that, I'd encourage a good vote,
for a discussion. Well, I mean, I would contradict what you're saying. Unfortunately, I had AFMC here. We didn't have time to hear them, but I think they would testify that when someone calls ConnectCare, they are always assigned a PCP. That is just not true that they are not assigned a PCP. Representative Pilkington, did
you have a discussion? Anytime you touch that mic, I'm going to be ready. Representative Ladyman, you're ready. Recognize for discussion. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You know, I've
enjoyed this debate, and this is a tough question for me because let me just, and I'll try not to go too long on this, but I could talk for a while, but let me just say, Ms. Reynolds that spoke, she opened a clinic in Elkins. When I was mayor of Elkins for six years, I did everything that I could think of to get a medical clinic in that town. It needed it. It was the third fastest-growing city in the state of Arkansas. We were growing at an 85% rate, and we really needed medical people there in that town. And I appreciate her statement about she opened the clinic there, and it really bothers me that it closed. But anyway, I think that's an example of where this was needed, and I believe, you know, I really feel like we should give our members of the House the opportunity to vote on this question because it's debatable. There's a lot of people on both sides. Many of my neighbors who I visit and play golf with are doctors, and many of them are opposed to this. But I think we should give our other representatives the opportunity to vote on a question that is debated this much. So for that reason, I'm going to
vote for it. Seeing no further discussion, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. No more rules than those have it. Your bill has failed. I got a roll call, so we'll get
No. With eight yeses and ten noes, your bill has failed. Thank you, Representative Brown, for your bill. We will move on to Representative Mayberry to concur an amendment. recognize, present your concurrence.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is the amendment to House Bill 1160 that we discussed on the floor last week. What this amendment does, a couple of different things, it adds Senator Linda Collins-Smith as the primary Senate sponsor, and it also adds some non-codified language that helps further describe the intent of the bill, and I would appreciate a good vote on
the amendment. Seeing no questions. Anyone in the audience speak for or against this concurrence? Seeing none, what's the pleasure of the committee? I got a motion to concur with a Senate amendment from Representative Meeks. Any discussion on that motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations. Your bill has
amended. The bill itself last week, if you'll recall, members, got 50 votes on the House floor. There were 37 members who either didn't vote or voted president. I think in follow-up there was a lot of confusion as to exactly what the bill did and what the intent of the bill was. I would certainly appreciate, members, if we had the opportunity to take it back.
That was not a concurrence in the Senate amendment. That is an amendment from the House floor, is it not? That is correct. Okay. That's the problem. Now you can present your bill as amended. Sorry. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, again, members. What's
was some confusion on the house floor last week as to what the bill actually did I understand this committee understood that and they voted in favor of it last week I just appreciate the opportunity to take it back to the House floor one more time. Again, this is a bill that is supported by the National Federation of Independent Business. Sylvester Smith is here to speak on their behalf, if needed. There is no known opposition to this bill at this point. I would certainly appreciate a good vote. Representative Gonzalez. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is this expanding the scope of practice of a specially signed electrician? This is he had to do it. I'd appreciate a good
vote. Representative Payton, you recognize for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm trying to comprehend what I keep. My memory is not good enough. Did we expunge the vote? I'm
very thankful to Representative Ballinger for making a motion to expunge the vote. We expunged the vote and sent it back to committee for purposes of amendment. Okay.
does is add, again, part of the issue, I believe, on the House floor last week was that some members simply didn't understand what the intent of the bill is and I'm trying to pull up that amendment right now and having a little difficulty I'm apologize for that representing and so we've added some some non-codified language in there saying that the General Assembly finds that a change to the law concerning the licensing of specialist sign electricians is needed in order to expand the scope of services Representative Gonzales to expand the scope of services that a special assigned electrician may provide by adding an optional an optional endorsement to an existing license without without expanding government by creating an entirely new license so we are simply trying to allow an individual who's been doing something for 30 years to be able to continue doing what he's been doing thank you thank you mr. chair thank you
see no further questions anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill? Seeing none, all those in favor say a pleasure to committee. I got a motion do pass. Representative Womack, all those in favor say aye. Aye. As amended. Any opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations your bill. It's passed as amended. Thank you committee. Representative McCullough, you're recognized for a non-controversial bill. I'm going to hold you to that, Representative McCullough. Can you give us the numbers? That's two bills, right? Yeah, just a moment. 21-77. You're recognized to present, 2177.
So I'd like to call up Craig Cloud, and maybe he can introduce himself. And if there are any questions, he could answer why this is necessary. But I can tell you what we're trying to do. We want to be able to identify and define the types of expenses that are not covered are the ones that should be covered by the Medicaid state plan that are potentially eligible for the
this bill because ultimately it impacts the state budget when we're taking away from that offset money that I was referring to. That means the state is having to pay. So take any questions. Any questions from committee? Seeing none
or anyone in the audience speak for or against the bill? Seeing none, what's the pleasure of the committee? You've got to do pass. Representative Miller, any discussion on that motion? Seeing none, all those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, ayes have it. Congratulations, your bill has passed. If you would, I'd want you to hold that other one until we can get a better feel of what it's going to be like. Representative Bentley, do you have a non-controversial bill as well? You don't? Okay. Representative Collins. there he is I believe you have an amendment to one of yours is that correct Mr. Chair I think mine was amended on the floor
here speaking on behalf of the Arkansas Self-Insured Association thank you very much mr. chair and committee HB 1953 does a couple different things with the with the worker comp arena as all of you know workers compensation is designed to do two things number one it's to help protect our workers from workplace injuries and things of that nature but it's also part of how we attract companies and expansions and jobs to our state so one of the challenges with any kind of a program like this is it's not enough to say let's just put this put the balance scales in one direction Because what happens is if we pay and pay and pay and pay and pay, then the workers' insurance costs get so high that for businesses in Arkansas to hire people, it costs them an arm and a leg. And so what 1953 does is address several things that the tort case law system has done to expand the cost of workers' comp claims and expand essentially the tax on what it means to hire Arkansas workers so that we can help move our state more in a direction to create more jobs. So this does five substantive things. I'm going to go through the top three, given that I know you have so much on your plate in this committee. The first most important thing it does is, with regard to workers who have a workers' compensation injury that then go into transitional work and then get terminated for cause in that new work, this would not cover lost wages. So just because somebody is in the workers' comp scenario for an injury does not mean that something that's completely unrelated to it, for example, termination for cause, would then generate another workers' comp claim. Now, obviously, obviously, if the injury was the reason, if the injury became exacerbated or something like that, then this has no effect. But if somebody is injured, has a workers' comp claim for that, is doing transitional work, and gets fired for bad behavior, that is not then eligible for a workers' comp insurance claim. the second major thing it does is prevents double payments for medical bills so for example let's say a worker has an injury files a workers comp claim the injury is then paid for through the insurance then the worker has a lawsuit settlement proceeds are paid medical bills are covered as part of that settlement in that scenario the medical bill portion of the settlement will then be applied to the workers comp insurance who actually paid the medical bills in other words somebody that is injured and gets a settlement for whatever is involved cannot have party a pay the medical bills and then party B pay a settlement for those same medical bills and then just pocket the second payment. The third change from this that I want to cover is when workers related injuries will be covered by workers comp. The injury must be work related. That must be a major cause of the need for treatment so if somebody is injured in some other fashion or has some other type of a problem which is not work related what this bill will do is make it clear that workers comp is not eligible to cover that so you might say to yourselves well what if it's not clear what if what if it's a it's a dual cause what if it's what if there's a relationship that there that goes beyond just clear-cut, you were drunk and jumped out a window on your free time, obviously work didn't have anything to do with that, but what if there was some hybrid type of a solution? Well, the workers' comp commission will then be in position to help make any decisions on that basis, and obviously, obviously, they're going to be fair in their adjudication, because what we want here is this balance between treating workers properly, correctly, and right, but not abusing employers and not turning the scenario into something where employers are seen as just a cash cow for things that are unrelated to the cause of worker comp. So I've just covered the three major changes that this bill would implement into the system, and with this fine young lady next to me, happy to take any questions.
you you may have kind of covered in it just floor my head representative column but my question is in regards to a medical injury that happens on the job and it seems like everything is settled and then three or four years later after all of this something arises that can be attributed back to the employer will that worker be able to come back and say hey this medical condition is as a result of something that happened on the job but it didn't come up until now yes there's there's no effect of this legislation on those types of scenarios in other words this does not get involved in changing how that is currently handled today in the application process the follow-up process and the assessment process for delayed impacts of worker injuries would still all be in place represent the appeal continue recognized for
a question mr. chairman I have a motion at the proper time I got you noted seeing no further questions or anyone in the audience speak for or against this bill speak for do what against I'll recognize you to speak against the bill if you would introduce yourself for the community and you recognize speak against the bill. Is
Follow the instructions. Mr. Chairman, my name is Mike Boyd. I'm an attorney from Magnolia where I'm city attorney and also have a small practice there. As part of my practice, I represent some injured workers from time to time. I've done that over the course of my nearly 20-year career because I feel it's an area that needs to be addressed, and there's a lot of times that workers that are injured on the job, unfortunately, are not able to get the care that they receive. I want to point out a couple things about this particular bill or at least some general comments about it. First, I would say that it needs to be recognized, I think, or this committee needs to know that Arkansas currently has the third lowest workers' compensation insurance rates in the nation. And last year, we had a 4% decrease in workers' compensation premiums. This year, the prediction is an 8.1% decrease in workers' compensation insurance premiums. Now, I'm not here to tell you that this entire bill is bad and all of it should be thrown out. What I am saying is there's a lot in this bill, and it touches on a lot of areas. And there's some areas that I think could be improved and by themselves would not be harmful to the injured worker. But there are other areas that would represent a hammer to the injured worker and to their families. And the first one I want to address with you is the made whole portion of this. Now, that wasn't described as made whole, but that's what this is. And for those of you not familiar with that phrase, it essentially means that until that worker is completely made whole from a third-party settlement, in other words, he's been paid for all of his harms and all of his losses, not until then does the insurance company receive their reimbursement. But if an administrative law judge determines that that has happened, that there is excess funds after that, then the insurance company receives its money. There is no double recovery in Arkansas. This bill speaks to that, but it does not exist. There is one single recovery, and it is up to our administrative law judges, which Representative Collins placed his faith in and I agree with, to decide whether or not that injured worker has been made whole. And if they haven't, then the reimbursement doesn't occur. If they have, then reimbursement occurs. What the biggest part of this bill does is that it flips that to where it becomes an insurance company made whole bill as opposed to an injured worker made whole bill. This means that the insurance company gets to break in line and get their money first. But it goes beyond that. Any money that's left over, if the injured worker recovered from someone, and let's say that they were a utility worker driving a truck somewhere for their employer and they were involved in a car accident and the person that hit them only had $25,000 of insurance coverage and their medical bills were $40,000. There's not, under this bill, that injured worker will receive none of that settlement, zero of it. Now, if there was, let's say there was $100,000 in coverage And the injured worker's bills exceeded that or all of his harms and losses, including his full lost wages and his pain and suffering and full permanency considerations of what type of injuries that he has. Well, in that instance, under this bill, the workers' compensation insurance company gets to basically deny future treatment because they're taking a credit for anything that might be related to that. which would effectively suck up or soak up all of whatever that person did manage to recover from a third party, which is not easy, by the way. So this made-whole bill flips something significant in favor of the insurance company, and I hope that you'll see it for that and not take this out on the injured Arkansas worker. Chairman, or rather, Representative Collins also spoke about the misconduct portion of this. And I would say this, I'm a law and order and a rules kind of guy, and so I have little patience for people that might misbehave terribly in the workforce. But my problem with this particular wording of this bill is that there's no definition for misconduct. It doesn't appear anywhere. So the problem is that that could open the door for some type of abuse, so as would misconduct indicate that if a person discarded their chewing gum on the ground, that that would be enough to now eliminate their temporary total disability benefits or if that worker was off of work and decided to tweet something that their boss thought objectionable, would that be misconduct that would allow the employer to discontinue benefits? I don't think that's the intent of this bill. I'm just telling you that I think that would be a problem because there's no definition of what misconduct is. the other portion that that was mentioned that i'll talk about too is major calls and what this means and i will tell you for purposes of a person bringing a workers compensation claim at this time when they get injured they must prove that they were performing services for the employer at the time they must prove a causal relation between what occurred and their actual injury, okay? And it's got to be connected or a doctor has to use special language called, based upon a reasonable degree of medical certainty, that has to be said in order for that particular injury to be covered. You're going to add another layer here when you start talking about major cause and whether or not a doctor can answer that particular question. And, again, I don't know if that's the intent of this or not. I'm concerned that what it does do is pick on aggravations of preexisting conditions, a person that might have a condition that they've had or maybe they had a back problem eight years ago, but they've been relatively stable and something harms them at work. The way this particular provision is written, I'm concerned that then it would be up to the doctor to make some call as to whether or not he believed it was more than 50% of the cause. And this only complicates it and makes it more difficult and burdensome on the claimant who's simply been injured at work and is part of the bargain that Representative Collins talked about, was supposed to receive a reduced package of benefits if he or she was injured on the job. In the exchange for that, by the way, was the employer receiving immunity from lawsuit, which is not unimportant. There are a couple of other matters within the bill that I think are of concern. You may or may not have seen the issue regarding muscle spasms. I won't spend much time on it. I would just add that I think that that is invading where a doctor's domain is at as far as determining a doctor's diagnosis and whether that diagnosis is good enough for the workers' compensation judge to determine. in general if some of these were broken out of this bill again it might be something that could be worked on there was a part related to the settlement of cases in Medicare that I think is something that could be worked on the language regarding misconduct is something that could be worked on and improved but I would strongly urge you not to sacrifice the injured Arkansas worker just so the insurance company who by the way has been paid their premiums for rating that risk. They've been paid for those for covering that particular incident, and that should not come back to haunt the injured Arkansas worker. And I would ask you this, if that insurance company gets their full amount back, if they get all the money back from that injured worker and what happened to him, are they going to return those premiums to that employer? I don't think that's going to happen. I would urge you to vote
against this bill. Representative Lundstuhl, you're recognized for a question. Okay. Any further questions from the committee? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ms. Carroll Worley, we have you signed up to speak for the bill.
you that wants to speak for the bill. I am signed up. I just have no idea which one you are. I'm Karen McKinney. I'm an attorney here in Little Rock. I have been an administrative law judge for the Workers' Compensation Commission, and I have been a commissioner on the Workers' Compensation Commission, and currently I'm in private practice. I simply want to speak to one aspect of what Mr. Boyd said with regard to the third-party settlements. I believe there was a misstatement in what he said. The statute has a formula set up that was set up by the legislature that any settlement off the top, after the attorney gets his fee, off the top, the claimant gets the first one-third of that settlement. And then of the remaining two-thirds, that is what is available for the comp carrier or the self-insured, which is to get reimbursed out of. And that has been the law. It was when workers' comp subrogation was created at the very beginning of workers' compensation. It was just this court decree that came down with regard to made whole that said, The carriers, the employers are not entitled to their money until the claimant has been made whole. So there was a misstatement that the insurance companies come first. They don't. The claimant always comes first. Thank you. Any
questions from the committee? Seeing none, thank you for your testimony. Representative Collins, do you want to close for your bill? Okay. Well, I took for granted he was speaking for you, Ms. Jessica. I'll allow you to speak against the bill. When you got my attention a
while ago, I took that for granted. I'm sorry. Yes, yes. He wasn't signed up, so that's why I took that. Okay, yeah, we're completely separate people, but it's okay. Good morning, good afternoon now. I'm Jessica Akers I am with the Arkansas AFL CIO and while I do agree with Mr. Boyd on many of his points I also wanted to testify against it guys in this bill one of the first thing and it it does is it starts to question case law right so this is looking to reverse case law it cites a tyson case in 2012 it cites a superior industry case in 2010 um so that makes me question the constitutionality of it right um the legislators are they take an oath to uphold the constitution but in any dispute over law um we let the judges decide. And this, I think, is a slippery slope when we go back in and try to reverse decisions through legislation that only scale back rather than protect. There's always someone that doesn't like the verdict of a case and to take that back out of the courts and put it here like I said is a slippery slope the second injury which was the part this bill has a lot of parts to it it was the part about was your injury caused only by workers comp so if I have a bum knee from being a athlete most of my life and I fall and I get hurt or I have a I have an old injury, and then I get hurt at work, and I get hurt to a point where I need a whole knee replacement, what this bill would do is to take away, the insurance company doesn't want to pay for your knee replacement, right, because you technically had a degenerative case before this injury, although this injury put you over the edge, right, so I think that also is a very slippery slope. I know a lot of people have have bad arthritis and and things of that nature. We did have a second injury fund but we defunded it a long time ago. I don't actually know a long time ago but we defunded it so that was used to cover this second injury but now like I said the insurance doesn't want to cover it. This bill also doesn't want to cover a situation, whereas if you were to get injured to the point where you're in a wheelchair, the insurance wants to cover your wheelchair, but good luck getting up your stairs at the house because they don't want to help you get a wheelchair ramp. So that's another part that this does. And I'll just say this you know we pay premiums to the insurance companies for a reason and when we start messing with made whole um we're just a making the insurance companies really really wealthy um and um you know we passed the house passed sjar sjar8 out right so if that were to become law and you are able to sue a third party you're only going to get 500,000 anyways um which a large majority of that could go back to the insurance company if your bills are that high, depending on your damage. And then we also just passed out of here to cap permanent disability workers' comp at 450 weeks. So I will leave you with this. The worst case scenario with this bill being passed, if you are permanently injured at work and you got crushed by a piece of machinery so you were in a wheelchair and you decide to sue the producer of that machine, that's the third party. if you won your case against that producer of the machine you would have to pay your insurance company back you wouldn't have a wheelchair ramp at your house but you'd be covered for a wheelchair and if it was permanent you've got about 8 years of workers compensation for an injury that left you permanently damaged at work so that is all I have Seeing no questions, thank you for your testimony.
liability for the employer? Thank you, Representative Lundstrom. The commission has reviewed the proposed legislation, and our concern would be, one of the concerns the commission has with this bill as amended is Section 7. That would be a significant change in the Workers' Compensation Act, and they believe that it's not needed. It would greatly change how an injured worker is treated. It would reduce benefits to an injured worker. And as you're aware, because of other discussions, our premiums are the lowest in the country right now. And if we had a cost problem, our commission would be here asking for ways to address those issues. Just last Friday, we heard from NCCI, who is our rate-making authority, that they are recommending an 8% reduction in rates this year. We've had 15% reduction in the last three years. So it's their position there's really not a need to change the law. If you'll be aware, that law was enacted in 1993, and it's so we've had 20 years of experience with this law other states have modified or modified and copied our laws because of our experience and the rates have actually dropped since 1995 65% in Arkansas so it's a the concern is that this would be a major change in section 7 Ms. Webb? Yes sir? I
have a question In Section 7, Line 9, that's on page 4 of the bill, they changed the wording from in connection with to for treatment of. Yes, sir. Can you explain why you think they would change that
wording or what that impact is? I can. I just mentioned there was a change in 1993 of the law. and actually the prior law before 1993 used the language for treatment of instead of in connection with. There were some court cases back then where injured workers that were confined to wheelchairs were denied benefits for apparatus, ambulatory devices, things that would help them do their day-to-day living. because of the language for treatment, but the court said those type of items are not treatment, even though they assist in the daily living. So in Act 796 in 1993, that language was changed to read In Connection With. And now, since that time, if there is an employee that is injured to the point that they are confined to crutches or wheelchairs, then the employer does provide or should provide not just the medical treatment but also the devices they need to live daily. It could include crutches or it could include redoing your bathroom so that if you're wheelchair-bound that you can access your bathtub. It could include a wheelchair-accessible vehicle, things like that. What about lines 11
sir. Currently, and I think Mr. Boyd mentioned this earlier in his comments, but currently for an injured worker to receive compensation for an injury, the claimant has to prove, and it is the burden of proof on the claimant, that they have suffered a work-related injury and that the medical treatment is reasonable, necessary, and related to the injury. This would change that standard of burden proof where the claimant would now have to prove major cause for the need for the particular treatment that is being recommended. And it would come up and place additional litigation and additional, I would say additional litigation, additional expenses regarding a pre-existing condition, for example. Under current law, the employer takes the employee as they find them. I mean, it would be great if all of our workers entered the workforce perfectly healthy, but some don't, and some have high school injuries, some have pre-existing conditions, And a major cause would make it very difficult or could make it difficult if there was a work-related injury and the person had a pre-existing condition to prove that that work injury was actually the major cause for their need for treatment. Probably comes up in like a knee replacement or a shoulder-type injury. I'm trying to think. there's also some cases relating to compensable consequence that I think that would have an impact of where they get the treatment a year later. There's some things that the treatment doesn't quite fix anything and they need to go back in for additional treatment. There could be an area that arthritis is set in and actually the arthritis is now the major cause, not the actual injury. So as an ALJ, I saw those type arguments made. So I think that's the concern with the major college language thank you any
mr. chair miss webb this might be a little bit long-winded but I need to know how you're how you think section 7 affects this in 1997 I was building an auction facility 40 acres had a lot of dirt work and construction going on man came to my office wanted a job and he told me right up front that he had a knee surgery scheduled six weeks out to do orthoscopic surgery on his knee and that he would need that time off and I said well can you drive a truck and he said yeah so I put him driving a water truck spreading water on the dirt work to keep the dust down a week or 10 days into his employment and he came in one evening after work and showed me a pretty significant bruise on his hip and I said what happened he said he fell on wet surface and and I said are you okay you know and you go to the doctor and he said no it wasn't here he just wanted to show off a bruise it happened that morning he worked the rest of the day he worked the following day he worked up until his his scheduled time to go get the knee surgery six weeks down the road and nothing between me and the employee was said or had any clue that workers comp would be involved I get a call from the hospital wanting my workers comp carrier information and I said why and I told them that the situation and told them it wasn't a workers comp claim the employee came back to work after the knee surgery it was minor orthoscopic surgery and worked for a month maybe six weeks and I get a call from my workers comp carrier and they're processing a claim now you said that the burden of proof was on the employee this employee wasn't trying to prove that it was work related I guess the hospital and the workers' comp carrier got together and decided this, am I reading properly here in Section 7 that it would change that situation to where my workers' comp wouldn't be paying because he already had that knee surgery scheduled and was already planning to do it? And the bruise was
on the hip. Right. I'm not sure why your workers' comp carrier paid that claim I mean that could have been controverted and taken to a hearing if he had that new surgery scheduled I don't know that this language change would change the result in that case since that was apparently done outside of the adjudication process well I fought with the workers comp
bill thank you very much mr. chair representative excuse me mr. boy may go back a little ways because I've been doing a lot of things that he has a comments on so I I want to address some of those things. I must have been a little bit surprised by Ms. Webb's comments, given that I've been told, I think you were as well, that the governor's neutral on this, and it sounds like she's got major issues with it. I'm also actually a little upset when we brag about insurance rates coming down in Arkansas in this area, as if it's an accident or as if we're surprised about it or as if we don't know what the heck's going on. When the truth is this legislature in a special session recently just made a massive change to this fund in order to reduce the cost. Did insurance companies put all that money in their pocket? Heck no they didn't. Why? Because you have competition. And if an insurance company says I'm going to stick all this money in my pocket for eliminating that death reinsurance fund that we eliminated, you wouldn't see a nickel come down in prices. And we're bragging about being near the bottom in insurance rates. Oh, we're near the bottom, that's true. But where the heck are we on median incomes? We're at the bottom. It better be low when you're at the bottom in median incomes. We've got to shift our point of view in terms of what God looks like. There is no reason the people of this state need to be lost and doggone near everything. There is nothing wrong with us that some policy changes can't turn around so that you, your kids and your grandkids can grow up in a place where they can make as much money as they make anywhere else in this country. And there's a lot of things that I know we're beholden to in the past. Mr. Boyle, where does his money come from? It's straight off the top. Straight off the top. This idea that settlements and settlement money should go for someone to pay medical bills and then also go in their pocket as an extra payment, that's not right. That's not what the insurance is for. And that money is passed on in cost to everybody else. This notion that SJR 8 is going to limit what you can get for your medical injuries is wrong. It doesn't cap medical. SDR 8 just caps the non-economic damages, non-economic damages. If you have medical bills due to some type of an injury, SDR 8 isn't going to change what you can get reimbursed for that. Folks, you have an opportunity in front of you to make a decision that is going to help people understand we are turning our state into a good jobs magnet instead of making decisions that are going to put job creators on the defensive. THESE PEOPLE UNDERSTAND THE LEGAL CLIMATE, THEY UNDERSTAND THE REGULATORY CLIMATE, AND THEY UNDERSTAND THE CHALLENGES THAT ARE ASSOCIATED WITH THAT. AND WHEN THEY MAKE DECISIONS ABOUT WHERE THEY'RE GOING TO DO STUFF, IT FACTORS INTO THEIR THINKING. YES, THE TRENDS ARE GOOD. YES, BUSINESS COSTS ARE GOING DOWN. YES, TAXES ARE GOING DOWN. AND WHAT? WE JUST RECORDED OUR RECORD LOW UNEMPLOYMENT IN ARKANSAS. The worst it's been since they started keeping statistics in 1957. The national rate is 25% above our rate. But all of us know times aren't booming here. Everybody's not running around singing, happy days are here again. We've got a long way to go. Yes, we're making progress. Yes, things are going in the right direction. And this will help make them go further, and I'd appreciate a good vote. It's a pleasure, committee. I
got a motion due passed. Representative Payton, any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed? No. The ayes have it. Congratulations, your bill has passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative McCullough, you want to try to run that bill? That's House Bill 2116, right? This will be the last one. Nope, we got one more. I'm sorry. I almost forgot. I'm glad. Representative McCullough, you're recognized.
media. and we have a law in place right now that could be interpreted as if you are an employer, you're not allowed to have any friends with any, basically the public at large on Facebook. We're going to keep the current language that says you cannot require to friend anyone that you want to hire or require that you, there's a lot of different platforms, but you may now if this passes suggest so the current law could also be interpreted as you can't even use LinkedIn if you're able to hire so for a lot of reasons I think this is a good idea I don't want to take up any more your time but if you have some questions President
it see you no further questions anyone in the audience speak for against this bill see it none most pleasure committee I got a motion to pass representative Womack all those in favor say aye. All those opposed? Ayes have it. Congratulations the bill is passed. Representative Stephen Meeks. Alright colleagues I'm gonna try
to be very quick with this because I know like me y'all ready to try to grab some lunch before we got to go to session. House Bill 1771 is a bill that most of you are familiar with. It's the light pollution bill. This bill is one of the best vetted bills that we have down here. Basically what it is, it's a cleanup, modernization, and government efficiency bill. I'll give you the 50,000-foot level, and if that's enough to get you where you're okay with passing it, then we'll go on. If you have questions, I'll dig into it as you will. Basically what the bill does is it's an attempt to try to curb light pollution in our state and in the process save taxpayer dollars to try to improve health, environment, blah, blah, blah. The 50,000-foot level is basically what it says. it's focused on government entities it says that when there is a cheaper or equal cost when you're going to install a lighting fixture that you will install the more energy efficient fixture that will reduce light pollution versus installing just any old thing that's going to light up the sky and cost more money and so forth so in essence that's what this bill does if you have any further questions i'll try to dig into that and i'll talk about the health ramifications and all that if you have questions on that but we do have a few questions uh representative payton's recognized
going to ask a question except for you put us on the spot that if we were ready to pass it don't ask any questions and i'm not ready to pass it so since you put me on the spot i'll come up with a question i'm all right far away i'm a pilot okay and it gets pretty lonely up there at night and uh a lot of times the city lights are a great navigational aid i know i have some friends that like drive up on mountains overlooking a city and see the lights i mean there's a lot of people consider them beautiful uh how would your bill change that probably not a lot that shocks me with all the shading that's your follow-up representative pain yes i i mean i mean your whole objective here is to shade them
to where But they do not send light up, right? Correct. The whole purpose is to encourage cities and towns and the state to install fixtures that are energy efficient, that save money, and that direct the light down. So what I'm not advocating is for the entire elimination of light. What I'm advocating for this bill is for a much more responsible use of light. The bill does not address private citizens. It does not address businesses, so there's not going to be a whole lot of change with that. I'll give you for an example. The city of Little Rock spends approximately $1.2 million a year on street lighting. You go outside at night, you look up, you see the sky glow, and that's something that we're all paying for. Under this bill, it won't happen tomorrow, but over time, the cities will be encouraged to install more energy-efficient fixtures. and let's say we only cut their electric bill by 20%. Now, with current LED technology, you could actually look at savings of 40%, 50% realistically. You know, 50% on, you know, that's half a million dollars a year the city could potentially be saving, and you can do a lot with
that. Representative Meeks, I read this bill, and I've been in this committee for this time makes seven years I've been here. You've ran a version of this bill almost every session I've been here. I still have the same problem I've had since the beginning, and it's the same problem I had with an earlier bill in here. How do we pay for this? Because people, the great citizens of Little Rock, they voted, they paid those taxes, those billage rates to the city of Little Rock to have their lights. That's their decision, not mine living in Warren, Arkansas. And the people in Warren have elected to pay for their city lights the way that they have them. So I'm wondering, is this not just an unfunded mandate to those cities? And how do you propose paying for this for those cities? Because those people are very strapped and down to the pennies on what it
takes to run their cities. And I'm very glad you asked that. This is not an unfunded mandate. It is a mandate, yes. It is not an unfunded mandate. And what do I mean by that? There are, say, protections, but there are definitions, and this is one of the concerns that the city of Little Rock had on this, that if there is excessive cost, so in other words, we're going to replace the fixture anyway. So this doesn't say that the city of Warren or anybody else has to go out tomorrow and change out their fixtures. What this says is when it comes time to replace those fixtures, if there is a cost-compatible or cheaper alternative that saves money, reduces light pollution, that that's the fixture they have to use, instead of putting up the one that increases light pollution and is more expensive in the long run. So what the net effect of this should be going forward is this should save those taxpayers dollars. I'll give you an example. One of those times, I ran it in the past, I had an economist come down from Missouri who specializes in this, who testified that the state of Arkansas wastes approximately $50 million a year on poor lighting. And so what I'm trying to do is hopefully we'll save the taxpayers some dollars in the process of time with this bill. Representative Bentley, you
you assure me that my daughters walking down the street will have the same amount of light that they do now? Yes. I appreciate that. And we think that maybe those girls, when they step out, might be able
to see the stars at night the ones that live in town possibly yes yes so again we can we can dig into a lot of the weeds with this one of the common myths out there is more light leads to less crime and actually in some cases more light leads to more crime but in the situation that you're referring to what we want to do is you know if you look at some of the light fixtures out here on the lawn of the capital you've got a pole with a light fixture on top the light bulb comes on and over 50 percent of that light goes up and off out into space it's wasted electricity wasted light what we're what i'm advocating here is that we take that light we aim it so it all goes down to the sidewalk where it's useful so it creates that protection that you're interested in and at the same time you can reduce the wattage on that bulb because you're not wasting half of it and you save taxpayer money so you get the security and you get uh savings how does that globe look
this? They don't really need us to tell them if there's a savings, the market will drive that savings. Yes and no. Cities can obviously already do this. Certain cities such as Conway and Fayetteville have already started to implement this because of the savings. they're under what is known that they are the municipal owned electric utilities so in other words the city of Conway is paying for the electricity and for the fixture that it uses City Little Rocks a little bit different they're paying what's called a tariff rate so in essence what they do is they pay energy five dollars and then energy just puts up whatever energy wants on the pole so what this does is this says that when energy puts that up on the pole as long as it is cost compatible that energy has to put up a more energy efficient fixture which should save the city long and long term. Also currently we currently have a law that's in place and the law does not include some of the exemptions that I've added to it so I'll give you for an example. If one of your cities wants to install ball field lighting which I'm sure they have done over the past 10 years since the law was first implemented, they would be in violation of the current law. They would actually have to go out, pass a resolution saying that no ball field lighting cannot be shielded, so therefore we can have our ball field lighting. That's for cities and counties. That exemption is not currently allowed for state agencies. So currently under the current law, if the Parks Department wants to install ball field lighting, it is illegal for them to do so. If the fixtures lighting the Capitol Dome here at night go out, it is currently illegal for the Secretary of State to pay to get those fixed. If the state police want to light up the American flag at night and the bulb in that fixture is more than 70 watts, it is illegal for them to do that. This bill is to correct a lot of that. So there's already a shielded law in place that states that any fixture over 70 watts has to be shielded. And part of the problem with that is, you know, back 10 years ago, light output was generally measured in wattage, you know, so everybody knew what a 70 watt incandescent bulb did. Well, nowadays, you've got a 70 watt incandescent bulb is going to be different than a 70 watt fluorescent is different than a 70 watt fluorescent or halogen is different than a 70 watt LED is different than, you know, go down. So the new terminology is shifted to a measure of lumens, which is a more scientific definition. So the bill also
updates that language representative Payton seeing no further questions or anyone in the audience speak for against mr. Bill Phillips for or against against okay I will tell the committee the highway department approached me before the committee to speak against and I don't know they are around or where they're at but they're supposed to be coming represent mr.
Phillips you reckon I speak against bill thank you mr. chairman I'm bill Phillips I represent the Arkansas Municipal Power Association that's 14 cities in Arkansas that own their own electric utility system this this seems to be a bill that's a solution looking for a problem. Just like Representative Nick stated, Conway and virtually all of my cities are replacing the worn-out fixtures with shielded fixtures. The couple of things that concern us, a lot of my folks have warehouses stored with some of these lamps that they've used for years and years. It does not address that. Do we have to dispose of those, or can we red and put those in until those run out and then by basically most everybody is going with these shielded fixtures because of energy savings because of cost factors and I don't think you need a bill to try to inject intelligence into those folks that are operating our cities right now I would stand for any questions seeing
no questions thank you for your testimony Anyone in the audience speak for the bill? Against the bill? Representative Meeks, I recognize you. Close for your bill. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. I do want to address what Mr. Phillips said here. Yes, a lot of the cities are already doing this on their own because it does make common sense. However, those old fixtures that he talked about, under the current law, it would be illegal for them to install those without the cities adopting an ordinance. It's already a law in place. This bill is to try to update and correct that. Also, as far as there being a problem or no problem, all you have to do is go outside at night and look up. The city of Little Rock, as I talked about, and you can go into any city, you go outside, look up, you're going to see a glow of light over the skies that the citizens are paying for. That glow also has health ramifications. I didn't go into it a whole lot, but I do want to talk about it because he said there's no problem here. There is definitely a problem here. It's very well established science that light pollution is an issue. In human health, when you and I sleep at night, our body produces a chemical called melatonin. Melatonin is only produced in the complete absence of light, only in total darkness. When melatonin is not present, it leads to increased risk of certain types of cancer. It leads to increased obesity rates. which that leads to increased diabetes, all sorts of other health issues. Light pollution is one of the very well-established factors in that. As a matter of fact, an Israeli study showed conclusively that people who live in cities have an almost 200% higher chance of getting these particular types of cancer. Meeks, I
Good afternoon. I'm Rita Looney, Chief Counsel at the Arkansas Highway Department. Apologize, I'm a little out of breath. Ran up the stairs. Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to testify just briefly today to tell you that this bill requires the Highway Department to basically become a lighting enforcement agency. We do not have staff for a lighting division, a lighting enforcement division. We don't have funding for a lighting enforcement division. It also has a section that gives the Highway Department authority over streets. We have authority over rights of ways of the highways, but I guess unless the legislature wants to give us authority over streets and rights of ways, I believe it's on page 11. I think this bill is unnecessary, and at least it requires the department to do things that we are not equipped with funding or staffing to do. any questions for the committee
just skimming over the bill real quick and you said something about it gave you the responsibility of enforcement and I was trying to find I see a definition for light trespass and I'm trying to find other place in the bill where that what we're doing with light trespass are you can you answer Any questions on the bill as far as what are we doing with light trespass and how would you enforce that?
How would the highway department enforce a light trespass? That's a really good question. I don't know about the definition of a lighting trespass. Once again, it's an... I guess that's my light getting on your property. Right. So
Representative Meeks, shake his head, so I'll let him answer that in his closing. That'd be great. Thank you, Ms. Rita, for your testimony. Representative Meeks, I'll let you answer that
in the close for your bill. All right, now continue with my closing. First off, I will say, and not to put her on the spot here, this bill has been sitting out there for about three weeks, right? and the first time they've approached me with this concern is today. They should have done that several weeks ago, and I would have been happy to work with them on any concerns with that. The enforcement on this is strictly for where, as far as the Highway Department is concerned, already places where their authority exists. I'm not telling them to go out and police things that they're not already required to look at, so that's not part of what I'm asking them to do. If they've got any concerns with that, I'll be happy to work with them to try to make that a little bit more clearer. Continuing on my thoughts, again, we talked about the health ramifications. It's not only for humans. It also affects wildlife. It also affects other areas of the ecology. So this is actually an issue, and we've got a choice. We can ignore it and say this is not an issue. We don't care about it. It's crazy talk. or we can begin to start looking at it now when it's easier to address this before it becomes more of a problem going forward. The nice thing about light pollution is when you correct it, unlike other types of pollution, you actually save money, you reduce energy cost, and you improve the environment. It's a win-win-win. The benefit, one of the points that Representative Bentley made, is if you go outside here in Little Rock 100 years ago, you could lay on the front lawn of the Capitol, look up, see a beautiful star-filled sky, and enjoy a meteor shower. You can't do that today in Little Rock. We've robbed our citizens of that. People go to the Ozarks from Dallas, from here in Little Rock, from Kansas City, from St. Louis. Part of the reason they go there is for the ambiance of being able to see a star-filled sky at night with fireflies. There's an economic impact to that. We're going to get to the place where our kids, our grandkids, may not have the opportunity to see one of the greatest splendors of nature. We can ignore it. We can laugh at it. I've had that reaction. I understand if you're not familiar with this topic, it sounds crazy. If you're not familiar with this topic, I would encourage you to become more familiar with it, because it is not only a public health, it's an aesthetic, it's an economic, and it goes well beyond just trying to regulate some streetlights. and with that I'll close and ask for a good vote I have a motion
to do pass from Representative Meeks the other Representative Meeks any discussion on that motion Representative Payton I'm going to recognize you for discussion okay just
for the members of the committee I have found the section in this about light trespass and there's a lot of stuff in this bill if you're skimming over it other than just the cities replacing their lights but light trespass says it is unlawful for a person to commit light trespass and it goes into talking about your light getting on a neighbor's property then also on page 3 line 33 you got commercial signage addressed I mean it would seem with a quick glance that this bill covers a lot more than just cities replacing fixtures I'd appreciate a no vote see you no further discussion all
Special Order of Business for Tuesday, March 14, 2017
Subtitle Number Sponsor
HB1021 Love TO PROVIDE PAY EQUITY FOR WOMEN; AND TO AMEND THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS CONCERNING PROHIBITED CONDUCT AND REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE WAGE DISCRIMINATION LAWS.
Speaker 6 presented Arkansas’s gender-wage-gap data, estimating a $3.6 billion economic gain from pay equity and noting that the bill would permit wage-discussion without retaliation and align Arkansas with a California model.
[10:02][10:05][10:37][11:07][11:38][12:09][12:40][13:14]
After further public testimony-including Paul Calvert’s objection that the employer-burden shift contradicts traditional justice principles-the committee voted against the measure, resulting in its failure.
[36:55][37:27][37:58][38:30][39:03][50:36]
SPECIAL ORDER OF BUSINESS - Thursday, March 16, 2017
Subtitle Number Sponsor
HB1815 Whitaker TO CREATE A STATEWIDE ANTIMICROBIAL OR ANTIBIOTIC STEWARDSHIP POLICY FOR D. THE STATE OF ARKANSAS REGARDING HEALTHCARE SERVICES; AND TO REQUIRE HEALTH FACILITIES TO IMPLEMENT ANTIMICROBIAL OR ANTIBIOTIC STEWARDSHIP POLICIES.
REGULAR AGENDA Number Subtitle Sponsor
HB2123 Branscum TO PROVIDE THAT SERVICES PERFORMED ON AN AS-NEEDED BASIS ARE NOT CONSIDERED EMPLOYMENT UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES LAW.
HB1653 Miller TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES WAIVER DEATH NOTIFICATION ACT; AND TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PUBLISH CONCERNING THE WAITING LIST FOR THE ALTERNATIVE COMMUNITY SERVICES WAIVER PROGRAM.
HB1714 Petty ACT TO PERMIT THE OPERATION OF MOBILE SALONS; AND TO CREATE A LICENSING PROCEDURE CONCERNING MOBILE SALONS.
HB1718 D. Ferguson TO CREATE THE PATIENT RIGHT-TO-KNOW ACT; TO PROVIDE FOR ACCESS BY PATIENTS AND THEIR HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS TO CONTACT INFORMATION; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1731 Jett TO PROVIDE AMENDED UNEMPLOYMENT CALCULATIONS AND BENEFITS FOR CERTAIN AGRICULTURAL AND CONSTRUCTION EMPLOYEES.
HB1746 A. Mayberry TO CREATE THE DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES WAIVER LEGISLATIVE TASK FORCE.
HB1771 S. Meeks TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS NIGHTTIME ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION ACT.
2:47:31 - 55:13
Representative Stephen Meeks introduced HB 1771, explaining that it would encourage municipalities to replace existing street-lighting fixtures with energy-efficient, downward-directed units to cut electricity costs and reduce light pollution, noting potential savings of up to 50 % for cities like Little Rock.
[2:47:48][2:48:14][2:48:17][2:48:20][2:48:55][2:49:03][2:49:25][2:49:58]
Committee members raised several concerns: Chair Jeff Wardlaw questioned whether the bill created an unfunded mandate for cities; Representative Mary Bentley asked if public safety lighting would be maintained; Bill Phillips of the Arkansas Municipal Power Association testified that many cities are already installing shielded fixtures and saw no need for legislation; and Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson of the Highway Department warned that the bill would impose unenforced lighting-enforcement duties on the department without funding.
[2:50:32][2:51:03][2:51:10][2:52:36][2:52:39][2:52:50][2:53:11][2:57:08][2:57:34][2:58:08][3:00:23][3:00:57][3:01:28]
During the closing, Rep. Meeks moved to pass the bill while Rep. John Payton opposed it, citing the bill’s expansive provisions on light trespass and commercial signage and requesting a no-vote.
[3:05:35][3:05:42][3:05:51][3:06:09][3:06:29]
The chair ruled the motion failed, and the bill did not pass.
[3:06:29]
HB1775 Johnson TO MANDATE THAT THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN A SUICIDE PREVENTION HOTLINE.
55:13 - 1:14:0579 segments16 speakers
Chair Representative Bob Johnson introduced HB1775, stating Arkansas ranks 10th nationally in suicide rates, lacks an in-state hotline, and that the bill would fund a hotline at $250,000-$500,000 annually with up to $2.3 million available from the health department and related appropriations.
[55:23][55:53][56:25][57:04][57:07][57:29][57:43]
Representative Meeks sought clarification on the fiscal impact, and witnesses including Tyler West explained that the health department already receives federal Garrett Lee Smith funds and would lose $1.4 million if 70 % of calls are not answered in-state, underscoring the need for a local call center.
[56:37][56:56][57:04][57:07][57:29][57:43][57:51][58:00]
HB1182 Sullivan TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO ALLOW AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO BE A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.
HB1818 Gonzales TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING AND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
HB1835 Dotson TO PROMOTE, RECRUIT, AND RETAIN A HIGHLY SKILLED WORKFORCE IN THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; TO ESTABLISH A SYSTEM OF RECIPROCITY FOR LICENSING, REGISTRATION, AND CERTIFICATION FOR CERTAIN PROFESSIONS.
HB1846 Collins TO TO AMEND AND CLARIFY THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; AND DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1857 Magie TO PROHIBIT DISCRIMINATION AGAINST A PHYSICIAN FOR A DECISION TO NOT PARTICIPATE IN ANY FORM OF MAINTENANCE OF CERTIFICATION.
HB1865 Ladyman TO AMEND THE STATEWIDE FLUORIDATION PROGRAM; AND TO PROVIDE LOCAL CONTROL OVER FLUORIDE LEVELS.
SB335 Irvin TO PERMIT VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; TO CREATE A LICENSE EXEMPTION CONCERNING VOLUNTARY RESPITE CARE; AND TO DECLARE AND EMERGENCY.
HB1628 B. Smith TO CREATE THE HEALTHCARE FREEDOM OF CONSCIENCE ACT.
SB351 B. Sample TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING COSMETOLOGY INSTRUCTOR TRAINING.
SB361 Flippo TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FROM THE LAWS REGARDING THE PRACTICE OF PHARMACY FOR DIALYSATE OR DEVICES NECESSARY FOR HOME PERITONEAL KIDNEY DIALYSIS IN CERTAIN SITUATIONS.
HB1186 Brown TO REMOVE THE COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT AS APPLICABLE TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES WHO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE.
1:14:05 - 2:08:40168 segments25 speakers
Representative Karilyn Brown introduced HB 1186, arguing that mandatory collaborative practice agreements add unnecessary cost, do not improve patient safety, and that advanced practice registered nurses (APRNs) already provide high-quality, cost-effective care supported by national research and organizations such as the National Governors Association and the Institute of Medicine.
[1:14:55][1:15:31][1:16:04][1:16:40][1:17:14]
The committee adopted a motion to limit debate to two minutes per speaker (motion by Speaker 249) and subsequently voted on the bill, with eight yeas and ten nays, causing HB 1186 to fail.
[1:37:05][1:37:10][1:37:17][1:59:20][1:59:38]
HB1894 Gates TO REQUIRE THAT BIRTH CERTIFICATES LIST THE BIOLOGICAL SEX OF AN INDIVIDUAL AS DETERMINED AT BIRTH; AND TO PROHIBIT AMENDMENT OF A BIRTH CERTIFICATE TO CHANGE THE BIOLOGICAL SEX LISTED ON A BIRTH CERTIFICATE.
HB1903 Bentley TO CREATE THE ENHANCED ELIGIBILITY AND AUTHENTICATION ACT.
HB1916 Hammer TO REQUIRE ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES TO USE THEIR OWN MEDICAID PROVIDER NUMBER OR A MODIFIER TO A MEDICAL CODE WHEN BILLING THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR HEALTHCARE SERVICES.
HB1951 Collins TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW ENACTED BY INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948; AND TO REGULATE FINAL SETTLEMENTS OF CLAIMS INVOLVING JOINT PETITIONS.
HB1952 Collins TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE LIABILITY OF AN EMPLOYER FOR MEDICAL COSTS RELATED TO A COMPENSABLE INJURY; AND TO AMEND PORTIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED MEASURE 1948, NO. 4.
HB1953 Collins TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948.
2:08:40 - 52:01
Representative Stephen Meeks presented HB 1953, outlining three major changes: (1) it prevents workers’-comp claims for lost wages when an employee is terminated for cause during transitional work; (2) it bars double payment of medical bills when a settlement overlaps with workers’-comp benefits; and (3) it requires a “major cause” finding for treatment eligibility, while also shifting the “made-whole” provision to favor insurance carriers over injured workers.
[2:08:45][2:09:23][2:09:59][2:10:38][2:11:15][2:11:46][2:12:21][2:12:57]
HB1954 Collins TO REQUIRE A PROGRAM SAVINGS PLAN FOR THE MEDICAID PROVIDER-LED ORGANIZED CARE SYSTEM.
HB2001 Baltz TO ALLOW THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD TO SUSPEND OR REVOKE THE CERTIFICATE OR LICENSE OF CERTAIN CONTRACTORS.
HB2004 G. Hodges TO REQUIRE COOPERATION BETWEEN THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AND THE OFFICE OF CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT REGARDING SNAP ELIGIBILITY.
HB2013 Lynch TO ESTABLISH AND REQUIRE CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR HEATING, VENTILATION, AIR CONDITIONING, AND REFRIGERATION LICENSEES.
HB2071 Pilkington TO PLACE LIMITATIONS AND SAFETY GUARDS ON THE MIFEPRISTONE PRESCRIPTION FOR ABORTIONS.
HB2000 Leding TO PROTECT THE RIGHTS OF EMPLOYEES AND APPLICANTS FOR EMPLOYMENT; REGARDING EMPLOYER USE OF CREDIT REPORTS AND BACKGROUND CHECKS OF EMPLOYEES AND APPLICANTS FOR EMPLOYMENT.
SB420 Irvin TO ALLOW INSURANCE CARRIERS TO OBTAIN PRACTITIONER AND DISPENSER INFORMATION MAINTAINED BY THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM; AND TO ALLOW PRESCRIBER DATA TO BE USED FOR RESEARCH PURPOSES.
SB429 L. Eads TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR MASSAGE THERAPISTS.
HB1625 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO KNOW YOUR PAY ACT.
HB2023 Fielding TO REQUIRE A FIRE EXTINGUISHER IN ALL APARTMENTS IN ARKANSAS.
HB2108 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING WORKERS' COMPENSATION COVERAGE REQUIRED FOR A CONTRACTOR.
52:01 - 53:083 segments2 speakers
Chair Rep. Bob Johnson explained that HB 2108 would require residential contractors to carry workers’ compensation insurance only when they meet Arkansas eligibility criteria, rather than mandating coverage for all licensees.
[52:03]
With no audience testimony, the committee moved the motion to pass and approved the bill unanimously.
[52:36][52:54]
HB2109 Johnson TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING FINANCIAL STATEMENTS REQUIRED TO BE SUBMITTED BY A LICENSEE OF THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD.
53:08 - 2:06:33248 segments35 speakers
Chair Representative Bob Johnson explained that HB2109 would change the financial-statement requirement for contractors earning less than $750,000 a year, shifting CPA work from an audit to a compilation to protect small contractors and CPAs.
[53:09][53:43]
Representative Stephen Meeks asked how many contractors fall below that threshold, and Chair Johnson estimated about 30 licenses per year, noting most small contractors are well under the $750,000 level.
[53:53][54:11][54:16]
Representative Bentley moved to pass the bill and the committee approved it without opposition.
[54:46][54:59]
HB2140 Rye TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS REGARDING ACUPUNCTURE AND EXEMPTIONS TO THE LICENSURE OF ACUPUNCTURISTS.
HB2145 Penzo TO CREATE THE MEDICAID PROVIDER-LED ORGANIZED CARE ACT; TO IMPOSE AN INSURANCE PREMIUM TAX ON RISK-BASED PROVIDER ORGANIZATIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2148 Penzo TO PROHIBIT THE USE OF SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (SNAP) BENEFITS FUNDS TO PURCHASE LUXURY FOOD ITEMS.
HB2149 Penzo TO REQUIRE A MERCHANT TO REQUEST A PHOTO IDENTIFICATION CARD BEFORE ACCEPTING AN ELECTRONIC BENEFITS TRANSFER CARD.
HB2150 Penzo TO CREATE AN INCENTIVE PROGRAM FOR THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM (SNAP).
HB2176 McCollum TO ENCOURAGE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT BY FACILITATING EMPLOYMENT OF INDIVIDUALS; TO REGULATE OCCUPATIONAL BOARDS, COMMISSIONS, AND OTHER ENTITIES WHILE PRESERVING HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB2177 McCollum TO CLARIFY THE PROPER ADMINISTRATION BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES OF THE FEDERAL REGULATIONS PERTAINING TO POST-ELIGIBILITY TREATMENT OF INCOME OF INSTITUTIONALIZED INDIVIDUALS OF LONG-TERM CARE MEDICAID.
2:06:33 - 2:45:4098 segments9 speakers
Representative Austin McCollum introduced HB 2177, explaining that it would clarify the Department of Human Services’ administration of federal Medicaid regulations concerning post-eligibility treatment of institutionalized individuals and would protect the state budget.
[2:06:38][2:07:03][2:07:06][2:07:08]
No committee members or public speakers offered questions or opposition, and Chair Wardlaw moved to pass the measure, which was adopted without dissent.
[2:07:17]
HB2216 McCollum TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING THE SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS OF CURRENT AND PROSPECTIVE EMPLOYEES.
2:45:40 - 2:02:04
Representative Austin McCollum introduced HB 2216 to amend Arkansas law governing social-media accounts of current and prospective employees, arguing the change would clarify permissible employer inquiries on platforms such as Facebook and LinkedIn.
[2:45:59][2:46:18][2:46:23][2:46:29]
No questions or objections were raised, and Chair Wardlaw moved to pass the measure, which was approved unanimously.
[2:46:37]
HB1624 Leding TO CREATE THE RIGHT TO WAGES EARNED ACT.
HB1040 Farrer TO LIMIT THE PRACTICE OF ATHLETIC TRAINING IN A NONCLINICAL SETTING.
HB1300 Miller TO REQUIRE THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PRIORITIZE SPENDING WITH DEPARTMENT AND THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO FULLY FUND HOME- AND COMMUNITY-BASED SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES.
HB1439 M. Gray TO AMEND THE HEALTHCARE QUALITY AND PAYMENT POLICY ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
HB1502 S. Meeks TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF RESIDENTIAL CARE FACILITY AND THE DEFINITION OF ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY.
HB1237 Hammer TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS ACT; AND TO ESTABLISH THE REGISTRATION OF SURGICAL TECHNOLOGISTS.
HB1254 Magie TO TRANSFER REGULATORY AUTHORITY OVER ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES FROM THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD.
HB1204 Magie TO ALLOW PHARMACISTS TO MAKE BIOLOGICAL PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS.
HB1205 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT.
HB1181 Sullivan TO CREATE THE TRANSITION TO PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY ACT; AND TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.
HB1228 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY OF AN ADVANCED PRACTICE NURSE.
HB1551 Womack TO STIMULATE JOB CREATION AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT WHILE PRESERVING HEALTH AND SAFETY STANDARDS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1525 Magie TO REQUIRE THE ARKANSAS STATE MEDICAL BOARD AND THE ARKANSAS STATE BOARD OF NURSING TO DEVELOP A JOINT APPLICATION FOR COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENTS BETWEEN COLLABORATING PHYSICIANS AND ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES.
HB1257 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.
HB1664 Payton TO AMEND THE FEES FOR WASTE TIRES; TO REQUIRE PAYMENT OF WASTE TIRE FEES FOR NEW CAR TIRES; AND TO REQUIRE PAYMENT OF WASTE TIRE FEES BY DEALERS MOUNTING TIRES SOLD AT OTHER LOCATIONS AND FLEET OWNERS.
HB1504 Hammer TO AMEND THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM TO MANDATE PRESCRIBERS CHECK THE PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING PROGRAM WHEN PRESCRIBING CERTAIN MEDICATIONS.
HB1809 Watson TO REFORM MEDICAID SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1810 Watson TO CLARIFY AND ESTABLISH AN APPROPRIATE MEDICAID REIMBURSEMENT METHODOLOGY FOR SMALL INTERMEDIATE CARE FACILITIES FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.