May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.
About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
SB758 Smith TO REVIEW, STUDY, AND REFORM ALL LAWS, STATUES, REGULATIONS, AND RULES Collins-PERTAINING TO BEER, LIQUOR AND WINE IN THE STATE OF ARKANSAS. 1:07
Representative Kim Hammer introduced SB 758, explaining that it mandates a joint review by the House and Senate State Agencies committees of all Arkansas alcohol statutes and sets a hard reporting deadline of October 1, 2018 to the Speaker and President Pro Tem.
[3:11][3:24]
Representative Andy Davis raised a procedural concern that the study was placed before the State Agencies Committee rather than the House Rules Committee, which has greater expertise on ABC matters, leading several members to propose an amendment to add the Rules Committee or create a joint committee for the review.
[3:58][4:30][5:01][5:33][6:35][7:01][7:06]
The chair accepted the suggestion, agreed to hold the bill while an amendment is prepared, and withdrew the measure for the time being, with no vote taken during the meeting.
[12:33][13:04][13:09]
SB521 Hickey TO AMEND THE PROCESS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR REQUESTS FOR PROPOSALS AND REQUESTS FOR QUALIFICATIONS; TO LIMIT THE TERM OF PUBLIC CONTRACTS; AND TO RE… 13:42
Senator Jimmy Hickey introduced SB 521, which would permit pricing to be a factor in RFQs, require disclosure of evaluation-team relationships, cap multi-year contracts at four years (with limited extensions and a possible ten-year term for contracts over $20 million), and create a sunset provision that keeps the current RFQ rules for seven professional groups until June 30 2019 while a study committee is established to review the process.
[17:32][18:04][18:39][19:13][19:47][20:21][20:51][21:24]
Committee members asked how the exemption would be applied, which groups it covered, and whether price could be waived in extraordinary cases; Hickey responded that the exemption includes architects, engineers, construction managers, financial advisors, legal and land-surveyors, that price can be reduced to zero under extraordinary circumstances, and that the bill allows design-phase bids to proceed under the existing RFQ framework.
[22:13][22:27][22:41][23:00][23:19][23:32][24:04][24:08][24:43][25:17][25:50]
Representative Kim Hammer and Senator Hickey emphasized the bill’s aim to improve procurement of billions of dollars in taxpayer funds, set clear deadlines for best-practice development, and assure that the process will function as intended, urging members to support it; Hammer’s motion to pass the amendment to SB 758 was offered, received no discussion, and was adopted unanimously.
[1:13:01][1:13:38][1:14:14][1:14:45][1:15:17][1:15:42][1:15:50][1:16:21][1:17:59][1:18:19]
SB758 Smith TO REVIEW, STUDY, AND REFORM ALL LAWS, STATUES, REGULATIONS, AND RULES Collins-PERTAINING TO BEER, LIQUOR AND WINE IN THE STATE OF ARKANSAS. 1:20:27
Rep. Kim Hammer introduced SB 758, emphasizing its hard deadline for recommendations and urging a vote to pass the measure.
[1:20:37]
Chair Rep. Jack Ladyman adopted an amendment and, after a voice vote, reported the amendment passed unanimously.
[1:20:56]
With no further discussion, the committee approved SB 758 as amended, effectively passing the bill.
[1:21:08][1:21:11]
SB175 B. King TO REQUIRE MEDICAID PROVIDERS AND GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS TO DISCLOSE OF CONFLICTS OF INTEREST. 1:21:49
The committee considered SB 175, introduced by Rep. Kim Hammer and presented by Rep. Josh Miller and Sen. Bryan King, which would require Medicaid providers, hospitals and related entities to disclose financial transactions over $2,000 to prevent conflicts of interest.
[1:22:01][1:22:07][1:22:26][1:22:29][1:22:38][1:23:14][1:23:34]
After prolonged debate, the committee voted on a motion to pass the bill, but the nays prevailed and SB 175 failed to advance.
[1:58:13][1:58:31][1:58:41]
HB1946 Tucker TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ACCESS TO PUBLIC INFORMATION; AND TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967. 2:00:09
Rep. Tucker’s HB 1946, amending the Freedom of Information Act to create a three-person panel for independent review of FOIA requests, was introduced and an amendment was quickly moved forward.
[2:00:21][2:00:30][2:00:42][2:00:51][2:01:02]
After brief discussion of the panel’s role in providing an objective appeal process without costly lawsuits, the committee approved the amendment and the bill by voice vote.
[2:00:51][2:01:02][2:01:26][2:01:57][2:02:29][2:02:42]
SB425 Rice AN ACT CONCERNING THE DUTIES OF THE STATE BOARD OF FINANCE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 2:04:18
Senate Bill 425, concerning the duties of the State Board of Finance and declaring an emergency over the hiring of an unqualified senior investment manager for the Treasurer’s Office, was presented by Rep. Justin Gonzales, who argued the position requires a mandatory college degree given the $3 billion at stake.
[2:04:43][2:04:47][2:05:16][2:05:48]
Gonzales requested additional committee time, proposing a post-session meeting to achieve broader consensus before any vote could be taken.
[2:06:55][2:07:00][2:07:21][2:07:28][2:07:37]
Okay, I think we've got mostly Senate bills, and we're going to jump around on the agenda here a little bit. We may have one or two House bills, but primarily we're going to run Senate bills, and we'll move around because people are here that may need to go to other meetings. I will let you know that we just got a text from Representative Ballinger, and he has a new 8-pound, 13-ounce granddaughter, and they're all doing well. Okay. So the first bill we're going to run is SB 758, Representative Hammer. Representative Hammer, you're recognized to run your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. If Senator
Linda Collins-Smith, I'm not sure if she's still in the room or had to leave, go to another meeting. All right. Would you give me that bill number again, please? 758. Members, this is a bill that Senator Collins-Smith is running, and it is really an excellent bill because what it does is it will put for the next two years on the table for discussion and study the laws and everything related around the ABC division. and areas that are going to be underneath their jurisdiction, specifically with regard to the dispensing of beer, liquor, wine in the state. There has been some discussions about the laws under which they operate, and this is actually not met with any resistance because it's a non-threatening environment that's going to be created in order to be able to have that discussion. And that's kind of the front porch. I'll let Senator Smith
build the rest of the House. Members, I'm proud to be here this morning. The purpose of this bill, when we had several things come up on alcohol and we saw some things through the tobacco, you know, some outrageous fines and things like that that we saw in judiciary. So this bill came about because it was needed. When we asked questions, people didn't know the answers. Many of us were not here when those laws were made. And I think Representative Hammer's done a good job opening that up. But when we are asked about why the fines are this way for someone and they're not for another, or why, you know, a certain rule about the distances is there, we need to know that. We have a friend, Dan Greenberg, as you all know, was a past representative, is now on the board for the ABC. and when mentioning to them about studying this, that it was necessary and needed, he agreed that they would be willing to do that. So this brings everyone to the table, leaves no one out. And I think that Representative Hammer's done a good job opening this up. But that was the true intent. We need to know. And we need to know if there's any changes
that are necessary. And, Mr. Chair, if I may add on that if you look on the bill, line 22 of page 2, part of what necessitates this bill is it sets a hard date in statute that the recommendations, it says, honored before October 1st, 2018, the committee, which is this committee along with the Senate committee that matches to this committee, shall provide a report to the House Pro Tem, I'm sorry, to the President Pro Tem of the Senate, the Speaker of the House of Representatives. So this will be a good unbiased way to have a discussion about all the laws and the bills and the fines and everything that goes along with that so we can approach it in a neutral way in preparation for the 19th session. We'll be glad to
Representative Hammer, I'm trying to figure out how to put this in the form of a question, but you've gotten the bill for this to go through this committee, state agencies. But in the House, anything pertaining to alcohol, I'm actually kind of surprised. This bill's not in the House Rules Committee. The members of this body that serve in House Rules are the members that are most familiar with ABC and all the ins and outs of these issues. I just kind of wonder if that committee wouldn't be better suited to review this as opposed to state agencies.
Actually, Representative, thank you for bringing that up. It's been a few days since we've talked about this again, but I want to say that we think that probably would be the committee that would be assigned to this, and we're not opposed to which committee that will end up getting to hear this. But today, this was assigned through this committee for passage, and that's the way it came to us. So that's the way we have to run the bill. But at the time of assigning, we're not going to complain where it goes. We want it to go where it's needed to go. I understand what the bill says.
Is that your follow-up? Can I have it? Yes, sir. The bill says that the Senate Committee on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs and the House Committee on State Agencies and Governmental Affairs meeting jointly shall conduct a review of operations. My point is, the House has a different committee that is already more up to speed on these issues than this one. So, you know, the bill is assigned where it's assigned, but the bill says that this review is going to be done in a committee that's not familiar with these issues.
Representative Davis, in a quick meeting of the minds down on this end of the table, if the committee votes us out of here today, I wouldn't mind trying to figure out the way to get an amendment on the bill that would put the rules, if you're wanting to accept the responsibility, to put the rules either in there exclusively or add them collectively to where it's a meeting of both committees. We are open to a friendly suggestion of an amendment.
House floor tomorrow or Thursday. Friday or next opportunity. But, I mean, you'd have that commitment for me personally if that's what brings relief and understand what you're saying and what you're voicing. That'd be step one for me, but I yield. Representative
Douglas, you recognize. I wonder if the solution would not be to add someone from rules onto your study and then to make sure that they're in the loop, and that could probably be easily done without an amendment. and the study is the important thing that they'd be involved in, probably, and be able to proceed on with the bill. This is just a study. It's not going to change any rules. It may offer suggestions, and then those suggestions would then go to our house rules. Correct? I think that'd be a fair process that
it would be, ultimately, it's all going to end up before rules, before it's said and done anyway, just because that's where these bills go. But for the purpose of the study, Senator can speak for herself. I think that was the intent of state agencies is that it is perceived as a state agency, whether it is or not. But ultimately, the responsibility would rest with, you know, going before rules for any changes in the law. May I, Mr. Chair? May
I have the? Yes, go ahead. Thank you. And I agree with Senator Hamer. When this was drafted, we were considering where does it go? Who's going to do the study? And then, again, I think that what Senator Hammer has said is accurate. It can go back to rules for the final decision. The key is everyone comes to the table, and
the committee? Representative Hendren, you're recognized. Yesterday, on the floor, Representative Tosh made a good speech, and I told him that privately, and I'll say it publicly today. We were dealing with the enforcement by an ABC officer, I guess, of about gambling regulations or whatever it was, some kind of gambling machines. And that bill gave a bunch of us heart, at least me heartburn, because essentially what we did, the guy was enforcing the law, the law of the state of Arkansas, and we said, we don't want you to do that anymore. And I just think that's a step in the wrong direction, and I think we made a mistake as a body when we did that. But my question is, is this directed to help fix stuff like that? When we have an ABC officer who goes out and some people thinks oversteps his authority, is this to clarify that and make that happen? Because if it does it, that's a step in the right direction rather than to step back like we did yesterday. Well, if a law doesn't, if a legislator around this table thinks it ought to be enforced or not be enforced, then we don't enforce it. If we're headed in
that direction, that's the wrong direction. Does this help reverse that? Senator Hendron, you may remember the comments I made on the floor yesterday with response to that bill. And one of the things that I said was that if there's a problem with the law, then we need to change the law. Because all the agent is doing is, and I would quote Representative Tosh, too, you know, who's going to be next? Are we going to tell the state troopers you can't do that? And it could be the proverbial slippery slope. What this bill is intended to do, and honest, God is my witness. If I had a Bible, I'd put my hand on it. I didn't even know this bill existed until after all that discussion yesterday and offered to help Senator run the bill this morning, make sure it gets through the process. But I think this bill will help put it all on the table to where we can have a good, thorough discussion about it. Everybody bring it to the table, ABC, the package stores, the wine, all those folks, and be able to say, are our laws up to speed with where we ought to be? Because no matter what enforcement agent it is that's out there doing it, whether it's the sheriff, prosecutor, or we go back to where we just left, they know what laws are operating under. If we don't like it, let's change the law, and that's what this is intended to do.
Thank you, Senator. Thank you, Representative. I agree with the focus of where you want to go with this. Is there anything to prohibit the Speaker and the President from appointing a committee to do this that you all know
of? If they, I'm staying subject to be corrected, which I get done quite often. I don't know that there's anything that prohibits the speaker or the pro tem from being able to do whatever they want, pretty much, with regards to appointing a subcommittee. I guess what would be the argument or the difference on this is it assigns it to an existing committee already instead of having to create another one. And as I mentioned a while ago to Representative Davis's issue, as a member of this committee, I'd be willing to offer a friendly amendment, if the chair would allow that, to substitute rules committee for the state agency's committee or adding them to it for a joint effort because we are dealing with a state agency versus the rules that are going to be made and maybe adding that. But it also establishes a hard date by which something has to come out. I think from a statute point of view, that gives this approach a little bit more teeth, so we've
do you recognize for a follow-up? Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think we're thinking along the same lines or coming at the same problem from a different direction. And I'm looking at my clock at what time it is and what day it is and whether you can get it through both houses and to the governor in time. But I do like the idea, and there is some confusion, and my head busts every time we take up an alcohol bill. So if you can amend it and get it back through here and through both chambers, great. If you can't, then we still have that option available as a backup plan,
correct? Yeah, I think so, Mr. Chair. May I address the chair for a minute? Yes. If you'll let me make a quick phone call, I'll get an amendment prepared to send over here that will be done by the time this committee finishes, and we can amend it to include the Rules and Regs Committee in addition to the state agency, and I'm looking for a head nod from Representative Davis, if he wouldn't mind, and we can get that done so we can come back before this committee is over and accept that, amend the bill right now so we can send it out of here that way.
you. Thank you. Okay, the next bill that we're going to take up. Which one do you have? You got somebody in order for it. Yeah, you're next after this one. Next after this one. All right, committee, we're going to take up Senate Bill 521, Senator Hickey. Senator Hickey, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. One of the things that Senator Hickey and I share in common is that we have both served as chairs for legislative audit. My history with legislative audit is about six years now. One of those terms within the six years was House Chair of Legislative Audit. And I know that Senator Hickey has made procurement a passion and a goal. And I know that he's spent a lot of time and insight, and we've worked together on this bill to get it to where it is today. The one thing I'd like to do in the presentation of this bill is ask the committee to keep an open mind because I know that we've been hearing via email, personal contact, phone calls, Facebook, and every other means under the sun except for smoke signals about this bill and some of the pushback on it and some of the ideas associated with it. The one thing I will say in the meetings that have been conducted between Senator Hickey, myself, and individuals that have come to us, the demeanor has always been good. It's always been professional, and it has always been with the end result in mind, and that is what can we do as legislators to make sure the procurement process for the state of Arkansas is as pure and in the best interest of the taxpayers as possible. And I think that's been the framework of the mindset for the last year that Senator Hickey has been working on this, and I've been working with Senator Hickey on this, even down to the point that an amendment was put on the Senate floor that would establish a deadline into the June of 2019, which would be after the next general session, to make sure that the processes as they are right now would continue while we move forward working on making our procurement system the best in the nation, taking best practices from all areas. So I want the committee to remember that as Senator Hickey begins to dig down into this, that there is already an amendment on it, and it should be represented in what you see on your tablet that puts a closure date or puts a recheck date, if you would, of June of 2019 so that we have an opportunity to make sure that if there are changes that need to be made as we go along, everybody will have a seat at the table, including those that may voice opinion of objections today, to be involved in the process. It will be one of the first times we've had all the players at the table at the same time, and I think that I would ask you just to keep a good open mindset as we go in, knowing that that amendment is already in the bill. With that, Mr. Chair, I'm going to speak to Representative Davis for a minute, and Senator Hickey can take control of the mic at this time if the
chair allows. Senator Hickey, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair and members. Members, I believe what was passed out in front of you was a document called A Brief Summary of Procurement Changes. It's not brief. The thing is, is this is the document that actually explains the weeds of what's in the law. What I would like to do is I'm going to just attempt to give you a few of the major objectives of the bill, but we want to be totally up front with everything that's included with it. But anyway, like I say, the major objectives of this bill, and then the next thing is that I'm going to explain the amendment that we put on the Senate floor. And I want to stress to this committee that that amendment is of great, great, great importance. So at the end of this, I will explain that. To give you a little detail, our current RFQ statute indicates that pricing is not to be a factor. It eliminates, what this bill does is it eliminates that language, and it sets up a process where an RFQ may be used and establishes a way to have pricing as a consideration. This is done by establishing a qualified vendor list. These lists can be ongoing for day-to-day operational-type needs, or they can be narrowed down very specifically for a certain-type project. It also allows for an RFP, your request for proposal, to require that price be a minimum of 30% when calculating evaluation factors. However, and this is also of great importance, we have included an exemption for extraordinary circumstances that would allow for the governing board of an entity or the governor, in the case of the state, if they need to adjust that accordingly. So even within the RFP process, we're saying that there should be a minimum of 30% with price. But if there were to be a project that either your city board or your quorum court or, in the case of the state, that we feel that that should be lower, that could be adjusted to down to whatever. It does not even have a floor, and you could basically adjust it to zero. So that's very important to remember that. This bill also requires that members of the evaluation team that a lot of you probably know that we have used in evaluating these contracts, that those are supposed to be disclosed prior to the meeting and also requires them to disclose any family or financial relationships that they may have. This bill also limits multi-year contracts to four years. However, they can be extended for up to three additional years after going through a request for information purposes and determining that the contract is still competitively priced and also that the vendor has performed well. We're going to be keeping up with that, and in talking with OSP, they've actually been working on that so that we can have those evaluation factors in place, and we're going to start using those the way that they were, the original intent was when that was put in place. It also, it does allow for larger type contracts of 20 million or more to be entered into up to 10 years if it is determined that a substantial savings could be achieved. An example of a contract like that would be if there was one that had a very high up front cost for us to initiate. And now I want to talk about the amendment that was put on. This bill was of a concern to a group of professionals who currently use the RFQ process. This group includes architects, engineers, construction managers, financial accountants, land surveyors, and legal. And what we're going to do is we're going to allow them to continue using their current procurement process, which they have been using and which is in law. However, we're going to set up a committee to study the entire process. Let me back up. We're going to allow them to keep using that process up to June 30th of 2019. The reason that we've done that, to be honest, is basically we know that if we just given an exemption, that that will require them to come to the table. And the amendment that I did, I actually had written that in there that they would all be invited so we could work on this together. But again, my deal is, is that how, how, whatever we come up within that committee, and I've already talked to Chairman Sample and Chairman Branscombe, they've got with the Bureau, so we will be setting that committee up if you all were to pass this bill. And like I say, we'll be studying that over the next two years, working with the members, getting what other states are doing. And if we were to find out that That the way that we're doing it is basically the best way. And whenever I say best, I'm looking at that from two standpoints. That that is of the best interest of the state, but we don't want to make it so burdensome that we're going to in any way harm any type of competition that they may have or make it so that they don't want to bid on this. So we were going to look at that entire process, also going to use that as an opportunity for for members because I understand that the procurement process is very detailed and hard to understand. We were going to start off with trying to educate our members within that committee and others that we'd invite on how that entire process works, and then go forward from there. At that point, Mr. Chair, like I say, I'll give you everybody all the details of the bill, and we'll get in the
weeds as much as we need to. Okay. Senator, I have a question, which might clarify some things. I don't know about the other committee members, but I've received a lot of emails and phone calls from these specific groups that you talked about an exemption for. Yes, sir. So could you either tell us, identify all of those groups, or tell us what line number that's on so that we can look at that? I mean, primarily the engineers and the surveyors who I was getting information from, but I
know there are other groups. Yes, sir, there is. The groups, and this is kind of the thing, members, there's only about seven groups that are supposed to even be used in the RFQ process. And those groups under the current law and the ones that would still be included is defined as legal, financial advisory, architectural engineering, construction management, and land surveying for their consultant services. All of those will, again, they will all be inclusive, or they are included in that bill. All right, thank you. All right, any questions from
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. What my engineers were trying to explain to me, and I'm not from that, you know, profession, but that a lot of times when they bid a project, they're bidding a design, not the construction necessarily. And that's different in the way, you know, in the way they operate. So is this allowing for that difference in what their business calls for? Again, that
is why we exempted this out all the way to June 30th. And to be honest with you, after our Senate state agency's meeting where it passed out of, did listen to their concerns. Now, I'm going to be honest, they could get there the way it's set up. Because as I stated, you could probably actually even use the RFP process. They could go to the city board and have them to, as long as they signed off on it, where it would all be up front and transparent, if you want to say it that way, so that they could negotiate that there would not even be a pricing factor in there. However, what they're talking about, of course, is a concern, and we understand what that is, that they do have to, like if they have a scope of work or the design phase. Right. You could actually, especially on larger type projects the way it's set up, you could go out and just put the proposal out for the design phase and then come back in and bid that. The way that we have it currently set up in the bill, and again, I want to keep stressing we have an amendment. I don't want to lose track of that before we're going to negotiate this, but the way that we currently have that RFQ process set up in the bill is this. What you would do is one of our agencies or whoever, one of the political subdivisions, they would set up, they would put out that RFQ, RFQ, and they would write that thing the same way that they currently do, and they would narrow it down, and I'm talking about a larger specific type project, they would narrow that down. Well, there would only be a few people that would probably qualify for that, and they would be put on that vendor list. Well, after that is where we would go in and have them to, if there was only three on there, all three of them would actually bid on the thing. If there was just two, we would require two to bid on it. The way the legislation is written right now, if there were seven people, it just says that they have to go in and look at the price of a minimum of three. It doesn't limit them from going all of them, but by the same token, it doesn't require them to do that
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Senator Hickey, I may have missed it if you said it at the very beginning, but can you explain to me what is the problem with the way we do
things currently? What is the problem you're trying to address with this bill? Well, just to be quite blunt, I believe this not only probably happens at the state, but it probably happens whenever I stay at the state level, but also within our political subdivisions. A lot of times we get fairly complacent with the firms or individuals that we're using. Under our current RFQ process, like I said, the law states, for whatever reason, that pricing is not supposed to be a component of that. If you have someone that you're used to dealing with, and of course I know it's our responsibility to make sure things are being done as efficient as possible, But what is happening is I believe a lot of times that agency directors or whoever is doing this, they get complacent with dealing with those type of individuals. Well, since price is not a factor, there's really no great concern on what the final, there's not as much concern as there should be on what the final dollar amount would be. So what they do is once they get that vendor in play or that qualified person, and then they go in and try to negotiate a contract. Those negotiations are only as good as, you know, as that individual that would be sitting in that position. So, like I say, we're trying to create a way that will make this thing not only so that there's more of a competitive pricing element to it, but to make sure that, and there is some value sometimes if somebody's used to working someone. So I don't want to say that that's not the case, but it also will open this thing up so that possibly other people that may be qualified and who may be just as good but willing to do it at a lower price
would have that option to come in. Can I have a follow-up? Yes. You recognize. So do we not already consider price after the RFQ process? We take RFQs. We make a list of qualified people or agencies to do a particular task, and then beyond that we do a proposal phase. Is that correct, and wouldn't pricing be considered then?
No, sir. They just are supposed to negotiate the contract, or I say they're supposed to. I mean, I don't know if there's anything that says they have to negotiate it, but it's in that negotiation phase. Well, the negotiations, wouldn't price be a factor? It would be at that part, but whenever they're first doing the RFQ, the statute states that that will not be a factor of it. Okay. Thank you,
that thing, as a matter of full disclosure, I happen to be a registered professional engineer, and I think Representative Davis is too, if I'm not incorrect. But anyway, I've received a text, and this is the question from one of my constituents, and it refers to page 13, lines 8 through 10. So if you're interested, you might want to look on your computer and see what those are as I read them. It says, does this invalidate our board approved policies that exempt us from Arkansas Building Authority and our contract with an on-call architect? We have an excellent, financially effective, and efficient track record on this matter. And so to help me answer my constituents' question, does that, in fact, invalidate that? And in your opinion, if it does invalidate that, do you think that serves the students at this particular institution well and the cost of their education?
Yes, this is in regards to higher education. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Some members of higher ed had discussed that with me and basically that gives them an exemption. That gives them an exemption from our procurement procedures is the way we see that. And that was not our intent. Our intent with this whole procurement process was try to bring all of that so that it was consistent. So, yes sir, I've heard those concerns, and we just think that it's the most reasonable thing to do for us to try to make everybody to follow whatever procurement procedures this body comes forward with.
Hearing none, we do have some people signed up to speak for and against the bill. I'm sorry, we have people to speak against the bill. So Brooks Jackson, would you go to the end table, please? You want to sit there? Let me help you get
do that if that's the will of the chair. Yes. Okay. Once again, thank you, Mr. Chair and members of the committee. I'm Brooks Jackson. I'm president of the State Board of Architects, Landscape Architects, and Interior Designers. I'm also chair of the Ethics Committee, and we are opposed to this bill. I've practiced in Arkansas for 50 years. have been licensed in 21 states. I'd like to tell you briefly how an architect becomes an architect because it's important to this bill. In the United States, on the average, when a student decides this is what he wants to become as an architect, it takes 13 years of school experience and testing to become a licensed architect. There are 1,617 architects licensed to practice in this state. As a mentor, I dread the day that I tell a student who's been in school six years, seven years when he asked me, how do I get a job? And I tell him, simple, nothing to it. Be the low bidder. You've only got 1,616 people to bid against. Why are we opposed to the bill in addition to what I've just stated? Bidding professional services we feel is unethical. I don't know of another state in the union that has such procurement law for professional services. None of the 21 states that I practice in have that law. To reduce fees by human nature, unfortunately, reduces services which therefore are not in the best interest of the citizens of the state of Arkansas. On the ethics committee, we have had to deal with architects on occasion who don't spend the time to develop documents accurately and correctly. Most of those, 99% of them, have been out-of-state architects, I'll say that. But it is human nature to do less if you're paid less. The best architectural documents result in the least expensive building of that type because the contractors who are bidding the work do not have to guess at what they're going to build. And at this point, I'd like to speak to Representative Douglas specifically about some confusion in this bill, as at least maybe not the bill itself, but the way it's been interpreted. There aren't any $10 million architectural fees in this state, and very few in the world that I know of. But at any rate, this bidding is about professional services. It's not about bidding of the construction. None of us have a problem with bidding the construction or the professional services handling the bidding process. We encourage that. bidding of professional services in architecture will eliminate a lot of small businesses because small businesses have to have that fee. They have to make a profit. Larger firms can carry a job. They can take it for less. They want that job really, really badly. They can be the low bidder, if that's the way it goes, and carry the job when other work is available for them to work on, and large firms generally have a number of projects. Best documents, the architects that put the most time in these documents, produce the best buildings, the buildings with the least amount of maintenance, the least headaches for the maintenance people that are left with the project after we architects and contractors are finished with it. I'd like to speak to the issue of our current situation of qualifications-based selections and fees. And I'm going to tell you something, show you something that probably nobody else has ever shown you, and I'm going to show it to you. I'm going to show you our fees and where they go. But I think it's almost an insult to the vice presidents of finance of all these institutions for us to say that they don't look at what our fees are. 50 years i've never had a contract with anybody for any job school college church bank whatever when we didn't talk about the services and we talked about the fees and we came to an agreement just like the defense department does just like the postal service does just like the Air Force Base does. I've had some clients tell me, my goodness, if you do what I ask you, I'm paying you more. I had a client from out of state tell me, when I do good, I'm going to pay you more because you're going to help me make more. So there is some reason in all of this, other than the bidding process. So we do feel, as a group, that it is in the best interest of the state for professionals to receive an adequate amount of compensation.
to speak where you can hear me. In the United States, in 1967, the American Institute of Architects had what we referred to as the green sheet. That's a fee schedule right there. Everybody's welcome to see it. And it says, and I'm going to pick it up for a school, a million-dollar school in the United States. The fee should be 6%, they estimate, based on the value of what those services are. when governor David prior establishes state building services and had six or eight name changes but same agency more or less there was a fee schedule that was a part of state building services the fee schedule showed a declining fee as the project got larger thinking that the repetition of a building might create less work for the architect therefore he gets paid less but it's basically a six percent fee today's schedule from building services which also by the way complies with the State Department of Education fee schedule so you won't find that schedule anymore that's been taken off the website and it's hidden and oh no we don't have one there was one for the purpose of showing the superintendents I suppose and school boards what a reasonable fee would be for the design of a new high school. So there are fee schedules and people believe me use those. So let me show you something. If you take a 6% fee of an architect where does it go? I mean Senator Bumpers used to say when I say it's not about the money it's about the money. This is about the money. It's about the money that comes to us and how can we save the state architect gets six percent let's say on a project one of the first things he has to do is hire his engineers i'm not speaking in their behalf they may be here today but i have to hire them every day a mechanical engineer to design the heating air conditioning ventilation and the state required fresh air requirements for buildings. They also design all of the plumbing systems, potable water, wastewater, all of those systems for the building. They get 1% of our fee. We're required by statute to pay for the basic engineering services out of our fee. 1% goes to the mechanical engineering. We are not, even though we have training in electrical in all these engineering disciplines we are not allowed to practice these engineering disciplines as licensed architects so we hire an electrical engineer well he does a lot more today than put the light switches on the wall locate pictures there's a tremendous amount of technology if you ever look at a new building and see the wiring running through that thing you'd understand that it's a very complex system today the electrical engineers we pay one percent now that's an average really complicated they get more this doesn't go up the next engineer that we're required to hire is a structural engineer structural engineers required to be responsible for the entire structure of the building roof walls foundations everything in addition to that state state statute requires that structural engineer to design the building to support the seismic loads in Arkansas and their multiple zones as everybody knows seismic zones in Arkansas northeast corner being the worst and that's pretty bad up there we've been blessed by not having a situation there in many many years and we've had one and it's predicted that we will but he has to design for wind loads dead loads live loads all the loads that go into a building and it's a rather complex issue we pay those fellows roughly one and a quarter percent so now we're we're down to the architects okay two and three quarter percent so an architect has to pay am i we're down to the architects part of it sir which is two and three quarter percent after we take out our professional engineers all of whom have to be licensed professionals too by the way so we have a insurance our health insurance office insurance professional liability insurance which is huge amount of money whether you've ever had a claim or not it's a lot of money then we have to pay our overhead. A student, if you hire the first student with a license, a person has spent 13 years getting there. They deserve and think they should receive a competent amount of salary for their work. So you have salaries. Got rent, got utilities, got licensures. You have tax for practicing, continuing education, which is something that we have to do. We don't have a choice. But those are all expenses. That's a long distance, Mr. Chair, from up there. If I were you, I couldn't see it. But that says a half a percent, 0.5 percent, is what is left. Now, that assumes that a project runs perfectly. There are no weather days. Doesn't rain or snow in Arkansas. And there aren't any material delays for the contractor that are unforeseen. He can't help but cause the project to be longer. It causes our services to extend and be longer. So there's two years of work, which this all assumes a two year time period, which on a million dollar project is an average, plus a year of the warranty. Can I
have a question? Yes, ma'am. You recognize Representative Douglas? And I do appreciate your explanation, but it's my understanding from this amendment that they put on there, you are going to be held harmless for two years through this while they do some further study on your unique position in the procurement process And then going forward, after that, you know, two years, the recommendations, and you all will be included in the study and in the conversation, there could be some, you know, some things that favor you coming out. And I would like to make sure I understood that from Senator Hickey, because that seems to be the problem here. You're going to be harmless for two years, so nothing's going to change. You're going to be in a conversation that's going to give you, you know, unique status going forward. And then we'll, at the end of that two years, we'll have some differences in the procurement that will consider you. And if I could have the senator to answer my question and see if that's something that we can live with.
Yes, ma'am. And to be honest, Mr. Jackson, if I remember right, what he is doing is exactly what we want to happen. And if the members would look on, actually, if you'll look on the last page, lines 17 and 18, we have, you can also look, if you don't mind, look on line 2, and then look on line 17 and 18. We extend this all the way out to June 30th of 2019 to make 100% sure. I mean, not only would we have special sessions in between here and there, but this would get us past a regular session. However, we even went ahead and said that we would have the study totally completed by January 1st of 2019. And it was a little bit odd with the legislation whenever we put the amendment on, but we actually, because I've worked with the construction managers and some other parts of the architects, we actually wrote in that legislation that we would be inviting them, of course, to the table. Now, and I'm just going to be honest right here. The reason that, because what they would rather us see, to be honest, is they would rather us see just exempt them out. We didn't just exempt them out for a reason. They're here today, and I appreciate them being here. They're here today because they see what could possibly happen. We want, and I hate to use this because I could take it wrong, but we want to be able to negotiate from a point of strength instead of a point of weakness. If we just exempt them out and then try to have the study, it will not be near as efficient as if we have this bill that has that time in there that we know we have to have it done by so that everybody will come in there and do it. And I don't know how to do it any more than I've done. I've done it from the Senate floor. The other members have basically said the same thing. And I give my word that we're fixing to try to go through this whole process. And if we cannot make it better, and when I say better, I mean better not only for us, but also from them. Because there may be parts of the process that we can sand the edges off to make it quicker or faster or whatever you want to say. Thank you, Senator.
discussing? Yes, sir, I do. Okay. You're recognized. Two things. First of all, all the professionals have to sell is time. One of the reasons that I brought this board is to play our card today. We can spend two years discussing our fees. That's all there
have questions for Mr. Jackson? Representative Hendren, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I think it was Mr. Jackson, right, talked about 50 years. Well, 1965, 52 years ago, I became a registered engineer, so I'm going to outrank you about two years, and I know I look that much older. Congratulations. And you've got a lot more hair. I appreciate that. I'm happy for you. One of the things that I'm concerned about, not only because a lot of us have been on school boards and city councils and so forth, and you mentioned the 6% doesn't change, and I'm also a real estate broker since for a long time. And I work for 6% too. But one of the things you didn't mention that bothers me and has always bothered me is you and I, you as an engineer architect and me and I as an engineer or real estate broker, have a built-in conflict of interest. And so do bond salesmen, in this member's opinion, is that I can't change the 6%, but if I can sure raise the value of that deal I'm getting 6% of, I get more money. And what bothers me, and I address this to Senator Hickey, what are we doing to see that an architect or an engineer or a real estate agent, they're not in this bill, I understand that, is there any incentive for efficiency? Because if I drive the cost up to that project, I don't need to raise my 6%. All I need to do is raise it a million dollars. And that's what bothers me, and I'm not sure that any of this does that, is to give an incentive to this gentleman here as an architect or to me as an engineer or a real estate guy to keep the cost down and we're getting ready to try to sell a bunch of bonds around here. And what bothers me, these three suited bond salesmen, the higher the bond is, the higher their commission, and the higher that goes in their pocket. So is there anything here to deal with that, Senator Hickey? Yes. Mr. Jackson, would
with Mike so we can hear you well? Oh, yeah. Pull the mic down there and push the green button. It's illuminated, sir. All right. Thank you. That's a big word. It lights on. Sir, I all do respect. I mentioned the chief financial officers, whether it's a school district or a college university or a church board, whatever it may be. Those folks are folks that you're thinking about and working with to try to figure out what your fees should be. And I give them credit because, in my experience, well, 50 years they've done that. But to answer your question specifically, the answer is, is the budget. How many architects get the job in the budget? Everybody has a budget, and that's the incentive the architect has is to get the project in the budget. And some of us, some of us have said to that client, Mr. Arkansas Tech, Mr. UCA, Mr. Arkansas Department of Correction, hey, what if we go through this project and we continue as architects and design people to work with the contractor to see if we can write a change order at the end of the job to reduce the fee that that contractor has agreed to, to reduce that budget. And that's happened in all three of those cases I just mentioned. But the hammer over your head is the budget. If you can't get it in the budget, the contract says the architect must get it in the budget and must do it at his expense. It's our job to tell you as we go what the project is going to cost in our estimation. And the job must be brought into the budget. So that's our incentive. Senator, did you have
anything to add to that? Yes, sir. I believe Representative Hendren that asked me that question. And to be honest, Representative Hendren, that's what the entire bill was about. Now, I'll be honest, whenever we put the amendment in, over their concerns, and I mean because there are, as Representative Douglas said, we do need to make sure that we're not creating anything that's going to make something where it's not as competitive or makes it so hard to go through the process. But that was our entire intent. Even though we were leaving the RFQ process in place and we're going to set up the vendors list, that in itself would make that more efficient. To give you all the story that, just to be honest, and it's exactly what you're saying, as you all know, a lot of you know I was in banking for 25 years, and one of my favorite things was is I was negotiating with an attorney one time, and legal is within these professions that we're exempting. One of my favorite things was is I'd been going back and forth with about three of them, and finally one of them sat back in a chair whenever I was negotiating with him separately, and he said, Hickey, he said, I don't care what you want me to tell you the hourly price is as long as you're allowing me to keep the clock. So that illustration is exactly right. I mean, it is hard on some of these professions to narrow that down. And I know I keep repeating myself, but we want to attempt that within this study to see if we can bring those processes closer together somehow, some way, make sure other states out there have not already, we're going to have the bureau to do the research to just make sure there's not some other better mousetrap. If it's not, we'll amend back the same way for those entities that we're discussing. All right.
Thank you, Senator. We have a lot of people to speak against this, so I'd like to move on. Mr. Jackson, thank you for your comments, and we definitely would appreciate your organization, your profession, being a part of this, thanks to your process.
kind words. Thank you. Okay. Tim Hawkins to speak against the bill. Mr. Hawkins, if you would, identify yourself, and I would like to remind you that we have a lot of people. We have a lot of things to cover today, so if you can, stick
to the bill and the amendment as much as possible. Thank you. My name's Tim Hawkins, I'm the Technical Services Director with the Springdale Water and Seward Commission. This bill appears to seek to require cost and qualifications instead of just qualifications when following the RFQ process for professional services. While this bill allows for a variety of procurement methods for engineering services, it states the RFQ method can only be used if price is predetermined or if the project is 100% federally funded. I urge a no vote on this bill for the following reasons. First, we want to hire engineers based on quality as it protects the public safety. Second, we often use engineers to estimate project costs and develop a scope. This bill limits that ability. Third, at this point there are virtually no 100% federally funded projects. This bill makes it difficult to meet federal procurement regulations on partially federally funded projects. And fourth, most of our project engineering costs are based on a percentage of construction for my commission, not based on price. I'll close by saying I believe the RFQ method isn't broken. We should choose engineering services based on quality and experience, and not cost. This bill should be passed properly the first time, not passed and then parts studied further.
Any questions? Representative Davis, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Sir, if this bill were changed so that it didn't implement these changes in the procurement process effective June 30, 2019, Would you still be willing to come to the table and study procurement processes and make
table? Mr. Williams, please identify yourself. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Dan Williams. I'm the President of Garver. We're an Arkansas-based engineering architecture firm, and we work almost exclusively on government-funded infrastructure projects. I'm also a member of the Government Affairs Committee of the American Council of Engineering Companies of Arkansas. We represent 40 engineering firms across the state. So today I'm speaking both for Garver and ACEC. I want to thank you for the opportunity to address the committee with our concerns. We oppose House Senate Bill 521. And I will specifically address the sunset provision. While we fully support and will participate in a thoughtful and detailed review of the request for qualification process for professional services, we believe a two year sunset on that process is bad policy and completely unnecessary. The existing RFQ process for professional services is fair, it's efficient. It's beneficial for governmental entities and it's also beneficial for the citizens of Arkansas. It ensures that they receive the highest quality work at a negotiated price that they control. There have not been any identified problems with the current RFQ process involving engineers and architects. We've had this law in place for almost 40 years. I'm not aware of a single time we've made the paper because of a problem in our process. The current Arkansas law is consistent with federal requirements for engineering and architectural services when federal funds are used, like Mr. Hawkins mentioned. Best practices has been mentioned. I think you have to look no further than the federal government and 46 other states that use the same procurement method that we use for engineering and architectural services, so we think we should leave it just like it is. And by the way, in engineering services, we don't use fee structure. we negotiate a fee based on the scope of work. And I want to bring your attention to, on page 18, when we talk about 30% or less, I never could figure out how the 30% applied to engineering services. On page 18, at the top of the page, it says the state agency, state support institute of higher education, or the political subdivision shall use competitive bidding to select professional persons from a qualified vendor list. that's considered the best qualified and capable of performing the desired work for the lowest price. Now, our current law says that a political subdivision in a selected firm shall jointly prepare a detailed written description of the proposed services. And if those two entities can't come to agreement, then if they're not able to negotiate the price, then negotiations with that firm will be terminated and you'll go to the second qualified firm.
House? You recognize? Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Williams, right? Yes, sir. Mr. Williams, you made a statement that the current system we're using meets the federal requirements, and I understand that there are a lot of federal rules that attach to money. My question is kind of backwards. The new proposal, does it fit within the federal requirements for use of federal funds? No, sir. In what respects? Thank you.
Yes, sir. There are literally hundreds of millions of federal funds that flow to public works projects in the state. Those projects are partially federal funded, not at 100%, less than 100%. And they're administered by local commissions and by cities and counties and by state agencies. The federal law currently requires a request for a qualifications-based selection where you have to select the most qualified firm, and the agencies actually have to certify that they've used that process when they accept those federal funds.
Is that responsive to your question? Yes, you recognize. Yes, in a way. My last 18 years was as a contracting attorney for the Department of Defense and Army and the National Guard, and one of the requirements of any contract was to consider price when you selected a service of any type. And what I just heard you say doesn't sound inconsistent with what this particular bill says. I'm still trying to grasp onto something that's in this bill that does not comply with federal law. Maybe you ought to tell me again if I didn't catch you. Yes,
sir. It's a matter of timing. In our current process, which meets federal requirements, you select the most qualified engineer, and then you negotiate a price. This current legislation would require you to submit a price from all qualified vendors. That is not acceptable to the requirements of the federal government. For professional services, engineering and architecture, and land surveying. Any other questions? Mr. Chairman? Yes. Could Senator
Senator, you recognize it. Yes, members. Just this same type thing come up during the state agencies as it relates to airports. And it was brought out that that was going to affect the way we had done our airports. The thing was, before I ever started with state agencies, I had got with Mr. Chisholm with the aeronautics. And he would ask me if I minded, which, of course, I didn't, if he sent this bill to Fort Worth with the people that they dealt with to make sure that this process was in no way going to be contradictory of the way that it would be. He called me back, left me a voicemail, which I have kept that actually said that they were good with the bill, and it would not affect the way that we did the procurement with them, again, to your study.
a valid motion, not debatable. The motion is to limit debate, five minutes for each side. Representative Hammer, would you like to reserve some time for closing? We'd
for closing. Okay. Five minutes to each side. Five minutes reserved on the positive side to close. All in favor of the motion signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Thank you, sir, for your comments. John Wilkerson, would you come to the table, please? We'll keep the time up here. John Wilkerson
with the Arkansas Municipal League. I will keep it brief because most of the points that we, our concerns have already been addressed. A couple of things. One, I'm sorry I'm late to the game. I'm usually covering the always fun Judiciary Committee over in the Senate, But they weren't there today, so I'm here. I have litigated cases like this before for the city of Blyville in particular, so I'm somewhat familiar, although I won't claim to be an expert. First, we agree with Mr. Jackson that we do take price into consideration. And fundamental to that, cities at least, we don't know of really any problem that we don't know of any problem that would necessitate this bill. So we're not sure we need it at all. The two concerns I have in particular, outside of those that have already been addressed, are in the language of the bill. For instance, in section six of the bill, referring to code section 1911-230. Political subdivisions are added into this section, although political subdivisions, we don't get our procurement authority from that code section. So we're confused as to whether or not we're now in this code section or not. Second of all, and the individual before me kind of mentioned this on page 18, line four, use of competitive bidding to select the professional person from the qualified vendor list that is considered the best qualified and capable to do the desired work at the lowest cost. This is kind of what we already do, but we're not sure if this requires us to pick the lowest price, Or if we have to pick the lowest price and then look at the qualifications and then negotiate a price, or do we negotiate a price first because we don't know the lowest. To us, it's confusing as to what exactly we need to do. And I'm not sure that the language of the bill, we're worried that litigation will be the only way to really clarify it going forward. So those are our two main points other than those that have already been made. And with that, I will close unless there's any questions, of course. Thank
you, if you have a question, we'd let you have asked that this time, but we're limited on time, keep that in mind. Seeing no questions, thank you, sir. Denise Hoggard, would you come to the table, please? Ms. Hoggard,
would you identify yourself for record? Denise Hoggard, I'm President of the Arkansas Bar Association. I'm here on behalf of that association to state our opposition to the bill as amended. The nature of the legal profession is that you may not get the best price and still get the best attorney through hourly rates. Those rates rise as we gain experience, knowledge, skill in a particular field where you want the very best lawyer, you're not going to be able to get them at the very lowest rate. You will get more likely an entry level lawyer at the lowest rate. So it will hurt the state. It will foreclose getting the best lawyers available. And it is very difficult to determine how to write the qualifications for a professional in the areas that you are interested in. I can tell you that I've represented a constitutional officer for the state because I was an attorney skilled in labor and employment having practiced that for almost 35 years. That made me uniquely qualified for that position, but it may not come up in a request for qualification or request for bids qualification. Additionally, there are a number of lawyers that contract with the state that will be very impacted by this, including those in your juvenile law division, acting as attorney ad litems and parents' counsels. So for those reasons, we oppose the bill. Thank you. Any
Okay, thank you, Chair. I'm Byron Hicks with McClelland Engineers. I urge you to oppose this bill. I have a lot of points. I'm going to only hit a few that I don't think have been brought up yet. One, I don't think that engineers can even abide by this law. But when I, this requires me to submit my request for qualifications, and it requires me to submit a price for my services at the same time. At this time, there is no scope of services that's been developed. My clients hire me to help them solve a problem. They don't know what the problem, they know they have a problem. They don't know what the solution is. So at the time that I am submitting my request, my statement of qualifications, there is no scope. I don't have a scope to base my fee on. That's not the way our services work. You have 30 seconds left, sir. Okay, you don't want the cheapest engineer designing your bridges. You don't want the cheapest attorney representing you in legal matters. That's why the bill is bad. It's going to be bad for the state, for cities, for the owners, because it encourages you to do things as cheaply as you can so that you can be the very low bidder. Your time's up, sir.
Thank you for your comments. We have no one from the audience to speak for the bill, So, Representative Hammer, you're recognized for your closing. You have five minutes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm going to try to take
about three of that, leave the balance for Senator Hickey, and then maybe come in for the final word. I guess one thing that I've listened to is people have come to the table of which we have mutual respect for each other. We're just trying to do an iron, sharpening iron approach to addressing an issue. First of all, disciplines have standards that upon graduation or certification level equals the playing field. And, yes, experience going forward has a valuable part in the consideration. However, I've seen people who have been in the business a long time that, based on what people coming out of school, newly learned, newly techniques, I think maybe carry a certain advantage. So here's my question. If there are bad actors within the discipline, shouldn't the discipline weed them out so that price does not become the major focus? I would probably take exception if I was an attorney to say that because I've been in practice longer, I'm a better attorney. When they all come out, their degrees hang the same on the wall. Why do various disciplines have poorly qualified individuals within their group, and who decides who is qualified or not? And does that create a current structure create a smaller entity or a smaller company from having a competitive edge because that factor has not been added in there? If there is something wrong with the process, then there should not be a threatened feeling by a process that has built into it a January 1st, 2019 deadline for a report to be brought out while the current systems are allowed for them to operate as they've been operating for the last 40 years, and then a follow-up date of June 30th, 2019, well after the general session. And that's what's written into the law. We have an opportunity to maintain a flow of current approaches while we move toward a set deadline of that January 1st followed by the January 30th. All the professionals are used to working with deadlines. And without a deadline, nothing ever gets done or meaningful ever happens without that ability to know we've got a deadline, which forces people to the table, whereas otherwise they might come or they might not come. Everybody's motivated by something. While working toward a deadline, there are change orders that occur throughout any job to make sure that best practices are achieved, which is what the model of the bill is intended to do, maintain best practices being developed while we go through giving the coverage of the way they currently are allowed to do business now. We have amended the bill to allow for that deadline, which did not bring total appeasement, but certainly should relieve some of the fears that over the next two and a half years, we can make sure that if indeed the best practices are in place, they'll be substantiated, if not a fair ground for us to work toward. And, Mr. Chair, I want to stop right now and give Senator Hickey some time to comment. But how much time do we have, please? Senator Hickey, you have two minutes and 19 seconds.
More than enough. I'm going to stay very brief. Members, this procurement process that we're listening to with these individuals, they're procuring contracts from government. And they're not in just the amounts of thousands or millions. We're talking about billions of dollars that is actually of the taxpayers' money. The only reason at this point that you would oppose the amendment is because you're saying that you do not trust this body to do what we're saying we are going to do. I have done it from the Senate floor. I'm doing it in here today. As other members with the chairs of ALC, we've already went to the process to make sure there wouldn't be any trouble with sitting up the committee. We already have an idea of how we're going to do it. Again, I give my word that's what we're going to do. And if we find that the way we're doing it is exactly the way that we should be, that there's not a better mousetrap, then we'll amend back. But like I say, this does keep us, everybody can sit here and say that they'll talk, that they're going to come down here and going to come down here, and they may or they may not or they may not have the initiative to do that. But the way we have this bill written, with that exemption in there, I can guarantee you it will work that way. I would appreciate a good vote. How much time, Mr.
Chair? One minute left. Thank you. Here's a couple questions I want to ask yourself in response to some of the things that Matt said. Should we exclude anyone from the process? Of everybody that's going to be impacted by this, who should be the one that should be excluded from the process? Who would you exclude? Why would you exclude that person? And what purpose would you want to exclude any entity that's being referenced or touched by this bill? The other question I'd want to ask you is as members, Senator Hickey's been working on this diligently for over the last year, and with our respective experience in legislative audit. And also what you see comes through in the way of contracts through ALC, which ALC will have a seat at the table based on a committee that's going to be appointed to make sure that this process works smoothly. How many of us really understand the procurement process? And would this create a fair environment to have that discussion while they move forward over the next two years with two back doors? Thank you, and would appreciate a good vote, and as a member of the committee make a motion, do pass.
All right, we have a motion from Representative Hammer, do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. I have to say the nays have
Thank you. Thank you. All right, we're going to go back up. Representative Hammer, if you are ready with your amendment on Senate Bill 758, you can go ahead and present
should be on the tablet, members. So it should be an amendment on the tablet to SB 758. Are you seeing that? I see a couple of nods there. All right, you're recognized, Representative Hammer.
Okay, I'm presenting this with the understanding that this should relieve some of the issues that were expressed before and added to House Committee of State Agencies, Government Affairs, and House Rules Committee, so that both will be at the table approaching it from the respective views that they would bring into the discussion. I'll be glad to answer any questions. Any questions from the committee? Okay, hold on just
a second. They're not getting the amendment. We've got hard copies coming around. I'll give you just a minute to look at that. I take it that's not a question, Representative House. All right. Any questions from the committee? Hearing no questions from the committee, Representative Hammer, are you ready to close? Yes, sir. All I would say is I think
this would be good to bring the state agency's perspective, the rules certainly respecting the history that they've got. At the end of the day, those that want to be at the meeting will be at the meeting. And the good thing about this bill is it does set a hard date for recommendations to come. Creates a level playing field where everybody can come to the table and not feel threatened by it. And with that, I appreciate a good vote, and I do make a motion, do pass. Is there a motion to
adopt the amendment? Sorry, Mr. Chair. Motion to adopt amendment. Motion is to adopt the amendment. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. The amendment is passed. You're recognized, Representative. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
amended. Any further discussion? Hearing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay? No. Ayes have it. Congratulations, your bill is passed. Okay, we're going to run SB175, Representative Miller, are you prepared to run that?
All right, members, we are going to look at Senate Bill 175. There are no amendments to it, and with that, Representative Layman will be back in just a second. He had to step outside. I'm going to take care of something, so we're going to recognize Representative Miller and Senator King to go ahead and represent your bill. All right.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, members of the committee. I won't rehash a lot of the arguments that we made uh the other day this is just a good bill i believe that the public would like transparency when it involves their tax dollars we have a lot of tax dollars that flow through medicaid uh i believe this common sense issue and uh i strongly uh urge you to think about this And consider the fact that there is disclosure when business is done with any other form of government, any other state agency, does any business with anybody, legislator or other government official, there's a paper trail of it. And we're just trying to bring Medicaid in compliance with the rest of our government. With that, I'll turn it over to Senator King for some distinguished remarks. Senator King. Okay, I'm recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank
you, members of the committee. This bill was discussed the other day. Let me touch on a few issues that I hear. Number one, this bill is too broad. Folks, I want to tell you, this bill is not that broad. What it is brought about is trying to bring to light a lot of things that's been going on in the legislature up here and with Medicaid money. As I said the other day, folks, if these things weren't in the newspapers, I wouldn't even be here today. But unfortunately, we're having these stories crop up of corruption with government officials. And we appropriate now, the next appropriation bill that you're going to be voting on is over $8 billion. We, on one hand, require government disclosure on government money. If you say you have a landscaping company and you do $1,000 worth of business with a government entity, or you're a legislator and own a building and you lease it to the revenue office in your local county, you have to disclose that. But these Medicaid providers get a lot of money, and most of them are honest, and most of them do things right. But unfortunately, as we've seen in the newspaper and unfortunate headlines, we've seen that that hasn't been the case. And we need disclosure. As far as being too broad, it outlines in there who this is designed to be pertaining to. I had somebody say, well, you know, my wife's a nurse practitioner. They don't see Medicaid patients. Then it doesn't apply to you. If you have a Medicaid patient that comes in, this doesn't apply to you. These are the type of situations to deal with. And had this bill been in effect, we possibly could have stopped corruption that has been already proven in the past between government officials and Medicaid providers. Where are we at? And let me say another thing, too, right past Mr. Chairman, I know you have these entities that have surrounded this committee, they've been in the hallways, they've been talking about this bill, and they try and bring up questions of this is going to do this or this is going to do that. This bill has been out there for 60 days, folks. Not one time until recently, just right here at the last minute in stopping the process have they come up to me. have sit here and passed legislation giving companies like Blue Cross Blue Shield over a billion dollars in a program, they ought to be able to disclose how much they're paying lobbyists to be able to get that money. And while you have the lobbyists and those special interests trying to tell you not to disclose, don't go with this bill. They've had 60 days once again, folks, to come talk to me about an issue or problem. They have not done it. They didn't show up in committee. This bill has been, at least in some form or another, before three different bodies down here. It passed the Senate in 2015. And I heard the story, they didn't think it was going to pass. Well, it passed in 2015. It's been up before. And companies like Blue Cross Blue Shield, if they're going to take over a billion dollars in people's hard-earned tax dollars, they'll at least tell us how much they're spending on lobbying to be able to get those dollars. And I'm just asking you, don't listen to lobbyists. Don't listen to special interests. Listen to your constituents back home where over 90% of the people in a lot of polls say that we need more disclosure in this area. And I'd be happy to take any more questions because of all the misinformation that you're getting hit with.
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. One of the questions I had was, and I'm trying to find it in the bill, and I can't find it right now, but it required, I got the impression it required state employees to do some form of disclosure. And could you speak on that part? Because the person that maybe is sitting in the cubicle just doing their job, how intrusive is this going to be on that individual, and what are going to be the requirements upon that person?
That's a good question, Representative Henry. If you've read the Democrat Gazette and headlines recently, we've got trials and convictions going on in the food stamp program in DHS. I keep hearing that DHS, you know, another misinformation they're saying is they're complying with this and it's going to cost a lot of money. They ought to be the people with the amount of fraud that is continuing to happen with employees at DHS. Read the headlines once again of employees at DHS through the food stamp that have already been convicted. And you want to tell me there's not possible influence and corruption going on? Just read the headlines, Representative Hambers. There's employees. This isn't just lead
slayers. Representative Hamber, you're recognized for a follow-up. Okay, and to that issue, when you bring up the word fraud, I would understand the essence of why the bill is needed when you identify that particular issue. And unless it gets vetoed in the next couple days, I've got a House Bill 2055 that enhanced the whistleblower ability for an employee to be able to blow the whistle and have coverage not to be afraid of losing their job if they have substantive evidence to show that they legitimately found areas of fraud. So why would, if that bill is allowed to be signed into law, would that not address the issue that you're trying to cover as far as at least that segment of your bill or
what's your response to that? It's two separate issues. For example, Bill Walker, during his reign at the Agency of Career Education, there was two whistleblower lawsuits where people basically told about wrongdoing and were fired, fired whistleblower lawsuits. We had to pay out over, I think at the time, like $170,000 or $80,000 of people's tax dollars to defend those lawsuits. So you have a situation where employees trying to say something is wrong, and that's what your bill covers. And that's one of the things when me and you were chair of audit that we were talking about at that time. What I'm talking about is a situation if you have a problem at DHS, which we've had multiple headlines about, that is using their influence in some way or capacity to get money and then they're administering or overseeing the grant process where there is fraud going on. Like I said, folks, we give out $8 billion worth of Medicaid and we've had headline after headline. So there's a difference between whistleblower and somebody standing up and doing the right thing and unjustly gets fired. There's a difference in trying to expose the top relationships that they would have a great deal of influence over a particular grant or a particular problem. As I keep saying, we've had multiple headlines about problems at fraud at DHS happening in programs that have cost taxpayers millions of dollars.
Mr. Chair, could I add just a little bit to that? Yes, you're recognized. Rep. Hammer, to your question, I think if you have an employee at DHS who on the side sets up an LLC or an incorporation and then they are getting paid by an insurance company or nursing home or a hospital for some random service that this LLC or incorporation may do or not do or whatever, Yes, this bill would require that that be disclosed. It would require that the provider, the Medicaid provider, be the one to disclose it. So I don't think we're going to be taking up, you know, like a lot of extra work time of that DHS or whatever hypothetical employee that you're discussing. I hope maybe does that help? Yeah,
the burden is not on the, it's on the provider. And let me give you another example. Stephen Jones, who was a former representative and then a DHS official, got convicted of bribery back to a Medicaid provider. So I don't know why DHS, I don't know, and I have not even been approached by DHS. Not one time. I mean, I've heard that, and they've had multiple opportunities to talk to me. I've discussed other bills that's been before this committee with DHS. Not one time have they come talk to me about this bill. And yet they had a DHS official plead guilty to bribery. They ought to be the ones here at the table supporting it. Representative Hammer, we're going
Representative Gray, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. As I read through this bill, you define Medicaid provider. And so I guess my first question would be if you are, you know, you're presenting this on the air of transparency, by omission, and you're essentially excluding primary care, specialists, dentists, dialysis centers, occupational therapy, physical therapy, I could go on and on. So if you're truly after transparency, why did you exclude all of these lines of business that do take Medicaid money from having to report?
Yeah, I think that whenever you take on something, sometimes you have to focus on the first problem first. As I mentioned, Stephen Jones that was convicted of bribery. As I mentioned, Medicaid providers out here, like in that case, That's what we've got to tackle first. As we keep saying, Representative Gray, one of the criticisms I keep hearing wrongly about my bill, it's too broad. So you're wanting me to broaden it on out. Follow-up, Mr. Chair? Yes, you're recognized. Thank you.
you limit your bill? I limited my bill, if you want to call it limiting that, to Medicaid providers, nursing homes, insurance companies, those type entities. If you have an individual with a doctor out here that then contracts with the legislator, I mean, it's making it more broad. So it actually puts it into the argument of the other people. I'm saying I'm dialing down on the entities that have been causing the headlines today. I have not seen a headline yet of a particular doctor or a dentist using that influence with a legislator, with a government official. So. Are you finished? If there's a headline out there that I've missed, be sure and let me know. I'm dealing with the headlines and the things that's going on in today.
Okay. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. Senator King, you made a statement a while ago that no one had met with you until right here at the end. If I understand this correctly, there was a certain provider group that met with you about three weeks ago. That would have been not right here
at the end three weeks ago. Can you clarify whether you met with these people? Yeah, it was the nursing home people that met with me, and I told them to either offer amendments to clear it up or not. I'm talking about specifically the hospital people and the nursing home people did meet with me earlier. I didn't mention them in that statement. If you want to dial down, it was the hospital people, and then I keep hearing text messages from other hospital-type people. So what you're telling me is that you
made a very incorrect statement in the beginning saying that no one had met with you until just now, when people have been meeting with you up to three weeks ago. No,
the nursing home people met with me earlier, and we just agreed, and I offered to them that they could make amendments or changes to the bill, and they said they would oppose it. I'm specifically talking about the hospital people and some of these ones you're getting a text message here lately. Representative Hammer, you're right. And I'm talking about DHS
brought it up. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for a question. This mystifies me because I've not gotten one email or call in opposition to this bill. I just don't see it out there. I don't hear it out there. I think it is something that brings some transparency. It's a report of money spent. And like I said, I've not gotten one call. I've not gotten one email that I've been able to identify. There may be in there, and I may have not seen it, but I don't see the pushback maybe outside the legislature. And is there anyone signed up to speak against it today?
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I guess I'm big money interest people since I'm pushing back. Part of my issue, too, is the wording of the bill, the language of the bill. So in the bill, you talk about any two of the following entities who do business more than $2,000 transactions. Those two, I could take a Medicaid provider and a spouse of the provider. So if I've got a woman who owns a hospital, and she's married, and they do more than $2,000 worth of business with Medicaid, they now
have to report. Same way somebody with a furniture dealership has to disclose members of our General Assembly, same way members of General Assembly have to disclose if their spouse gets hired, the same difference, no different. We have one, as I stated earlier, Representative Gray, we have one standard for everybody out here that deals with government entities such as that person that may have a spouse that owns a building that leases buildings to a revenue office. And then we have one different one for all these other ones. I'm not seeing government officials with government monies in the headlines, unfortunately, making headlines for corruption. Follow up, Mr. Chair.
You're recognized. I don't think you quite understood what I was saying. This doesn't link it to any government official or anybody that's appointed or elected. It literally says, number one is A, Medicaid provider. B, government official. C, spouse of the Medicaid provider. D, the business in which the Medicaid provider, blah, blah, blah. Any two of the following. So every Medicaid provider who has a spouse that does more than $2,000
have to do a disclosure report and report their, if I could, please let me finish my question. They're now required to file a financial disclosure report in which they have to list private transactions between them and their lobbyists or their consultant or whoever it is. So the bill, this is being touted, so I'm going to look like I'm against transparency, although I have a transparency bill on the House floor right now. So it's being touted that I'm going to be against transparency. I'm against bad bills. This is a bad bill. So please explain to me why you're after every Medicaid provider in the state of Arkansas that's married.
Are you finished? I am now finished. Thank you. Okay. I will answer. This bill addresses conflicts of interest. It's in the bill. It's in the bill. May I finish? Yes. Go ahead, Representative Miller. Thank you. Now, the bill addresses conflicts of interest. That is in the language of this bill. I don't think you can find anybody in this room who is going to stand up and say that transactions between a Medicaid provider and their spouse are conflicts of interest. If there's anybody in here that would like to stand up and say that, please do, right now. That is not a conflict of interest. The bill is set up to disclose conflicts of interest, meaning if there is a Medicaid provider doing business with the spouse of a legislator or the spouse of a government official, that would pose a conflict of interest, meaning it needs to be disclosed. We're not trying to nab anybody. We're not trying out to get all Medicaid providers. I love Medicaid providers. As a Medicaid recipient, I'm all about some good Medicaid providers. Seriously. I'm not out to get anybody. I'm just simply saying let's bring the tax dollars that are being spent through Medicaid up to the same level of transparency that all the other government agencies have to abide by. And that's it. So hopefully I've cleared up that question. Mr.
Chairman, I'd like a follow-up. Number one, Representative Gray, if my wife, who's an accountant back home, if she gets a job at UAMS or anything like that the way other legislators have, it comes before the legislative council. Why have two different standards out here when it comes to Medicaid money? If we're going to do that and we want to do your problem, let's do away with that rule. I've been down here multiple times where a spouse has been hired and they had to come before the legislative council and have to disclose
Okay, I think I got it on now. Here's why I feel like this is a little too broad. On page one, line 25, where you define government official, and then as an employee of a person who is elected or appointed to hold public office. Okay, so I'm the guy you talked to earlier about that my wife's a nurse practitioner. Yeah, there was somebody else that talked to me, too, about the same issue. She does not take Medicaid at all. She does, on the other hand, have an employee who is a nurse practitioner that's a part-time employee. That employee also has a second job that does take Medicaid money. It's a home health service. So by definition here, she is now a government official because she is an employee of our business. So you have her defined as a government official. then you go down on page two, line seven. Oh, and she's also a Medicaid provider because she accepts money from Medicaid now. So she's a government official and a Medicaid provider. And now she's filing a disclosure statement. Not only is she filing a disclosure statement, but the home health provider that employs her on the other side has to, because she's now a government official, they have to file the disclosure as well. And how do they even know that she's defined as a government official? Can you tell me again how she's a government official? Because you have it listed here
In your situation. Government official, an employee of a person who is elected. Yeah. So she's our employee at Compass as part-time employee. She's an employee there. She also takes Medicaid money from her second job. So now she's having to file a disclosure statement because she's a government official. And because she's a government official, the other people that employ her have to file a statement as well. That's why I say this goes too far. It's too broad. They don't even know. They have no idea that she even works or may not have any idea that she works for us and is a government or is it defined as a government official.
Here's my question in your scenario here. Hypothetically, does she work for Representative Justin Gonzalez or does she work for Gonzalez Family Medicine or whatever the business name is? Well, I mean, that doesn't matter.
It says here an employee of a person who is elected. So if we own the business, she is technically an employee. So it goes too far. I mean, it's not like she's my personal secretary.
this environment that we're in, and home health care gets millions and millions of dollars, yeah, in your situation in that deal, they would have to disclose. And Representative Gonzalez, it's the same thing. We have two different standards out here that if you own a business and you do business with another government entity, then you have to disclose that. So we're wanting to stop short on all this Medicaid money, But then on the other hand, we want to have all kinds of disclosure that if UAMS or some hospital or government agency hires a spouse, we want to have them disclose. And then it's like I'm getting criticized on one side of the bill, it's too broad. And then one side is saying, bringing questions, saying it's not broad enough. Listen, folks, Representative Gonzalez, that is an issue in that separate situation you have to disclose. But Representative Gonzalez, other people have to disclose things, too. I mean, when it comes to $8 billion, and Representative Gonzalez, I hate that I have to put that situation or we have to bring this bill, but I don't even want to go through all the situations we've had headlines. And, folks, if we're not going to police ourselves, if we're not going to police ourselves, the people's going to police us.
Representative Hammer, you're recognized. What's your motion? That's a valid motion, non-debatable. There's nothing to be in the Senate, we'll let no motion make. Yes, correct. Representative Wardlaw is correct, has to follow a main motion. We don't have a main motion. Any further questions from the committee? It's correct. Representative Sturt, you're recognized for
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I just had a quick question, page two, line 21. Question. I keep talking about two different sets of rules. We've had a lot of transparency bills come through the committee. Different groups say yay, different groups say nay. I'm wanting to know, are there any other entities out there or regulations that we have where we disclose
how much lobbyists are paid? Yes, UMS has to disclose exactly. University of Arkansas has to disclose. Okay, non-governmental entities? Non-governmental entities? name me a non-gunte rule entity that's getting over a billion dollars this year or hundreds of millions of dollars that hasn't representative starch that we've seen headline after headline after headline folks i keep saying it's the same thing if we didn't have headlines out here every day or that we've had and the corruption in dhs that i mentioned with the food stamp program with with grants and everything like that i wouldn't be here today representative starch but we do have those issues. And we're dealing with $8 billion worth of Medicaid. And we need to know how much. It's a simple question. If Blue Cross Blue Shield is going to take all this money, you know what? They ought to disclose how much they spend. If they were taking all private money, this doesn't apply. And let me give you another example. The University of Arkansas that takes all this government money, they still get private money and donations. They still have to disclose that. The only thing they don't have to disclose is that the U of A Foundation, the one that hires some football coaches and stuff, that's all private money. The University of Arkansas takes private money. They take students' tuition money. People's hurt
are dox dollars. Representative Douglas, you're recognized for what purpose? Have a motion do pass. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Have a motion for immediate consideration. That's non-debatable. All in favor? Signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. Say the ayes have it. Roll call. For the immediate consideration. This roll call for the immediate consideration motion.
votes, this takes two-thirds, so the motion fails. So we're back to the motion that you made, Representative Douglas, do pass. Any discussion on the motion? I will remind you, Representative Miller, you're part of the committee, so you can take part in the discussion. Representative Gray, you're
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I'm just going to present a scenario, another scenario here, just to show it's not so much about the transparency piece as it's about the wording of the bill. The language of the bill is bad. So you take, say, an Arkansas State Police Commissioner, that commissioner's spouse, and it's so complicated I had to write it down. The commissioner's spouse is a nurse at the heart hospital. So now Mr. Commissioner must file a Medicaid disclosure statement because the salary transaction between his wife and the hospital was more than $2,000. And now the commissioner must include how much that he spent at the Hart Hospital was paid to lobbyists, how much the Hart Hospital paid to lobbyists. Now, also, the Hart Hospital has to file a statement because they employ the commissioner's wife. I mean, the complexities, just to like what Representative Gonzalez was saying in this bill, are very unforeseen, and they're going to be very far-reaching. So what's going to happen is this Mr. Commissioner finds out and he doesn't want his wife to lose her job because Heart Hospital says, I don't want to hire someone that's going to make me have to file this disclosure statement. They're going to let her go. Mr. Commissioner then stuck with a wife who loses a job. Getting off the board, I've now got a governor who's having problems appointing people because of the disclosure forms and all the problems that come with it. It's not about the transparency that I'm against. I have a bill on the House floor about transparency. It's about the way this bill was written and the far-reaching effects of every person in the state of Arkansas. And I'll be quick as I finish this up. This also says you exclude patients from having to file, but you don't exclude the business from having to file. So we have a member of this very body, one of our colleagues whose wife has cancer. Let's say she's been to UAMS. He doesn't have to file the form because of her. But UAMS would now have to report because they treat an elected official's spouse. That's what the wording in the bill says. That's the way the language is spelled out in this bill. And then that's a violation of HIPAA, plain and simple. So my issue with this bill is not what it's trying to do. It's how it's doing it and the unforeseen complications with it. So with that, I will vote no.
Chair. I've been texting back and forth with a few agencies here in state government, and as you guys know, I'm a pretty consistent no voter on big government issues. And I had this discussion the other day with somebody about this bill, and I got confirmation of it now. Now, if this bill passes in its current form, it's going to create a whole new division at DHS, which is, let me remind you, big government. That agency is going to be responsible for having all these disclosure forms filed. So I just want to remind you guys that want to go home and say that you're for small government and lessening government, that when you vote this through, you're voting for big government. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you. Just to respond to a couple things, Representative Gray, you brought up a legitimate concern. However, I will down, I don't have the bill where I can see it right now to show the exact line. But there is exemptions made for folks who are being seen as patients. That is in the bill. It's very clear. Representative Wardlaw, I appreciate your anti-big government stance. I think I've got a pretty clear record of being the same way myself. For someone to say that this is going to create a whole new division at DHS is absolutely laughable. That is laughable. I will personally make the commitment to DHS. We're talking about DHS has to provide a disclosure form of paper. All they have to do is provide a sheet of paper. If we are so pathetic in the state of Arkansas that we have to form a whole new branch of government to get enough people together to come up with a sheet of paper, we're in worse shape than I thought. A sheet of paper. I'll donate $100 a year to DHS to buy the paper and the ink. That's ridiculous. I'd appreciate a good vote for good transparency. Is this bill perfect? No. I don't want to say it is. Have we passed any bill out of here that's been perfect? But at some point, you've got to start somewhere. And this is where we're trying to start. And I would, you know, again, I think folks back home like transparency. They want to see government tax dollars, and they want to see some form of transparency. We're spending more through Medicaid than we are a lot of other branches of government that are transparent. We're just trying to bring it up to
Can you speak real loud? It came on then. Again, my biggest issue, I think, with this bill is not the transparency part, but a lot of it's how we define government official in here. We all ran for office. We set ourselves up for this. We decided, you know, it feels like sometimes we have to prove our innocence all the time of forms and stuff that we have to fill out. My wife didn't sign up for that. Our employees didn't sign up for that. You know, they are not government officials just because they work for us in some other capacity somewhere else. That is a, to me, that's a big problem, and I would appreciate a no vote on this. Comment? Yes, Representative Douglas,
do you recognize? And I do sympathize with that, and I agree. But, if someone is trying to get to me to influence a vote, one of the best ways they can do it is through my family. And that's why that spousal relationship and and money should be included in this because that degree of separation is very, very small. So, that was just a comment that I think that we need to consider. Representative Gonzales, you're recognized. Thank
you, Ms. Chair. Point taken, I get that. If somebody wanted to do favors for me, to do that through my wife would be a good way to do that, but not through our employees. Just because we have an employee that we share with someone else, and they are, you know, that other person is a Medicare provider, Medicaid provider, and then that employee is now a Medicaid provider because they are paid by somebody who's paid by Medicaid, you know, that's just way too many steps, and, you know, that has no effect on us at all. And that's a real-life situation. That is not hypothetical. That is real life that she would have to report according to how this bill is set up. Again, I appreciate a
no vote. Any further discussion? Hearing none, the motion on the table is due pass by Representative Douglas. Yes, sir. All in favor of the motion signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. I'd say the nays have it. All
With seven yes votes, the bill has failed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Okay, we're going to do House Bill 1947 by Representative Tucker at this point. And there's an amendment on it. 1946. 1946. Thank you. HB 1946, there is an amendment and it's on the tablets, is that correct? The amendment's on your tablets. So, Representative Tucker, if you would identify yourself and then we'll do the amendment first. Yes, sir. Mr. Chairman,
thank you. Representative Tucker, and I've got an amendment on House Bill 1946 to make consistent what I presented to the committee and passed out last time. Any discussion? Your motion was to
approve the amendment? Oh, I'm sorry. You can't make a motion. I can't make a motion, Mr. Chairman. I have a motion do pass. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your amendment is passed. You're recognized to represent your bill. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. This is the bill to create the panel for the Freedom of Information Act, the three-person panel, that if either a custodian or a requester could appeal a decision to this three-person panel. The reason I'm back here, you all passed this out last time, which I'm grateful for, but But the reason I'm back here is because I presented the bill the first time, an amendment was adopted, and then I pulled the bill down before you all voted on it. And then I made an amendment based on that, and I brought it back. And staff pointed out as the committee meeting was started that we actually needed to expunge the vote on the first adoption and make a combined amendment. And so the bill drafter had to put that together in a matter of a few minutes, and it was two complicated amendments. And so one thing got left out, and there's one thing I told you all that was being removed that was not removed. So I did want to run it on the House floor with the bill not being the way I presented it to this committee. And so, that's why I re-referred it to the committee, and I realize time is running short. But I wanted to stick by what I presented to the committee and commitment I made to another group. So that's what I've done, and so I'm back here to ask for your vote another time. And again, the purpose of the bill, and I can go into it as much as anybody wants, but I'll just limit it by saying the issue is that it would provide an objective, independent review for every FOIA request to the extent this panel would accept those requests for FOIA requests in the state of Arkansas. It's a pro-FOIA bill. Right now, custodians are the ones who determine whether or not they turn a record over. And this would allow someone the option of having an independent review of that without having to incur the expense of filing a lawsuit. So I think it's a good bill and I
appreciate a good vote. All right, any questions from the committee? But we do have, is there any questions? If not, we have one person in the audience that signed up to speak against the bill. Denise Hoggard, would you please go to the end of the table if she's here? She has left the room, I think. Okay. I have a motion. I have a motion from Representative Wardlaw. Do pass. Any discussion? Representative Gonzales. I'd just like to
Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. I would say that Representative Tucker has been awesome in finding these mistakes in these bills, and that's what makes him such a great lawyer. And I do appreciate this transparency as well for bringing this back. I do recommend a
due pass. Okay, we have a motion of due pass as amended, is that correct, Representative, as amended? Yes. Okay, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. The ayes have it, motion carried. Your bill is passed, congratulations. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, thank you, members of the committee. Okay, we have one more. Okay, we're going to go ahead and run Senate Bill 425. Representative Gonzales, are you prepared to run that bill? I just don't hear all the discussion again. Representative Gonzales, you're recognized to present your
bill. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Committee, we've already heard this bill once, so I'm not going to go through all the details on it. Again, Senate Bill 425 adds a couple of positions to the Board of Finance. Let me get down to what this is about. This is about accountability for $3 billion of state money. What we have is the Treasurer's Office has hired a guy in. And, you know, let me put this out there, too. I have not, I do not have anything personally against the treasurer's office or anybody in there. This is not, for me, any type of personal vendetta. This is about having qualified people by statute of what this body has decided. So they have hired a senior investment manager that, by statute, that position requires a mandatory college degree. We've got this guy passing out cards that say senior investment manager. His hiring paperwork says he has hired in a senior investment manager. He does not have the qualifications to fill that position. That's what this is about. Board of Finance has the authority to say these people are or are not qualified to fill these positions. What's happened here is they spun it around, tried to give them a different title, but that's not what he was hired in at. I don't deny that the guy has the experience to fill it. By all accounts, he's extremely experienced. But fact is, the qualifications are not there. The qualifications are mandatory college degree for dealing with $3 billion of state money. So that's it. Can I ask the chair a question, please? Yes, yes, you're recognized. Are we meeting after session today? Well, Representative
Gonzales, I'm glad you brought that up because I was going to ask you a question about that. With the number of people that we have here and the importance of this bill, I would ask you to pull it back down. We will meet after the session today unless it goes to 8 o'clock or something. But we also will be meeting on Friday, probably. So if you would pull that down when we get more people here, I think that
would be- Yeah, if we're planning on meeting after session, I would be glad to do that because I'd like to have pretty full consensus on this. Like you said, it is a very serious matter. We're talking about $3 billion of state money, and I think we deserve to have a full committee for that.
All right. Thank you, Representative Gonzales, for that. We will make an announcement in the session if we're going to meet after the session today. It looks like we may do that now, but we'll make an announcement, so please listen for that. But I talked to Chairman Ballinger, and we will definitely either meet after session today or on Friday, so we are adjourned. Thank you.
HB1946 Tucker TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ACCESS TO PUBLIC INFORMATION; AND TO AMEND THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967.
2:00:09 - 1:59:10
Rep. Tucker’s HB 1946, amending the Freedom of Information Act to create a three-person panel for independent review of FOIA requests, was introduced and an amendment was quickly moved forward.
[2:00:21][2:00:30][2:00:42][2:00:51][2:01:02]
After brief discussion of the panel’s role in providing an objective appeal process without costly lawsuits, the committee approved the amendment and the bill by voice vote.
[2:00:51][2:01:02][2:01:26][2:01:57][2:02:29][2:02:42]
HB1766 D. Douglas TO CREATE "THE NONPARTISAN BLANKET PRIMARY ACT"' TO INSTITUTE THE NONPARTISAN BLANKET PRIMARY ELECTION SYSTEM; AND TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS ELECTION CODE.
HB1819 K. Hendren CONCERNING BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES OF CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS PROPOSED BY THE GERA ASSEMBLY.
HB1931 Gillam CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES OF PETITIONS PRIOR TO CIRCULATION.
HB2074 Leding TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING INITIATIVES AND REFERENDA.
HB2095 G. Hodges THE CENTERS CAMPUSES STATE-SUPPORTED OF ON TO VOTE ESTABLISH POSTSECONDARY AND HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING VOTE CENTERS.
HB2162 Gonzales TO PROMOTE VOTER TURNOUT; TO AMEND THE LAW TO LIMIT THE DATES ON WHICH CERTAIN SPECIAL ELECTIONS CAN BE HELD; TO AMEND THE LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT 1 OF 1942.
HB2196 Henderson TO AMEND LANGUAGE CONCERNING THE SPORT OF PROFESSIONAL WRESTLING; AND TO CREATE AN EXEMPTION FOR CHARTABLE EVENTS.
HB2259 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE NATURALIZATION TEST USED BY UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES BEFORE A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY MAY VOTE FOR OR AGAINST A BILL OR RESOLUTION.
HB2260 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE NATURALIZATION TEST USED BY UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES BEFORE A PERSON MAY BE ELIGIBLE TO SERVE AS A DIRECTOR OR HEAD OF A STATE AGENCY.
HB2261 Walker TO REQUIRE THE PASSAGE OF THE CIVICS PORTION OF THE NATURALIZATION TEST USED BY UNITED STATES CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES BEFORE A PERSON MAY BE ELIGIBLE TO SERVE AS A CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICER OF THIS STATE.
HB1861 Ballinger CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF BALLOT TITLES AND POPULAR NAMES6 OF PETITIONS PRIOR TO CIRCULATION.
HB1881 Dotson CONCERNING A REQUIRED REPORT OF STATE AGENCY RULES; AND CONCERNING THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES ACT
HCR1015 V. Flowers REQUESTING AND PETITIONING THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO PROPOSE AN AMENDMENT TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS REPEALING THE LANGUAGE OF THE THREE-FIFTHS COMPROMISE.
HB1004 Blake TO CREATE THE DEMOCRACY ACT; TO REQUIRE AUTOMATIC VOTER REGISTRATION; AND TO AMEND AMENDMENT 51 OF THE ARKANSAS CONSTITUTION.
SB377 Hickey CONCERNING THE ELIGIBILITY OF AN INMATE OF THE DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION TO PARTICIPATE IN A WORK-RELEASE PROGRAM OR UNDER ACT 309 OF 1983.
HB2200 M. Hodges TO MODIFY THE DEFINITION OF "SMALL PROCUREMENTS"; TO INCREASE THE ABILITY OF THE STATE TO CONTRACT WITH CERTIFIED MINORITY BUSINESS ENTERPRISES; AND TO ELIMINATE BURDENSOME DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS.
HCR1014 V. Flowers REQUESTING AND PETITIONING THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO PROPOSE FOR SUBMISSION TO THE STATES FOR CONTINUED RATIFICATION AN EQUAL RIGHTS AMENDMENT.
SB425 Rice AN ACT CONCERNING THE DUTIES OF THE STATE BOARD OF FINANCE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
2:04:18 - 1:21:49
Senate Bill 425, concerning the duties of the State Board of Finance and declaring an emergency over the hiring of an unqualified senior investment manager for the Treasurer’s Office, was presented by Rep. Justin Gonzales, who argued the position requires a mandatory college degree given the $3 billion at stake.
[2:04:43][2:04:47][2:05:16][2:05:48]
Gonzales requested additional committee time, proposing a post-session meeting to achieve broader consensus before any vote could be taken.
[2:06:55][2:07:00][2:07:21][2:07:28][2:07:37]
SB175 B. King TO REQUIRE MEDICAID PROVIDERS AND GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS TO DISCLOSE OF CONFLICTS OF INTEREST.
1:21:49 - 13:42
The committee considered SB 175, introduced by Rep. Kim Hammer and presented by Rep. Josh Miller and Sen. Bryan King, which would require Medicaid providers, hospitals and related entities to disclose financial transactions over $2,000 to prevent conflicts of interest.
[1:22:01][1:22:07][1:22:26][1:22:29][1:22:38][1:23:14][1:23:34]
After prolonged debate, the committee voted on a motion to pass the bill, but the nays prevailed and SB 175 failed to advance.
[1:58:13][1:58:31][1:58:41]
SB521 Hickey TO AMEND THE PROCESS AND REQUIREMENTS FOR REQUESTS FOR PROPOSALS AND REQUESTS FOR QUALIFICATIONS; TO LIMIT THE TERM OF PUBLIC CONTRACTS; AND TO REQUIRE CERTAIN DISCLOSURES IN PROCURING PUBLIC CONTRACTS.
13:42 - 1:07
Senator Jimmy Hickey introduced SB 521, which would permit pricing to be a factor in RFQs, require disclosure of evaluation-team relationships, cap multi-year contracts at four years (with limited extensions and a possible ten-year term for contracts over $20 million), and create a sunset provision that keeps the current RFQ rules for seven professional groups until June 30 2019 while a study committee is established to review the process.
[17:32][18:04][18:39][19:13][19:47][20:21][20:51][21:24]
Committee members asked how the exemption would be applied, which groups it covered, and whether price could be waived in extraordinary cases; Hickey responded that the exemption includes architects, engineers, construction managers, financial advisors, legal and land-surveyors, that price can be reduced to zero under extraordinary circumstances, and that the bill allows design-phase bids to proceed under the existing RFQ framework.
[22:13][22:27][22:41][23:00][23:19][23:32][24:04][24:08][24:43][25:17][25:50]
Representative Kim Hammer and Senator Hickey emphasized the bill’s aim to improve procurement of billions of dollars in taxpayer funds, set clear deadlines for best-practice development, and assure that the process will function as intended, urging members to support it; Hammer’s motion to pass the amendment to SB 758 was offered, received no discussion, and was adopted unanimously.
[1:13:01][1:13:38][1:14:14][1:14:45][1:15:17][1:15:42][1:15:50][1:16:21][1:17:59][1:18:19]
SB627 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING MEETINGS TO CONSIDER APPEALS OF DECISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS THE CLAIMS COMMISSION, REVIEW OF CLAIMS STATE MEETINGS INCLUDING SUBCOMMITTEE OF THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL.
SB633 Williams TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE STATE MARKETING BOARD FOR RECYCLABLES E. AND THE COMPLIANCE ADVISORY PANEL.
SB758 Smith TO REVIEW, STUDY, AND REFORM ALL LAWS, STATUES, REGULATIONS, AND RULES Collins-PERTAINING TO BEER, LIQUOR AND WINE IN THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.
1:07 - 1:20:27231 segments25 speakers
Representative Kim Hammer introduced SB 758, explaining that it mandates a joint review by the House and Senate State Agencies committees of all Arkansas alcohol statutes and sets a hard reporting deadline of October 1, 2018 to the Speaker and President Pro Tem.
[3:11][3:24]
Representative Andy Davis raised a procedural concern that the study was placed before the State Agencies Committee rather than the House Rules Committee, which has greater expertise on ABC matters, leading several members to propose an amendment to add the Rules Committee or create a joint committee for the review.
[3:58][4:30][5:01][5:33][6:35][7:01][7:06]
The chair accepted the suggestion, agreed to hold the bill while an amendment is prepared, and withdrew the measure for the time being, with no vote taken during the meeting.
[12:33][13:04][13:09]
SB758 Smith TO REVIEW, STUDY, AND REFORM ALL LAWS, STATUES, REGULATIONS, AND RULES Collins-PERTAINING TO BEER, LIQUOR AND WINE IN THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.
1:20:27 - 2:08:27147 segments18 speakers
Rep. Kim Hammer introduced SB 758, emphasizing its hard deadline for recommendations and urging a vote to pass the measure.
[1:20:37]
Chair Rep. Jack Ladyman adopted an amendment and, after a voice vote, reported the amendment passed unanimously.
[1:20:56]
With no further discussion, the committee approved SB 758 as amended, effectively passing the bill.
[1:21:08][1:21:11]
HB1046 Tucker TO PERMIT PAID MATERNITY LEAVE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.
HJR1001 Ballinger APPLYING TO THE UNITED STATES CONGRESS TO CALL A CONVENTION FOR PROPOSING AMENDMENTS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE V OF THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION.
HB1011 Sabin POLITICAL COMMITTEE PROVISIONS ACTION CONCERNING AMEND TO CONTRIBUTIONS; AND TO PROHIBIT DIRECT CONTRIBUTIONS BETWEEN POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES.
HB1012 Sabin TO AMEND PROVISIONS CONCERNING POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PROHIBIT DIRECT FROM TO CONTRIBUTIONS COMMITTEES POLITICAL ACTION CANDIDATES.
HB1179 Ballinger BENEFITS DEATH DESIGNATED TO PROVIDING TO PROVISIONS AMEND BENEFICIARIES OR SURVIVORS OF POLICE OFFICERS.
HB1009 Leding TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEES; AND TO PREVENT A MEMBER OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY FROM FORMING MORE THAN ONE (1) APPROVED POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE.
HB1447 M. Gray TO TRANSFER THE STATE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONERS TO THE OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE; TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COMPLAINTS OF ELECTION LAW VIOLATIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1151 Davis TO REQUIRE THAT REGISTERED VOTERS BE NOTIFIED BY MAIL OF THE DATES FOR CERTAIN SPECIAL ELECTIONS; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING SPECIAL ELECTIONS.
HB1741 Vaught NOTIFICATION CONCERNING SYSTEM; ALERT AND TO BLUE A ESTABLISH EMERGENCY ASSISTANCE TO LAW ENFORCEMENT
HB2231 Rushing TO REGULATE THE ADMINISTRATION OF REAL PROPERTY OF THE STATE AND POLITICAL SUBDIVISIONS OF THE STATE.
SB38 A. Clark TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING ELECTIONS AND BALLOTS.
HB1005 Tucker TO REQUIRE REPORTING AND DISCLOSURE OF ELECTIONEERING COMMUNICATIONS; AND TO RESTRICT THE AMOUNT OF MONEY SPENT ON CAMPAIGN COMMUNICATIONS PRODUCED IN COORDINATION WITH A CANDIDATE FOR OFFICE.
HB2128 Lowery TO AMEND ARKANSAS LAW CONCERNING THE APPROVAL OF STATE AGENCY RULES.
HB2183 Lowery TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS WHISTLE-BLOWER ACT; AND TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "WHISTLEBLOWER".
HB1932 Gillam CONCERNING THE REVIEW OF RULES PROMULGATED BY THE STATE BOARD OF HEALTH AND THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH.
HB1832 House TO ALLOW THE EMPLOYMENT OF SPECIAL COUNSEL BY A STATE OFFICIAL OR ENTITY IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES; AND TO REQUIRE SPECIAL COUNSEL TO OBTAIN APPROVAL BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL BEFORE ENTERING INTO A SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT.
HB1988 Lundstrum CONCERNING COUNTY JAIL REIMBURSEMENT FOR HOUSING STATE INMATES.
SB252 B. King SERVICES HUMAN TO DEPARTMENT MONTHLY SUBMIT TO OF THE REQUIRE FINANCIAL REPORTS TO THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL.