Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Governmental Affairs

March 20, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·1:20:36
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026

SB701 36:05

[106] [36:19]

[107-108] [36:52] [36:57]

HB1008 37:39

Representative Michelle Gray introduced HB 1008, which amends the ethics statute to add “knowingly taking” to the prohibition on using campaign funds as personal income and aligns penalties with existing categories B, C, and D. [37:50] [38:10] [38:15] [38:21] [38:38] [38:43] [39:13] [39:44]

[112-118,120-125] [38:15] [38:21] [38:38] [38:43] [39:13] [39:44] [40:15] [40:38] [40:45] [41:05] [41:20] [41:56] [42:12]

SB426 46:50

Graham Sloan, director of the Arkansas Ethics Commission, explained that SB 426 updates reporting requirements for ballot-question committees, distinguishes entities that receive contributions from those that spend over $10,000 of their own funds, removes unconstitutional paid-canvasser reporting provisions, and clarifies filing locations for district judges. [46:52] [46:56] [47:24] [48:00] [48:31] [49:06] [49:43]

Representative Kim Hendren raised a brief comment questioning whether the bill would further restrict FOIA laws, which was answered without further debate. [49:52]

The committee moved to pass SB 426, with Representative Davis making the motion, no opposition was recorded, and the ayes carried, resulting in the bill’s passage. [50:17] [50:47]

SB513 51:37

Representative Jim Dotson introduced Senate Bill 513, a “pro-Israel” measure prohibiting Arkansas public entities from contracting with or investing in companies that boycott Israel, outlining its findings and purpose. [51:56] [52:05] [52:20] [52:29] [52:43]

Representative Dan M. Douglas asked whether the bill targeted the Israeli government or all Israeli citizens, prompting clarification that the restriction applies to any company deemed anti-Israel or doing business with Israel’s enemies. [52:20] [52:29] [52:43]

The committee moved to pass SB 513, Representative Dobson made the motion, no discussion was offered, and the ayes carried, enacting the bill. [52:59]

HB1980 54:07

Representative Jim Dotson explained House Bill 1980, which would allow the display of the national motto “In God We Trust” on Arkansas public buildings provided the signage is funded solely through voluntary contributions to local school boards or the Building Authority Division. [54:12]

The committee heard no questions, proceeded to close the bill, and Representative Dobson moved to do pass; with unanimous aye votes, the bill was adopted. [54:46]

Representative Tim Lemons presented House Bill 1386, seeking to require the state library system to receive final copies of agency records-beyond the preliminary versions they already obtain-so that libraries can retain complete historical documents for research purposes. [55:42] [55:49]

HB1386 55:50

Committee members questioned the cost and necessity, with Representative Kim Hendren asking about financial impact and Representative Warwick Sabin inquiring why only preliminary copies were previously provided; Lemons responded that the bill merely mandates a paper copy with no significant expense. [56:29] [56:44] [56:55] [57:09] [57:15] [57:26]

After discussion concluded, Representative Wardlaw moved to do pass the bill, no opposition was recorded, and the motion carried, passing HB 1386. [57:41] [57:57]

HB1893 58:56

Representative Michelle Gray offered an amendment to House Bill 1893 that eliminates the Class D felony for failing to file the Act 557 procurement report and adds provisions allowing state agencies to issue requests for qualifications to create a statewide qualified vendor list for passenger motor vehicles, thereby expanding purchasing options beyond Little Rock. [58:59] [59:30] [59:33] [1:00:07] [1:00:37] [1:01:08] [1:01:38] [1:01:52]

Committee members sought clarification on the amendment’s impact, with Representative Jeff Wardlaw confirming that vendors on the list must match state bid prices and register with the Department of Procurement, and Representative Kim Hendren verifying that the amendment retained the $25,000 threshold and removed the misdemeanor language while retaining the felony removal. [1:01:54] [1:02:02] [1:02:05] [1:02:10] [1:02:42] [1:03:05] [1:03:13] [1:03:42] [1:03:47] [1:03:57] [1:04:01] [1:04:05] [1:04:19]

Additional concerns were raised by Representatives Dan Douglas and others about whether the changes would weaken fraud safeguards; the sponsors assured that only the felony penalty was being removed and no fraud protections were altered. [1:04:27] [1:04:54] [1:05:25] [1:05:47]

The committee moved to pass HB 1893 as amended, Representative Ward-Long made the motion, no opposition was voiced, and the ayes carried, enacting the amended bill. [1:08:16]

HB1988 1:09:10

Representative Bob Ballinger introduced House Bill 1988, which would raise the per-prisoner reimbursement to county jails from $30 to $35 per day-a $5 increase annually for 25 years, estimating a $2.75 million yearly cost to the state. [1:09:12] [1:09:25] [1:09:30] [1:09:33] [1:09:41]

Committee members questioned the bill’s funding source and impact, with concerns raised about the state’s tight budget, the reliance on county taxes, and the need for counties to find additional money, while Ballinger noted the increase would barely cover existing costs. [1:09:45] [1:10:06] [1:10:15] [1:10:27] [1:10:35] [1:10:42] [1:10:46] [1:11:13] [1:11:18] [1:11:34]

After discussion, Representative Smith moved to do pass the bill, but the committee voted 10 ayes to 2 nays, resulting in the bill’s failure to pass. [1:12:00] [1:12:13] [1:12:20]

HB2183 1:13:11

Representative Brandt Smith presented an amendment to the whistleblower legislation in House Bill 2183, redefining the proper authority for forwarding allegations to the Internal Audit division of the Department of Finance and Administration and adding a provision allowing the Attorney General to be notified of fraud cases. [1:13:17] [1:13:23] [1:13:57] [1:14:06]

He argued that the current law’s focus on reporting to supervisors creates a chilling effect, and the amendment would both streamline reporting and increase the employee reward for successful waste or fraud recoveries from 10 % to 20 %. [1:14:27] [1:15:05] [1:15:39] [1:15:58] [1:16:11] [1:16:18] [1:16:44] [1:17:41]

The committee heard no further questions, and Representative Wardlaw moved to do pass the amended bill; despite unanimous aye votes on the amendment, the overall bill failed with 10 ayes and 2 nays, leading to its defeat. [1:18:30] [1:18:41] [1:19:13] [1:19:43] [1:20:22]

Bills discussed (11)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1008 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1008”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1386 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1386”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1893 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1893”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1980 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1980”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1988 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1988”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2183 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2183”
Pre-2017 bill
HB2242 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB2242”
Pre-2017 bill
HJR1003 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HJR1003”
Pre-2017 bill
SB426 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB426”
Pre-2017 bill
SB513 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB513”
Pre-2017 bill
SB701 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB701”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
Chair sees a quorum. We're going to run HJR 1003 first. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized to run joint resolution number 1003. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I appreciate
▶ Play
so many members of the committee showing up when it's so late. I'm going to try to make this as quick as possible, but also answer any questions we may have. We have ran this before, but we did it in the subcommittee, so I want to make sure. And then, of course, on the House floor, but we haven't really had a chance to dig into it. So as much as you all feel like you need to dig into it, then we will. I'm just going to go through it. So if the amendment, the latest amendment is actually the bill. In fact, I think that that's what we need to do is adopt the amendment first.
▶ Play
Ms. Sherry, there is an amendment to this, correct? Yeah. You're
▶ Play
speaking on the amendment? Yeah, I think that Ms. Sherry, don't we need to adopt the latest amendment? Okay, so if I will, I'll just move that we adopt the latest amendment. The amendment actually is the bill. We've included everything, and I'll go over it in just a minute. So I'd make a motion to adopt
▶ Play
the amendment. Okay, the motion do pass on Joint Resolution 1003 Amendment. The amendment, yes, sir. Yes. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor say aye. All opposed, nay. Ayes have it. Motion carries. your amendment is
▶ Play
passed. Okay, so I think everybody has a copy of the amendment in front of you, the members, and if you don't, then I know that the committee would be happy to get you one. And so I'm going to just go over the amendment, and then I'm going to try to go over it pretty quickly, and then I'll answer any questions that anybody has after that, and then we'll go from there. Okay, so the first thing that you'll notice is that it has a two and a half page title. And the reason is, is we're complying with the same standard that the public has when it comes to the title. So there is a certain standard that public has to have, but we're going to do the same thing in order to, because the fact that this resolution itself calls for constitutional amendments to meet that standard, it would be kind of hypocritical if we didn't at least try. So the substance of the resolution starts on page three. And actually, if somebody can give me a copy, I have a draft version of it. If someone could give me a copy of the actual resolution, it'll help me with the numbering of it. Yes, thank you so much, of the amendment. Okay, this will end up being kind of the same on the amendment. But on page three, you look under section one. The first part of it, you'll see some underlying stricken stuff because there's cleanup that's in it. But then if you see, what we've done is move up the date from when the names need to be, the signatures need to be submitted to 180 days prior to the election day. And the reason for that is it gives time, and it is a tight time constraints, but it is a time constraints that will actually make it where by August 15th, There can be a challenge, and we'll know for sure whether or not a title is actually going to be on the ballot and valid or not before we actually have to print the ballots. And so that's what that's about. That's one of the reasons for the bill. The rest of that page is basically cleanup. Then if you look on page 4, in the middle you see one paragraph under B2 that's all underlined, and this increases the threshold from 15 counties. that has to add the requisite number of signatures to 25 counties. And this is only for a constitutional amendment. So if you look above that, that is still 15 counties if somebody is wanting to do an initiated act. So if they want to pass a bill, Representative Lemon's bored by what we have going on here. But, you know, this is the thing. This is rather technical. Yeah, I called him out. You better hide if we're going to do that. This is rather technical, but I don't know of any other way to do it and just go through it like this. So, you know, I'll try to make it as quick as possible. But we've increased the threshold. So we're going to increase the threshold on us. We're also going to increase the threshold on the public to amend the Constitution. And the policy reason behind that is to try to create a stable, consistent Constitution. If the citizen wants to do an initiated act, then that standard has not been increased. But if we're going to actually amend the Constitution, something more permanent, we're going to try to make it more permanent. All right. Then going to page five at the top, consistent with that, you see in section B, which the first paragraph that's underlined here, that is actually requires three-fifths for it to actually be adopted. It has to pass by three-fifths or 60% for a constitutional amendment to be adopted. Then down here, you'll see in the middle, it actually creates a mechanism where we could do a proposed law. So the legislature could propose as many as three acts. And the reason why you'd want that is that there is something that's fairly big and significant that we would debate, but then we'd want to actually send it out to the public for them to approve. And it's just a little bit of sort of a relation of direct democracy, just that's the policy change. And this is, you know, a lot of this stuff is stuff that other legislators had wanted in different places, or the Speaker, one of that was one of the things that particularly the Speaker had suggested. suggested um if you look one of the things that's important is that it will be that we'll propose those only during a regular session and the the vote would be in a general session on it and then down there you'll see towards the bottom it's where it's limited no more than three um okay and then there's no change in referring out the bond issues all that is still still the same all All right, if you go to page six, the bottom of that first paragraph. All right, so this is for the challenge on the title. Now, this is not the challenge on the signatures, but a challenge to be sufficient on the title as used on the ballot must be no later than 60 days after the filing of the petition of the selection. And then if you look in the next paragraph is actually a challenge on the signatures. And that is you have to make the challenge on the signatures within 30 days from when the signatures are actually certified by the Secretary of State. All right. Then on page 7, at the top, you see the increased threshold for the 25 counties again. Then if you go down to the bottom half, the second half of page 7, you see the increased threshold on us. So for us to refer out a constitutional amendment, it requires a vote of two-thirds passage in order for it to actually be referred out for the public to do that. The policy reason is the same as it is on the public. What we're doing is we're creating a burden on us to actually amend the Constitution. We have the ability to pass laws all the time. But if we're going to touch something like the Constitution, then it's going to either take something that there's a very popular thing or it's relatively benign and just clean up stuff that has no, it's not controversial. And I think that that creates a little more stable constitution. And then if you look down at the very bottom of seven is where you will get into the standard. It's the same standard that the public has on a ballot title that would be intelligible, honest, and impartial. And so we're incorporating that standard as our standard. Now, there's a little bit of a unique situation. So what will happen is just like the public will go to the AG, the AG will judge it and decide whether it's sufficient or not. Well, if it's the public, they'll give it back to the person who's made the application if it's not sufficient in order for them to amend it. In this case, what the AG will do is give it back to the legislature. And to decide how that will happen, we'll need to actually pass enabling legislation to say exactly the process. Probably the process, it'll be ALC when we're not in session. And my recommendation would be that the committees of state agencies, both in the House and Senate, would meet to reform the ballot title, make it consistent with the AG's opinion. But that's not that is not being debated here. So that'll be debated enabling legislation if this is actually passed. We are actually keeping the same thing with the popular name, the same standard. And then we're also keeping the same standard. So if a citizen were to challenge the ballot title, then currently the standard that the court uses is and you'll see that starts at the at the bottom of page eight and goes into the top of page nine. And currently, the standard is whether it's manifest fraud or not. So the court gives us deference on the amendments that we give out and the ballot titles that we have. Well, we're keeping that same deference that the court gives us, but we're actually creating a new level of scrutiny on our ballots by having the AG actually have responsibility to approve it by this standard. And then anything that we pass out also has to be approved by a 60% vote in order for it to actually amend the Constitution. If you look down at the bottom of page 9, you'll see a section that says that there will be no private benefits given to any individual or any corporation specifically. So we're not going to name a corporation when we amend the Constitution. And if you look down at the kind of the three quarters or one quarter of the way down on page 10, you see what the popular name of the ballot title. We're constraining ourselves into the same standard the public has. And so it's not real sexy or exciting, but it's a constitutional amendment concerning proposed measures and constitutional amendments considered by voters at an election. So that's going to be the popular name of the title. We had a lot of work that's been put into this, but I do understand that we are admitting the Constitution. It is kind of an important thing, so I would be happy to try to entertain any questions and answer whatever I can. Representative Ballinger, I had
▶ Play
a question, actually. Yes, sir. On page six there, section seven, where it talks about 30 days to challenge, is that a change? I mean, did the number of days change on that? You know what I'm talking
▶ Play
about? Yes, yeah, and I think that it has. So what we're doing is we're actually putting in some new barriers or limitations, And we actually need to be able to do that in order to squeeze everything into the time frame. But this is 30 days to make a challenge on the signatures themselves. So that is just a matter of somebody getting together and deciding whether they're going to make
▶ Play
that challenge or not. Okay. All right. All right. Any questions from the committee? Representative Douglas, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. The section that we were just looking at on that front page, where it's talking about 30 days, no more than 90 days? Yeah. What was that? I'm on page one. Page one. Well, I'm actually in the ballot title, but where is that in the actual bill? Okay, let me give you
▶ Play
a couple of things. I don't remember you talking about it. To figure out which one you're actually concerned about. So the first place that you'll see the 180 days is on page three, right in the middle. And what that 180 days is, is the requirement for the signature to be turned in prior to the election day, whatever date the election day is on. And so that sort of starts the clock ticking, is the submission of the ballots with the names. And then the other section that we were talking about just now is on page six. And then you have a challenge to the title. It has to be made no later than 60 days after the filing of the petition. So that 100 days prior to the election, then essentially 120 days prior to the election or 60 days after that submission is when they have to make the challenge on the
▶ Play
ballot title. Okay, so that's the petition you're talking about. What was that before we said 30 days, 30 to 90? Okay, the 30
▶ Play
days, okay, I'm sorry. You may be talking about something else, and I'm not sure what you're. I can just find
▶ Play
it in the title, but I don't see it in the body of the bill. I'm right in the middle of your title
▶ Play
where it says... Okay, I think that you are talking about a section that is primarily just cleanup, and it would be down... But the question
▶ Play
was, what was it before you put, change it to?
▶ Play
There is a, there was an issue that has dealt with the, let me find it, that dealt with the counties and cities that was originally a, dealt with a referendum and who has the authority. There's a little bit of conflict in the constitutional, in the constitution. Originally, we had it set, so it cleared it up the way I thought it ought to be cleared up, but it's not the same way that cities and counties thought it needed to be cleared up, so we actually end up doing it the way cities and counties in order just to avoid any conflict on it. And essentially, it gives the authority to the cities and counties to set those dates. And it doesn't change what the cities and counties interpretation of it was. It just makes it where it's clear that they have the authority to set that time, and it's not the legislature that sets it. And does that go towards your question? I think so.
▶ Play
So you're talking about the quorum court and the time that they had to. Or the city council. Yes, to accept a petition saying that they disagree.
▶ Play
That is correct. So, and that's actually, I found it. So it's
▶ Play
on the bottom of page four. Okay. Okay. So my question was, we're changing it to 30
▶ Play
to 180? No. So that 180 is something altogether different. 30 to 90. Yeah. No, we're actually not making a change on that. I mean, if you look, most of that is the same. What we've done is provide a little bit of clarity as to who actually has the authority to do that.
▶ Play
Okay. Let me look at it, and I'll get back in
▶ Play
the queue. Yep. Well, we don't have any questions in the queue, so you're up if
▶ Play
you've got another question, Representative Douglas. I'm not sure you answered my question. It seemed like it was a much lower number in the past, like a week, and now we're increasing
▶ Play
it. Is that not right? No. Okay. So prior to this and after this, the Constitution provision in this section, in Article 5, said that a city will provide no less than 30 days and no more than 90 days in order to submit a referendum. And this is definitely not my area of expertise, but what this does is this actually goes back to that standard. So originally, we were going to try to clean that up because there's also in the section says that general laws will override a city ordinance. Well, in order to just basically we've just agreed to amend it in such a way to make it clear and take that part out that would make it where the general laws would override. Does that make
▶ Play
sense at all? Yes, it does. I just wonder if we need to hear from a municipality or a county
▶ Play
and just see how that's going to affect them. Yeah, well, that's what I'd be happy, especially if they're signed
▶ Play
up to speak on the bill. Okay, thank you. Probably wouldn't be a bad idea. All right, are there any other questions from the committee? Hearing none, we do have some people in the audience to speak against the bill. Scott Trotter, would you come
▶ Play
to the end of the table? Mr. Chairman, I believe Mr. Trotter had to leave, so I don't believe he's here.
▶ Play
Okay. All right. Jerry Cox, then you're up to speak against the bill. So, Mr. Cox, would you identify yourself for the record? Yes, sir.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Jerry Cox. I'm the director of Family Council. And if I could find a category that was not for or against, I'd probably be speaking from that vantage point. Because this particular measure is not all bad. In fact, some parts of it are very good. And so in that regard, you know, I could be very complimentary about the way some of this is put together. Just to give you a little bit of background, the organization that I represent, has been a part of five citizen-initiated ballot efforts. So that means that I've been through this process of going out, getting a measure drafted, taking it to the Attorney General, getting them to approve it, and then drawing up petitions and going out across the state of Arkansas and gathering enough signatures to qualify for the ballot and going through all the legal challenges that you have to go through many times to finally get your measure to a vote and then run the campaign. That would be for the Arkansas Marriage Amendment back in 2004. That would be for Amendment 68, which is the pro-life amendment that most of us are really proud of, and also the Adoption and Foster Care Act that was passed in 2008. And then we had two failed attempts at getting the pro-life amendment passed before that. And so I won't say that I know everything there is to know about this issue, but I sure have lived on the side of the issue of being the proponent of it. And I will tell you this, the mortality rate among people that try to exercise this option is, like, really high because it's just so difficult to be able to take a measure from inception all the way through to make it into a law. And so I would not really be for anything that makes it harder on regular folks out here who live here in Arkansas who wish to exercise their rights under Amendment 7 and under Article 5 of the Constitution to be able to draw up a petition and get something on the ballot and bring it to a vote. I mean, I wouldn't want to encumber that. And I think we're all aware that one of the real problems has been these out-of-state groups that come in as hired guns and gather signatures and get paid $3 or $4 a name. And they'll tell people anything to get them to sign the petition. And so, if anything, I think the way this is drawn up, when it says you've got to have, instead of a simple majority, you've got to have 60% of the vote, that favors those people that have money. Because they can just keep running ads and running ads until they finally persuade enough people that they get to that 60% threshold. The other thing that this measure does is it increases the number of counties that you have to what's called validate. And I don't know how familiar you are with the process, but rightfully so. It's drawn up in such a way that a group can't just get all their signatures from Pulaski County and amend the Constitution and affect every other part of the state. What you have to do is get signatures from at least 15 counties, and you have to get a certain number from those 15 counties. Well, this ups it to 25, which is not a problem, really, for a group that has a lot of money. They can go hire canvassers to drive down to Monticello and get signatures or drive down to El Dorado or wherever. But if you're a little guy just limping along on a shoestring, then I think it makes it harder on those folks to be able to actually get their measure to the ballot. Does it make it impossible? No, it doesn't. Will it stop that process? No, I don't believe it will. Will it put some extra hurdles up there for an already cumbersome and difficult process? Yes, I believe it will do that. The other thing that this measure does is Representative Ballinger mentioned manifest fraud. That's being now enshrined into our Constitution, where up to now it's sort of been the court kind of viewed it that way. And what I mean by this is this. If I, as a citizen, go out and draw up a petition and want to put it on the ballot, Somebody can challenge me before the Supreme Court, and the court can take me off the ballot, guess what, for any reason whatsoever. This would set a different standard for the legislature than it would for regular folks, because regular folks could have their measure taken off the ballot just for any reason that the court wanted. But for a legislative measure that was put on the ballot, they'd have to be guilty of manifest fraud, which is never going to be proven. I mean, it's never going to happen. And so pretty much this says that no measure referred by the legislature is going to be able to be removed from the ballot by the court, no matter really pretty much how bad the title is. I think that's going to be the end result of it. The other thing this does is it puts a lot of authority on the attorney general. And we all may say, well, that's good, as long as the attorney general is someone we agree with. But I've been out here long enough, and many of you have, where we had attorneys general that I did not agree with, and they probably didn't agree with us much. And so the more power that you put over there, the greater the likelihood is that that could come back on you. Last thing, Mr. Chair, and I thank you for letting me talk as long as I have, But if you look at the number of measures that have been put on the ballot by this body that did not get 60 percent of the vote over the last 20 years, there are about 10 measures that did not get 60 percent of the vote. One of those would be the term limits one, issue three that passed a few years ago that affected term limits and salaries. That would not have gone into effect had this been in place because it did not get 60 percent of the vote. Same thing is true for the Game and Fish tax that was passed, sales tax increase, revising the judicial article. And so be careful what you ask for on this because it may come back and be something that we're not real proud of. And so I, for that reason, would urge this, that this measure not pass in its current form, because most of us haven't had a chance to really thoroughly review these amendments. Most people just saw them recently. And so I think there's more good that could be done with it. Like I said, the part about the dates, that's wonderful, because that prevents these last-minute ballot challenges where people are suing two weeks before the election. That's all really good stuff. And there's some other good things in here, but it has enough not good in there that I would urge you not to support it. Mr. Chair, I appreciate you letting me talk this long, this late. Would you take questions? If you all want me to sit here, I'll be here to answer questions. Are there any questions from
▶ Play
the committee? Representative Emman? I don't know whether I can reach that outfit or not. Jerry, one of the things that bothers me about this deal is that I don't understand it. And I'm not sure anybody around this table understands it on the end or around it. And that's why that I had a proposal that just to make these ballot titles have the same standard for the legislature they do for the people. That was just a one-shot deal, which I'm just a simple guy. I can understand that a little bit better. And what's your comment about how can we modify this thing or change it so that the voters out there, maybe some of them are smarter than we are, I hope some of them are, that can understand this better than this 10 pages we've got here before us that's so difficult and raise those issues that you've just raised? Well,
▶ Play
and you make an excellent point. There are very few people in Arkansas that thoroughly understand the initiative process and all that has to be done with it. And quite frankly, I have to go back and review every time I do one of these to remember that I'm dotting all the I's and crossing the T's, and I've done a bunch of these. I think it would behoove us to get some people around the table who've actually done these, I mean, who've actually run these things. And I think those folks could share quite a bit with you about how to make the process run better than what it does right now. But I agree that it needs some work, And I agree with Representative Ballinger's intent to try to fix some things. I'm just not sure we're hitting the target with this. And in fact, I believe we're missing the target.
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Setting the bar up higher on the amount of counties that you
▶ Play
have to have. It's called validating. I think that's the term of
▶ Play
art. Yes, ma'am. But is that really getting the best cross-section of the state, or should it be almost a certain percentage from each congressional district? I know that sounds crazy, but, I mean, you can still sway a vote toward a certain part of the state, even raising the bar, as we have. What would your suggestion be on
▶ Play
that? Well, my suggestion on that is, and I'll tell you straight up, when I've done these, you just need to know, we have validated more than 25 counties on the ones that I have done, Representative Douglas. But that's because we went way over and above. Like on the marriage amendment, we had a lot of good support on that years ago, as you can imagine. And so we did. We went over that amount. But I will say this. I think the 15 counties seems to be a pretty reasonable number. In fact, I don't know of anybody that's really ever had an issue or a problem with that number of being 15, because that gets you outside of the bigger metropolitan areas, generally speaking. And so I would just leave that pretty much the way it is, I think. You could do congressional district. The spirit of that is that one part of the state would not be able to dictate to the rest of the state what goes on. And you could see how that could happen. If Little Rock, Fayetteville, and Fort Smith all got together, they could push the rest of the state around. And so that's the reason for that being the way it is.
▶ Play
So you're not saying that taking five counties from each congressional district would be an improvement? It would be too
▶ Play
much. It would be different, but I don't know if it would. It's hard to tell if that would be an improvement or
▶ Play
not. Okay. Thank you. And thank you for the follow-up,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. You're welcome. Seeing no other questions, we thank you for
▶ Play
your comments. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank you, committee, for letting me talk this late in the day. I appreciate it.
▶ Play
We have Eric Treat to speak for the bill. Mr. Treat, if you would,
▶ Play
identify yourself. Yes, Mr. Chairman, my name is Eric Treat. My name is Eric Treat, and I'd like to thank you and members of the committee for being here today They just think of this important, important initiative. As of a person with a disability, and most people with disability don't vote because they do not understand what's written in the ballot initiative. A lot of people with that disability don't understand what's on the initiative. And so that's why I'd like to see the ballot initiative to be written and written in language where everybody can understand it.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you, Mr. Treat, for your comments. Thank you. Appreciate it. All right. We don't have anyone else signed up to speak for or against the bills or anyone else in the audience that would like to speak. I'm seeing no one. Representative Ballinger,
▶ Play
you ready to close for your bill? I have a question for you.
▶ Play
Speaker 54 31:23
For Representative Ballinger. You have a question? Okay. Representative Douglas, go
▶ Play
ahead. I'm going to clear this up once and for all for my stumbling around a while ago. Let me give you a situation, and then let's see if I've understood it. let's say one of my municipalities, Lavaca, passes a dog leash law, when does that go into effect? Is it at the 30 days? If they vote it to be 30 days, they have to wait 30 days for any petition to be filed? Or are you changing it in here to another date? It's not being addressed in here at
▶ Play
all so that that that is not being addressed at all in this okay that's what I could not tell yeah the confusion is because there was going to be a change on something that was was a conflict that doesn't that actually is not changed here at all so any municipal county ordinances that isn't addressed by this okay thank you you know just basically in in closing is there are extra hurdles. There's no doubt. I mean, I do understand some people having some concerns about that, but that's the fundamental policy position is it shouldn't be so easy to amend the Constitution. The value of that is that it encourages people to go do initiated acts. I want citizens to be able to touch their government. We're not touching the initiated act. They can still do initiated acts. If you're going to amend the Constitution, then just like us, we're going to have a higher burden and hurdle that we'll have to convince the public that it's a good idea. We'll have to convince our fellow legislators it's a good idea in order to amend the Constitution. We pass bills all day long, but if we're going to amend the Constitution, it's going to have to be more important. We are actually putting ourselves through this under the same exact standard as the public when it comes to ballot titles. Now, the tool for redress, if it doesn't meet it, is different because what happens is it goes to the attorney general, attorney general approves it, and then it comes back to us because what we're trying to do is still keep the deference between the court and the legislature, you know, because we are ambitions, check ambitions. We're two separate branches. I appreciate the deference that the court has given to the legislature when it comes to referring constitutional amendments. I didn't want to mess that up. And so we've imported exactly the standard that the court uses as manifest fraud to put in this. So it's not, it doesn't change anything. We aren't adopting a new standard, where actually, to some extent, we are adopting new standards, the same standard the public is under, only the difference is it doesn't go to the court. It goes to the attorney general's office, who is the attorney for the state, who can make recommendation. We can come back and we can reform the title to make sure that it fits in with the same standard as the public. Essentially, this is something that we have worked hard on. I do appreciate some of the other ideas that people have presented. I think that probably everybody in this room has had the opportunity to visit it to be able to make folks even on the table, because it's come up at different times, and to make amendments. Some of the biggest opponents to this, the last amendment, the reason why we did it was to try to incorporate some of their concerns in this bill, because frankly, I want to have the very best resolution possible. Having said that, I do appreciate this committee, and I would move to pass.
▶ Play
Thank you, Representative Ballinger. Appreciate your closing for that. I'd like to recognize Representative Wardlaw for a motion as amended. Wardlaw made a motion do pass as amended any discussion on the motion I'd like to make a statement I think mr. treat presented why we need to do something very well there are many people that don't understand these ballot titles and I think he presented that very well at the end of the table so I think that's That's a good reason to bring this forward. Any other discussion? Hearing none, all in favor of the motion, say aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. The ayes have it. Motion carries. Representative Valger, your bill has passed. Thank you, committee. All right. Representative House, would you like to run SB 701?
▶ Play
Speaker 100 35:49
Mr. Chairman, a matter of personal privilege, these
▶ Play
two ladies have waited here all day long for this bill from the state police, and I just want to commend two noble civil servants for doing their job. Thank you. You're recognized, Representative House. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. There are federal and state guidelines on what you can use forfeited assets for. This bill says that it will be placed in a court awards fund, which shall consist of both state and federal asset. Forfeiture is managed by the treasurer. They can only be spent for certain things. Different accounts, the monies have to be segregated. I understand that. And you can only buy certain things out of each of those two funds. That's the bill. it sets up the accounts. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chairman. Any questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience who wants to speak for or against the bill? Hearing none, Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a motion. Have a motion do pass by Representative Wardlaw. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, an A. The ayes have it. Representative House, congratulations. The bill is passed. Representative Gray, do you want to run H-Bill 1008? And there is an amendment? House Bill 1008. House Bill number H-B-1008. It's been a long day. There is an amendment, and I think it's on your tablets. Yes, thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. The amendment adds one word or two words to the bill and adds the words knowingly taking. So I'd appreciate a good vote on that. And I'll explain it in the bill.
▶ Play
All right, is there any questions? Are you through presenting your bill? I'm through. I
▶ Play
make a motion. Do pass. Or adopt the amendment. I have a motion to adopt
▶ Play
the amendment. Any discussion on the motion to adopt the amendment? Hearing none, all in favor? Signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your amendment is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You're recognized to represent your
▶ Play
bill. Thank you. And Representative Tucker asked me to run this bill for him today as he could not be here. I am in agreement with this bill. And what it does is it takes the penalty for taking campaign funds as personal income, and it puts those in line with one of his other ethics bills that we ran earlier in the session that a majority of us did sign on to. And it essentially tiered out and made the code, the statute, more consistent as far as the penalties and their felony status, B, C, or D. And so this essentially takes campaign funds and if it's used for personal income and delineates them into B, C, and D categories for felonies. And it goes through the statute. It goes through essentially food, clothing, what else we have in here? Mortgage, rent payments. and then it also has a section where it shows kind of what's excluded as far as food and conferences and things like that. And page 4, line 28, where it says taking campaign funds as personal income is A, he added those words, the knowingly taking campaign funds as personal income, said he should not. He wished he hadn't overlooked that to start with, and I believe Representative Ballinger pointed that out to him, he said. So this puts this in line with the other ethics laws that we passed earlier in the session.
▶ Play
I'd be glad to take any questions. Are there any questions from the committee? Hearing none, is anyone in the audience here to speak for or against the bill? Hearing none, are you ready to close for your bill? Yes,
▶ Play
I'm closed. Do you want to make a motion?
▶ Play
Yes, motion do pass as amended. Okay, I have a motion do pass as amended by Representative Gray. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. I'm going
▶ Play
Speaker 118 41:05
to say the ayes have it. Representative Gray, your bill is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Roll call. I see two hands. Representative Ward-Law. Representative Ward-Law. Representative Hammer, Representative Hammer, Representative Eubanks, Representative Eubanks, Representative House, Representative House, Representative Douglas, Representative Douglas, Representative Dotson, Representative Dotson, Representative Miller, Representative Miller, Representative Womack, Representative Womack, Representative Davis, Representative Saban, Representative Hendren. Representative Drown, Representative Drown, Representative Gray, Representative Tosh, Representative Tosh, Representative Gonzales, Representative Ferguson, Representative Ferguson, Representative Representative Sturge? Representative Smith? Representative Smith? Representative Ballenger? Representative Ballenger? With three yays and
▶ Play
three no. The bill has failed. Thank you.
▶ Play
Mr. Chair and Committee. It's not mine. It's Representative Duggars. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Davis, do you have two bills to present? Representative Davis, which bill did
▶ Play
you want to present? Let's run the House bill
▶ Play
first. 22-42? 22-42, yes, sir. Okay. You're recognized to present 2242 House
▶ Play
Bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Committee. What we're doing in this currently, basically water usage records for individual water meters are exempt from FOI. And what we're doing here is just adding a section to say that the information could be provided if a person or entity is authorized by law to engage in planning or construction of a project that requires the release of the information. So we still wouldn't release personal information like a name or whatever, but occasionally Certainly when an engineer is trying to model a water system for a utility they may request the number of meters and the locations of water meters in a certain segment of the system. And while it's not real clear, some city attorneys have advised their utilities not to release that information based on this FOI exemption. So just trying to clarify that that could be allowed in the case of a planning or construction of a project. That's it. We have to take
▶ Play
questions. Any questions from the committee? Representative Dobson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
Representative Davis, I guess this raises the question, and I may be reading this correctly or maybe incorrectly, but an individual customer's data to identify, you know, what the usage usage rates are and the, as I recall, when we were looking at this a few years ago, the reason the exemption was put into place was so customers of public utilities couldn't be FOI'd and people could find out exactly when they were home, when they were not home, and that sort of data that usage rates might allow for. Does this allow for people to FOI individual customers' usage rates so we can tell, you know, they're home Monday through Friday or they're not home Monday through Friday and only
▶ Play
on the weekends or that sort of thing? It does allow them to use customer usage data, but I'm not sure. know names or anything like that, but as far as usage data, typically you're just talking about what quantity of water is used. I'm trying to think of an instance if I've ever seen it on a day. Typically, you know, meters are read on a monthly basis. As far as I know, there wouldn't be any data as detailed as what's used in a day. It's usually just in a month, and then we would use averages to try to break down how much is used in a week or a day and things like that. Thank you.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Are there any other questions from the committee? Hearing none, anyone in the audience who would like to speak for or against the bill? Representative Davis, would you like to close for your bill? I'm closed, and I move to do pass. Have a motion to do pass by Representative Davis. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor, signify by saying aye. Opposed, say nay. I'm going to say the ayes have it. Congratulations. Don't wait too long to go to the next one. Congratulations, Representative Davis. Your bill is passed. All right. Thank you. Did you want to run
▶ Play
a Senate bill? Senate Bill 426 is an Ethics Commission cleanup bill. and Mr. Graham's been here all day. Senate Bill
▶ Play
Speaker 137 46:46
426, okay. You're recognized to run your bill.
▶ Play
Would you tell us your name? Yes, my
▶ Play
name's Graham Sloan. I'm the director of the Arkansas Ethics Commission. Senate Bill 426 contains changes that the commission has identified in the past two years concerning the laws under its jurisdiction. And let me begin by saying that those changes don't directly affect y'all. as members of the General Assembly, for the most part, this bill contains changes that concern ballot and legislative question committees and also parallel entities known as local option ballot question committees. And essentially, there's two ways to meet the definition of a committee. One is you're an entity receiving contributions to, and then you're spending that money to expressly advocate the qualification, disqualification, passenger, defeat of a ballot measure. There's another way to meet that test, and that is you're an entity and you're spending your own money, and you made a $10,000 2% test. So if you're an entity, you've spent more than $10,000 of your own money, and that constitutes 2% of your income. And that's existing law. But if you look at the list of required information that a committee has to report, the list of required information, it's really tailored for the entity that's receiving contributions and it doesn't fit the entity that meets that $10,000 2% test. And so what the majority of this bill does is just delineate two sets of information. One just keeps the existing information for the committee receiving contributions. Then the other, it pairs it down to the, takes that same list of information, but it pairs it down to the applicable information for the second type of entity. And then other notable changes in there, Sections 3 and Sections 9 remove language that's very likely unconstitutional under United States Supreme Court case law. The committee is required to report its paid canvassers and how much each person got paid. And the United States Supreme Court took a look at that as Buckley v. American Constitutional Law Foundation, and they said that didn't pass constitutional muster. So we would be removing that. And then Section 5 clarifies where district judges file their contribution and expenditure reports. Over time, they used to be, district judges used to be county and municipal elected officials. time they've moved and become state, truly a state or district elected official. And so the place of filing, the Section 5 clarifies that the place of filing is going to be the Secretary of State's office, which is the same place that y'all file y'all's reports.
▶ Play
I'd be happy to answer any questions. All right. Representative Hendren, you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question. well it's after seven o'clock and a lot of us are hungry that raises a question in my mind uh just to write up just a plain simple question are you here to take a graham this is for graham andy i know you you know the answer to this probably but graham are you taking another bite out of the foi laws with this bill no sir thank you all right any other questions from the
▶ Play
committee. Hearing none, anyone in the audience to speak for or against the bill? Hearing none, Representative Davis, are you ready to close? I close and I move do pass. Have a motion do pass by Representative Davis. Any discussion? Hearing none, all in favor of the motion, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. The ayes have it. Congratulations. Your bill is passed. All right. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, committee. Representative Dobson. Pardon? Not quite. Representative Dobson, you have two bills I think you want to run. Did you want to run 1980, House Bill 1980? Let's start with the Senate Bill 513. Senate Bill 513, okay. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair, members of the committee. This is a fairly simple bill. The title pretty much sums up an act to prohibit public entities from contracting and investing in companies that boycott Israel. So that is pretty much what the entire bill goes into detail on. There's a legislative findings section that goes into a lot more detail of how it works and what it does, but this is a pro-Israel bill. I'll take
▶ Play
any questions. All right. Any questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience speak for or against the bill? Do you have a
▶ Play
question? Representative Douglas, you're recognized. Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Dodson, when you say pro-Israel, there could be people in Israel that I might not think are worth supporting. Are we talking about the government of Israel or any person with citizenship? You know, that...
▶ Play
What we're talking about is any public entities in the state of Arkansas from contracting with companies that are anti-Israel or actually have business dealings with enemies of the state of Israel.
▶ Play
Okay. Any other questions? Seeing none, Representative Dobson, you want to close for your bill? I am closed. I move to do pass. Have a motion do pass by Representative Dobson. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. The ayes have it. Representative Dobson, your bill is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Also, I have House Bill 1980.
▶ Play
1980, okay. You're recognized. Again, this bill is a very simple bill. It's a very short bill as well. And this is with regards to the display of the national motto. This would have the national motto and God we trust to be displayed on public buildings in the state of Arkansas. as long as if you look on at the very bottom of page two, sorry, the top of page two, that the copies or posters authorized under this section shall either be donated or shall be purchased solely with funds made available through the voluntary contributions to the local school boards or the Building Authority Division of the Department of Finance and Administration. So as long as voluntary contributions are made available, then the display of the national model in God We Trust will be displayed on public buildings in the state of Arkansas, or in public buildings in the state of Arkansas.
▶ Play
Any questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience want to speak for or against the bill? Do you want to close for your bill? I am closed, and again, move, do pass. Okay, I have a motion from Representative Dobson, do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor, say aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Congratulations, your bill is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lemons, would you like to run your bill? Yes, sir. House Bill
▶ Play
1386. Thank you, Mr. Chair, 1386 is actually a very simple little bill that does nothing. But it does do something for our library system. At the present time, our library system receives certain records. But for the most part, they're just the preliminary version. They rarely ever get the final version with any emergency clause that is attached. So they would like to be included in the loop for future reference, for history, and for research to be included with the other agencies, Secretary of State's Office and Legislative Council, so that they would have copies of those records.
▶ Play
And that's it. All right. Any questions from the committee? Representative
▶ Play
Hendren. I guess this is after Dodson's rules have all been wiped out that we don't need, I understand. How much is this going to cost? Is there a cost, and how much is it going to cost, and can they do that with the website right now? Well, I believe
▶ Play
what they're wanting is to retain a copy, a physical copy, in their hands that has all the recording information on it. To my knowledge, there was not an impact statement done, nor do I believe that there was a need to. It's just a piece of paper that's transmitted to them for their records. They're already getting the preliminary version. They just want the final version to go and file with it. Are there other questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Representative Sabin? I've just got to ask this. I appreciate it, Mr. Chair. Why would they get a preliminary copy, but not
▶ Play
the final copy? Same question we've been asking ourselves, but we don't know. They're just not in the loop for the final decision for some reason. So creating a law.
▶ Play
Any other questions? Anyone in the audience to speak for or against the bill? They're
▶ Play
all here for it, but you know. Are you ready to
▶ Play
close for your bill? Yes, sir. I'm very much closed for this bill. What's the feeling of the committee? Motion do pass by Representative Wardlaw. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor signify by saying aye. All opposed, nay. The ayes have it. Motion carried. Congratulations. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
The bill's passed. Y'all have a wonderful evening.
▶ Play
I'm going to see the wife and eat supper. Okay. Representative Gray, do you
▶ Play
Speaker 162 58:17
have a bill, 1893? Okay, committee, we only have three more
▶ Play
bills to run, so hang in there. We'll be done here shortly, hopefully.
▶ Play
Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I had House Bill 1893, and I do have an amendment to put on, reluctantly adding Representative Wardlaw to the bill with me. And I'm deleting an entire section that there was some issue with, especially with Senator Hickey. And then I'm essentially putting another section in. I'll explain it once we get it engrossed in the bill. And I would appreciate a favorable vote. I'll make the motion.
▶ Play
I'm so tired. You make a motion on the amendment? Yes, sir. Okay, we have a motion to pass the amendment to Bill No. 1893. any questions? Any discussion? Hearing none, all in favor of the motion to pass the amendment? Signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your amendment is passed. You can represent your bill.
▶ Play
All right. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So what my original intent with this bill was, is as I talked to purchasing agents across the state that just work in different state agencies and in higher ed, we have what was, it's Act 557, which is part of why Senator Hickey was upset with me for trying to change it, but so I think he should be okay with this now. So I deleted one of the sections, the section that I did leave in the bill, right now, it's current statute that if a purchasing officer at any state agency, higher ed, anywhere that they purchase with state funds, if they don't comply and complete this Act 557 report, they can be found guilty of a misdemeanor, personally found guilty of a misdemeanor for not completing this report. And so the issue I have with that, I worked in higher ed for about 10 years, and higher Ed doesn't have ACES reporting system. And so the requirements in 557 are set up based on the ACES system, and it's making it very, very difficult for them to pull the information. So they are essentially, it depends how large the agency is. Some have hired one to two new employees just to try and keep up with the contracts, to try and keep up with their completion phase, just to try and hit these reporting requirements. So what's happened is, as you have your normal turnover, it's becoming very difficult to find purchasing agents to backfill these positions because of the threat of misdemeanor under this Act 557. So we struck the language for the misdemeanor so they can no longer be held essentially accountable for not completing a report. And then the amendment, what we did with the amendment, essentially saying that for purchasing vehicles, the director might issue a request for qualifications for the procurement of passenger motor vehicles and trucks to compile a qualified vendor list that includes vendors in multiple areas of the state so that they don't all have to purchase from here in Little Rock. They can actually purchase locally, and that will, you know, it helps the economy as long as the prices are competitive. This does allow them to go outside of
▶ Play
Little Rock. So that broadened the people that they
▶ Play
could get? Yes, it broadens greatly the vendor list, the available vendors for vehicles. Yes. All right, Representative Ward, why
▶ Play
don't you have a question? Go ahead. It's
▶ Play
more of a statement, but I'm going to put it in a question. The amendment, Representative Gray, that you're talking about for the vehicles, Actually, the way it works is the vendor list that they're going to add into that RFQ is that it lists here by the procurement officer of the state, which would be Mr. Armstrong. They would have to match the state bid. It wouldn't be a competitive price. It would be an actual match to the state bid. And that vendor list, those people would have to register. So you would have like a UAM in Monticello, and they could purchase that vehicle in Monticello, but they would have to have it at the exact same price that they would purchase in Little Rock. Really, where the money savings comes from on this is they wouldn't have to drive to Little Rock and send two people to get a vehicle. They could get it right there at their local dealership. But their local dealerships would have to take the initiative to sign up on this vendor list with the Department of Procurement to be included. Do you agree? I would definitely agree. Thank you
▶ Play
for clarifying that, Representative Wardlaw. That's why I added you to the bill, see? Are there any other questions?
▶ Play
Representative Hendren. This is 1893? Yes. I notice in here that the IA is amended, but I notice that we've changed the parameter of this from $25,000 to $100,000. That we struck that, Representative Hendren. That's not in the amended bill? That's correct. I took that part out. What about the C down here? It says, as using this section, contract does not include one-time purchase orders. Is
▶ Play
that still in there? Yes, that is still in there, I think. Hold on just a moment. Let me make sure. That's still in there, and I honestly don't even know what that's in there for. Well, I
▶ Play
can understand that then. But it's still at $25,000, right? It's still at $25,000, and
▶ Play
I would like to correct and say that I had said It does away with the misdemeanor. It doesn't do away with the misdemeanor because that's not right. It does away with the Class D felony.
▶ Play
Other questions from the committee? Representative
▶ Play
Douglas. So just, and thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Gray, just relieve my fears that we are going to ease up on the fraud that we're seeing in procurement. because we're having some real problems in three or four of the, you know, the contracts that have been awarded here lately, and we don't want to do that at this point.
▶ Play
To me, and that's, to me, this doesn't ease up on that at all. It just, I personally wouldn't want to work, because I used to supervise purchasing agent. I wouldn't want to be the purchasing agent when I could be found guilty of a, what I thought was a misdemeanor, but this is worse, a felony because I didn't complete a 557 report that I wasn't actually capable of completing because I don't have the software capability to do it. And that's been part of the issue and is trying to get these purchasing agents in higher ed that don't have the same software, that don't report the same things to be able to complete these reports that they want completed. So this just became an issue when that Act 557 of 2015 came in place. So all we're doing with this is taking away the felony and then adding in the piece about the
▶ Play
vehicle purchases. So we're only removing a felony for the lack of a report. That's correct. Not for any fraud that we could find through a report.
▶ Play
That's correct. So 19-11-270 is that Act 557 piece that deals with reporting. And if I could just have
▶ Play
this one last follow-up, and I'm so sorry. Yes, one more. Thank you. One more? Okay. If this is mandated, I think that higher ed needs to make sure that they've got the programs to make sure their employees comply with the law. And instead of making them comply, we are giving them a pass on it. And I really, help me here. And I don't feel like we're giving
▶ Play
them a pass. A lot of them do report it, how accurate it might be. I mean, when you have someone like, I'm going to use UAMS, who has, I don't know how many millions or, you know, dollars worth of, hundreds of dollars worth of contracts, and they don't use the software that Act 557 was set up around, they have to manually track all of those. And it's not just that we are tracking a contract, we did an RFP, we awarded it, this is it. That Act 557 actually needs to know percentage of completion. There's like a hundred different questions that they have to fill out. So they've all had to hire new employees. I mean, it was essentially an unfunded mandate that we put on them. All I'm trying to say is whether if you don't fill the report out or you don't fill it out essentially correctly, you can't be found guilty of a felony. That's all I'm saying. I mean, I wouldn't go to work in one of the purchasing offices knowing that I could be convicted of a felony for not filling out a report, for not completing the report.
▶ Play
All right. Seeing no more questions and no one in the audience to speak for or against the bill, are you ready to close for
▶ Play
your bill? I'm closed for the bill. And I would like to say one thing as I close for the bill. So to Representative Douglas's point, I want to make sure that that 1911 270 is the actual Act 557 felony that we're doing away with and nothing else. So I don't know when exactly I need to do that because we have it if we if we if we pass it today and I find out that that this touches more than just what I told you it touches, I'll refer it back to committee. I mean, I'll give you my word on that. We just don't
▶ Play
meet again for two days. Any questions from the committee about that? Any issues there? So are you closed for your bill? I'm closed for my bill. All right. Representative Ward-Long, you have a motion? Have a motion do pass. HB 1893 as amended. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. All opposed, nay. Ayes have it. Motion carries. Your bill is passed. Thank you, Mr. Chair, committee. Okay. We only have two more bills to run, if you all can hang in there with us. Representative Lundstrom, you have a bill, a quick bill, I hope? HB
▶ Play
1988, is that correct? Yes, that is correct. This bill is pretty straightforward. What it does is your county jails are getting reimbursed at the rate of $30 per day per prisoner, and this would increase it by $5 with $1 a year for the next 25 years. Pretty straightforward. It still won't get them back to scratch, but you can only do so much. It does have a physical impact, and I will take in questions. Representative Ballinger, you're recognized
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:09:25
for a question. Do you have your physical impact statement? Yes, sir,
▶ Play
I do. It's $2.75 million per year. Okay. I mean, you actually have one from BLR? Yes, I do. Okay.
▶ Play
Okay. All right. Any other questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Speaker 192 1:09:45
Representative. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think you know what I'm going to ask you about. Yes, yes, I do. That's okay. It's all good. On page four, starting at line four, striking the language of requiring prior off from the Department of Community Corrections for health care in these county jails. I don't know why
▶ Play
that was struck. I think it's because it's redundant language in that part of the bill, but that's no intention. of having that in there. My focus is on this bottom part. If I need to, I'll go back and have that just taken out of that part of the bill. I think it was redundancy that they were, the reason they were striking it in that section, but I will check and
▶ Play
get you an answer. Thank you. You're welcome. The economic impact statement should be on
▶ Play
your tablets now. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative Lundstrom, where do you suppose we get this $2.5 million from? We have
▶ Play
a lot of money here in Little Rock, and we have a very big budget. Unfortunately, it is tight, and I understand that. But what's happened to us is the feds pass on unfunded mandates to us, and then we turn around and pass it on to our local county jails. I am not asking for a huge increase because we can't afford it. $2.75 million, I think we can squeeze that out somewhere, and we'll have to see
▶ Play
where that will be. Any other questions? Representative Douglas, you're recognized.
▶ Play
And if we don't find the money, then- Then we don't have it. No, where I was going with this is that our counties- Our counties. Are just going to, I mean, they're going to have to find the money. Yes. And where does that come from? That goes back to our taxes. Currently,
▶ Play
Washington County and a lot of other counties, It costs between $50 and $60 a day to keep a prisoner. They're not going to get rich off of this. This is barely going to keep them at level, and it is $1 a year for the next 25 years.
▶ Play
Speaker 93 1:11:49
So we weren't going to go for broke on this one. Yeah. Well, thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Smith, you're recognized for a question. Motion at the proper time. Any other questions? Anyone in the audience who wants to speak for or against the bill? Hearing none, are you ready to close for your bill? I would
▶ Play
ask for a good vote. Thank you for your time, especially at the end of the day. What's the wish of the committee?
▶ Play
Representative Smith, you're recognized. Do pass. I have a motion of do pass from Representative Smith. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay? No. The nays have it, your bill has failed. Thank you. Thank you for your time. I think Representative Lowry has left the room. No. There he is. Okay. Thought I saw you at the door a while ago. House Bill 2183, is that correct? Yes, Mr. Chair. Mr. Chair,
▶ Play
that was wishful thinking that I had
▶ Play
left. I know I saw you go out the door. You must have been back in while I was busy. Yes. You
▶ Play
have an amendment? Yes, I do have an amendment. You recognize to present the amendment. Okay. This bill deals with the whistleblower legislation. The amendment that you have defines the proper authority that an allegation can be forwarded to, It defines it as the internal audit section of Arkansas Department of Finance and Administration. It also adds a section at the end that upon notification of a violation under this subchapter, the appropriate authority may refer the notification of a violation to the office of the Attorney General. So if it is a matter of waste, internal audit of DFA can take care of it. But if it is an instance of fraud that's been reported, they can refer it to the Attorney General. And that's the
▶ Play
amendment. What's the feeling of the committee on the amendment? Have a do passed by Representative Wardlaw. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor of passing the amendment, signify by saying aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your amendment's passed. You're recognized to represent the bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
▶ Play
Thank you, members. I think one of the greatest assets that we have in state government, in government, period, for us to be able to have a more efficient system are our state employees. And as such, we have to do everything that we can to protect them if they want to come forward and acknowledge or to report an instance of fraud or of waste that they have identified. The current whistleblower legislation seems to focus more on an individual and employee reporting to their supervisor. And that's somewhat problematic. If you remember, Representative Hammer ran a bill the other day on the House floor about protecting the identity of whistleblowers. I think the way that he went about it ended up not being supported by the members. But the issue is still the same, that we have to protect them. And I think at the point that the main focus is on reporting to your supervisor or someone within your division, that has a chilling effect on state employees being able to come forward. And let me just, I mean, not give a specific example, but just speak to the fact that, say, an employee spots see something that is waste or fraud, even though it may not involve their supervisor, they report to the supervisor. The supervisor's committee, would you please hold it down a
▶ Play
little bit so that he could speak? Representative Gray, could you all go over here? It's hard to hear the presenter.
▶ Play
Speaker 163 1:16:11
It wasn't stopping me. Go ahead, Representative
▶ Play
Larry. Go ahead. You just go on. But if the incident is reported to the supervisor, even if it does not involve the supervisor directly, the supervisor still may have a reluctance to report it on to any other authorities because it would reflect on their management. So this legislation tries to clean up, you know, the original legislation has all kinds of, I mean, a long list of appropriate authorities, and we've actually streamlined this. The other thing that the bill does is it incentivizes employees coming forward. Right now in the law, if there's restitution or if there's an identification of waste or fraud, the employee can receive a reward of 10 percent of whatever the identified waste or fraud is. And what I've done here is just increased that to 20 percent. You know, that may seem like a big jump, but at the point that you've already lost this money or you've already lost this resource because of waste or fraud, if 20 percent incentivizes employees coming forward more and if streamlining the reporting authority does this, and my understanding is that DFA Internal Audit already has a hotline in place to take calls like this. I had thought originally and actually had an amendment drafted that reporting would go to the Office of Transformation and the governor's office. The feedback that I got before that actually was implemented is that the governor's office just felt like Office of Transformation is more policymaking than it is regulatory, and that DFA internal audit would be more regulatory and it would be more appropriate. And that's the bill in a nutshell.
▶ Play
All right. Any questions from the committee? Anyone in the audience here to speak for or against the bill? Hearing none, are you ready to close
▶ Play
Speaker 205 1:18:24
for your bill? I am close for the bill unless someone needs me to say something more. No. Okay. No, I'm
▶ Play
close. What's the feeling of the committee? Have a due pass from Representative Howes. Any discussion? As amended. Bill as amended. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. Ayes have it. Motion carries. Congratulations, Representative Larry. Your bill is passed. Thank you. I only see one hand, so there's no roll call. Roll call. Representative Wardlaw. Representative Wardlaw. No.
▶ Play
Speaker 118 1:19:13
Representative Hammer. Representative Hammer. Representative Eubanks. Representative Eubanks. Representative House. Yes. Representative Douglas. Representative Dotson. Representative Dotson. Representative Miller. Representative Miller. Representative Womack. Yes. Representative Davis. Representative Davis. Representative Davis, Representative Sabin, Representative Hendren, Representative Drown, Representative Drown, Representative Gray, Representative Gray, Representative Tosh, Representative Tosh, Representative Gonzalez, Representative Ferguson, Representative Ferguson, Representative Sterch, Representative Smith. Representative Ballinger.
▶ Play
With 10 ayes and 2 nays, your bill has failed. All right, committee, we'll appreciate you hanging in with us here, and you've earned your money today. We are adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB701

36:05 - 37:39 4 segments 2 speakers

[106] [36:19]

[107-108] [36:52] [36:57]

HB1008

37:39 - 42:51 21 segments 4 speakers

Representative Michelle Gray introduced HB 1008, which amends the ethics statute to add “knowingly taking” to the prohibition on using campaign funds as personal income and aligns penalties with existing categories B, C, and D. [37:50] [38:10] [38:15] [38:21] [38:38] [38:43] [39:13] [39:44]

[112-118,120-125] [38:15] [38:21] [38:38] [38:43] [39:13] [39:44] [40:15] [40:38] [40:45] [41:05] [41:20] [41:56] [42:12]

HB2242

42:51 - 46:50 12 segments 4 speakers

SB426

46:50 - 51:37 12 segments 4 speakers

Graham Sloan, director of the Arkansas Ethics Commission, explained that SB 426 updates reporting requirements for ballot-question committees, distinguishes entities that receive contributions from those that spend over $10,000 of their own funds, removes unconstitutional paid-canvasser reporting provisions, and clarifies filing locations for district judges. [46:52] [46:56] [47:24] [48:00] [48:31] [49:06] [49:43]

Representative Kim Hendren raised a brief comment questioning whether the bill would further restrict FOIA laws, which was answered without further debate. [49:52]

The committee moved to pass SB 426, with Representative Davis making the motion, no opposition was recorded, and the ayes carried, resulting in the bill’s passage. [50:17] [50:47]

SB513

51:37 - 54:07 8 segments 3 speakers

Representative Jim Dotson introduced Senate Bill 513, a “pro-Israel” measure prohibiting Arkansas public entities from contracting with or investing in companies that boycott Israel, outlining its findings and purpose. [51:56] [52:05] [52:20] [52:29] [52:43]

Representative Dan M. Douglas asked whether the bill targeted the Israeli government or all Israeli citizens, prompting clarification that the restriction applies to any company deemed anti-Israel or doing business with Israel’s enemies. [52:20] [52:29] [52:43]

The committee moved to pass SB 513, Representative Dobson made the motion, no discussion was offered, and the ayes carried, enacting the bill. [52:59]

HB1980

54:07 - 55:50 5 segments 3 speakers

Representative Jim Dotson explained House Bill 1980, which would allow the display of the national motto “In God We Trust” on Arkansas public buildings provided the signage is funded solely through voluntary contributions to local school boards or the Building Authority Division. [54:12]

The committee heard no questions, proceeded to close the bill, and Representative Dobson moved to do pass; with unanimous aye votes, the bill was adopted. [54:46]

Representative Tim Lemons presented House Bill 1386, seeking to require the state library system to receive final copies of agency records-beyond the preliminary versions they already obtain-so that libraries can retain complete historical documents for research purposes. [55:42] [55:49]

HB1386

55:50 - 58:56 15 segments 6 speakers

Committee members questioned the cost and necessity, with Representative Kim Hendren asking about financial impact and Representative Warwick Sabin inquiring why only preliminary copies were previously provided; Lemons responded that the bill merely mandates a paper copy with no significant expense. [56:29] [56:44] [56:55] [57:09] [57:15] [57:26]

After discussion concluded, Representative Wardlaw moved to do pass the bill, no opposition was recorded, and the motion carried, passing HB 1386. [57:41] [57:57]

HB1893

58:56 - 1:09:10 36 segments 6 speakers

Representative Michelle Gray offered an amendment to House Bill 1893 that eliminates the Class D felony for failing to file the Act 557 procurement report and adds provisions allowing state agencies to issue requests for qualifications to create a statewide qualified vendor list for passenger motor vehicles, thereby expanding purchasing options beyond Little Rock. [58:59] [59:30] [59:33] [1:00:07] [1:00:37] [1:01:08] [1:01:38] [1:01:52]

Committee members sought clarification on the amendment’s impact, with Representative Jeff Wardlaw confirming that vendors on the list must match state bid prices and register with the Department of Procurement, and Representative Kim Hendren verifying that the amendment retained the $25,000 threshold and removed the misdemeanor language while retaining the felony removal. [1:01:54] [1:02:02] [1:02:05] [1:02:10] [1:02:42] [1:03:05] [1:03:13] [1:03:42] [1:03:47] [1:03:57] [1:04:01] [1:04:05] [1:04:19]

Additional concerns were raised by Representatives Dan Douglas and others about whether the changes would weaken fraud safeguards; the sponsors assured that only the felony penalty was being removed and no fraud protections were altered. [1:04:27] [1:04:54] [1:05:25] [1:05:47]

The committee moved to pass HB 1893 as amended, Representative Ward-Long made the motion, no opposition was voiced, and the ayes carried, enacting the amended bill. [1:08:16]

HB1988

1:09:10 - 1:13:11 22 segments 8 speakers

Representative Bob Ballinger introduced House Bill 1988, which would raise the per-prisoner reimbursement to county jails from $30 to $35 per day-a $5 increase annually for 25 years, estimating a $2.75 million yearly cost to the state. [1:09:12] [1:09:25] [1:09:30] [1:09:33] [1:09:41]

Committee members questioned the bill’s funding source and impact, with concerns raised about the state’s tight budget, the reliance on county taxes, and the need for counties to find additional money, while Ballinger noted the increase would barely cover existing costs. [1:09:45] [1:10:06] [1:10:15] [1:10:27] [1:10:35] [1:10:42] [1:10:46] [1:11:13] [1:11:18] [1:11:34]

After discussion, Representative Smith moved to do pass the bill, but the committee voted 10 ayes to 2 nays, resulting in the bill’s failure to pass. [1:12:00] [1:12:13] [1:12:20]

HB2183

1:13:11 - 1:20:35 19 segments 5 speakers

Representative Brandt Smith presented an amendment to the whistleblower legislation in House Bill 2183, redefining the proper authority for forwarding allegations to the Internal Audit division of the Department of Finance and Administration and adding a provision allowing the Attorney General to be notified of fraud cases. [1:13:17] [1:13:23] [1:13:57] [1:14:06]

He argued that the current law’s focus on reporting to supervisors creates a chilling effect, and the amendment would both streamline reporting and increase the employee reward for successful waste or fraud recoveries from 10 % to 20 %. [1:14:27] [1:15:05] [1:15:39] [1:15:58] [1:16:11] [1:16:18] [1:16:44] [1:17:41]

The committee heard no further questions, and Representative Wardlaw moved to do pass the amended bill; despite unanimous aye votes on the amendment, the overall bill failed with 10 ayes and 2 nays, leading to its defeat. [1:18:30] [1:18:41] [1:19:13] [1:19:43] [1:20:22]

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Jack Ladyman Chair Unverified
64 segments
Representative Bob Ballinger Unverified
49 segments
Chair Unverified
2 segments
Representative Dan M. Douglas Unverified
26 segments
Jerry Cox Unverified
26 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Chair Unverified
6 segments
Eric Treat Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 54
1 segment
Speaker 100
1 segment
Representative Douglas House Unverified
2 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
28 segments
Speaker 118
5 segments
Representative Andy Davis Unverified
7 segments
Representative Jim Dotson Unverified
7 segments
Speaker 137
1 segment
Graham Sloan Unverified
5 segments
Representative Tim Lemons Unverified
7 segments
Representative Warwick Sabin Unverified
1 segment
Speaker 162
1 segment
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 192
1 segment
Speaker 93
1 segment
Representative Brandt Smith Unverified
10 segments
Speaker 163
1 segment
Speaker 205
1 segment