Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Government Affairs Committee Meeting

March 15, 2017 ·Committee Room 149 ·1:28:22
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

HB1807 0:14

Representative Charlie Collins introduced HB 1807, explaining that continuing the current birth- and death-certificate fees would fund bond repayment for a new health-care building and avoid a projected $5 million budget shortfall beginning in 2020. [0:18] [0:33] [1:06] [1:39] [2:11] [2:44]

Rep. Douglas House asked about the trust-fund balance and parking needs, and Deputy Health Director Ann Purvis testified that the trust fund has no balance, parking is a critical concern, and the existing bonds carry an interest rate of less than 3 percent. [3:16] [3:41] [3:50] [4:22] [4:44] [4:49]

The committee heard no opposition, a motion to pass the bill was made by Rep. Bladyman and carried unanimously, approving HB 1807. [5:55] [6:10]

SB373 AMENDMENT 11:34

Chair Rep. Bob Ballinger presented the amendment to SB 373, stating it would create a narrow exemption for attorney-client communications and work product related only to pending or threatened litigation, with specific definitions and a sunset provision of 30 days after litigation or one year after a threat. [11:59] [12:32] [13:04] [13:36] [14:07] [14:39] [15:11] [15:43] [16:20] [16:52] [17:25]

He emphasized the need to protect the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act while allowing government attorneys to serve the public effectively, and clarified that the amendment replaces the original bill’s language rather than merely adding to it. [18:01] [18:33] [19:04]

Rep. Douglas House asked whether the amendment would delete Section 24 of the original bill, and the chair confirmed that the amendment supersedes the prior sections, effectively removing them. [19:47] [20:10] [20:20]

The committee voted on the amendment, with a motion carried unanimously, approving the amended SB 373. [20:41]

SB373 22:12

Attorney Joey McCutcheon testified that SB 373 would dramatically expand the attorney-client exemption, effectively gutting Arkansas’s Freedom of Information Act by allowing any communication related to litigation strategy to be shielded and warned that “threatened litigation” could be abused. [22:49] [23:20] [23:57] [24:27] [25:01] [25:33] [26:04] [26:34] [27:07] [27:37] [28:17] [28:49] [29:24]

Jim Parsons, Dan Greenberg, and Brad Phelps-argued that existing court-order protections already address the issue and that the bill’s broad exemption could be misused, with Greenberg illustrating a scenario where a “sister-in-law” call could perpetually extend secrecy. [35:20] [35:48] [36:30] [37:03] [37:11] [37:22] [37:37] [38:04] [38:10] [38:44] [39:17] [39:48] [40:22]

After limited questioning, the committee moved to pass SB 373 as amended, and the motion carried unanimously. [58:50] [59:01]

HB2029 1:00:04

Rep. Warwick Sabin introduced HB 2029 to create a modest 16-hour caregiver leave funded from the catastrophic leave pool, emphasizing its limited fiscal impact and narrow definition of eligible family members. [1:00:16] [1:00:50]

Human-resources analyst Susie Barthol testified about her personal need for caregiver leave, illustrating how the lack of such time forces employees to choose between work and caring for aging parents. [1:02:53] [1:03:00] [1:03:38] [1:04:11] [1:04:46] [1:05:20]

The committee adopted Sabin’s amendment and passed the bill as amended without opposition. [1:01:12] [1:01:21] [1:01:29] [1:07:46] [1:07:56]

SB448 1:08:51

Senate Bill 448, presented by Rep. Jeff Wardlaw, would permit the state procurement officer to negotiate prices on RFQs and RFPs after the lowest-responsible-bidder is identified, with an estimated savings of up to $2 million. [1:09:04] [1:09:12] [1:09:18] [1:09:31] [1:09:40] [1:10:13]

After brief clarification that the authority applies only to non-bid qualifications and no substantive opposition, the committee moved to adopt the amendment and passed the bill. [1:10:20] [1:10:29] [1:10:36] [1:10:43]

SB584 1:11:07

Representative Bob Ballinger presented Senate Bill 584, proposing that the Arkansas Supreme Court be allowed to set its own hiring standards for an executive director, removing current qualification restrictions. [1:11:25] [1:11:29] [1:12:01]

Representative Douglas House asked whether the proposal reflected Chief Justice Kemp’s wishes, and Ballinger indicated it likely did. [1:12:15] [1:12:20] [1:12:23]

No committee members sought to speak for or against the measure; Chair Jack Ladyman moved a due-pass, which carried unanimously. [1:12:31] [1:12:50] [1:12:55] [1:13:02]

HB2055 1:14:25

Representative Kim Hammer introduced House Bill 2055, a whistleblower protection bill that would provide expedited judicial hearings and rulemaking authority to shield employees from retaliation. [1:14:41] [1:15:15]

Representative Douglas House queried whether the expedited hearing would occur before a circuit-court judge or an agency head; Hammer clarified it would be before a circuit-court judge with a panel review. [1:15:45] [1:15:58] [1:16:16]

After brief discussion, Chair Jack Ladyman moved to do-pass the bill, and the motion passed without opposition. [1:17:20] [1:17:28] [1:18:04] [1:18:26] [1:18:35]

HB2169 1:19:22

Representative Vivian Flowers presented House Bill 2169, which would transfer oversight of the Arkansas Entertainers Hall of Fame to Pine Bluff’s Advertising and Tourist Promotion Commission to improve efficiency and fundraising. [1:19:37] [1:20:07]

Representative Michelle Gray asked about the $30,000 warrant payment, which was confirmed, and then moved to do-pass; the committee approved the motion unanimously. [1:20:25] [1:20:33] [1:20:37] [1:20:42]

HB1707 1:21:37

Representative Michelle Gray offered an amendment to House Bill 1707 to shift the primary election date from three to four weeks before the general primary, citing higher voter turnout in March primaries and related fiscal-session timing. [1:21:40] [1:22:15] [1:22:23] [1:22:30] [1:22:48] [1:23:22] [1:23:55] [1:24:26] [1:25:02]

Representative Warwick Sabin sought clarification on the difference between preferential and general primaries, which staff explained; the amendment was adopted and the bill was do-passed as amended without opposition. [1:25:40] [1:25:45] [1:25:58] [1:26:05] [1:26:26] [1:26:29] [1:26:37] [1:26:50] [1:27:07] [1:27:17] [1:27:20] [1:27:39]

Bills discussed (9)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB373 · 7 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “SB373 AMENDMENT”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1807 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1807”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1440 · 1 mention in transcript
Matched: “…n passed it. So we're expunging the vote by which we passed HB 1440 so we can send it back to the Senate”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1707 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1707”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2029 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2029”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2055 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2055”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2169 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2169”
Pre-2017 bill
SB448 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB448”
Pre-2017 bill
SB584 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB584”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
Let's hope we keep getting a few more people to come in. Representative Collins, if you want to present HB 1807. Thank
▶ Play
you very much, Mr. Chair. I really appreciate you working me in. And I'll try and be quick because I know you have a lot of things you're trying to do. What House Bill 1807 does is continuous on our current path. What do I mean by that? Several years ago, we needed a new health care laboratory building. A fee was raised on death certificates and birth certificates in order to pay for that. Bonds were issued in order to build the lab. It has worked so splendidly. We're breaking our arms, patting ourselves on the back. One of the beautiful things that happened is we were able to refinance the bonds at a much lower interest rate. So the fee plan out to 2026 is actually something where these bonds will be paid off in a matter of a couple years. So it's all good news, right? Well, yes, our plan worked perfectly. But what have we discovered? What we've discovered is another building wore out in the intervening time. the actual health care building itself now needs to be either replaced or refurbished or new rent facilities need to be identified. So what this bill does is continue our current fee structure for birth certificates and death certificates rather than having that fee structure revert to what it was in prior years. It keeps it the same and allows the folks to issue bonds to build the new building. So what do the numbers look like? Today, the current fee structure pays $2.5 million a year against the existing bonds. When those bonds are paid off, that $2.5 million a year will be able to go against new bonds for the new facility. Let's say we don't want to do that and we want the fee to revert back so people can get their birth certificates and death certificates at the price they paid years ago. Then what happens? Then you'll have to vote $5 million a year more in general revenue to the health department in order for them to rent facilities for the operation to continue. So by allowing us to continue the good news we've had on this bonded approach to go for the next project, we're avoiding a $5 million problem in our budget beginning in about 2020. So we're trying to get in front of this, asking for this committee's approval of a bill that would allow us to continue the fees that are in place so that we can continue to work to to ensure people have an office to go to in the most efficient way possible. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'm happy to take questions. Okay. Are there any
▶ Play
questions from the committee? Representative Houts, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Two quick questions, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. How much of you, first question, how much do you have in the trust fund is the first question. And the second is I tried to come to, I came to a committee meeting the other day when they were going over the new marijuana testing rules. could not find anywhere to park. Do your building plans contemplate additional parking for your clientele? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. What I'm going
▶ Play
to do, Mr. Chairman, is ask Ann Purvis to introduce herself and who she's with for the record to address Representative House's questions.
▶ Play
My name is Ann Purvis, Deputy Director of the Department of Health. And right now, this is just giving us a little bit of hope that we can start making those plans. But parking is always critical in that area because you have maybe eight to ten thousand people that work in a very small area and so you know any any vision or any type of planning has to take parking into account. The second thing there's really that that trust fund currently has no balance because we pay that we're continuing going to be paid those bonds. When I was told a few weeks ago that that bond issue would be paid off maybe in late 2018 before we'd go into another session is when we really decided that we needed to make a decision today whether or not we could actually not sunset that, but use it for another building purpose. You're recognized for a follow-up. What
▶ Play
was the interest rate you're paying on the current bonds? I'm
▶ Play
sorry. I don't have that number. I think it was less than 3%.
▶ Play
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Yes, just thinking about, you know, your payment to the bonds and your parking. During the Razorback Games, you guys charge for parking on your parking lot. Is that correct? And then where does that money go? Is it helping you to pay that? No, actually, first of all,
▶ Play
there's only one game a year. It's not going to fund very much at this point. But I will say this. We don't get that money. They do use our lot. It actually goes, I think, to the city or to the stadium. We do allow maybe our emergency command centers used for ambulances, and so it's a site for those kind of things as well. But, yeah, we work together for that purpose. I just did not know
▶ Play
how much of a gift that was to you or not at all. So, okay, thank you very much. Any
▶ Play
other questions from committee? Okay, seeing none, there is nobody signed to speak for or against this bill. Representative Collins, you're recognized closed for your bill. bill. All right, he's closed for his bill. What is the will of the committee? Representative Bladyman gives me a motion to do pass. All in favor
▶ Play
say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations, your bill passes. Thank you
▶ Play
very much, Mr. Chair and committee. Thank you. I'm going to take care of something without objection. We, earlier today, we amended Representative Gray's bill is 1440 so we concurred in the Senate amendment and amended it what they tell us and then actually passed it out what they tell us is that actually needs to be sent back to the Senate for an amendment and so in order to do that we actually have to expunge the vote and so um I will make a motion and to the committee that we expunge the vote vote by which we concurred in the Senate and Senate amendment one adopted the house amendment which would have been house Amendment 1 and then passed it. So we're expunging the vote by which we passed HB 1440 so we can send it back to the Senate for amendment. Does everyone understand what's going on? All right. Any discussion on the motion? All right. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay. So that is expunged. Okay. Any other members have any bills to pass or to do? Actually, you know what, if you don't mind, we're going to pick up the one Representative Douglas ran earlier. So, Representative Douglas, if you want to go down and present your amendment. Mr. Chair and committee. Representative Douglas, you are
▶ Play
recognized to present your amendment. Yes. I appreciate the committee's input this morning and feel like we have brought back a bill that is a compromise. I feel like we had to give a little, and I feel like DF&A had to give a little. We want to let the process work with this amendment. We have made the changes that the chair suggested. We included the definition of review and also said that review does not mean the authority utilized by the General Assembly in its analysis of proposed rules or appropriations, so that that was completely cleared up what the word review meant in the instance of the board being able to review proposed changes and granting how much money and where the grants were going. So we cleared up review, and then we also felt like C on page 2 was a little bit unclear as to what we were requiring, and so we cleared up the language on that so that it complied, we feel like, with the federal intent that the board not be able to overstep their bounds. So we would appreciate a good vote on that, and we're open for any questions.
▶ Play
Did this satisfy the concerns with DF&A?
▶ Play
I would be glad to let them speak.
▶ Play
Okay. That sounds like it did. Any questions from the committee? All right. Seeing none, we don't have anybody to sign up to speak for or against, I don't think, that bill. So Representative Douglas, actually what we need to do, I'm sorry, is adopt the amendment. So that's where we're at right now. So are you closed for your amendment? I am closed.
▶ Play
Speaker 24 9:48
Okay. I would ask for a due pass. Okay,
▶ Play
so the motion is to adopt the amendment. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay, your amendment is adopted. Essentially, you just presented the bill as amended. Do you want to close
▶ Play
for your bill? I would just appreciate all the people involved. DF&A was great to work with and all of my advocacy groups for victims. I just want to remind the committee of how hard they work for us 24-7 for victims in our state. And I think this will be an improvement in, you know, making sure money and rules are promulgated to the benefit of victims in the state. So thank you to the committee. And I would ask for a due pass on the bill as amended. Okay. The motion is due
▶ Play
pass as amended. Any discussion on the motion? All right. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, committee. And Mr. Chair. Representative Gray, we actually did your expungement already, just so you know, we got that taken care of. Okay, so Representative Leidyman, if you'd take the chair, I'm going to run the amendment for Senate Bill 373.
▶ Play
Unknown speaker 10:58
Where is that at? 373. Sorry.
▶ Play
Representative Ballinger recognized to run your bill, Senate Bill 373. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay,
▶ Play
this is an exciting story. So you all remember this bill, or most of you will probably remember this bill when it came through before. We had some discussion on it. Essentially, what it's about is providing attorney-client privilege for attorneys who work for the government in some form or another, and that was what the intent was when the legislation came through the first time. Well, what we've done since then, it actually was referred out, went to the floor, and after that happened, we had a chance to meet with some people, and they brought to my attention and Representative Davis' attention that there may be some holes in this that could make it where we would really damage the Freedom of Information Act. I hope all of you all have the amendment. The amendment is essentially the bill now. So if you look at the amendment, it's still a short bill. It's one page, or just a little more than a page. But I'll go over that and explain what we did. So I agreed with some of the people who had some concerns about this. And I didn't want to create a situation where, like I've heard one person say, the exception swallowed the rule. I wanted to create a situation where we can actually protect what I think is completely fair and yet still provide the clarity and transparency that is necessary to have good government. We do have the best Freedom of Information Act, I think, or one of the best in the country, and I don't want to lose that. And I do understand that there's been lots of bills that did affect the Freedom of Information Act, and I think some people have done a good job of trying to make it as narrow as possible. Maybe it hadn't happened every time, but I think that this is the case where we've tried to narrow it down to just do what's fair. So let me first explain the problem, then I'll explain how we fixed it here. The problem is that within litigation, there is actually no exemption for what is attorney-client privileged in the private sector. And so you can actually go out and you can, through an FOI request, request what is in the private sector would be privileged communications and work product. And those actually include things like notes for depositions or your pleadings right before they're due that you could do that. There's a lot of things. Now, is this widespread? Are there a lot of attorneys doing this? The answer is no, not yet. There's five or six attorneys that are plaintiff's attorneys that are out there doing this now. But since they are getting away with it, I promise you it's going to be something that is widespread. So, the question is, how do we address that and not do substantive damage to the Freedom of Information Act? And that's essentially what we're trying to do. So let me go over the bill and how we did it. One of the things we did, usually the do not codified section is not that important because it usually is fluff. In this case, the do not codified section is important because what we're wanting to do is put in some narrow constraints for interpreting this statute. So when judges come and they look at this, I want them to make sure that they don't expand from what our intent is, but keep it narrowly focused. And so we did, I mean, I'll just read here, you know, it says the purpose is to develop a balance between protecting transparency in government provided by the Arkansas Freedom Information Act and still provide privacy necessary for attorneys to efficiently and effectively serve the public. So these people are, you know, the attorneys we're talking about are the ones who are serving the taxpayer. And I think it's really important that we provide them the tools to do so in a way that is effective so that justice actually can be served. The second part says, exempt only narrow category of attorney-client communications and work product strictly related to pending and threatened litigation. And then we want to make this real clear. It is not the purpose of this act to exempt all communications between attorneys and clients or all work product of an attorney. So we're making it real clear that just because an attorney is copied on something or even it's communication with an attorney, it doesn't necessarily exempt the attorney work product or client privilege. You know, it's not exempt from the Freedom of Information Act. Okay, in Section 2, this is where the code actually gets started. So in Section 2, this first part right here says that we're going to exempt records that are associated with pending or threatened litigation. Now, one of the concerns that I had when we were trying to do this is how do we define threatened litigation? We do that in here as well. So we'll get to that in just a second. As if kept by a private attorney. So the same way that a private attorney, but not any further, receives privilege is the same way that an attorney working for the government would receive privilege within the limited scope of either litigation that is ongoing or litigation that's threatened. Okay, if you come down here and you see the definitions of the threatened litigation, means an awareness by a governmental entity through actual written or verbal communication from a potential claimant or the claimant's representatives that the claimant will likely seek legal relief in court. So what has to happen is you've got to get a demand letter from an attorney. You have to have an individual say, I'm going to sue you, or we're going to sue you, or if you don't do this, you're going to sue. We actually have to have an actual, you know, response or connection saying, you know, a threat, essentially, to file suit. Okay. Written or verbal communication means, this is in II, means an indication by a person or entity, including an action by an administrative agency. So one of the things that is important to make sure that we do include is some actions are not even ripe in the circuit court until it goes through an administrative agency. So those would also be included in threatened litigation. Okay. Then right here, we also will set an expiration date. This is something that in working with a couple other individuals had some concerns about. And so what we want to do is make sure that this, that eventually all these records can become, because all we're really trying to do is not try to hide the information at all. What we're trying to do is make it where we can have a fair, you know, the taxpayer attorney will be able to do a fair trial and justice can be served. And so this exemption will actually end either 30 days upon the conclusion of litigation, if there is litigation, and if there is no litigation, then it will end a year after the threat has been put in place. And so, yeah, I'm sure other people will look at this and say that it doesn't go far enough. You know, I've been open to ideas and amendments and visited with several people. Yeah, I think that there are some people who are going to be happy that we've taken steps to limit it the way that we have done it. But I just don't know that there's really anything more we can do to be able to put individuals on the same playing field. I had a conversation with a really kind, sharp professor who had some concerns about this. And I used the example of a professor, and actually I got this from Representative Davis, actually mentioned this first, but the idea that a law professor, when I was in law school, what would have been really helpful for me as a student would be to actually have all of his tests the day or two before we actually took the test. and all of his notes from his class. Now, he's a government employee, frankly, and an attorney. All his records are government records. And so doing a Freedom of Information Act, I should be able to get his test. However, they are exempt. There's an exemption for that under Freedom of Information Act because it would be an undue benefit that would come to that individual. And it makes sense because it totally thwart the purpose of going to law school if I could get the test beforehand before we had to take the test. Well, that's kind of the situation here. The justice system is designed so that you can have two individuals who can present their evidence by the rules of evidence, by the rules of civil procedure, and be able to have a fair hearing before an impartial judge. That's the idea, right? And so what this would do is give you that opportunity to an attorney who's working for the taxpayer. And having said all that, I'd be happy to answer any questions.
▶ Play
Speaker 49 19:34
Okay, members, now remember we're
▶ Play
talking about the amendment here, so are there any questions for Representative Houser? Representative Houser,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Representative Houser, for working on this and addressing the problems that a lot of our people, our citizens had. I'm trying to figure out if the amendment is going to delete Section 24 in the original bill, or is it additional to?
▶ Play
No, the amendment is the bill. So basically everything is removed, and this is going to be the bill. Okay, gotcha. I didn't go up to the top. Everything in
▶ Play
the bill is deleted as far as Section 2? That's correct. I figured it would be a little easier to actually be able to
▶ Play
go over it. And we actually tried to get it on member's own, but it was kind of late by the time we got there. Okay. Thank you very much,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. All right. Are there any other questions from the members? Hearing none. So the question is approval of the amendment to SB 373. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. All those opposed, nay. Motion carries. Congratulations, Representative. Would you like to present your bill now? I would. And I think
▶ Play
we've done the easy part now for the hard part. And essentially, I've kind of went over the purpose and everything for the bill, sort of ran the bill when we ran the amendment. We have went, We have worked. We've done, frankly, I feel like about all that we can to try to narrow it down as tight as we can. You know, I do believe that this probably would have passed off the floor if we would have just ran it, but I would have been disappointed about the product, I think, that we got. Now we've been able to pull it back, go to work on it, take ideas from many different people in order to get this to where we are. And I'm actually pretty pleased about the product, and I think that we'll actually be able to have the citizens be able to be represented in court without the concern of having unfair advantage by the plaintiff's attorney simply because they're not government attorneys. And so I'm open to any questions on the bill. Are there
▶ Play
any questions from the committee? Hearing none, we do have some people signed up to speak against the bill. Joy McCutcheon, would you please come to the table? Would you like me to serve here? At the end of the table, please. Mr. McCutcheon,
▶ Play
you're recognized. Please identify yourself for the record. Thank you, Representative. My name is Joey McCutcheon. I'm with the Western Arkansas Transparency and Government Group. Our Constitution derives its powers not from a king or not from a Congress, but from the people themselves. Professor Robert Steinbuck has repeatedly talked about this bill and the fact that it will gut our Freedom of Information Act. I agree. As many of you know, Professor Steinbuck is out of state, but he has recently helped write the sixth edition of the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act, along with Professor Watkins and Professor Peltz. There's a clear and undeniable difference between the attorney-client privilege for government lawyers and agents and private lawyers. The attorney-client privilege for government agents is and should be sharply smaller than for private lawyers like myself or other lawyers who represent the people when they're seeking information from a government body. Why? Because the government's business is to satisfy its legally mandated obligations to the citizens, to we the people that our constitution refers to. When government officials fall short, as we've seen them do repeatedly, whether it's in Fort Smith, whether it's in Northwest Arkansas with Ecclesia College, citizens seek address. Therefore, there's no bright line between the privileged and non-privileged communications. Private companies do things private. They do private things. Private companies, their job is to advance their own interests. The important point is that public bodies owe a special duty to citizens that private companies do not. I'd like to talk about what we have seen as threatened litigation. That clause is huge, and I believe that Professor Steinbuck has also said not only is it huge, but it's undefinable. take the take the case that we talked about this morning of a client of mine of a nine-year-old boy who was raped on a on a area agency van last year about this time I can assure you that the government has and will refuse to review reveal records when there's only a possibility of litigation exists. And that's what threatened litigation means here. It's protection. And we could just as well call this the Child Molestation Protection Act of 2017, as Dr. Steinbuck has referred to. This bill has huge unintended consequences. Now let me talk about the when, the timing, and that's the threatened litigation. The timing is the bait in this bill. Threatened litigation, as you can read in the bill, which thankfully was, I believe it was amended last Friday, giving us time to look at the bill. Threatened litigation says awareness by a governmental entity through actual or written or verbal communication that the claimant will likely seek legal relief. But I also want you to look at what written verbal communication means. That's important. When we're dealing with something that's been in existence and the strongest in the nation for over 50 years, Look how written or verbal communication is defined. It means an indication by a person or an entity. And that's not a demand letter. That's an indication. An indication is defined. How is indication defined? Well, the dictionary defines it as a sign or piece of information that points out or shows something. Is that me jumping up and down? Is that me pulling my ear? What's a sign or indication? If we're going to amend this, then I can assure you what the government's going to say. The government's going to say that a sign or indication is anything they make it out to be, that Joey McCutcheon's a trial lawyer, and that's a sign or indication that he's getting ready to file a lawsuit. So let's now talk about the important part of this bill, and that's the what is the exemption. What is the exemption is the most dangerous part of this bill. The actual exemption has not been narrowly, it has not been narrowed one iota by this amendment. How much wrongdoing is going to go unnoticed in the darkness? Is this really accountability? SB 373 states a record will be privileged from disclosure as an attorney-client communication, and I want you to look at the language under the Arkansas Rules of Professional Conduct. That's extremely important, because under our Arkansas Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.6, which is our rule of confidentiality, That rule is a fundamental principle in the attorney-client relationship and states that a lawyer must not reveal information relating to representation. And here's the important part, the comment on Rule 1.6, confidentiality. This is what makes this so broad that it's going to gut the Freedom of Information Act. it says the confidentiality rule applies not only to matters communicated in confidence to the client. That is, if a client tells me something, it's not just that, but it's also, according to the comment to this rule, which is going to be excluded in this attorney-client privilege, but also all information relating to the representation, whatever its source. Let me repeat that one more time. All information relating to the representation, whatever its source. We're gutting the Freedom of Information Act. This bill literally keeps the absolute broadest definition of what is exempt. The actual exemption is not narrowed but widened. and we've been told repeatedly that we expect the bill to be amended in such a way that it will narrow it to the litigation context. Also, we've heard about the unfairness to the government lawyers, but what we haven't heard about in this committee is part of what our, in 1967, when this act was created, 2519-105, which is a protective order. I can assure you that if Joey McCutcheon or any other trial lawyer, we keep hearing this word trial lawyer like we're the big bugaboo, but if any other trial lawyer, if there's any, has there been any testimony anywhere where a court has refused to request a protective order? A protective order allows the court to protect documents that Representative Ballinger has talked about. So why are we trying to fix something that is not broken? And why are we going to gut the Freedom of Information Act? Because five or six of these trial lawyers, we haven't heard who they are. We haven't even heard testimony that it's happened. After 50 years, why is this suddenly a problem? For 50 years, have trial lawyers just not understood that they could get all these notes from the other side? Arkansas has one of the strongest Freedom of Information Acts in the country. This is going to have unintended consequences of gutting the Freedom of Information Act. As I said this morning, if this bill passes in any parts of the other 10 anti-openess bills, this administration will be known as the most secretive government body in the history of Arkansas, period. not even close. We, the people, will expect the governor and expect that he will live up to his promise and his commitment to open government that he stated in 2006 when he vowed to veto any attempt to weaken the state's Freedom of Information Act. And we hope that the governor will veto this if this does pass. Thank
▶ Play
you, sir. Thank you, Mr. McCutcheon. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question? Okay, Representative House, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you, Counselor, for coming and bringing your perspective on this information. I asked some of the people that have come to us about protective orders, and yes, that's true. They said that third parties go out under the—because we have broadened our definition of journalist to be anybody now, Any citizen can make the FOI request that third parties not subject to the supervision of the court are the ones that are gathering this information.
▶ Play
How do you address that? Well, I don't I don't again, I can't I can't speak to something that's not not before this body because I don't know what the circumstances are. But what I would say is this is about the people, and it's about protecting the people. It's not about protecting the government. As I said in the first part of my presentation, and I think it's very, very clear, there's a distinction between a private context and a public context. Um, the, the, the role here is, is that the government's business is to satisfy its legally mandated obligations. And I can assure you, just like the example that I gave this morning, that the government, the government is going to use this exemption repeatedly over and over again, uh, to, in, in a case of rape. Uh, I mean, these are real live people and these are real live clients that I represent. And I can assure you, had this been the law, we would have never seen those records. We would have never seen that videotape because they would have been screaming this, this exemption. And, and this is about, this is about the people purely and simply. It's not about protecting, uh, government lawyers. It's about protecting people. And this isn't the private context representative house. That's how I would, that's how I would, uh, but, but, you It would be nice to hear if we're going to gut the Freedom of Information Act 50 years of what Governor Rockefeller signed 50 years ago. It would be nice if we had more testimony about all these supposed violations that we're hearing about because we haven't heard any at this point that I'm aware of. Thank you, sir.
▶ Play
All right. Seeing no more questions. Thank you, Mr. McCutcheon. Thank you. Is there anyone here to speak for the bill? Okay. We'll move on to Jim Parsons. Would you go to the end of the table, please? Mr. Parsons, you're recognized. Would you please identify yourself
▶ Play
Speaker 71 35:20
for the record? Mr. Chairman and committee members, Thank you for allowing this freedom of speech. I am Lieutenant Colonel Jim Parsons, retired, and I'm also currently chairman of the Benton County Chapter of TIG. That's Transparency in Government, the same one that Attorney McCutcheon just got through relating to that he's in Fort Smith and I'm in Rogers. So, together, we have filed probably more Freedom of Information Act cases in Arkansas. As a matter of fact, I personally maybe have filed more than any person, so much so that in this morning's Gazette, in the West Arkansas edition, they referred to me not by name, but just simply the gadfly. And they know me as a gadfly, and for the last 20 years, when you go and ask questions, that's the perception that people get, that you're being nosy, you're a snitch, and you're scooping things out. Who do you think you are? Are you better than anybody else? And so you kind of take your knocks to do this kind of business. But this Freedom of Information Act has worked for us very well. And so there is no reason, I can see, to these 10 amendments that are scheduled right now. Mr. Parsons, I hate to interrupt you. We are very much against all of them, particularly this Senate Bill 373. This is the worst one because it does make it to where I, right now, have a lawsuit against Ecclesia College. Mr.
▶ Play
Parsons. Yes, sir. I hate to interrupt you, but we're really pressed for time, and could you please stay on the bill if you could? We're really
▶ Play
Speaker 71 37:22
pressed for time here. All right. I will just simply say that we are against this Senate Bill 373 and hope that you will not allow this to happen, and there's no such thing as a bad short speech, so I will close.
▶ Play
Are there any questions? Thank you, sir. Are there any questions from the committee? Hearing none, thank you, Mr. Parsons. Thank you. We have Dan Greenberg to speak against the bill. Mr. Greenberg, you're recognized. Would you introduce yourself for the
▶ Play
record? My name is Dan Greenberg. I'm a lawyer. I run a good government organization here, the Advance Arkansas Institute. I'd say Bob Ballinger is about one of my five favorite House members of all time, and it really kind of breaks my heart to be up here. It really does. But I do want to say I am really profoundly concerned about what I see as a mistake with respect to the measure that this committee is hearing right now. And I want to begin by saying this whole question of court orders and what one needs in order to get a court order, and how a court order works is, you know, if you successfully get a court order, you know, you can get that information frozen for everybody, not just the requester, not just the original lawyer. And I think that the existing phenomena of court orders that a custodian can get if they're concerned about revealing litigation strategy solves this problem. So this was not a problem before this legislation was introduced. And, of course, what I originally tried to do is I originally tried to present a more formalized piece of legislation that would provide for a more rapid submission of a court order. And that was summarily rejected by one of the sponsors of this measure. So I really don't think that there is a problem that exists here, and it is really hard to see what problem we're attempting to solve. I'd also add that once that first measure that I suggested was rejected, we also brought a second proposal that would have limited the exemption to litigation strategy. And as far as I can tell, that's also been rejected. So I'm continually saddened and a little mystified as to, again, what problem we're trying to solve here, because it seems to be a moving target. I guess I want to say something about how this newest proposal is going to work in practice if, say, you're an agency head or a governor that really wants to keep things secret. Here is how you would keep things secret more or less forever under this new proposal. You'd simply have your lawyer or perhaps your sister-in-law call an agency head every nine months and the sister-in-law would say, you know, I'm really concerned and I'm seriously thinking about suing you. simply have your sister-in-law make that call. That threatened litigation, I guess, has a time period of something like one year, I believe, under this amendment. And so this is really a recipe for eternal extension of these deadlines. And so when we have this broad new threatened litigation exemption, this is not just extending into one year. This is something that lends itself to abuse and can last forever. And so I'll just sum up by saying I don't think we've clearly identified what the problem is here that we're trying to solve. I think that the problem that some people have identified, which is, you know, litigation is being unfairly revealed by one side, is already solved by the court system. I think that that problem is easily solved by a much smaller measure. And so I fear that this committee is on the verge of making a large mistake that's going to provide a highly, highly overbroad and overextensive loophole in the Freedom of Information Act and is going to change our Freedom of Information Act from one of the best to one of the
▶ Play
worst. Thank you very much for your indulgence. Thank you, Mr. Greenberg. Are there any questions from the committee? Hearing none, thank you, Mr. Greenberg. We have Brad Phelps, who is going to speak for the
▶ Play
bill. Mr. Phelps, would you identify yourself, please? Yes. Hi. Phelps. I'm general counsel for the Arkansas State University system. Just very briefly, first, thank you to the committee for having this discussion and Representative Ballinger for his work. Just so the committee knows, this bill has been through several versions. We've had several discussions about it as we work through to make changes. A couple of things about the FOIA are important to keep in mind. Number one, any document maintained in an office by a public employee is presumed to be a public record. And what we're talking about here is an exemption under FOIA. An existing case law says when you apply an exemption to FOIA, such as would be created by this bill, that exemption is to be narrowly construed. And that narrow construction will apply to any one of the 23 existing exemptions that would be applied to this one. I think the risk of it being applied to broadly simply is not there because the Arkansas Supreme Court tells us if we do, we're in violation of the law. The examples that have been given by the University of Arkansas and other entities who've had requests made during active litigation have occurred. I don't know that they did occur when the law was contemplated. And the final thing I'll say is that there are a number of states who have provided some kind of protection to government attorneys. And the way this bill is written too, this exemption expires at a certain time. So the records will ultimately become open. So we support the bill. We think it's written in a very narrow way. And we will apply this, and other entities would apply this exemption narrowly as the court instructs us to do. Thank you very
▶ Play
much. Thank you, Mr. Phelps. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. I'd like to ask you a question, and if you can, answer it. Have
▶ Play
you ever in your position with the university had the law as it is currently written now be used by another attorney who is representing somebody else in order to extract information that caused you to go into court at a disadvantage?
▶ Play
At Arkansas State University, in my current role, I have not now. I have a gentleman behind me at the University of Arkansas. They have dealt with this specific example, so they could speak to that more so than
▶ Play
I could. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
I guess my confusion is not being from the law profession. I thought this was already protected. And I don't understand the effort to have to beef that up. I understood that if I'm talking with my lawyer, that's protected already. So what does this do that is not already on the books? Sure.
▶ Play
There is existing protections for attorneys who work for the Attorney General's office, for the Governor's office, for the legislature. However, those protections do not extend to other governmental entities that would be covered under this bill. So in the course of your work as a legislator, you most certainly would probably be represented by the Attorney General's office. The Attorney General's records and documents related to their representation of you would be protected under the working papers exemption.
▶ Play
So you're saying, if I could have a follow-up? Yes, you recognize. So you're saying that if a lawyer for University of Arkansas or whoever has a client that they're working for under the University of Arkansas, then those papers would not be protected under attorney-client already? Yes. They're not protected. Just because they're in a university system that
▶ Play
is a state? They are a public record that is deemed presumed open under FOIA, and there's no specific exemption under current law that
▶ Play
covers it. Okay. So just to make clear, if I'm attending the university and your state and your council there on campus was available to advise me, that would not be protected. But if I decided to get counsel out in the public domain, not at the university, that would be protected. If you
▶ Play
were represented, well, let me say this carefully. If you are a private citizen represented by a private attorney in a private matter, you have attorney-client privilege that attaches to that representation. The kinds of requests that we're talking about that are made to government officials could not be made to you in that instance because your attorney could simply just say, I'm not providing this. What we're saying is that if you use that example to like an employee of Arkansas State University that's been sued in their official capacity that I'm defending in a case. Anything that I write related to that case is open and subject to the Freena of Information Act under current law. As part of this bill, if that's in litigation, that would be exempted until the conclusion
▶ Play
of the litigation. So that protection I have in the private domain is not extended into the public domain of a university? Correct. And how many other public domains are exempted besides universities
▶ Play
or the K-12? I'm only aware of the Attorney General's Office, Governor's Office, and Bureau of Legislative Research that have some protection under existing law. You know, attorneys for the Municipal League, counties, universities would not be protected. Representative Douglas, we do
▶ Play
have another question. Thank you, and I apologize for extending. Representative
▶ Play
House, you're recognized for a question. It's wonderful to practice or be an attorney in a state where most all lawyers know everybody else. I don't know as many as I used to. They've gone on. But Lawyer Greenberg made a remark a while ago, and I certainly respect his analysis of situations. Whether I agree or not, I respect it. He said that a court order was available to protect not only opposing counsel but would extend as well to anybody else who might not be involved in the litigation but making the request. Do you disagree with that analysis? In the FOIA, there is an exemption for documents covered by court order or court rule. know, I don't disagree with the analysis. What I would point out, though, is two things. One, it is often difficult, given the FOIA's time requirements of immediate response to documents with your documents, unless they're in active use or storage, to get in front of a court to get those kinds of protections, and you risk either running the risk of a court not giving you protections or violating FOIA, which has not only a criminal penalty, but also a civil penalty. The second point I would make not only relates to the timeliness of it, but also the fact that when you construe these exemptions, you construe them narrowly. And there's nothing in current law that would provide an argument to protect these kinds of documents because as you can't create FOIA exemptions or read them liberally, they have to be narrowly construed. So there's nothing there now that would offer any kind of protection or give you an argument to even
▶ Play
make. Okay, seeing no more questions, thank you, Mr. Phelps. David Curran, would you please go at the end of the table? Mr. Curran, would you identify
▶ Play
yourself? Yes, my name is David Curran. I'm Associate General Counsel at the University of Arkansas System. I want to hit real quickly on two points or two questions that were asked previously. One is, are there any real-life examples of this being a problem? Attorneys within the University of Arkansas System have had opposing counsel ask for deposition notes being taken by opposing counsel during the middle of depositions. That has happened. We have had broad requests for all emails that would include emails pertaining to litigation, attorney-client privilege emails during the middle of lawsuits. And we have had attorneys, opposing counsel, ask for draft briefs before they're actually filed. So those three things have happened. Those are real-life examples of problems. And then the other thing I want to talk about is this idea of an order. There is a provision in the FOIA about the judge's order, but there has to be a legal basis for that order. Under the Arkansas Supreme Court's decision in Edmark versus City of Fayetteville, the court basically said that our FOIA does not recognize any exception for the attorney-client privilege type situation, and that would be a matter for the legislature to decide. It's not an existing FOIA. That is up to the legislature. I've never heard of a circuit court entering this kind of order, and having read that case, I can't see any legal basis for it. But the dissent in that case basically said that we need that type of exception. And the author of the leading treatise, Watkins, also said it's time for Arkansas to get with the program and join the vast majority of states and the federal government who are allowed to benefit their citizens and their taxpayers with the proper degree of representation that they deserve. And that's the basis for this legislation. I'm happy to answer any questions about those points or
▶ Play
any others. Okay. Representative Hammer, you're recognized for a question. Hey, Mr. Chair, I'm a layman caught in a
▶ Play
room full of lawyers trying to figure out which way is up, okay? Sure. And in your opinion, because you said you have had personal experience, this sounds more like an issue that's between attorneys that are trying to take each other to court more than it does interfering with the press or the public being able to access information for what is of concern to them. Do you feel that's a fair statement, and in short version, if you want to respond? I'd appreciate hearing
▶ Play
your thoughts. I think that's very fair characterization. That was the original tent, and Representative Ballinger has done a lot to ensure that that's the narrow focus of the current bill as it's been amended. Are there any
▶ Play
other questions from the committee? Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
In the examples that you cited, what was your response?
▶ Play
I was not involved in any of those. I was not an attorney with U of A then, so I don't know whether they just said, you know, we're not going to provide. Well, the emails we did provide, so I know those were actually provided. But other than that, I don't know the answer to the
▶ Play
question. Are there any other questions? Seeing none, thank you, Mr. Guerin. We have Rita Looney signed up to speak for the bill. Ms. Looney, I hope I pronounced that right. Would you please
▶ Play
Speaker 105 54:19
identify yourself? I'm Rita Looney, Chief Legal Counsel for the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department. And I, too, respect Mr. Greenberg. He and I are friends, and we many, many times have agreed on many things about the law and about state government. However, I will tell you, I'm here only about a very brief, it's not really anecdotal. it's just quite frankly very practical in terms of what this exemption would allow me as chief counsel to the highway department and the other attorneys who represent the department and our employees there. And that is, I cannot prepare notes or a memo or a legal draft of a brief that I've read, or even a list or a chronology of events to strategize in order to prepare for trial, I have to retain it all in my mind and then have a conversation on the phone or in person with my client, because otherwise, all of that which I've just described is foiable by the person on the other side of the case. So from a practical standpoint, I'm put in a box and not able to represent my client properly. And it's a disadvantage to the people of the state to not allow its attorneys to represent its officials in a way that is efficient, effective, and provides good legal process for that representation. That's all.
▶ Play
Thank you, Ms. Lenny. Representative Wardlow, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Ms. Looney, you and I got to know each other yesterday. No, public health. The one thing that concerns me, does this give you any more lead way than any attorney in the private world representing any private citizen? No,
▶ Play
Speaker 105 56:19
in fact, this would only put me on a level playing field with that attorney in the private sector.
▶ Play
Follow-up? Yes, you're recognized. The reason I ask that is we've had witnesses testify before us against this bill saying that we're protecting government. And I see my job is here to protect the people from government, not government from the people. And I want to make sure that I'm not giving the government any lead way by a yes vote on this that wouldn't be any equal. It would be equal playing field, as you call
▶ Play
Speaker 115 56:53
it, as the people already have. I think
▶ Play
Speaker 105 56:56
a yes vote would be a vote that actually serves the public good by allowing them to have advice of counsel in matters that the public is interested in. Thank you. Seeing no
▶ Play
other questions. Thank you, Ms. Lenny. Representative Ballinger, would you like to close for your bill?
▶ Play
Yes, I would. But just real quick, just like had been presented, this is going to be narrowly construed. I just had a Supreme Court decision where the Supreme Court issued an order saying, you know, when the legislature says what its intent is, you don't have to guess about the intent. So if there's anything that was declared ambiguous, they're going to go back to what our purpose and intent was to interpret it. And that is narrowly. And we even tell them narrowly to do it here. And if you have questions about, you know, what threatened litigation is, it says right there what threatened litigation is. It takes an actual written or verbal, and it's not even forever. So if people are hiding this, they may be able to hide it for a year, but they won't be able to hide it after that. And if we have the kind of individuals in our state government that will set this up so that an aunt emails them occasionally asking for documents, I mean, that may happen. But this is not going to help them break the law any more than they're already breaking the law, if that's the kind of character that we have, and I hope that we don't have very many of those. And actually, with my knowledge, I'll say that we don't have very many of those. You know, this does very simply make it where we're not even necessarily even on an even playing field with private attorneys because there still are a lot of things that aren't exempt. But in active litigation, then at least work product and privileged communications as defined with the private sector would be exempt. And having said that, I would appreciate a good vote and do move, do pass
▶ Play
as amended. Okay, we have a motion of do pass on Senate Bill 373 as amended. Is there any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor of the motion say aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Congratulations, Representative Bounder. Thank you, committee. Thank you.
▶ Play
do want to run bills. I know it's late. We'll keep working as long as you guys can be here. But I do have two bills and I definitely want to get Representative Sabin done because he has had a witness who was here earlier and has been very patient. And I apologize that you've had to wait so much. But you are recognized, Representative Sabin. What is the bill number?
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's House Bill 2029 and I have an amendment first before we go further. Well, let's run your amendment real quick. Thank you very much. And the amendment actually was suggested by Representative Dodson, who I think is still here. The chairs are so big. There he is. He was taking a look at this bill, and you'll learn more about it when I present it. It's regarding caregiver leave, but he said it would be a good idea perhaps to adopt the same language that we adopted when we passed the maternity leave bill earlier in the session, which basically creates a situation where this leave would be drawn from the catastrophic pool and therefore would not really have a fiscal impact because it would be drawn from that pool and no one would be able to apply it otherwise, but it also wouldn't apply against their other leave, which, again, was part of that bill that we had adopted earlier in the session. So that's really all the amendment does. I know there's more language in the amendment that's simply because it had deleted certain lines out, I guess, for consistency, and then it puts them all back in, and really the only part of the amendment that we're adding to the bill is the part about the catastrophic lead pool. Okay. You've
▶ Play
presented your amendment. You move adoption of the amendment. I would like to move due pass on the amendment. Okay. We have a motion on the floor to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? All right. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. You've adopted your amendment. You're
▶ Play
recognized to run your bill. Thank you very much. And members of the committee, I appreciate the opportunity to do this, and I know it's We all want to be somewhere else, but Ms. Bartol, who's sitting next to me, as the chairman mentioned, had been here earlier in the day through that long committee meeting we had and then was here as well since we've been here before 5 o'clock. And she's the one who brought this issue to my attention. And real quick, you know, obviously, you know, we know about maternity leave and other kinds of family leave, but caregiver leave is, you know, obviously becoming more important as everyone is living longer. And in fact, one of the things that Ms. Bartol brought to my attention was the fact that, you know, if you look at sort of the average age of state employees, more of them are probably past the age when they would be having kids and are probably going to need leave more to take care of loved ones who, you know, are obviously moving on in years. And she has a kind of a personal story about that that I'm going to let her share with you, since it's sort of what moved me to bring this bill. But I do want to emphasize that the request here is pretty modest. It's for 16 hours in one calendar year, if you notice that in the bill. So, I mean, it's really not much, but it can become critical. And if it's all right with the committee, I'd like Ms. Barthol to introduce herself and testify for the bill with me right now. Yeah, you're
▶ Play
recognizing. You've told me to introduce yourself for the
▶ Play
record. Yes, my name is Susie Barthol. I am a Human Resource Analyst with the Arkansas Department of Workforce Services. I will be as brief as I possibly can. I know y'all are tired. I'm tired. I am the primary caregiver for my mother, who is 84 years old. I've been a state employee since April of 2010. Over the years I have, the accrual has changed, of course, with my tenure with the state, and I honestly, with all my heart, thought that that would be enough. I we have worked very hard to keep my mother out of a nursing home These are her final years and we wanted to keep her home as much as possible and therefore I adopted the role of primary caregiver But I work full-time and I really don't have a choice in that particular matter I've been in human resources for almost 20 years And I have seen application after application of individuals who have quit their jobs To take care of someone in their family And I used to scoff at that and think, well, that's a little bit over the top. I am in that position. I mean, I understand that so much today. I have run into the problem of the one thing that has scared me the most through this is what happens if I have a medical emergency and I am out of leave because of how much I have taken for her, meeting with caregivers, meeting with social workers, meeting with chaplains, hospice, Medicaid. And the very thing I was afraid of happened in December. I had a bum gallbladder that had to be taken out. Made the appointment with the surgeon and sat there and said, there's no way I can be out two weeks. There's absolutely no way you're going to have to let me go back. So we talked back and forth and I said, I will be on the phone three days afterwards begging you to let me go back to work because I ended up on leave without pay. And if you've ever had that situation that happens before, it becomes a snowball rolling downhill. Um, and as other things come up, any illness that I have, essentially I am having to use my leave time annual as well as sick for basically two people, um, is what it kind of comes down to. Um, I have done everything I could to be judicious with the use of my leave time as a caregiver, life can get really stressful. Um, trying to manage a full-time job as well as, two people's lives. I get told, you know, why don't you take a vacation? And it's like, well, that would be great. But I have nothing to go on vacation with. So I'm asking the committee to seriously consider this bill. 16 hours might not sound like a lot to a lot of people, but it might have been the difference between me having to take leave without pay and or, you know, having having a little bit of extra time to buffer that for when I have medical emergencies. I'm no spring chicken, and I anticipate as I get older, more of these things will come up. And as long as I'm able to keep my mother at home, I know that those issues are going to come up as well. When she was in a rehab facility for breaking her pelvis last summer for 10 weeks, I didn't miss a day of work. But immediately upon returning home, I started to miss. What that says to me is that in some ways it would be easier to put her in a nursing home very much against what I and my family want to do. However, I run into the problem with leave. I'm trying to keep it as short as possible, so thank you very much.
▶ Play
And I'll just add, if it's all right, before we take questions, just that we looked at other states that have caregiver leave, and there are quite a few, and really went with the most restrictive definition of it that we could find, just because, again, we understand that this is something that's new. That's why we're not asking for a lot of time. And, you know, you can see the definitions of the kinds of people for whom this kind of caregiver leave would be applicable. And it's really just immediate family only, that listing there. So it's short and sweet. It's restrictive. It's modest. And with that, of course, we'd be glad to take any questions.
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Douglas, you recognize her
▶ Play
question? Yes. Who pays for this, and is it out of a catastrophic where the other employees can give a day, and then you apply to the account? Am I answering my own question? You are, but that's all right. I mean, again, Representative Dodson
▶ Play
had suggested that we do it that way. We had done that with the maternity leave that we passed earlier, and it seemed like a good way to make sure that we weren't going overboard with this thing, and it wouldn't cost the state any money. Thank
▶ Play
you. Good plan. All right. Any other questions from the committee? Okay. Seeing now, we don't have anybody to sign up to speak for or against. You're recognized to close for your bill, Representative Sabin. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I'll just close by moving to pass on the bill as amended, and I appreciate a
▶ Play
good vote. Okay. We have a motion to pass as amended. Any discussion on that motion? All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? No.
▶ Play
Speaker 56 1:07:56
Okay. The ayes have it. Congratulations. You passed your bill. of
▶ Play
Wardlaw has a bill that he'd like to run. I have one that I told the justice I would. It'll be quick. He's promised and I promise mine is one sentence and should be a
▶ Play
good one. 448, Senate Bill 448. It's got a quick amendment. Okay. Let's run your amendment. The amendment just deletes some lines on page three. Okay. You
▶ Play
move to adopt the amendment? I do. Okay. We have a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor, say aye. Opposed? All right. Your amendment is adopted. You're recognized. Run your bill. I just love
▶ Play
Speaker 139 1:08:35
her. I do love you. I do. I'm saying
▶ Play
it on record from the end of the table. All right. Run your bill so we can get out of here. All right. Senate Bill 400 and something. I can't remember. 448. 448. It's a procurement bill. It allows Ed Armstrong or whoever our procurement officer is in the future to be able to make negotiations with the end of the contractor to negotiate price down if that ability is there. That's all the bill does in a nutshell. The amendment got some vendors okay with the bill, and that's what
▶ Play
made it a non-controversial. Okay, any questions on it?
▶ Play
Representative House, you're recognized. Is it cricket to put something out for bids, you get the lowest responsible bidder and then start talking to the next responsible bidder and no sir
▶ Play
and uh a lot of these a lot of these items that are on rfq are are requirement for qualifications not an actual bid so it gives him the authority to kind of negotiate price down on rfq on an rfp like you're talking about you would just be stuck with the lowest bidder but on one that's not a bid process it would allow him to kind of work that deal down a little bit more. He thinks he could save up to $2 million, and that was a conservative figure he gave me this morning. Tell me, who was that? Edward Armstrong, the Curement Officer. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. There's a companion bill coming behind it from the Senate that allows negotiation on a different set of bids. Okay. Any other questions from
▶ Play
committee? Okay. Seeing none, there's nobody to sign up to speak for or against. You recognize or close for your Senate bill. All I would say is you'll probably
▶ Play
see me here again with the companion bill shortly. So, thank you and appreciate a good vote. Motion to pass. Okay. So, we
▶ Play
have a motion to do pass as amended. Any discussion on the motion? All All right, all in favor, say aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations, you passed your bill. I had a bill that I was wanting to run earlier, and if the committee will indulge me, and there's a couple other people who want to run bills, but I'm going to, we'll do this and we'll work as long as I still have a quorum. But it's Senate Bill 448.
▶ Play
Speaker 129 1:11:01
It's real short. Sorry, Senate Bill 584, sorry. Representative
▶ Play
Ballinger, you're recognized to run your bill.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is just in an effort to prove that I don't hate the Supreme Court of Arkansas. I'm going to carry this bill for them. Essentially, real short, it just basically says that the Supreme Court can go out and they can hire their executive director and do so without having limited restrictions on it. Basically, let the court set their own restrictions. They're in a situation where they have an interim director. The interim director actually wouldn't meet the qualifications in here, and they'd like to be able to consider that person, but also other people who may not meet it. But basically, let the court decide on its own what standards to set for its employees. And that's basically it. I'd be happy to answer any questions.
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:12:15
Representative House, you're recognized for a question. Representative, is this what Chief Justice
▶ Play
Kemp wants to do? My guess is actually Justice
▶ Play
Womack is the one who contacted me. So I would assume this is what Chief Justice Kemp also wants to do. Okay, thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other questions? I'll be happy to close for my bill. Is there anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or
▶ Play
against the bill? Hearing none, would you like to close for your bill? I would. I just
▶ Play
would appreciate a due pass, and I move due pass. Have a motion of due pass on Senate Bill 584. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor say aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Representative Boundary Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 39 1:13:19
is passed. you're welcome to finish if you want who's up
▶ Play
we're running hammer and then we'll run okay actually Representative Flowers, Representative Hammer said it would be one minute to run his bill, so do you mind it? I promised the committee that we'd cover committee members' bills, and after that, then you're next. So he's promised one minute. We'll see if we can get him in and out. Okay. I do. Somewhere. Yeah. That's all right. Representative Hammer, what bill is it we're running? This is 2055. 2055. Okay. You're recognized to run House Bill 2055. I'll get to the long and short
▶ Play
of it and leave time for questions. In our state, we've done a lot of things to deal with whistleblower laws as far as trying to encourage people that are in positions of knowledge to come forward with the information they have to make for a pure government and to make sure that all funds of public, that are public funds are being dealt with in the utmost manner. But this bill, but the problem is that when people feel that they don't have any protection when they blow the whistle, they're not going to come forward. And basically what this bill does is allow that if a person blows the whistle so as to avoid fear of persecution or retaliation is, number one, it allows for an expedited hearing before a judge so that the judge can hear the information to give that employee the protection that they need. but it also allows us to promulgate rules on page 2, line 32. It allows for rules to be promulgated so that that individual can also, under 21.1.603, have the opportunity to have that information put before a group that would decide that, yes, in fact, there are merits, and that person would therefore be able to retain their job without fear of persecution while the civil process runs. And long and short, it just provides some protection for those that blow the whistle and make sure that they don't get fired out of retribution the next day. And I'll be glad to answer any questions. Are there
▶ Play
any questions from the committee? Hearing none.
▶ Play
No, Representative House. Oh, I'm sorry. Sorry, Representative House. I'm sorry. I was moving around. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The expedited hearing, now, is that in front of the agency head or is it in front of a
▶ Play
circuit court? Well, the expedited hearings in front of the circuit court, and I realize we can't make them do anything, but this emphasizes that if a person comes and this presents themselves, that we would like them to expedite it. But as far as the agency head and what the agency uses, that's pretty much patterned after what they currently do. They would pull together a panel to hear the information, and if they rendered an opinion that, yes, this person really had some legitimate cause to come forward, it would allow them to be able to retain their job, put on administrative leave to make sure they don't get fired while
▶ Play
the civil process runs its course. I recognize for a follow-up. My only reservation about, I mean, they have a priority for criminal defendants in custody to give them an immediate hearing. FOIA cases, gosh, those are the only two that come to mind, but I know there's a whole list of things that they're supposed to take care of rat now and this is another one
▶ Play
so well to relieve your your concern page two line one may request an expedited hearing that don't mean they're going to get one but they may go before a judge and request one so this creates that avenue for them in that particular situation to be able to get you know get the request before the judge so it's not a shell it's a may and we all know, there's only so much judge
▶ Play
time to go around. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions? Hearing none, are you ready to close for your bill? Uh,
▶ Play
members, we can pass all the whistleblower laws you want. And I had a lady who could have came testify, a classic example. That's why I brought this forward, but I respect for time for the committee. Um, you know, I, I didn't, but she was in front of legislative audit. That's when this idea sprung up, uh, when she came before it, This gives those employees out there that have information some coverage that if they blow the whistle, they know out of retaliation, they're not going to get fired, provided they can come before that body that's conforming with what's currently allowed and be able to show that there's just cause for why they ought to be afforded what's allowed in this bill. So I think for that reason, I believe it'll help make sure that we keep pure government. If somebody out there knows something, they'll have the means to bring it before. It also only allows in cases where it's legitimate, not vendettas against your boss, because it's got to pass the high bar test. With that, I'd appreciate a good vote, and, Mr. Chair, I'd move to
▶ Play
do pass. All right, I have a motion to do pass on HB 2055. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Congratulations, Representative. Your bill passed. Thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair, members of the committee. All right, Representative Flowers, you're recognized, and then Representative Gray, we're taking up her bill next, and then we won't do any more business, I promise, committee. Thank you very much.
▶ Play
You're recognized. And I appreciate you waiting around, Representative Flowers. It's been interesting. I bet. I'm glad to be here. This is a hard-working committee. I see. I'm here today to present. First of all, thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm here to bring before you House Bill 2169, and just the title makes it really simple to describe exactly what it is, An Act of Transfer Oversight of the Arkansas Entertainers Hall of Fame to the Advertising and Tourist Promotion Commission of the City of Pine Bluff. This came about because this has been under the oversight of parks and tourism. The board has been relatively inactive. The fundraising efforts have not netted very much money since the first event that they had. And so they came to me wanting to see if the city of Pine Bluff wanted it. All of the artifacts are already owned and on display in Pine Bluff at the convention center. We pulled together Kane Webb, the director of parks and tourism, along with the mayor. They were both agreeable. The governor is agreeable to this, as well as those who are signed on as co-sponsors, which is basically the Pine Bluff delegation. And so I'm just here to bring it before you. It's a good bill that really doesn't do much. It's actually an efficiency bill. Okay. Thank you. Any questions from committee? Representative Gray, you
▶ Play
recognize for a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just one quick question. Sure. They talked
▶ Play
about the monies would be sent by warrant. Is there anything in there? There is. It's about $30,000. Okay, that's fine. I'd have a motion at the proper
▶ Play
time. Okay. Representative Gonzalez, you recognize no question? Okay. Any other questions of the committee? Representative Gray, what's your motion? Motion do pass. Okay, we have a motion do pass. If you want to close for your bill, Representative Flowers, but, you know, once you've got an offer, it's probably good to take it. Closed. Okay, great. All right. The motion is do pass. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, congratulations.
▶ Play
You passed your bill. Thank you. I'm going to go tell everybody this place is not
▶ Play
really that scary. All right, we'll see how scary it is. Representative Gregg, you're recognized around your bill. I appreciate that. All right, we're going to go right back to the top of the agenda, to the bill we've been passing over, over and over, 1707. And you have an amendment, apparently.
▶ Play
Yes, I do. Adopt your amendment. I do. Thank you. The amendment, so there's been a little bit of confusion. I'll try and make this fast. Secretary of State's office was working with Representative Charlotte Douglas to move the preferential primary. Right now it's three weeks before the general primary, and they were working to make it four weeks before the general primary. As I've kind of vetted that, I do think that that's a fine. I mean, I'm good with that. The people that I've vetted it with and my colleagues seem to be okay with that. So essentially, I have to adopt that amendment because this is date specific. So make a motion. Do pass. Okay. We have
▶ Play
a motion to adopt the amendment. All in favor, say aye. Opposed? All right. Your amendment is adopted. you to recognize and
▶ Play
run your bill. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. And this bill is one that moves the primary. So what we did this last presidential election in 2016, we moved the primary, I think with the exact number of votes needed to March. And we put a sunset on it. And so for the next election cycle in 2018, we go back to a preferential primary in May. So what this bill does is it moves the primary back to March. There is no sunset on it, so this would leave it in statute until that statute was possibly changed again in the future. And let me say this, this is not a do or die issue for me. I think this is a good idea. This is what the majority of the people in my district want and what I've heard quite a few legislators want. Essentially, what I'm asking for is to let the full body vote on it to decide if this is what we want to do or not what we want to do. So this is not a do or die. I just think it's good policy. I did, and I'll be quick, I did pull some numbers. Yeah, okay. I did pull some numbers. It's way too quiet. We'll ignore what's going on in that room over there. Yeah, I don't even want... If Wardlaw's in there, I don't want to know. So I pulled some numbers, and I looked at – so one of my questions – I talked to the Secretary of State's office about this, and Kelly Boyd was possibly splitting the presidential primary from the rest of the preferential primary. We tried that, and so I went and pulled the numbers from 2008. We had a good turnout for the presidential primary in February of about 34% of the registered voters. And then May, for our preferential, we had a record low of 18% turnout. So we don't want that to happen. That split's not good. So then we fast-forward to 2012. It went back to May for everything. We had a 21.83% turnout, so only about 335,000 people out of 1.5 million voted. Then we come back to 2016, 49.2% turnout when we moved it to March. so we were in that super SEC primary, 832,800 people out of 1.7 million voted. I mean, the numbers are staggering as to the amount of turnout we actually had when we had the primary in March and made it, it made my district, it made my constituents feel like they had a voice in the presidential primary. It brought a lot more people out to vote and got people a lot more interested in their government. So that's what I'm doing today is bringing this here. It also addresses fiscal session. Essentially, this is the same bill that we ran before without the sunset. So it does address fiscal session and moves fiscal session, if I believe, if I remember correctly, to April, just like we did before. And that's it. I would take questions.
▶ Play
Okay. Any questions from the committee? Representative Sabin, you're recognized for a question. Sure. And I don't know
▶ Play
whether it's because it's late, but I feel like I've got a couple of really dumb questions. It's okay. I apologize. So the difference between a preferential primary and a general primary, what is that? I'll let the Secretary of State's office explain that. I'm looking at Kelly while I ask
▶ Play
Speaker 176 1:25:58
that because I don't understand the difference between the two terms.
▶ Play
What I think, and they'll probably tell me I'm wrong, come on up, is that the preferential primary, which is held right now three weeks, I'm trying to make it four weeks before the general, Preferential is when what we all know is the primary, and then the general would be the runoff. Is there some kind of runoff or some kind of something? He just
▶ Play
Speaker 178 1:26:26
put his thumb up, so that's... Woo-hoo! I never heard that term that
▶ Play
Speaker 179 1:26:29
way, but... Peyton Murphy, Assistant Director of Elections for the Secretary of State. That is correct. The general primary is what we commonly call the primary runoff.
▶ Play
Okay. I've learned something every day here. That's good to know. I think that answers the rest of my questions, then, because I was genuinely confused, but now I think it makes sense. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. And I would
▶ Play
like to say that this bill, as it encumbrances Representative Douglas' three-week to four-week change, if this were to make it through, she would not have a need to run her bill, and she's aware of that and fine with that. But if this doesn't, that's why her bill is out there.
▶ Play
All right. Any other questions from the committee? You know, well, I'll save this for discussion. No other questions from the committee? All right. You
▶ Play
recognize the close for your bill? Thank you. I'm closed for my bill, and I'd
▶ Play
make a motion to do pass as amended. Okay. We have a motion to do pass on the table. I'll start discussion. You know, my opinion on it is kind of like hers. You know, I don't necessarily care where it's at, but I do like the idea of nailing it down. And I think because of presidential elections, I think moving it up early will make it where we'll have a little more of a voice. So I do appreciate you carrying this bill, and I do believe it's something that the body I'll have a chance to vote on. But having said that, there is a motion on table. Any other discussion? Okay. Yeah. The motion is do pass as amended. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? No. All right. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair and colleagues. All right. Anybody else have anything that they want to run who's in this committee? Want to keep us here any longer? All right. Well, I sure appreciate your hard work, committing. There is actually, I want to set the speaker's resolution for special order on Friday, first out on Friday. So without objection, we're going to set that for special order. And seeing no other business, we are adjourned. Thank you.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1807

0:14 - 11:34 40 segments 7 speakers

Representative Charlie Collins introduced HB 1807, explaining that continuing the current birth- and death-certificate fees would fund bond repayment for a new health-care building and avoid a projected $5 million budget shortfall beginning in 2020. [0:18] [0:33] [1:06] [1:39] [2:11] [2:44]

Rep. Douglas House asked about the trust-fund balance and parking needs, and Deputy Health Director Ann Purvis testified that the trust fund has no balance, parking is a critical concern, and the existing bonds carry an interest rate of less than 3 percent. [3:16] [3:41] [3:50] [4:22] [4:44] [4:49]

The committee heard no opposition, a motion to pass the bill was made by Rep. Bladyman and carried unanimously, approving HB 1807. [5:55] [6:10]

SB373 AMENDMENT

11:34 - 22:12 26 segments 4 speakers

Chair Rep. Bob Ballinger presented the amendment to SB 373, stating it would create a narrow exemption for attorney-client communications and work product related only to pending or threatened litigation, with specific definitions and a sunset provision of 30 days after litigation or one year after a threat. [11:59] [12:32] [13:04] [13:36] [14:07] [14:39] [15:11] [15:43] [16:20] [16:52] [17:25]

He emphasized the need to protect the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act while allowing government attorneys to serve the public effectively, and clarified that the amendment replaces the original bill’s language rather than merely adding to it. [18:01] [18:33] [19:04]

Rep. Douglas House asked whether the amendment would delete Section 24 of the original bill, and the chair confirmed that the amendment supersedes the prior sections, effectively removing them. [19:47] [20:10] [20:20]

The committee voted on the amendment, with a motion carried unanimously, approving the amended SB 373. [20:41]

SB373

22:12 - 1:00:04 107 segments 15 speakers

Attorney Joey McCutcheon testified that SB 373 would dramatically expand the attorney-client exemption, effectively gutting Arkansas’s Freedom of Information Act by allowing any communication related to litigation strategy to be shielded and warned that “threatened litigation” could be abused. [22:49] [23:20] [23:57] [24:27] [25:01] [25:33] [26:04] [26:34] [27:07] [27:37] [28:17] [28:49] [29:24]

Jim Parsons, Dan Greenberg, and Brad Phelps-argued that existing court-order protections already address the issue and that the bill’s broad exemption could be misused, with Greenberg illustrating a scenario where a “sister-in-law” call could perpetually extend secrecy. [35:20] [35:48] [36:30] [37:03] [37:11] [37:22] [37:37] [38:04] [38:10] [38:44] [39:17] [39:48] [40:22]

After limited questioning, the committee moved to pass SB 373 as amended, and the motion carried unanimously. [58:50] [59:01]

HB2029

1:00:04 - 1:08:51 31 segments 7 speakers

Rep. Warwick Sabin introduced HB 2029 to create a modest 16-hour caregiver leave funded from the catastrophic leave pool, emphasizing its limited fiscal impact and narrow definition of eligible family members. [1:00:16] [1:00:50]

Human-resources analyst Susie Barthol testified about her personal need for caregiver leave, illustrating how the lack of such time forces employees to choose between work and caring for aging parents. [1:02:53] [1:03:00] [1:03:38] [1:04:11] [1:04:46] [1:05:20]

The committee adopted Sabin’s amendment and passed the bill as amended without opposition. [1:01:12] [1:01:21] [1:01:29] [1:07:46] [1:07:56]

SB448

1:08:51 - 1:11:07 11 segments 4 speakers

Senate Bill 448, presented by Rep. Jeff Wardlaw, would permit the state procurement officer to negotiate prices on RFQs and RFPs after the lowest-responsible-bidder is identified, with an estimated savings of up to $2 million. [1:09:04] [1:09:12] [1:09:18] [1:09:31] [1:09:40] [1:10:13]

After brief clarification that the authority applies only to non-bid qualifications and no substantive opposition, the committee moved to adopt the amendment and passed the bill. [1:10:20] [1:10:29] [1:10:36] [1:10:43]

SB584

1:11:07 - 1:14:25 15 segments 6 speakers

Representative Bob Ballinger presented Senate Bill 584, proposing that the Arkansas Supreme Court be allowed to set its own hiring standards for an executive director, removing current qualification restrictions. [1:11:25] [1:11:29] [1:12:01]

Representative Douglas House asked whether the proposal reflected Chief Justice Kemp’s wishes, and Ballinger indicated it likely did. [1:12:15] [1:12:20] [1:12:23]

No committee members sought to speak for or against the measure; Chair Jack Ladyman moved a due-pass, which carried unanimously. [1:12:31] [1:12:50] [1:12:55] [1:13:02]

HB2055

1:14:25 - 1:19:22 18 segments 5 speakers

Representative Kim Hammer introduced House Bill 2055, a whistleblower protection bill that would provide expedited judicial hearings and rulemaking authority to shield employees from retaliation. [1:14:41] [1:15:15]

Representative Douglas House queried whether the expedited hearing would occur before a circuit-court judge or an agency head; Hammer clarified it would be before a circuit-court judge with a panel review. [1:15:45] [1:15:58] [1:16:16]

After brief discussion, Chair Jack Ladyman moved to do-pass the bill, and the motion passed without opposition. [1:17:20] [1:17:28] [1:18:04] [1:18:26] [1:18:35]

HB2169

1:19:22 - 1:21:37 8 segments 4 speakers

Representative Vivian Flowers presented House Bill 2169, which would transfer oversight of the Arkansas Entertainers Hall of Fame to Pine Bluff’s Advertising and Tourist Promotion Commission to improve efficiency and fundraising. [1:19:37] [1:20:07]

Representative Michelle Gray asked about the $30,000 warrant payment, which was confirmed, and then moved to do-pass; the committee approved the motion unanimously. [1:20:25] [1:20:33] [1:20:37] [1:20:42]

HB1707

1:21:37 - 1:28:22 23 segments 6 speakers

Representative Michelle Gray offered an amendment to House Bill 1707 to shift the primary election date from three to four weeks before the general primary, citing higher voter turnout in March primaries and related fiscal-session timing. [1:21:40] [1:22:15] [1:22:23] [1:22:30] [1:22:48] [1:23:22] [1:23:55] [1:24:26] [1:25:02]

Representative Warwick Sabin sought clarification on the difference between preferential and general primaries, which staff explained; the amendment was adopted and the bill was do-passed as amended without opposition. [1:25:40] [1:25:45] [1:25:58] [1:26:05] [1:26:26] [1:26:29] [1:26:37] [1:26:50] [1:27:07] [1:27:17] [1:27:20] [1:27:39]

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
69 segments
Representative Charlie Collins Unverified
8 segments
Representative Douglas House Unverified
28 segments
Ann Purvis Unverified
5 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
16 segments
Speaker 24
1 segment
Representative Jack Ladyman Chair Unverified
31 segments
Speaker 49
1 segment
Joey Mccutcheon Unverified
22 segments
Speaker 71
5 segments
Dan Greenberg Unverified
8 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
13 segments
David Curran Unverified
7 segments
Representative Justin Gonzales Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 105
6 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 115
1 segment
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
13 segments
Susie Barthol Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 56
1 segment
Speaker 139
1 segment
Speaker 129
1 segment
Speaker 39
1 segment
Representative Vivian Flowers Unverified
4 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
14 segments
Speaker 176
1 segment
Speaker 178
1 segment
Speaker 179
1 segment