May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 13, 2026
HB1847 Capp TO PROVIDE FOR ARKANSAS AGRITOURISM SIGNS AT STATE WELCOME CENTERS AND TOURIST INFORMATION CENTERS THROUGH THE ARKANSAS WINE COUNTRY TRAILS PROGRAM. 1:26
Representative David Hillman introduced HB 1847 to authorize agritourism signage at welcome and tourist information centers, explaining that the bill would direct the Parks and Tourism Department and the State Highway Department to install the signs.
[1:41]
Lawmakers raised concerns that the language appeared to favor the wine industry over other agricultural sectors and questioned whether the bill would equitably promote agritourism statewide.
[2:21][2:49][3:14]
Testimony from the Arkansas Wine Producers Council highlighted the year-round nature of wine tourism and the desire to place large signs near tourist centers, while the State Highway Department warned that the proposed 12-by-48-foot signs could encroach on right-of-way and lacked a clear funding mechanism.
[3:52][4:22][4:54][5:27][8:35][9:12]
Facing unresolved right-of-way and cost issues, Representative Hillman asked to withdraw the measure, and the chair noted that the bill was being pulled from consideration.
[9:39][9:48][9:51][10:22][10:25][10:42]
HB1536 M. Gray TO AMEND THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT TO INCLUDE WOMEN-OWNED BUSINESSES. 11:53
Representative Michelle Gray moved an amendment to HB 1536 that restructured the Minority Business Economic Development Act by keeping a 10 % goal for minority-owned firms, adding a separate 5 % goal for women-owned firms, and reducing the service-disabled veteran goal from 5 % to 2 % while shifting it to the economic-development statute.
[13:12][13:26][13:34][13:48][14:20][14:52][15:34][16:13]
The committee voted to adopt the amendment after a motion and voice vote, with the chair recording the amendment’s passage.
[13:26][13:34]
Subsequent testimony from the Arkansas Economic Development Commission and committee members clarified that the changes would not increase agency staffing or reporting burdens and would consolidate certification data for better tracking.
[23:13][23:35][24:06][24:39][29:31][30:03][30:06][30:34]
The chair then moved to pass the bill as amended, and the committee approved the final version.
[46:06][46:08]
HB1748 Pilkington TO DESIGNATE THE WOOD DUCK AS THE OFFICIAL STATE DUCK. . 46:28
Representative Aaron Pilkington presented HB 1748 to designate the wood duck as Arkansas’s official state duck, noting that the wood duck was chosen over the mallard after committee consultation.
[46:41][46:55]
After brief discussion and a co-sponsor’s confirmation, the committee adopted a procedural amendment and proceeded to vote on the designation.
[47:20][47:41]
The motion to adopt the amendment and the final vote to make the wood duck the state duck both passed unanimously.
[47:20][47:41][48:13]
HB2078 Sorvillo TO CREATE AN OFFENSE FOR SALE OF DOGS OR CATS ON PROPERTY WITHOUT OWNER'S WRITTEN PERMISSION; AND TO PROTECT CONSUMERS AND ANIMALS FROM PUPPY A… 48:16
Representative James J. Sorvillo introduced an amended version of HB 2078 that would exempt commercial parking lots and require written permission from property owners for dog or cat sales on private land.
[48:39][48:46][49:20][49:53]
Breeder Suny McLeod questioned the definition of “commercial parking lot” and asked how written permission would be obtained on public property, arguing the bill did not advance animal-rights or consumer protections.
[50:34][51:01][51:33]
Sorvillo replied that permission must be obtained from the property owner-whether a private business or a public agency-and that the written document would satisfy any sheriff’s inquiry.
[52:05][52:08][52:39]
No motion to approve the amendment was offered, and the chair declared the bill dead for lack of a motion.
[53:13][53:45]
HB1717 Sorvillo TO CREATE THE DOG AND CAT SALE REGISTRATION ACT; AND TO CREATE THE DOG AND CAT SALE REGISTRATION FUND. 54:57
Representative James J. Sorvillo presented HB 1717, describing it as a consumer-protection measure that would require breeders to register dogs and cats, post registration numbers, and allow owners to recover veterinary costs under the state’s lemon law.
[55:04][55:21][56:00][56:40][57:16][57:55][58:28]
After a brief exchange, the committee reached consensus that the bill in its current form should not be acted upon and agreed to refer it to interim study.
[1:05:49][1:06:20]
HB1876 M.J. Gray TO REQUIRE AN ENTITY THAT RECEIVES AN ECONOMIC INCENTIVE FROM THE STATE TO EMPLOY OR CONTRACT WITH ARKANSAS RESIDENTS IN COMPLETING THE PROJEC… 1:06:55
Speaker 149 (representing HB 1876) moved an amendment granting the Economic Development Commission authority to promulgate rules for projects receiving state economic incentives, and the committee approved the amendment by voice vote.
[1:07:13][1:07:25][1:07:38]
Despite these concerns, the chair called for a final vote, the committee voted “aye,” and the bill was reported passed as amended.
[1:23:47][1:23:55]
SB553 J. Cooper TO PROVIDE A CERTIFICATION FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ENGAGE IN LIVESTOCK EMBRYO TRANSFER OR TRANSPLANT AND LIVESTOCK PREGNANCY DETERMINATION. 1:28:34
The bill was introduced by Chase Duggar (Speaker 176) who explained that SB 553 would create a certification for individuals to perform both embryo-transfer and pregnancy-determination work, listed two pages of qualifications, and included a two-year grace period before the Veterinary Medical Board could enforce the provisions.
[1:28:56][1:29:25][1:29:31][1:30:07][1:30:31][1:31:01][1:31:12][1:31:28]
Committee members, notably Rep. Stephen Meeks, questioned whether the two-year exemption could become a loophole for “bad actors” and urged an amendment to add protections against misuse.
[1:30:40][1:31:01][1:31:12][1:31:28][1:31:44][1:31:52]
HB1755 Collins TO CREATE THE TRAIL OF TEARS HISTORIC BIKE ROUTE. 2:14:33
Rep. David Whitaker presented HB 1755, proposing the Trail of Tears historic bike route from the Oklahoma-Arkansas border to the University of Arkansas along Highway 62, to be funded through private grants and gifts rather than state highway dollars.
[2:14:54][2:15:04][2:15:17][2:15:26]
Chair Dan Douglas raised a safety concern about cyclists on a farm road, and Whitaker assured that the route would employ federally-standard bike lanes set apart from traffic.
[2:15:36][2:15:57][2:15:59]
The committee moved to close the bill, a vote was taken with members voting “aye,” and the motion to pass was adopted without recorded opposition.
[2:16:17]
All right, members, glad to see everybody here this morning that we have. A little bit short, people are around different places. I'd like to have one more, but let's go ahead and call the meeting to order. We're going to start down the list here. We want to try to clear the calendar up and be through with things. I don't know that we'll meet again unless it's some Senate bills, House bills. We need to pretty well finish them up today. I'm going to start down the list on the bills. Representative Pilkington, I do not see him here. Anybody to present for Representative Pilkington? Do we have the amendment here on that bill? Okay. Let's move on. We'll wait and see if he comes. Representative Collins. Don't see anybody for Representative Collins in his bill. Representative Tucker is not going to run his bill, 1766. Representative Kapp has House Bill 1847. I believe Representative Hillman is going to run that for Representative Kapp. Representative Hillman, you are recognized to run your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Kapp couldn't be here today, and she asked for someone to run this bill, and I guess I'm it. What it does, it just puts, asked the Department of Parks and Tourism and the State Highway Department to put signs up on thoroughfares and stuff like that to for agri-tourism signs and I think it's a good idea anytime we can promote agriculture in Arkansas we need to so mr. chairman I would at your pleasure do as you wish okay you've
that I have and I don't know I mean this may be better for representative cap or someone from the department the way the bills drafted is to promote Arkansas agritourism incorporating Arkansas wine country trail symbols is this going to if it's accurate tourism in general I wouldn't have an issue with that i guess my concern is is with this language we're promoting one industry over another that we're you know promoting or pushing the wine side and you know over in western arkansas where the wine is okay you might could make a argument for that but if you're coming in from memphis you know the main agritourism over there is going to be more rice and soybeans and things like that and so i'm wondering if you've talked to her about that particular issue or
don't know we have um Mr. Whitaker, you're signed up to speak for it, but you were going to testify here anyway. Why don't you step down to the table, recognize yourself, and fill us in with your pertinent information.
Yes. Good morning, and thank you for hearing me. I'm the chairman of the Arkansas Wine Producers Council, which is a state agency appointed by the governor and confirmed by the Senate. We already have passed the Arkansas Wine Trails Bill, and as you can see on all the state maps are symbols here of where people can go to tour these wineries, et cetera. What the agritourism thing does is like 15 other states, for example, on I-40 that goes right through Arkansas, it also goes through North Carolina, and we're doing a similar thing that those other states are doing. They're simply putting these large billboards up before their tourist information centers. And the reason is this. In talking to the Department of Agriculture, they said, Al, these corn mazes and stuff don't last year-round. He said, you know, they grow during the growing season. He said, but the wineries and vineyards are open year-round, free tours and free tastings, and it's an important thing for us. So we're going to share these signs with them. And what they do is put them about a mile before the tourist centers so that people have time to stop and pick up maps and brochures on agritourism at the TIC center. It's better to have it before that as after so that they can stop in and get those. The only place we have a problem in discussing this with the highway department is just as you're coming across a bridge from Memphis, is in the concrete jungle between there and the first TIC center, but it reads, the bill does, or as soon thereafter as possible. I have some colleagues in Tennessee and wine country that said they may help us get a sign up on the Tennessee side, so we think it's a good thing. I represent six states on the National Grape and Wine Initiative Board, and we work for U.S. Park Agriculture getting research funds for the University of Arkansas on muscadines in various areas. I represent Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, and Hawaii. And they've all got wine trails, and we're trying to hook our wine trail in with them so that in the long term, we try to stop tourists. Robert Moore from the Highway Department, he said, that's what builds highways and builds roads. The tourist taxes give a great deal to us, and the more we can stop and get them to spend, the better. And also, since Senate Bill 284 passed, the so-called Walmart bill, it's going to put It's a squeeze on our industry and push a lot of our wines off the shelf in a lot of these grocery stores that we've been in since 1935. So I'm 82 years old, and I remember when I was born a year of repeal, so I've been around the block a few times with these laws, and I've also helped farm what's called Wine America. It's 46 states. All these states have incentive programs for their in-state industry, And we need this to increase our tourism for our industry to survive after Senate Bill 284 passed. As a matter of fact, we've already had to lay off some of our vineyard workers, and we're going to be pulling up some of our vineyards. Every state in the union, 46 states, help their people.
and the industry is paying for the science. And if we can't afford to steal, it's written so that we can use power line poles or such as that. And usually the electrical companies help us do the drilling and such as that with permission from the highway department.
No expense to the state? No. Thank you. Representative Pitts. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Hillman, a little bit of information is always dangerous. In passing, Scott Bennett, he mentioned a bill that Representative Kapp had with regard to signs that he had some consternation over. Mr. Whitaker just referenced that. I noticed they're not in the room. This was like an hour ago when I heard that. Have we worked this out with our highway folks who are traditionally?
I believe someone from the highway department is here. Are they? Okay. Yep. Yeah. Gil, why don't you come down and recognize yourself, introduce yourself, and give your input on this from the State Highway Department. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'm Gil Rogers, the Governmental Relations Officer for the State Highway Department. You're recognized. Go ahead. The Highway Department has not been consulted on the bill. As far as we can tell, there's not a method or methodology or discussion of funding. It indicates that the testimony has been that there won't be any funding issues relative to the Highway Department, but it doesn't speak to whether or how it's paid for. But the bigger problem is these are signs larger than a billboard that will be required to place in our right-of-way, which may or may not fit within our right-of-way. So we don't even know if there's going to be additional expense related to the acquisition of land or right-of-way that will allow us to put these signs up. These are 12-foot by 48-foot signs, as big as a billboard. And being able to stick those in the right-of-way outside these, I think there are 10 welcome centers throughout the state, is not something the Highway Department is interested in having done. That's bigger than any sign, by the way, that we have out there, other than those that hang over the interstates that give directions to other states and other
right. I can answer his question. This was discussed with the Highway Department. The first time it went in was when the other trails bill went in, which is now on the state highway maps, and it was tied together. At the time, the only reason we pulled it down before was that it was supposed to be on the TIC Center property. But the Parks and Treasurer worked with us on this. We met with the Highway Commission, and they said way
And the problem is— Mr. Whitaker, let me interrupt here just a second. We're short on time. Well, the right-of-way is extra wide. Yeah. At the TIC. Mr. Whitaker, that's enough. All
right. The representative said he'd like to pull it down at this time. There's evidence that the Highway Department is not in agreement. Representative, thank you for pulling your bill down. Next bill. Representative Gray, are you ready to present your bill? Yes, sir. As I sign up on it, it's been changed already. Okay. House Bill 1748. No, that's Pilkington's. It's been changed. It's been a big while. Oh, okay. He's not here. Just let me sign him in. Okay, she's signing some amendments, and then we'll go on. Just one minute, and we'll have Representative Gray down here. Getting hers. Do we have any other members here besides Representative Gray to present their bills? Ms. Representative Sevilla. After her, we'll get you. I can't see you back there in the back. You kind of hid. Thank goodness. All right. Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Okay. I sat here before you all several weeks ago, and I ran a bill that added women into the small business program and put them in with minority business as far as trying to get a certification and essentially a little more availability on contracts with the state. So you passed it out of this committee, and I let it sit on the House floor for probably two weeks as I talked to different people. There were several different groups that had issues with it. lots of different angles, and I had not at that point in time talked to economic development, the governor's office, the Black Caucus, either. So long story short, I pulled it back. It's sitting back in this committee. We filed a new bill that, to the best of my knowledge, there's no opposition to. Economic development is good with it. The governor's office is good with it. The Black caucus representative vivian flowers we've worked in monty hodges we've worked a whole lot to get this right um so what i have first is an amendment to run to the bill um and it essentially changes the entire bill so if i could get a motion on the amendment then i will
amendment is passed Thank you. Proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So what my original intent was was to add women to, right now we have minority-owned businesses that have a 10% goal of purchasing with the state and all state agencies. My original intent was to add women to that so that they were also allowed, women-owned businesses, they were also allowed into that purchasing space. So what we have all essentially in the Veterans Coalition, we've worked with them as well now. So what we've kind of come to an agreement on is we have the minority business still at a 10% goal. One of the questions in here was whether or not the women-owned business would cut into that 10% goal, and that was a possibility. So we have added women with a 5% goal themselves. And what we're doing with that, the federal government recognizes women-owned business just like that. They have minority-owned business and then women-owned business. And one of the biggest things we found as I've talked to women-owned businesses is they are not able to effectively bid on federal contracts because in the federal space there are actual set-asides for minority-owned businesses and for women-owned businesses. But because they look at experience in other contracts in this space on the state level, we don't have that. And so they were not successful, a majority of them not successful in actually bidding on federal contracts that fall underneath that set-aside. So we have the 10% for minorities, the 5% for women-owned business. Within that 10% for minorities, I've learned a lot about this since I ran the bill the first time. So within that 10% for minorities, the very last thing that was delineated was service-disabled veterans. You go to a whole other section of the code. It's 1911-106, and I'll remember that until the day I die, I think. But 1911-106, we actually had this service-disabled veterans set out over there with a 5% goal. So currently the way the law reads, we have minorities at 10% and service-disabled veterans are supposed to be at 5% of that 10%. So we have all minorities at 5%, service-disabled veterans at 5%. So what we have agreed to do is there are only eight certified service-disabled veteran businesses in the state, and there are hundreds of minority businesses. So we've agreed to expand the minority business to 8%, shrink the service-disabled veteran from 5 to 2 because of the number of certified businesses. And it also moves them from a DF&A statute to an economic development statute. And so economic development is, they're actually here and would testify for the bill or answer questions if you wanted. But essentially what we're doing by doing this is they're going to be able to essentially be more proactive in marketing with the certifications, and we'll be able to track minority purchasing, service-disabled veteran purchasing, and women purchasing, so where we can get good, reliable data moving forward to kind of see if we need to adjust the percentages, is you know if we need to do a better job of marketing these within the state of Arkansas so that's a majority of what this bill does it's a large bill nine pages where we change a little bit of the commission with the council trying to think what else we do and poor Joy I tell you what she in drafting this she's been back and forth 100 times we also in this when we change that veterans piece from eight or from five percent to two we do strike that language in dfna so now we have everything just like it is on the federal level all underneath one statute um within the small
there's no known opposition to this bill now that's correct i can tell you that the To my knowledge, there is none. The Veterans Coalition helped with this. The Black Caucus helped with this. Economic Development helped with this. And the Governor's Office helped with this. And this is a good bill? I think it's a very good bill, and I think it helps promote diversity and women-owned business in the state of Arkansas, and it will help us on the federal level with contracts because there is a set-aside amount of money that we are not doing a
just go down the line. They're on that side. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I appreciate what the goal here is. But right now, if we pass this bill, we have probably about 65 or higher percent of the population of Arkansas now qualifies, at least in this bill, as minority status. half the state is women 12-14% is minority and very small percent is disabled veterans now we have 60% of the people higher than 65% of Arkansans now qualify for minority status I understand part of the reasoning is to qualify for federal funds but is there any unintended consequence of having 65-plus percent of Arkansans in a minority status group?
Okay, and that's a great question. And 65% is nowhere close to who actually owns businesses in Arkansas. You know, we're down around 20% to 30% of this group that I've said actually own 51% of businesses in Arkansas. So women may make up half the population, but they make up a very small percentage of businesses that are owned in the state of Arkansas. So almost to your point, what we're trying to do is promote women-owned businesses in Arkansas. The numbers over the last 10 years for employees, the economic status, we've gone from 36 in the country to 46 in the country, and that's just happened within the last
four years. I want to follow up, Mr. Chair. Go ahead. So if we are low in the percentage of women and minorities and service veterans who don't participate, is there data that suggests or would identify maybe they're not participating out of choice? I mean, maybe it's not that they don't want to, maybe they want to. Is there any data that suggests we want to, in Arkansas, that we want to get in there but we're barred
because of whatever bars them? There are, I have heard from several minority-owned businesses and then women-owned businesses. Some of the women-owned businesses would love to be in this space but currently aren't allowed to by statute. And then some of the minority-owned businesses don't get into this space just because there are no incentives. There's no reason to do it. That's why we're beefing this up with economic development. And these are just goals. These aren't mandatory. And part of what we're trying to do, and I can tell you that the Black Caucus, They spent a lot of time looking at, because in their mind, they still had 10%. Even without that 5%, they thought they still had 10%, so there was some misunderstanding. And they weren't necessarily excited about giving up the little 2% for service-disabled veterans. But we understand that getting this all in one place for the next two years until the next session, we'll get some great data as to how the numbers work, how many businesses we actually have in Arkansas that will qualify under this. Technically, we have, say, there are 30% of businesses in Arkansas that are minority-owned or women-owned, and we're not doing a goal of 30%. We're just doing a goal of 15% total. Representative Brown, you're next. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
And this might be a question for someone from economic development, but I did have someone from the Veterans Coalition explain to me why a bill of this type was important, and they commended you on your collaboration with the other groups to get this hammered out, but I had not heard the final result. But I would like for somebody to address, now does this mean that, let's say, a minority woman is going to qualify in two categories? I don't know if that's a problem, but I'm just curious. and I would like for somebody from Economic Development to maybe explain to us why this is important on the federal level.
Thank you. Mr. Chair, do I have your permission? Certainly. I'm Curt Nauman from the Arkansas Economic Development Commission, Director of Research and Planning. The way that I understand, I have not seen this amendment, so I cannot speak to that, but the prior version of the bill that I saw addressed the issue of double counting and basically it's up to the state agency that is submitting that contract to make a designation amongst the various groups so that those numbers, those contracts would not be double counted. As far as the federal issue goes, as you may or may not be aware, our agency has moved towards doing more with our military installations. We have a military affairs grant program. We've worked very close with projects such as the joint vehicle facility that we tried to get to Camden. What we want to do is we want to be able to solidify our veterans base, our military installations, and we just see this as another way of being able to build on the governor's military initiative that he announced in 2015. So by getting the number of veterans contractors, which is very, very small now, upwards, we think we can do two things. we get them into the program they have to be certified as an eligible contractor under the minority business now minority veterans and women's business enterprise certification program we'll get more veterans businesses that want to locate here now that we have an incentive for retiree relocation there might be some connections there we'll be able to build on those numbers we'll be able to use that to also strengthen what we're trying to do with our military installations So as far as the federal contracting, I really can't address that, but I can say that it fits in well with our economic development initiative and with the governor's military affairs initiative.
I'm kind of glad you came to the end of the table because I've got some tough questions and I didn't want to have to ask my colleague these tough questions. we live in a world where we vote on things that cause unintended consequences you mentioned i haven't seen the bill none of us have seen the bill we're up against the hard deadline which is very very tough i am a supporter of this concept i made the motion on the first bill i have real huge concerns what's in this i i don't doubt everybody's behind this but we're up against this and I don't know if there's an alternative I mean I am not a big fan of vote on it and we'll see what's in it later that's just not how I'm I'm good with can you you mentioned uh Mrs. Leonard Joy wrote a bunch of stuff in this and God bless her and I'm trying to use your words I'm confused what else is even in there from my sponsor I have real concerns that we're not hearing bills after today in the house is my understanding is there an alternative because this is something we need to do but can we i don't know i hate isps but there's this is this has ripe for all of a sudden we get down the road and find ourselves of oops we didn't mean to do that because we do that even when we
okay so he's not seen this amendment but it is the exact amendment. I mean, it's everything that they knew was going to be in it, but we weren't for sure about the percentages, and I told him that right before the meeting started, but everything else in it, all groups that worked
worked to write this amendment. I understand. I guess my concern, though, Representative Gray, I guess follow-up, is that I don't think any of my colleagues have read this amendment from head to toe, and it's completely different than what the motion was whatever week or two ago this is a nine-page amendment that's very critical i get that and i wish we were looking at it two weeks before we were voting on the last day of bills is my concern and i'm not certain that i'm not going to go conservative on this in my vote and i need i
guess that's where i'm at here's it took us lots and lots of meetings to get to this point in an interim study the only problem with an interim study is then we go two more years without these certifications and without them economic development being able to advance and try to recruit these businesses into Arkansas and I do understand this is the last day and I think that we've been very willing to we want this right there's in no way I mean I'll commit and I know this is the last day and I think I've always kept my word on if I would pull something down or change something if we find something in this that's not right we'll amend it on the senate and just concur back in the house the last week we will I mean this this has been a huge project between everyone to work on
and if I might add the bulk of this bill is already building on an existing certification program that's been operated by our agency for many years what we're doing is we're adding a new category for women And we're also kind of modifying the category for veterans. So when it comes to the process and the procedure and the way that the certifications are done, there's not a lot of substantive changes there, mainly in the percentage and with the additions. You've had a
And I may actually be going where your follow-up was going here. How can you say that? You haven't built. I definitely understand what it's like to work on complex pieces of legislation, and at some point there is a degree of trust that we must have in each other that these things are done correctly. I know with a lot of other things I'm trusting in other people's judgment because they're just not my area of expertise. So I generally support what you're doing here in just my brief look at the bill. I haven't seen any red flags. I guess my one question is, because we're asking agencies to do something a little bit different here, we're putting an additional burden on them to make these, instead of right now one report, I guess, we're looking at three different categories that are going to be combined here. Do you see or can you talk on a practical level how much, if any, extra burden this is going to put on the agencies to be able to gather and report all this information back up to AEDC? And I guess that would be my primary concern that
I see here. As far as AEDC staff goes, we don't anticipate any increases in administrative costs. Right now, we currently have 255 certified businesses in the program. We would anticipate that number to double, which we will be able to take care of. The reporting is going to be the same, that we're not increasing the number of reports. As a matter of fact, we had requested that the number of reports actually go from four a year to two a year. I don't know if that was in this amendment change or not. But the idea was to work within what you're doing now, within the same confines, the same ways that you do your contracts, and it would just be simply reporting that information in the existing format. So we really don't see other agencies having to add staff or increase costs to be able to comply. I'd like
to respond to that as well. I have talked to some of the purchasing agents across the state, and originally they were having problems. They wanted women added, like I said in the last minute, to try and help them get to their 10% goal. But as we've talked this out, and they've been great to work with, as we've talked this out, essentially they've realized that we don't have the participation that we need, And hopefully by doing this, you know, like he said, we can double the number of minority. We can get women in there. And so they actually, for the most part, it wasn't an official, but essentially said, go ahead and add that extra 5%. Let's get some real numbers and see where we stand. And that will help us be able to, when we double these contracts, it will help us be able to actually, you know, use minority vendors more effectively. And so it's essentially the same report. they would just have to delineate whether it's minority, service-disabled veteran, or women-owned. So that's the only difference in that report. All right. Thank you.
all had. Yes, sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have scanned this bill. It's basically eight pages. And in most situations, you've just added and women-owned. and the additional text, I think, seems relatively harmless. One of my concerns, and particularly since I had this long discussion with another individual who I trust who explained that this was very important for our state, I'm not worried about getting this at the last minute. Maybe I should be, but I trust you. I was not for this bill when it was initially presented, even though I voted out of committee. One of the things I think most of us are concerned about is we do not want this in any way to be a discrimination against white men and their businesses. We've seen an awful lot of discrimination against white men in the last 50 years. Is this going to be any kind of a discriminatory thing, or are we going to be accepting contracts based on the merits of the contract, not just that it is coming from a minority, a woman, or
a veteran? I don't feel, and we don't want to discriminate against anyone in any way, shape, or form. So the total of 15% is a goal to try and reach. If it's not reached, there are no punitive actions in place or anything like that. So this just helps promote these areas, but it doesn't discriminate at all. So we don't have set-asides like the federal government does where a certain dollar amount or a certain type of contract has to be awarded to a minority or a woman. It's left fairly open up to the agency's discretion when and when not to use this. So they could pick the most qualified person for a contract no matter what space they fell in. And while doing that, trying to achieve that percentage. Thank you. Representative
guess my follow-up is still along the same lines. I was getting that this doesn't cost from the AEDC, doesn't cost us anything, we have no more work, et cetera. But I guess I question how we can be so certain of that if we haven't seen the bill yet. And as I'm scanning down through here, I see things that could cost us employee time, who knows how much more. and it really that that's what's got me twisted in a knot over this is I tend to tend to trust my colleague here but the experts even haven't read the amendment much like we haven't and I guess my question is how can you feel so certain this isn't going to have unintended consequences this isn't going to cost more people this isn't going to cost more in
general? The ADC division that's responsible for administration of this program is the small and minority business division. When it comes to the information that they provide, they will simply have to change their materials to reflect service disabled and women's owned businesses. They'll still continue to do the same workshops and seminars and certifications that they do now. They can simply change some existing forms that they have, and we've recently hired an admin an assistant that I share with that division that we'll be able to absorb some of those without hiring any new personnel. We've not made any requests for any funds for any anticipated changes in regard to this program. And again, if we're talking about even if we double the number of businesses that are involved in the program and are certified, then I feel we should be able to handle that internally. And as was stated earlier, as far as the state agency reporting goes, the number of reports has been changed. Instead of quarterly reporting, it's now going to be semi-annual. And the only distinction would be to designate among the groups of minority veterans and women. So I really don't see any additional increase in cost or personnel for this that could not be absorbed with current budgets.
And Representative Pitch, when you say we haven't read the amendment, everything that's in here was agreed to. He's just not seen the exact language that was in here. But every single piece that's in here was discussed
Okay, members, any further questions? If not, we'll go to the audience. Is there anybody to speak against the bill? Okay. Speaking for the bill, first of all, we have Christina. No, Christian? Okay. Yes, go ahead, Mr. Taffner. Give us your name, sir, and who you're with,
and you're recognized. Sure. Colonel Retired Christian Taffner. I'm here representing the Veterans Business Coalition, which is a subcommittee of the Arkansas Veterans Coalition. I'm also president of Peregrine Integrated Management, which is a federal contractor out of Sherwood. We do training, consulting, and so forth. First of all, I want to appreciate Representative Gray for bringing this forward. I'm not from Arkansas. I'm from Pennsylvania. I'm an Air Force Academy graduate. I spent 20 years in the United States Air Force after graduating from the Academy. I retired out of Little Rock Air Force Base and had a very difficult time finding a job here in the state. Subsequent to that, I started a consulting firm here in Arkansas. I've been working my way through the federal ranks. Fortunate enough to go to the National Veterans Center or Representative Hill sponsored me to go to the Veterans Institute for Procurement up in Washington, D.C. We're also a certified minority business here in the state. Quite frankly, after going through DFA regulations and so forth, I found a lot of inconsistencies between federal law and requirements for service-disabled veteran-owned small businesses and what the state has. Currently statute defining a veteran-owned business here in the state, service-disabled veteran-owned business here in the state, requires a 30% service disability as opposed to the 0% required by the federal statute, so it's much more restrictive. Secondly, regarding veteran procurement here in the state, it requires a veteran business to be established for two years prior to applying for a minority business certification here in the state. If I'm a retiring veteran from outside the state and I want to come here and start a business, and I thank everybody for your support of the retirement tax relief, but why would I want to wait for two years to be able to enter into this body when I can do it in another state, okay, on day one, and even in the federal sector is day one. So this bill does, okay, get rid of those barriers to owning a veteran business. Another thing is we talked specifically about federal contracts and what it could mean here to the state. In the last two years, in 2015, okay, Representative Gray, you said there were eight minority or SDVOSBs here in the state. Those are eight SDVOSBs that are registered as a minority business. However, in the last two years, 283 service disabled or veteran-owned businesses have done business here with the federal government. They have brought in, in 2015, $127 million in revenue to the state, 80% of which came from outside the state, and last year they brought in $91 million in federal contracts. Once again, about 82 percent coming from outside. Service disabled veteran owned businesses and veteran owned businesses bring outside dollars into the state, and it's critical, I mean absolutely critical for bringing federal contracts here to the state. Every federal contract above $675,000 requires 25% of that to go to small, capable small businesses that are registered with the federal government. If a federal contractor can't find those capable small businesses, they're not going to come here, quite frankly. Neither does the contracting officer, they're going to go look for other places to do that. So having that past performance is critical, I mean absolutely critical for us to reach out there and obtain those contracts. In the last year, our business did approximately $750,000 in business. We returned all of that, okay, to Arkansas citizens, which is fantastic from my perspective, okay. As a business owner here in the state, I want to see us thrive. So I think it's critical for us, okay, as opposed to the last two years here in the state, I'm going to take a guess at how much we did for veteran businesses, $131,000 in the last two years. $131,000. I'm sorry, but that's nowhere near the 5% goal that's already in statute. Regarding extra diligence as far as recording this, on every state solicitation right now, right below the header, there are two comments. Number one is, are you a registered minority business? Okay, and if so, please put down your license number. We do that. There's another block saying, are you a service-disabled veteran-owned small business? Okay, those processes are already in place. Okay, Arkansas DFA numbers do register federal contracts, or all contracts in the state, and they do break them out by the different minorities, women-owned, service-disabled veteran-owned at this time. So that's already in Excel documents that are in place. So this is critical. When we go out for federal contracts, there's technical capability as far as can we do our training, can we do our consulting, can we do this? And we weren't professionals. If we couldn't do that, we wouldn't be applying for this, first of all. But then they also look at, from a contractor's perspective, is can you execute a government contract? That's a specific technical skill that they look for, because they want to make sure they're getting it right there. Having past performance at the commercial level really doesn't care that much, okay, matter that much to the federal contracting officers. They want to see, can you do government contract? Can you dot your I's? Can you cross your T's? Do you know the languages, okay, contained in these contracts? And that's why it's critical. You know, as far as registering us for minority business, it takes 80 hours worth of clerical work to take the same documents I used, register for the federal government, and resubmit them for the state. That's 80 hours a year of work. We'd like to see that reduced, you know. But you know, that's why you only see eight service-disabled veteran-owned businesses registered here in the state. One, if there were, well, I can't do the math in my head right now, but if there were 283 of us there, trying to do $131,000 of business, is that worth my 80 hours of work? So we would like to see the goal, one, in place, in percentages. You know, I think they're representative right now. I highly support the minority businesses and the women-owned small businesses, simply because teaming relationships with them, the better they are, the better we are. You know, very common in federal contracting, you can't do everything yourself. So you need those other minority businesses or women-owned small businesses to step up and where they have capability, let them run with it. You know, where we can come in and assist them on that, that's fantastic, and vice versa. I look out quite often and say, you know, quite frankly, I'm a hard-skilled guy. I really, you know, I love the numbers and the analytics and so forth, but when somebody's out there asking me for an emotional intelligence training, I'm looking to, you know, other minority business partners to help us out there. So the better off they are on these contracts, the better off we are on these contracts. So we're very much in favor of that. And from a Veterans Business Coalition perspective, we're very proud that we're bringing outside dollars here to the state. And I highly support this bill. Okay. Thank
out about this. When we started digging into this two years ago to find out, we knew there was a 5% goal out there, but we could never get the numbers, okay, to see where we stood until about a year and a half ago. When I saw those numbers, $131,000, I was appalled by those. That's when I started bringing the attention of those that I
knew. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay, any other questions? All right. Thank you, sir. Members of our audience, is there anybody else to speak against the bill? Anybody speak for the bill? Representative Gray, you're welcome to close for your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And just in my closing, I won't rehash, but I wanted to address Representative Sullivan's question and why it took so long for them to get here. And part of that has just been the confusion between the statutes being in different places. And when I worked in higher ed and supervised this reporting aspect, we didn't include service-disabled veterans in the 10%. We didn't know we were supposed to So some people were reporting it Underneath that five Half of that ten percent And some were totally excluding it And doing it separate So it's just kind of come to light In the last two years That there was an issue And we weren't being consistent And needed to change it So with that I would appreciate a good vote Thank you Okay members
you've heard the explanation of the bill And the amendment was the pleasure of the committee I have a motion do pass as amended all those in favor signify by saying aye opposed nay representative your bill is passed as amended thank you mr. chair and committee you bet all right moving on I see represent Pilkington here let's get you real quick because you got one can you do this in one minute I thought you could you're recognized go ahead all
All right, House Bill 1748 to designate the Wood Duck as the official state duck. After conferring with members of this committee, we decided that the Wood Duck was a lot better choice than the Mallard, and I'm always
open to collaboration, so I agree with you all. We change it. We're good. Okay. Any questions, members? Too bad, McElroy. All right, any other questions? Representative Pitch?
off when it became the Wood Duck. That's why I'm asking. Okay. Any other questions for the representative? If not, is there anybody in the audience speak against the bill? Oh, thank you, Representative. We have the amendment. All in favor, the amendment signified by saying aye. Aye. Opposed? Amendment is adopted. All right. Now then, is there anybody to speak against the bill, for the bill? Representative, are you closed for your bill? I am. Okay. Members, all in favor of making the wood duck the state duck of Arkansas, signify by saying aye. Aye. Opposed, nay. Motion is passed. All right. Members, Representative Savillo wants to rerun. He has an amendment to House Bill 2078. You don't have the amendment here?
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. We amended it based on the conversation with the committee. The amendment would be under B. This section does not apply to commercial parking lots. So if a casual breeder wanted to sell a litter of puppies or kittens, they can go to a Walmart parking lot and you remember walmart still has the right to ask them to leave the other thing that's significant is written uh permission and what that basically the written permission removes the question of whether seller should be selling on someone else's property and the example would be is if the sheriff came by and asked the seller if they had evidence of consent it is just a matter of showing them the written document that eliminates the time and the effort for the sheriff to verify if someone has made a complaint complaint on this so it's basically those two issues are really I think significant in regards that you can still have a litter a puppy a mother that wants to sell that litter of puppies can do it
on a on a commercial parking lot. That's it. Okay, members, any questions for Representative Cervillo on this bill that is amended? Okay, let's see. Do we have anybody? We have to speak against the bill. Sunni McLeod, you recognize? Go then to the table, ma'am, recognize yourself, introduce yourself and who you're with and uh you may proceed express your concerns okay my name
is suny mcleod i'm sorry my name is suny mcleod and i breed and show pomeranians and i had a couple of questions on this the first one i think he already answered which was the definition of a commercial parking lot um is so the definition of the commercial parking lot is any parking lot that is run by a business, or I didn't know if a commercial parking lot was one where you had to pay and did not carry a thing. The other question I have about this is that if we're talking public property, where does written permission come from? And that's a question that I also have that nothing is said in the bill. I'd also just like to say that I don't think this bill does anything for animal rights. I don't think it does anything for the consumer. And that's really all I have to say about it okay any questions members
as a commercial parking lot whether you have to pay or not needs to be decided by the owner because you are running a business on their property public land of course you would have options whether it would be county or or city to go to those particular agencies that would that would cover that so we don't want people in a an easement or right away i bought i bought a dog on a county road uh i don't know who owned that uh that that property or if it was private or or not but that's basically what we're trying to stop and i think the main thing is if you got written permission then there's no problem uh but if you're going to set up a business on a person's property and and bring additional liability to them then you know they need to take that on by making that decision and allowing you to be there. So, like I said, it's a simple situation. Just get written permission. Thank
you. Okay, members, you've heard the explanation of the bill. What is the pleasure of the committee? Representative, seeing no motion, the bill dies due to lack of a motion. Okay, I'm sorry. all right members representative servilo had another bill that was placed on deferment house bill 1717 he did ask me last week to remove it from deferment i forgot that was my problem my fault got busy with some other issues going on but um to pull it off of deferment and Considered at this time it would take a motion to suspend the rules and pull it off a deferment. At that time, is there anybody that wishes to make a motion to suspend the rules to hear this, House Bill 1717? Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Since the representative did
of the committee. Okay. Members, we have a motion to suspend the rules to hear House Bill 1717. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. The ayes have it. Representative Cervillo, you may proceed with House Bill 1717. Thank you very
much. I'll be as brief as I can. As you know, this issue has been in conversation for a long time, and you have two sides of it. Basically, what this bill is doing is what we would say is a consumer protection bill. And basically, as you can read on page one, item number two, It ensures the citizens of Arkansas to have additional information regarding persons who sell dogs, cats, or both within the state of Arkansas. We looked at casual breeders because we didn't want to look at someone that is doing this kind of as somewhat of a hobby and what we basically classified that. So we've given definition that if you own three female dogs that you breed and have one litter a year, then you would qualify. And basically, you're going to pay $25 to register. We also define a commercial breeder, which would be above three dogs. The sale does not include the exchange. So if you're talking about someone giving away dogs, you don't have to register. So basically, concept is you're going to have a registration number, and the state will post that registration number so that you're identified as a breeder. There is some basic information that will be required that will be done online. your name location so forth but the location will not be published because they're his questions of possibly uh having people come to your property if you're doing it and say at your home so we want to protect them but the the other question that you have is that if by chance someone sells you a an animal that is diseased or ill Arkansas has a lemon law and what that lemon law basically will do is will allow you to recover the cost of the veterinarian care for that animal up to the cost of that that particular animal that you purchased the problem that you have here is that you can't find the seller and representative Prissy Hickerson had that situation when she bought an unhealthy puppy from a puppy mill could not find the the the seller of that so it's once again we get back to animal protection in in this bill we also provide the grace period and and what that basically would be is let's say, I didn't realize that I needed to register if I was going to advertise, and that once again, this is advertise, this animal, then you have a grace period of 10 days to go ahead and file without any particular penalty. Once the registration is completed, it's a two-year registration, and so if there's changes within that, there's no cost to the person to update that information. so I guess that bill is already working excuse me I'm so sorry my duck was calling anyway so why don't I I I open up for questions okay are there any questions for Representative
I definitely agree that there's a situation and there's a problem here that we have to work on. My problem is I'm not comfortable enough to know where we need to go with this. I'm facing kind of a similar situation with the light pollution bill I've been trying to work on, is to get everybody comfortable with where we're going with that to get the votes. I need to get something like that passed. You know, for example, and I guess I'll make this my question, the you know where we've got to uh include a registration number in advertising the sale of a dog or a cat so you know if i if i've got a puppy that i want to get rid of and i go on craigslist and i post an ad on there am i going to have to register with the state in order to be able to sell that and what if it's somebody from oklahoma who's trying to sell that um you know how do we how do we enforce that and so i i guess there there's a lot of questions in my mind on this and i'm wondering if and i hate to tell someone to put something in isp but i would like for us as a committee to have hearings on this subject so that way we can get comfortable as a group moving forward on where we're going with this i guess it's kind of where I'm at with that I'm just wondering what your thoughts are on that and how it relates to this bill and this this issue because I think most of us would agree this is probably an issue the questions is how do we handle it I think you're
how we handle it you know I think what most people on this committee and in the state they just want humane treatment of animals and i think that's been the as you see the puppy bill i mean puppy busts have been like in madison county and you say well they someone said the other day they get their day in court well they that hasn't happened it's been postponed and postponed so uh there's you know it's a felony um that have been filed and misdemeanor so so um we know that this is existing people want it to stop it's how do you how do you create the vehicle to stop it and one of the things that we thought with the registration normally people that are not um breeding animals correctly and so forth which we would say were puppy mills would not want to register with the state so i think what it does it's the first step of identifying uh breeders out there that are that that are breeding in the right way that at least the consumer now has the ability to look at the fact that they have filed with the state. So I think that's the identification. So really what you'd want to do is you want to promote the fact that if someone advertises, and once again it gets back to everything. if you have puppies and you want to sell them in your neighborhood and you're not going to advertise them, you don't have to do that. But it does tell the consumer if there's a registration number there that they've kind of gone through that process. There is a protection if you buy, if you get by on the old dog, because through that agency, we do have that information. We do have, you know, how they operate, where they're operating. And so that That would give the agency the option to go to those people and get restitution for the animal that cost them to take to the vet and so forth, so it's really consumer protection.
Representative Meeks asked if he wanted to send this to interim study and you said you thought he was right on target do i misinterpret uh are you wanting to send this to interim study or or what's your your intent here i was just trying to get some clarification there
i understand where you're going i appreciate that i just give me about three minutes and i'll give you that um respond to that if you would and let me just kind of give you another aspect of this that i think is a very important thing and that's the requirement of operating a business if one of your constituents starts a business, you're going to require them to have a license, collect sales tax, and pay income tax. If we don't support this bill, then we're allowing people to evade paying taxes. Let me give you a situation. Let's say Representative Hillman buys his wife a $2,000 necklace because he loves her, and so he's going to pay taxes on that. But if Representative Brown buys a $2,000 puppy online, she didn't pay anything. And so I think, you know, this has been a good thing for breeders, and it's not a situation that I'm trying to impose more taxes on them, but we've just run a bill concerning Internet sales, and we've said, if you're buying through the Internet, you're going to be paying taxes So we've tried to not pick and choose who wins. I think in this situation, people are picking and winning who pays and who doesn't. And I think that's really the crutch of this. And so with that, I would say to you, I'd like to go ahead and close and ask for a vote on this, Representative.
Chairman? Members, you've heard the explanation of the bill here. Are there any more questions for Representative Cervillo? I can take it to you and I'm going to study. Go
ahead. Representative Cervillo, I love you. You know, you're a wonderful guy, and you really got the best heart, and you want to do the right thing. But this is one of the most explosive things that I've ever dealt with in my years up here. And there's so many questions that are going through my mind. The puppy owners themselves are the ones that are really against it. I would beg you, I would ask you to put this in interim study and work it out with the people and bring us a good bill that will protect the puppies because that's what you want to do. We want to – every one of us love animals, so I would ask you to do that rather than vote.
Okay. Let me ask you, close your eyes and just think about this. A young little boy walking from his mom's – Okay, I'm thinking – I know. All right. Okay. Okay, if that's the desire of this committee and I get a commitment that you guys will work with us to get something done, then I will take it down and move it to interim study. Mr. Chairman. Okay, committee.
What is the desire of the committee? Do we feel like that is proper? Everybody just weigh in here. I think you've got a consensus here that this does not need to be addressed in its present form and you'd be better served pulling it down and putting it in an interim study, Representative. We would appreciate that. You can get with Ms. Martha and get that done. Thank you. All right, Representative Michael John Gray, you're recognized for House Bill 1876. And do you have an amendment for that bill, sir? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Yes, sir, I do have an amendment for that bill. Okay. You're recognized to
present your amendment. The amendment strictly, it's language that was left out of the bill for some reason that gives the Economic Development Commission authority to promulgate rules as to this bill.
Proceed with your amended bill, Representative. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. This bill does one simple thing. It creates a method and directs the Economic Development Commission to promulgate rules to make sure that when we use Arkansas tax dollars for economic incentives to construct or to bring a factory or jobs into Arkansas, that Arkansas workers get priority. and we're using Arkansas tax dollars to create those jobs there is anecdotal I'm sure many of you have heard in some of the last couple of big super projects where you could drive through the parking lot and finding an Arkansas license plate in the in the parking lot was pretty hard to find understanding that some positions are specialty and are not defined by state borders but a A lot of the emphasis on trade and workforce that we're promoting in Arkansas not to create a vehicle where those people trained in Arkansas and live in Arkansas would get to take advantage of our tax dollars in this way, I think is something we should start the conversation on. And I will be completely honest with this committee. The only, and I'm not saying there's more, but the only conversation negatively that I've had against this bill has been with Director Preston and Economic Development simply because they don't want to be hamstrung. They use an example I think some of you guys could relate to. They use an example as if they secured a plant in West Memphis or Fort Smith that the circle of potential employees would extend across state borders. and I think that's an absolutely reasonable position, and that's why the bill leaves that bottom for them to, where necessary, and we added in just now to give the commission some leeway to promulgate those rules to bring back for us to allow for situations just like that. And with that, Mr. Chair, I'll open to questions.
Chair. I see on page two, line three, I'm sorry, line four, shall ensure that whenever available and to the extent possible. That seems a little vague. And so would that not open us up to a lawsuit if you're in one of those border cities and they hire somebody from out of state to come over and then the person in Arkansas says, well, it was, I was available and I was to an extent possible. So would that not open us up to lawsuits for
that? So, Representative Sullivan, I think that's a very fair question, and I've asked that, too. I would be out of my league and above my pay grade to say what's open to a lawsuit and what's not. But what I will say is that one of the additional language in the amendment we adopted to allow the commission to more specifically define, I think that's one of the things I've learned in my short time here is that if we can leave room for the agencies that actually have to apply these rules to define more clearly the avoidance of issues just like you're pointing out could happen, and that's definitely why we wanted to include the language to allow the commission to promulgate rules that, just like any other set of rules, would have to come back through ALC
or the legislature for approval. Okay, Representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Well, I definitely appreciate the intent of what you're trying to do here. My concern is, and maybe you can address it, is that government is once again, I don't want to say picking winners or losers, but it's placing boundaries around business. And whenever you do that, you inadvertently or almost always, you end up driving the cost up. So if we've got a business comes to Arkansas or wants to develop in Arkansas and say it's a border situation, they've got to choose between two contractors. If the guy in Mississippi can do it cheaper than the guy in Arkansas, we're forcing them to choose the guy in Arkansas who's going to be the more expensive choice. So I'm concerned about these limitations that could end up being price drivers that I wouldn't think would prohibit these businesses from coming, but I don't want to create a situation or
an unintended consequence here with this. Representative, I think that's a very fair question, but I think it's one that's easily addressed. I think it would be quite the opposite. I think that we could see some real price competition because out-of-state contractors and in-state would, but past that, we're not asking companies to choose, we're not mandating that they choose a contractor. I have personally been an employee of a contractor that most of my time was spent out of state. But my point is, if they're going to use tax dollars to hire these contractors, the tax dollars of you and me and Arkansans, then priority going to Arkansans. But I think to address some of the concerns you have is why we would turn to the experts. And in this case, it's Economic Development Commission. And just like if we were in other committees, we direct the Department of Education, so to speak, to do things that we think are better for the people and the children of Arkansas, but we lean on that department with their expertise to actually draw in the specifics. I think your point's fair, but I don't necessarily think it would be a cost prohibitive or an increased cost on the company. I think by taking advantage of economic incentives from Arkansas taxpayers, I think that increasing jobs in Arkansas would
Whittaker, you had a question? Thank you, Mr. Chair. Representative, just to be clear, this would only apply to companies that had agreed to take millions, if not tens, and potentially hundreds of millions of dollars of
taxpayer money? Yes, sir. It would apply to people that are taking a financial incentive from the state of Arkansas. My discussions with the lawyers around this bill and with the Economic Development Commission once again allows them to set rules and parameters because we can do what-ifs all day long of what is an incentive and what's not an incentive, and that's why I would defer to AEDC to set up a strict set of guidelines based upon the premise that if you're using Arkansas tax dollars, then Arkansas workers would have the priority. Thank
you. Any other questions for the representative? Okay, anybody in the audience to speak against the bill? Come to the end of the table and recognize yourself,
sir. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Kurt Naumann, AEDC, Director of Research and Planning. Some of the comments that have been made, I think, particularly those of Executive Director Preston's, I would like to reiterate at this time. first and foremost the definition of resident requires that a person be domiciled or maintain an abode within the state for six months our biggest concern by far is with the border city businesses such as Texarkana, Fort Smith, Crossett, West Memphis when we sign an incentive agreement we sign incentive agreements for companies that hire people who are taxpayers of Arkansas so even though they may be a resident of texas or louisiana they're still paying taxes and we take that into account in our negotiations and our incentive agreements we do believe that this would be an undue burden on our border city businesses we're at 3.8 percent unemployment rate right now it's hard on companies now to find qualified workforce while honestly we would love for everybody who works in arkansas to live in arkansas we realize that that is not always a reality. And to maintain the financial viability of a business, it might be important that a certain percentage of the workforce be able to commute from a longer distance. It's a great idea. It's just highly impractical for some of our existing businesses. When it comes to recruitment of businesses, I think this puts us at a competitive disadvantage. If we are competing against other states that do not have restrictions like that, I think we'll be eliminated in the process or it will be another factor of cost which will potentially eliminate us again those are the the comments that mike preston presented uh that i would like to also make for the record today
so you don't feel like the amendment that was added will give you an ability to promulgate rules or fix those problems. I'd like your comments on the amendment that was added. Thank you. Well, I think
there were some issues that were raised, too, that we've not been able to address, like how is this going to affect the Commerce Clause and being able to have employees be freely moved between borders to be able to do the work. When we start putting restrictions on, again, we would have to define what an incentive is, and it sounds pretty simple and easy, But when you think about all of the various tax credits and exemptions and refunds and grant programs and other programs that are operated beyond AEDC, we're talking about a whole lot of things that can come into play here. I would love to find a solution offline to this so that we make that intent as purposeful as possible to the companies, perhaps in the incentive agreements themselves, as opposed to having legislation that mandates yet more rules and more bureaucracy. Representative
you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Dallman, do we not give these incentives to companies to come here so that they will employ Arkansans and will cause a tax base to grow in Arkansas? Is that not the reason we give them?
Absolutely, and we would prefer, like I said, that a majority of the folks here be residents of Arkansas. They are taxpayers. They will pay corporate individual income tax. I could see that they would pay
okay represent makes you had a question thank you mr chairman um in in the bill um it talks about um that the employee will be in our cans and when available and to the extent possible we we would definitely like taxpayer dollars to go to employ arkansans but we also at the same time have to make sure that taxpayers get the best value for their money absolutely so with that in mind the when available to the extent possible in your mind how much flexibility and i'll give you kind of a for instance let's say that you have an arkansan and you have somebody out of state the person out of state has a greater skill set to achieve what is needed and they may be even a little bit more expensive because of that greater skill set that the business owner would need and would be more profitable for the business owner to have. Would this allow for that to happen or would the Arkansas business have to take the less qualified employee because of this statute or how much flexibility does it give in these type of circumstances? I'm sorry, Representative, I assume
know what, when available and to the extent possible, really means, to be very honest with you. The only thing I could equate that to is you'd have to look at things like commuting patterns and labor shed analyses to see what a fair amount of that would be. If my memory is correct, I think areas like Texarkana have a 40% commuting patterns where folks come in from outside the agency. I don't know how that would affect on the actual hiring of employees. Again, that's another issue that I think is not well-defined in the bill to where there's some ambiguity that I
questions? Okay, thank you, sir. Thank you. All right. Anybody in the audience speak for the bill, against the bill? Seeing none, Representative Gray, you're welcome to close for your bill.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, members of the committee. I'd like to simply address a couple of those questions that came up. Representative Bentley, I think that was the reason this bill was very vague, was to allow the department to promulgate some rules. I think that you, as long as many of our colleagues in here would agree, is that sometimes when When we try to specifically define a bill, the department's come to the end of the table and says, this doesn't give us enough leeway. We can't do this. We can't do that. So while the gentleman was flipping about the vague language, it was very intentional to give them that leeway to make it work within their parameters and for it not to be a bar. Representative Fortner, I think your point was very well taken. I hope the statute has run, but I have worked out of state as a contract employee, and I paid taxes in Arkansas, not in Ohio and Indiana and the other states. I'm not going to name in case the statute of limitations hasn't run on that. So there will not be income tax from me in those states. So I think that was a fair point. I did pay sales and use tax when I operated there. I think, Representative Meeks, I think your point is absolutely spot on, which is exactly why that language is in this bill. if you are in a highly specialized field within, you know, hanging red iron and pouring concrete may sound one thing, but there may be a special machine, millwright specs that have to go into a building that the availability of the best person to do the job is not there. I think that's exactly why the language of this bill is vague, to allow for that to happen. And with respect to the department, respect to I appreciate their points, but I really think that what we're doing here is saying, OK, make it work. But we're going to use our Arkansas tax dollars to build buildings to use to we get beat in over the head with the term corporate welfare a lot around here. And we're going to say we're going to do that. We're going to use your tax dollars. But the priority is going to be on Arkansas employees. But we're going to allow the experts, the people that the governor and the legislature have seen to be the experts to do our economic development, to help promulgate the rules so as not to handcuff them but do the best for Arkansas with their taxpayers. And I think to the extent possible and the language allowing them to promulgate the rules versus us doing it and arguing over every rule at the end of a table like this is absolutely the best way. But I think your point is very well made there. and with that mr. chairman members of the committee I appreciate your time I would appreciate a do pass motion and a good vote
okay members you've heard the bill was the wish of the committee have a motion do pass as amended all those in favor signify by saying aye opposed nay representative I'm going to rule that the eyes have it your bill has passed thank you mr. chairman thank you committee okay committee we're getting down about to finish the house bills is anybody here to run the bill for 1755 for representative Collins saying no one we will move on to the Senate bills anybody here to run Senate bill 620 for a representative Standridge saying none The last bill we have, Senate Bill 553 by Senator Cooper, and I will turn the chair over to Vice Chair Hillman at this time. Mr. Chairman, when you get to the end of
members, but I don't know where they're from. I'm Zach Rose, and I'm the Southside District President. We're from baseball, Arkansas, but we go to Southside High School. All right. Good deal. Do you have your instructor with you? Yes, sir. All right. This is Mr. Justin Green. Okay. The rest of you guys introduce yourselves, or ladies, or whatever the case might be. I'm
Lynn Dallas, I'm your representative. Is your message in the city? Colton Geekoff, the secretary. Bill Thompson, the junior advisor. I want to talk to you. All right, good thing to do on spring break.
That's what my daddy always did, was we always worked the cows on Saturday when I was home from school. Mr. Chairman, you're recognized to present Senate Bill
553. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. At this time, I'd like to also bring to the table with me Adam McClung with the Cattlemen Association and Mr. Chase Duggar while I'm starting the bill. All right this bill members Senate Bill 553 provides for certification of individuals who engage in livestock embryo transfer or transplant and pregnancy determination if you look on the bill page or page 1 line 28 section a until july 1st 2019 the veterinary medical examining board is prohibited from investigating and prosecuting individual technicians who engage in both livestock embryo transplant and livestock pregnancy determination. In section B on line 33, it says before engaging in these practices of embryo transplant and preg checking, the individual must obtain certification from the board, the veterinary medical board. Then on page two, you will see on line three, section A, It says a letter from a licensed veterinarian who has witnessed the applicant's ability to perform embryo transplants and preg checking on at least three occasions within six months. This shows that we're just not letting anybody go out there and hang up a shingle and say, put a sign on the truck and say, hey, I do this. they are going to be required to show proficiency in that. On down on line 18, section B, it says, A record of successfully completing a qualified course taught by a livestock reproduction specialist on both embryo transplant and livestock pregnancy. Again, ensuring that individuals out there that are not licensed veterinarians but do have sufficient training and skills and have demonstrated proficiency can do this for a livestock producer if he or she so wishes. And with that, Adam, do you have anything to add to this? uh mr chairman
and committees of the member committee members of the committee i'll get it out here in a minute my name is adam mclong i'm the executive vice president of the arkansas cattlemen association our policy and legislative committee and our board looked through this we had numerous discussions over this issue and over this bill we feel like as an industry we've had a great working relationship with the veterinarians but we have a numerous members that weighed in during our policy and legislative committee discussion that we feel like that there is a demand for these services as far as embryo transplant work in moving our industry forward this is the next level and in in innovation in moving our industry forward and we feel like that there is a deficit in these services being provided so that we're in support of the bill my
name is chase duggar i represent rck genetics i believe representative douglas did a good job of explaining this bill i'll just point out a couple things adam and i have been working on this for the past several months i don't believe that either one of us see this as an attack against veterinarians rather we see it as supplementing the work that they are doing in a way that we feel better protects livestock owners and animals so we've created a list of qualifications that we think should be met to ensure that that those standards are met and the other only thing that I saw that I felt needed to be pointed out because there seems to be a little bit of misunderstanding is you'll notice that this this legislation says that it qualifies somebody to do both embryo transfer work and pregnancy determination which is commonly called prec checking I want to make it clear that this does not allow somebody to just do prec checking. You have to be an embryo transfer tech in order to do prec checking. So I wanted to make sure that that point was made clear. With that, there's two pages of qualifications here, so if you have any questions, we're happy
representative Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Only question that I have on this, the first thing that you do is you say that you're going to stop the veterinary medical board from investigating or prosecuting individual technicians for looks like two years to allow for implementation of the program. My concern is, is by doing that, um, are you going to leave it open for the bad guys to do a lot of bad things in the next two years before the good guys can get
qualified? I think that's a fair question. I, we stole that language from when the equine teeth floating bill was passed verbatim. A lot of remembrance. That's right. The, uh, the reason we included that was simply to give everybody time to ensure that the vet examining board had the opportunity to put everything together on their end and to ensure that these laymen who are out there performing these practices today have enough time to realize that they need to get certified and have the opportunity to do so.
Okay and and I will support that but as you go as this runs through I would I won't say be appreciative but but if you can come up with an amendment that would still allow them to get the bad guys i don't know if there are any bad guys out there whatsoever but um if that's something that y'all can maybe put your heads together and see if you can put some protection in there to stop the bad guys uh if
person but just something to consider thank you mr chairman representative brown you're recognized for a question thank you mr chair um i received an email this morning from a woman who works for a veterinarian and she was very supportive of this bill saying that there just aren't sufficient large animal livestock veterinarians in the state and even fewer who are willing or agreeable to perform the procedures of which this bill allows. Is that what has made this bill important to you? representative that that's
one of the problems that we find the number of large animal veteran veterinarians is in short supply in the state of arkansas probably nationwide one of the problems is it all comes down to economics you can stay in the office and you can work on 10 dogs and cats there and people don't care how much they spend on a dog or cat myself if i have a calf out there that's sick or something, and it's going to cost me more than the value of the calf, I'm going to shoot the calf. You know, and the thing is also, by the time the veterinarian makes the trip where he could see 10 dogs and cats in an hour, he can only see one sick cow. And so there are economic issues at play there that limit the number of large animal veterinarians. plus it's dirty a lot of it's outside kicked and dangerous work so we don't have a lot of large animal vets anymore there is they are in short supply and this is new technology uh adam you can weigh in here on this on the technical side of it representative brown that
that was the discussion that our our board and our policy and legislative committee had and why we landed on in support of this bill was because of the the deficit of services that's being offered in the countryside and more and more and more cattlemen even commercial cattlemen it's been pretty prominent technology used in in purebred operations with registered cattle but more and more and more it's becoming a used technology to move things forward even in commercial cattle and there's just a lot of these the discussion went on and on and on in our association and a of the large animal vets just they don't have time to offer the embryo work we're not trying to take anything away from them putting food on their table by no means we're not trying to to be against the vets it's more especially young vets that are coming back to the state to get started that's not our intent at all but we have a need for this service and a lot of times these large animal vets they're referring these guys to techs and lay people so it's already going on in the countryside and this would really clean it up and make everybody you know come into compliance thank Thank
you for that explanation. Any other questions from the committee? Is there anyone in the audience that would want to speak against this most, this bill? First of all, I have Austin Williams. Would you come to the end of the table and identify yourself, please? And you'd be recognized to speak against the bill. okay thank
you mr. Douglas for letting me speak and you know give you a peace of mind where I come from there's a group would you identify yourself please yes sir who you represent so I'm a large animal practitioner in northwest Arkansas most of the cows in the state are in the northwest region with that being said I work out of a four doctor practice we do this for a living. We have somebody on call 24-7. It's our life. I run up into Missouri, all over northwest Arkansas, spend a lot of time on the road. We never turn somebody down that makes a call. I visited with several other colleagues of mine about this situation. We were all in the same boat, and I wanted to come up here and kind of speak for them. I'm not a speaker I work one big goal of our clinic is to get young people like these guys right here involved currently we have a student at Oklahoma State and one at Missouri that have spent a lot of time at our clinic they've kind of grown up there we're molding them you know we want them to succeed at this they're both very interested a female and a male in large animal practice you know will we have room for them if we keep growing and spread out probably so but currently there's one of them looking at an underserved area um but we're at what i'm getting at here is when they were at home over spring break i had them read this bill so after they got done with it they both kind of had the same idea they were very discouraged and that scares me for these guys i'm not so much worried because i've made enough contacts and i've done this long enough you know i have good relationships with my producers another issue that i am concerned with is some of the jargon in the bill i'm no lawyer i don't write bills um you know it's it leaves it leaves a little bit of open-endedness there i know that um preg checking and embryo transfer you know if you're qualified for both of these i guess you can pull up to a to a farm and just preg check that day if if that if
if a uh if if you had this certificate would you be able to pull up to a farm yeah you you know how to flush cows you know how to put embryos in could you just preg check on that farm that day that's a question I had being being that said what happens is I preg check thousands of cows work sale barns thing is I very seldom go just to preg check cows we talk about tons of other stuff other issues that go on one thing leads to another so I think that's the part we're gonna miss out on also several purebred breeders that are in my neck of the woods I could think of five off the top of my head that have cows flushed yearly and have had for years some of those guys are even trained well enough they put in their own embryos so the services the opportunities are out there if you have guts and that's what it takes so you know visiting with colleagues I know there was a sale barn they were talking about at 101 not having anybody to preg check I talked with a group of guys the other day hey we'll come down there we'll rotate every week we'll preg check for that barn you know whatever it takes we'll sacrifice a Saturday but they're going to have to pay us so that's just an offer on the table addressing that talking with Dr. Churchy he's an ex-board member you know we both kind of had the same concerns you know that this bill will change the practice act um this allowing non-vets to provide services without clear knowledge supply you know of the supply and demand um you know of of these concerning issues um so that's why i extremely feel like it's at minimum this needs to go to a study guys i vet school is a for me it was one of the hardest things I've ever done it's very expensive you know if there's a will there's a way in life but I just really think that these guys right over here are the ones that are going to suffer from this because if you can pull up to a farm and just preg check you're going to start cutting these vets out that's just my opinion but But that's all I really have to say. I know I probably left some stuff out I wanted to say, but if you have any questions, please let me
know. A question from a committee representative, Meeks. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And as I stated earlier, I'm definitely not an expert in this area. But part of your testimony kind of alluded to this question. Are there guys that are already doing this that have no sort of qualifications, that are out there, freelancing, if you will, that this would be $1,000 to get licensed to be able to do this. I mean, you're not just going to have fly-by-night guys. These are going to be guys who are serious about this that are probably already doing it. Is there a lot of guys that are already doing this that aren't licensed? I mean, what are
you seeing along that? There are a few guys in our area that do run around and do this, but they've kind of weeded themselves out. There's one guy in particular that worked for a semen company and AI'd cows, lots of cows. I'll tell you right now, he's as good as I am every bit of it. He's had his hands in thousands of cows, and that's what it takes. He does preg check for a few guys. I'm friends with him. He accepts $0 for them. But I do hear stories about other parts of the state. I had one situation where a guy he was roughly an hour away called me he said hey I've got a disaster on my hands didn't know the guy from Adam so I pull up to his farm we preg checked a set of cows the lay person and I didn't criticize him I didn't do anything I just preg checked the cows he had called most of these cows non-pregnant and he was fixing to load them on a truck well they were they were pregnant the majority of them and at the time that was about a sixty thousand dollar mistake so being being said you know i don't know if the criteria set even for preg checking the cow is enough you know a few separate occasions a few months apart man that's a it's a dark hole until you do thousands of them i will tell you you're not comfortable with it and that that's a big deal to me so all right thank you thank you mr other questions from the committee all right uh
you're excused okay thank you uh now we have someone to speak for the amendment, John Knight. Mr. Knight, you're recognized once you identify yourself and who you represent.
I'm John Knight. I wear a lot of different hats. I'm here mainly today with the Livestock Marketing Association. I'm also the owner of 101 Livestock Auction and I've been a cattleman for 30 some odd years. Um, just like to speak, uh, the gentleman that just spoke, the doctor, uh, my firm called his firm, uh, about a year, year and a half ago. Uh, and they declined to service our barn at that time. Um, you know, sentiment may have changed. Um, first of all, I'd like the committee to know that, uh, you know, we find no fault with the veterinarians, uh, in the situation that, that we've got right now the issues about about cash flow uh and and obviously the practices that serve small animals are just like he stated before a lot more lucrative for them um and today uh the industry uh as far as large animals goes we're just in a mess we don't have enough guys to to service and do what we do uh you know it's it's dangerous work uh it's hard work it's hot work just to put it in perspective for you our livestock market employees as far as workers comp goes our employees are classified uh in the same class as far as workers comp goes as coal miners as i stated before i'm the owner of 101 livestock auction a little over a year ago our veterinarian that we'd had worked with for several years needed to go and take some time off and be with his family. I had a young son growing up, so he went to one day a month for us. We advertised this position on the state veterinarian's website for three months. I made over 55 phone calls to veterinarians across the state. We ran ads in the Arkansas Democrat Gazette. We had zero interest. We never had a single person inquiring to this job. There never was an issue about the pay. We had zero interest. You know, this kind of work, I think if we don't do something here, we're hindering the ability of the cattlemen of the state of Arkansas, and we're restricting commerce within the state of Arkansas. We need to do something here to take care of this and put a patch on this.
All right, any questions from the committee? Mr. Knight? Okay, Mr. Knight, you're excused. Do we have anyone who wishes to speak against the bill? The next one on the list is Grant Williams. if you go to the end of
the table and identify yourself you'll be recognized to speak against the bill my name is grant williams and uh i am a uh sit down there I'm a cattle production owner in North
Arkansas. I have a herd of usually purebred charlays, and I have about 140, 50 cows and calves a year. And it's very, I've got several things to say about this, if I can beg of the time. But like Dr. Williams said, if you make a mistake on pregnancy checking as to the term or if it's pregnant or not, it could cost a lot of money, a lot of money. And when I sell it, I've had it, just like you said, occasionally something will not be exactly the way it is, and it's a big blowback from a contract that you have. So, and these fellows that are licensed vets, they've gone, I know, for four years, and I understand it's a lot of experience also and time spent, you know, as the best teacher. So you may, and I'm sure there are probably fellows out there that do a great job of that, but I'm thinking you may be opening this up for a wholesale business of doing this, and it might not be to the benefit of the cattle operator. But that's not for me to say. That's for y'all's business to say. But other things that I have to say are that, let me get my notes out. When you have a veterinarian out to work the herd, I can almost assure you they're not going to call someone out just to preg check and then get the herd up again and run all the cattle through the same procedure again. so somebody's probably going to follow by the wayside either this practitioner won't be called or the veterinary won't be called because i'm saying you're going to they're going to do other work for you they're going to go ahead and dehorn castrate give all the cathode shots if there is anything to give and all the annual vaccinations and this usually happens at least a couple of times a year and i can i can envision that they would probably uh they probably will if these fellows get pretty good at you're going to cut down on probably the number of veterinarians that will come back to the state of Arkansas and Arkansas is the only state that there's the only state in the central location that all the surrounding bordering states have a veterinary medical school I happen to know somebody who tried to become one I've taught schools too for 36 years and this is also I'll tell you the story the person that got in was one of 600 out-of-state applicants to get into this particular vet school uh they said when he was there they granted interviews to 60 of you and we'll be picking 20 of you now that's the ratios of how hard it is for these kids like these guys to ever get in because we don't have a school here and and uh uh that being said i in teaching public school i was a vocational business teacher i was i was an ag I was in business. I've taught accounting, business management, entrepreneurship, economics, business law, and such as that. I had a great time, but it's broken my heart. I've seen counselors year after year after year after year for 36 years push high schoolers into upper-level science and biology courses, heavy math stuff, because they say you will be able to, if you want to be able to be in any medical profession, you need to take this upper-level stuff. They get out. They'll go to maybe the U of A and get in freshman chemistry or biology. and they're weeded out, they're told immediately there, you can't do this. And they know, they're telling the truth. There won't be 1% of you guys make it, so you might as well get this out of your mind, get your pipe dream going. This continues right here, will hurt, this will also make it a pipe dream for these guys if this particular bill becomes a law, in my opinion. And that's, you know, 35 cents in that, and you get a cup of coffee, okay? and I have talked to other vets around our area most of them were they'd had no idea that this was even coming down the pike they were all real saddened existing vets and unless there were there was one that was very old he was a little bit older and he said well my days are numbered anyway so it won't make a whole lot of difference to me and I think that you wouldn't want to do harm to someone who has happened to have given their and i happen to know this person got in that school cost them 250 000 too to get out of that particular school and that's what it cost whereas this bill i think reads maybe a thousand or something so and that that can be you know anyone can get into that and maybe you guys if this passes you guys should try that uh uh any one of you. The other things that I was going to mention here, let me see, I'm taking up valuable time here for you. Oh, I'm not only an independent cattle producer, I belong to the Cattlemen's Association, and I'm here to speak for a lot of individuals who are Arkansas cattlemen who do not agree with the policies and procedures, at least on the issues that we're talking about today and other issues that are expounded by the Cattlemen's Association. That particular group has been for the merger of major companies like JBS and National Beef. they have they have talked against the country of origin label and in 2015 they got it done. Our prices went to pot immediately after June of 2015 and they have remained that way and that organization which is represented here and I'm a member of it and I'm despicably against what they represent they are members they have in 1996 The national affiliate of this, which is the National Cattlemen's Association, they were merged with the Meat Packers Association. The name does not say Packers or Processor anywhere in that National Cattlemen's Association name of the association. And they lobby before Congress. They lobby here before you. And they don't always represent the will of the guy who mainly pays the dues. and they have lobbied they're lobbying against the reinstatement of the cool that stands for country of origin label where the beef was born raised and originated in
of them so thank you sure i guess my question is is that there's a lot of concern that we're going to create competition so so on so forth provisions of the bill state that in order for somebody to be licensed to be able to do this that they have to have the approval of a vet so if the veterans if the vets don't want competition all they have to do is not sign off on any of these these letters so my thinking is and maybe you can correct me if i'm wrong the only way you're going to get a veterinarian to sign off on for somebody to compete against them in their area is if that vet sees a need and believes this person to be well qualified to fulfill that need uh to maybe help them out am i seeing that wrong or do you see that do you think vets are going to start signing off on these all over the state and before you know it they're going to flood
the market and they're going to let there's there's there's a two facets of veterinary medicine large animal small animal the majority or small animal, they're licensed to do the large animal stuff just like the large, and they probably will not mind signing off to get somebody off their back to get rid of the calls they will get for those type of services they're not intending to render. And there's so few large animal vets that come back to Arkansas. I do think this will dissuade people from coming back, and if the cattlemen don't mind not having a vet to do, I hope these guys, I hope that they will also license them to do cesarean sections and stuff like that so they can go ahead and do that because if they want to do one thing, they can go ahead and license it to do other stuff. Why not do that? It's, you know, that's my take on it. I had one other thing. Thank you, Mr. Williams. I probably
the committee? Quickly. Fortner. Yes, sir. Do you or I don't know if you speak for all the vets, But would you think there would be any opportunity for a compromise if Representative Meek said that he's a kind soul, he thinks altruistic people? How about if the vets made a portion of the profit from the people that were getting the certificate and they worked under their direction out of their practices but had the independence to do the job that we need done? Do you think there's any flexibility there for the veterinarians? Well, if what you're saying, they have to
work directly under them each time, I'm not too sure that that would work. It might. if they had to work under the same person that licensed them, signed off initially and have a close contact with them then that might be a viable thing. I was also in reading the bill I think it was brought up before there might be some misunderstanding. I think there's been communication there and somebody needs to correct me on this for everybody's benefit I thought that it was being proposed I've heard that you can only preg-check those cows that you also embryo transplant to see if they were pregnant. Not necessarily go to a farm and just forget the embryo work, just preg-check cows. I think it needs to be very clear in this bill, if it is not clear, as to what this intent of this bill is and the effect that it is really going to have, I don't know. What was the answer to my question?
Do you think there's flexibility or not? If it was directly, if they worked under one vet all the time, more or less like an agent or an employee, it probably would.
Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Williams. You're excused. We have anybody to speak for the bill? Someone to speak against the bill? Mr. Jenkins, Paul Jenkins? If you don't have anything else to add, be very brief. Okay, all right. Yes, you may.
Good morning. Thank you. I'm Paul Jenkins. I'm a veterinarian. I practice at Valonia. I practiced two years in South Louisiana before I came to Arkansas. I am also on a farm at El Paso and have some commercial cattle of my own. I share some of the same concerns that y'all have heard this morning from the Cattlemen's Association about a shortage in large animal veterinarians and then also Mr. Knight from Livestock 101. But I do have some concern that this is going to create a slope that negatively impacts us getting some more large animal veterinarians coming to the state because it would be seen as a deterrent. I'd want the committee and those in the room just to understand a little bit about what embryo transfer is and all of the ingredients that come along with that. Embryo transfer is taking an individual cow, a female, manipulating her heat cycle through hormone injections. Some of those are implants causing her to super ovulate. generally there's artificial insemination of that individual and then a few days later usually seven to ten those embryos are going to be flushed that requires a media some states require that a caudal epidural be done as well at that point the the person that's doing the transfer is going to evaluate those embryos for viability. And then there would be a donor cow or cows that would be timed with her heat cycle as well from, I'm sorry, recipient cows that would be timed with the donor that would receive those. So I want y'all to gain some appreciation that there's a lot of medications that have to be used for this, hormonal drugs, prescription drugs, as well as the implants as veterinarians this year if any of you are aware from that committee in January 2017 the the veterinary feed directive came out and you know now it certainly limits antibiotics so you know there is more scrutiny on us to regulate drugs and and prescriptions and that sort of things and that veterinary feed directive came from the federal government not from us so I want you to gain an appreciation that there are a lot of drugs that are to be used there needs to be a veterinary client patient relationship established with that producer and and you know before those drugs can be ordered and used it's not something you can go grab off the shelf at your local feed store I've got some concern about need for it in Arkansas I would like to see a study that possibly Cattlemen's Association could put before us that says, hey, there's a big need for this. Generally speaking, my experience has been this is going to be more of your registered herd owners, folks that are willing to spend a lot of money on cattle and embryos. There even can be international trade of these embryos if they're frozen. And that brings up a whole new area in itself that when the international trade starts with them. Other concern I have in reading this bill is I do not see any wording about consumer protection, i.e. liability insurance. As a licensed veterinarian, I pay a lot in my liability insurance to have several hundred thousand dollars of protection just on myself. that doesn't include my employees my building etc and you know that from the examining board standpoint yes they are there to protect the consumer okay that cattle owner and i've got some concern is when this is being done does that producer that has embryo transfer work done if something goes bad in that situation do they have protection do they have consumer protection to fall back on for one of these individuals that's that's doing it so there you know there's certainly some importance with with with that consumer protection I also want to keep the animals in mind here. We are stewards of animal welfare, and we have to be the surveillance of infectious disease. There are many reproductive diseases that also can be transferred zoonotically, none of which I want as a veterinarian. There's also some diseases that we are constantly aware of and need to make our federal veterinarians aware of if we see any of those so I've got some concern about let's make sure these individuals are properly trained and also looking out for those those issues as well from the animal welfare standpoint I will tell you Arkansas has not been a state that has had glowing reviews on our animal husbandry and the education you know thereof on looking out for that animal. And I will tell you that a broad spectrum of species. So, you know, I want to make sure that these folks are trained well that, you know, are looking out for the welfare of the animal. Those animals are our patients as veterinarians. Obviously, we don't look at them as property. I raised my right hand and took an oath the day I graduated that, you know, I would do that as a veterinarian. And so I want to make sure that that training is in place. And from the standpoint of training, generally speaking, my experience has shown that these folks need to have advanced degrees. This typically is a master of science. Would you please hurry on and conclude your remarks, please? Absolutely. The final thing
list, is that I don't feel comfortable with somebody learning this at a weekend seminar, and I'm open to questions. Thank you for your time. Mr. Town, do you have anything to add to that?
Identify yourself, please, for the record. Yes, sir. Thank you so much, Vice Chairman Hillman, for allowing us the gravity to speak together in the interest of time. Yes, sir, we do have a little bit of additional stuff, and I will try to hurry through it. I'm a member of the Arkansas Cattlemen's Association. I have a multi-doctor veterinary clinic in Searcy, Arkansas. We are a multi-species clinic. I concentrate primarily on large animal. I'm a member of the Society for Theriogenology, which is the Reproductive Experts Association, AETA and IETS. To go very quickly, yes, as he was expounding, There is a large number of well-educated people out there that are veterinarians that do embryo transfer. I know that there are at least four that come into the state of Arkansas that do this, that are licensed within the state of Arkansas. There is also some problems. If there are problems associated with those individuals, of course, they can go to the exam board. To speak about the ultrasound portion of the bill, the Society for Theriogenology, which are the animal reproductive experts, has a short statement about that. They said, for the diagnostic techniques to be effective in extensive knowledge of the veterinary disciplines of anatomy, embryology, and physiology are required, as well as training in pathology and radiographic principles, all of which are provided in a veterinary medical education. As such, the Society for Theriogenology and the American College of Theriogenology told that the ultrasonography as a diagnostic imaging procedure in determining reproductive status constitutes the practice of veterinary medicine. So they are against this sort of thing. In our area in particular, in our county in particular, We have four individuals that do ultrasound determination of pregnancy. I'm sure that there, I definitely agree with Mr. McClung, that there are least perceived hotspots of where there may be quite some distance from a veterinary clinic or from a veterinarian to the need. My concern is, of course, that that will only be increased by a bill such as this. As far as y'all were asking earlier about a potential compromise, in this state, while we have no veterinary school, we do have a wonderful veterinary technology school, which is an associate's degree program which leads to licensure called a certified veterinary technician. And we have several certified veterinary technicians within the state. They have extensive training in anatomy, physiology, and reproductive abilities. And I believe that they would be excellent as a potential in-between that they could perform these services. Currently, our Practice Act does not allow them to work under indirect supervision. But if it would at some point please the committee, that would be something that I believe that the VMA would be interested in exploring with you. And I also spoke with the director of the program, Dr. Christy Coley, and she was very excited about the potential of teaching a large animal elective that would also do embryo transfer for those individuals. all right we have some questions
chairman my question i guess came up when mr jenkins was speaking so i'll ask him that i'm intrigued i have cattle interests like you in other states where do you practice i guess is the first mini question i practice in bologna bologna do you do embryo transfer i do
not sure i'm aware of an individual that's uh around white county that may be coming over in our area that's doing it who is not a veterinarian or one of these licensed practitioners so the
person in White County that is doing this now is doing it without veteran oversight, without veterans or vets. That's my understanding. Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Other questions from
and you're excused. Is there anyone else in the audience who want to speak for the bill, against the bill? If not, Mr. Chairman, you are recognized to close for your bill.
Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. You know, the last thing we want to do is hurt our veterinarians. We want them to be successful. We want young people to go into veterinarian medicine and come back to the state of Arkansas. The fact is that there are some veterinarian deserts or some places where we don't have enough large animal vets. This is just trying to fill a niche where other people can come in and do that. You know, we have made sure that the bill has adequate provisions that allow for training for oversight by the veterinary medical board to get their approval and ensure that these people are proficient in this and then it boils down to this is an expensive procedure you spend a lot of money and I as a cattleman number one I don't do this practice, but if I did, I would want to make sure that who I had performed this practice was proficient and well qualified. I would hire a vet, a veterinarian, to come out and do it because of their in-depth training on other issues also if I could find one that could do it when I needed it done but if that there is not the availability there we need to be able to allow other individuals and the cattlemen to make that decision on who they use and have available to perform these services with that i would close and i would appreciate a good vote was that a motion do pass?
no. Okay. You know, as a practicing physician, one of the things out here in the legislature that we can do is we can legislate anybody to do anything and and I I have a problem with legislating a lay person to do a procedure that that requires as much expertise without having the supervision of a practicing veterinarian if if if to me if if if a if one of these people worked for a vet and was trained and that vet was liable and responsible if that guy goes out and does something wrong and that animal dies or he doesn't pick up some type of transmittable disease that the animal has and that a vet would have recognized, somebody's got to be responsible. And if these people worked for veterinarians and were under their supervision, I wouldn't have a problem. But I have a little bit of difficulty in letting someone that may not have the educational experience out there. So I understand the intent of it, and I don't need to speak against my chair, but I'm going to have to be a no on this.
to interim study. Okay. Are there other bills to come before this committee today? As the chairman makes his way back up here before you all leave, I think he has some announcements. Okay, Representative Wood.
Real quick, I got a message from. Pull the mic down. During that last discussion, I got a text from Representative Collins. If I could run 1755 very quickly. Okay, that's
up to the chair get after it real quick because we still need to eat two before session I just want to thank everybody that's leaving right now for your attendance today and your
your input there You're recognized. Thank you. Mr. Chair. Representative Collins is tied up in other business. He's asked that I run the the House Bill 1755 in committee for him. It authorizes the Trail of Tears bikeway from the Oklahoma-Arkansas border into the University of Arkansas down Highway 62. It does not require highway funds. It authorizes Highway Department to erect these things and collect grants and gifts, both public and private. It'd be a great economic driver for my district and for Northwest Arkansas. okay
represent pitch okay any other discussion committee i i do have one question you say the highway department will bear no expense on this um okay on paper
i don't think they'll use highway department funds is what i should say obviously any grants or uh private gifts they get would pass through their uh accounting systems and procurement systems and pay for the actual signs but it does not require budgeting of highway department funds. Okay, and my
only other concern is as a farmer and being out on roads and stuff with bicyclers, sometimes they can be an impediment to moving equipment. They can be dangerous. Is this going to put a lot more people on that highway on bicycles? Well, the hope is it
will put more people on bicycles, but it also calls for the construction of federal bike lanes that meet federal standards. So they won't be in the actual traffic lanes of Highway 62. And, of course, none of this will happen if the money doesn't, you know, if they don't raise the money. Okay. Anybody have any further questions? Okay. Anybody in the
HB1536 M. Gray TO AMEND THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT TO INCLUDE WOMEN-OWNED BUSINESSES.
11:53 - 46:2897 segments11 speakers
Representative Michelle Gray moved an amendment to HB 1536 that restructured the Minority Business Economic Development Act by keeping a 10 % goal for minority-owned firms, adding a separate 5 % goal for women-owned firms, and reducing the service-disabled veteran goal from 5 % to 2 % while shifting it to the economic-development statute.
[13:12][13:26][13:34][13:48][14:20][14:52][15:34][16:13]
The committee voted to adopt the amendment after a motion and voice vote, with the chair recording the amendment’s passage.
[13:26][13:34]
Subsequent testimony from the Arkansas Economic Development Commission and committee members clarified that the changes would not increase agency staffing or reporting burdens and would consolidate certification data for better tracking.
[23:13][23:35][24:06][24:39][29:31][30:03][30:06][30:34]
The chair then moved to pass the bill as amended, and the committee approved the final version.
[46:06][46:08]
HB1748 Pilkington TO DESIGNATE THE WOOD DUCK AS THE OFFICIAL STATE DUCK. .
46:28 - 2:14:33259 segments32 speakers
Representative Aaron Pilkington presented HB 1748 to designate the wood duck as Arkansas’s official state duck, noting that the wood duck was chosen over the mallard after committee consultation.
[46:41][46:55]
After brief discussion and a co-sponsor’s confirmation, the committee adopted a procedural amendment and proceeded to vote on the designation.
[47:20][47:41]
The motion to adopt the amendment and the final vote to make the wood duck the state duck both passed unanimously.
[47:20][47:41][48:13]
HB1755 Collins TO CREATE THE TRAIL OF TEARS HISTORIC BIKE ROUTE.
2:14:33 - 1:26
Rep. David Whitaker presented HB 1755, proposing the Trail of Tears historic bike route from the Oklahoma-Arkansas border to the University of Arkansas along Highway 62, to be funded through private grants and gifts rather than state highway dollars.
[2:14:54][2:15:04][2:15:17][2:15:26]
Chair Dan Douglas raised a safety concern about cyclists on a farm road, and Whitaker assured that the route would employ federally-standard bike lanes set apart from traffic.
[2:15:36][2:15:57][2:15:59]
The committee moved to close the bill, a vote was taken with members voting “aye,” and the motion to pass was adopted without recorded opposition.
[2:16:17]
HB1768 Tucker TO CREATE AN INCOME TAX CREDIT FOR INVESTMENTS IN SMALL ARKANSAS-BASED HIGH-TECHNOLOGY BUSINESSES.
HB1847 Capp TO PROVIDE FOR ARKANSAS AGRITOURISM SIGNS AT STATE WELCOME CENTERS AND TOURIST INFORMATION CENTERS THROUGH THE ARKANSAS WINE COUNTRY TRAILS PROGRAM.
1:26 - 1:06:55185 segments24 speakers
Representative David Hillman introduced HB 1847 to authorize agritourism signage at welcome and tourist information centers, explaining that the bill would direct the Parks and Tourism Department and the State Highway Department to install the signs.
[1:41]
Lawmakers raised concerns that the language appeared to favor the wine industry over other agricultural sectors and questioned whether the bill would equitably promote agritourism statewide.
[2:21][2:49][3:14]
Testimony from the Arkansas Wine Producers Council highlighted the year-round nature of wine tourism and the desire to place large signs near tourist centers, while the State Highway Department warned that the proposed 12-by-48-foot signs could encroach on right-of-way and lacked a clear funding mechanism.
[3:52][4:22][4:54][5:27][8:35][9:12]
Facing unresolved right-of-way and cost issues, Representative Hillman asked to withdraw the measure, and the chair noted that the bill was being pulled from consideration.
[9:39][9:48][9:51][10:22][10:25][10:42]
HB1871 Lemons TO ENSURE THE CERTIFICATION AND TRAINING OF ANIMAL CONTROL OFFICERS.
HB1876 M.J. Gray TO REQUIRE AN ENTITY THAT RECEIVES AN ECONOMIC INCENTIVE FROM THE STATE TO EMPLOY OR CONTRACT WITH ARKANSAS RESIDENTS IN COMPLETING THE PROJECT THAT IS SUBJECT TO THE FINANCIAL INCENTIVE AGREEMENT.
1:06:55 - 48:16
Speaker 149 (representing HB 1876) moved an amendment granting the Economic Development Commission authority to promulgate rules for projects receiving state economic incentives, and the committee approved the amendment by voice vote.
[1:07:13][1:07:25][1:07:38]
HB2078 Sorvillo TO CREATE AN OFFENSE FOR SALE OF DOGS OR CATS ON PROPERTY WITHOUT OWNER'S WRITTEN PERMISSION; AND TO PROTECT CONSUMERS AND ANIMALS FROM PUPPY AND KITTEN MILLS.
48:16 - 1:28:34126 segments20 speakers
Representative James J. Sorvillo introduced an amended version of HB 2078 that would exempt commercial parking lots and require written permission from property owners for dog or cat sales on private land.
[48:39][48:46][49:20][49:53]
Breeder Suny McLeod questioned the definition of “commercial parking lot” and asked how written permission would be obtained on public property, arguing the bill did not advance animal-rights or consumer protections.
[50:34][51:01][51:33]
Sorvillo replied that permission must be obtained from the property owner-whether a private business or a public agency-and that the written document would satisfy any sheriff’s inquiry.
[52:05][52:08][52:39]
No motion to approve the amendment was offered, and the chair declared the bill dead for lack of a motion.
[53:13][53:45]
HB2218 M. Gray TO AMEND THE MINORITY BUSINESS ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ACT.
HB1956 M. Gray TO DEFINE THE PAYROLL CALCULATIONS FOR MEETING THE PAYROLL REQUIREMENTS OF EMPLOYERS RECEIVING INCENTIVES UNDER THE CONSOLIDATED INCENTIVE ACT OF 2003.
SB553 J. Cooper TO PROVIDE A CERTIFICATION FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ENGAGE IN LIVESTOCK EMBRYO TRANSFER OR TRANSPLANT AND LIVESTOCK PREGNANCY DETERMINATION.
1:28:34 - 54:57
The bill was introduced by Chase Duggar (Speaker 176) who explained that SB 553 would create a certification for individuals to perform both embryo-transfer and pregnancy-determination work, listed two pages of qualifications, and included a two-year grace period before the Veterinary Medical Board could enforce the provisions.
[1:28:56][1:29:25][1:29:31][1:30:07][1:30:31][1:31:01][1:31:12][1:31:28]
Committee members, notably Rep. Stephen Meeks, questioned whether the two-year exemption could become a loophole for “bad actors” and urged an amendment to add protections against misuse.
[1:30:40][1:31:01][1:31:12][1:31:28][1:31:44][1:31:52]
SB620 Standridge TO EXEMPT CRYSTAL QUARTZ MINING ON PRIVATE PROPERTY FROM THE ARKANSAS OPEN-CUT RECLAMATION ACT.
HB1717 Sorvillo TO CREATE THE DOG AND CAT SALE REGISTRATION ACT; AND TO CREATE THE DOG AND CAT SALE REGISTRATION FUND.
54:57 - 2:16:28237 segments29 speakers
Representative James J. Sorvillo presented HB 1717, describing it as a consumer-protection measure that would require breeders to register dogs and cats, post registration numbers, and allow owners to recover veterinary costs under the state’s lemon law.
[55:04][55:21][56:00][56:40][57:16][57:55][58:28]
After a brief exchange, the committee reached consensus that the bill in its current form should not be acted upon and agreed to refer it to interim study.
[1:05:49][1:06:20]