Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Gonvernmental Affairs

March 29, 2017 ·Committee Room 151 ·19:56
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

SB425 Rice CONCERNING THE DUTIES OF THE STATE BOARD OF FINANCE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 0:18

Representative Justin Gonzales introduced Senate Bill 425, arguing that the State Board of Finance needs qualified oversight for managing $3 billion and noting a current appointee lacks a required college degree. [0:45] [1:03]

Treasury officials, including Chief Deputy Treasurer Grant Wallace and legal counsel TJ Fowler, testified that the qualifications are set by the Board, not statute, and that the hired Treasury Division Director meets the Board’s standards and possesses extensive experience. [1:34] [2:06] [2:10] [2:40] [3:12] [3:16] [3:47] [4:19] [4:49]

Representative Douglas House and the Treasury witnesses countered that the bill would create an unconstitutional dual-employment scheme, undermine existing checks and balances, and shift responsibility without clear legal authority. [2:10] [2:40] [3:12] [8:43] [9:04] [9:39] [9:50] [10:12] [10:45]

After a brief question period, Chairman Ballinger dismissed the witnesses and Representative Gonzales closed the bill without a motion or vote, leaving SB 425 without passage. [14:31] [14:58] [15:03]

SB627 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING MEETING TO CONSIDER APPEALS OF DECISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS STATE CLAIMS COMMISSION, INCLUDING MEETINGS OF THE CLAIMS REVIEW SUBCOM… 15:28

Representative Justin Gonzales explained that SB 627 would add members to the existing claims-review board who would work under the treasurer’s direction, citing the bill’s language on the senior investment manager position requiring a degree. [15:53] [16:09]

Chairman Ballinger called for a motion, the committee moved to pass the bill, and after a voice vote the motion was recorded as opposed, resulting in the bill’s failure. [16:34] [16:39] [17:02] [17:37]

SB633 E. Williams TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE STATE MARKETING BOARD FOR RECYCLABLES AND THE COMPLIANCE ADVISORY PANEL. 17:49

Representative Jack Ladyman presented SB 633, outlining that it merges two boards, creates a compliance advisory panel to aid businesses with environmental requirements, and requires no new funding. [18:40]

With no committee questions, Chairman Ballinger moved to pass the bill, the motion carried unanimously, and the committee reported SB 633 as passed. [19:30] [19:33] [19:42]

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
SB633 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “Vladyman, are you going to pick up and run SB 633? Yes, I will.”
Pre-2017 bill
SB425 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “So you're recognized to run Senate Bill 425. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee. I hate to reha…”
Pre-2017 bill
SB627 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB627 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING MEETING TO CONSIDER APPEALS OF DEC…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
All right, members, if we don't mind getting gathered in, we'll go ahead and get started. I think we have two bills to hit here, and I don't mind listening to membership if they have something else on one of these. But I think about everything that's on our agenda had an opportunity to be heard at one point or another. So I don't think Senator Rice is. I think that Representative Gonzalez has taken up that one. Again, and I think that we're going to go ahead and get started with you.
▶ Play
So you're recognized to run Senate Bill 425. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Committee. I hate to rehash everything we've already gone through again, but again, this is about managing $3 billion of the state's money and having qualified people to do it. This board having oversight to say who is and is not qualified right now. I think we have a, well, I know we have someone that by statute is not qualified to fill the position. The position requires a college degree, and a person filling the position does not have that. So, you know, that's really all I've got to say about this. other than what we've already been through, so I'll leave it with that.
▶ Play
Okay, any questions from the committee? All right, seeing none, we do have Mr. Grant Wallace from the Treasurer's Office. Actually, both of you all from the Treasurer's Office, if you don't mind taking the end of the table, then introduce yourself for the record. What I'd say is that, yeah, go ahead and introduce yourself, but, you know, just remember the committee has kind of heard the testimony before, you know, maybe the shorter, maybe the better.
▶ Play
Speaker 15 2:06
Yes, sir. Grant Wallace, Chief Deputy Treasurer for Treasurer
▶ Play
Milligan. TJ Fowler, legal counsel for the Treasury. You want me to go ahead and start? I just want to correct one thing that Representative Gonzalez just said. He said that there are statutory requirements on the job. There are no statutory requirements on how much college. Those are requirements that are set forth by the State Board of Finance or regulatory. And the issue, and I believe Mr. Watts will speak on this a little bit more, the main issue we have is the position that this one individual is in, he meets all the qualifications for that position under how he is employed by DF&A. Y'all heard my three legal arguments last time. I won't rehash those unless someone has questions about them. But the bullet points were, we believe this statute is unconstitutional because it violates the separation of powers doctrine. We believe it's unconstitutional because it violates the due process rights of the treasurer who's criminally liable for things that go on in the treasury. And then it creates some legal impracticalities and problems with regards to employment law. With that, I'll just turn it over to Mr. Wallace
▶ Play
Speaker 15 3:16
and we'll be brief. Again, in regards to the recent hire that we have made, titles on business cards do not matter. We can actually change those. If that really is the issue, then that is something we would be open to discussing. The standards are set by the State Board of Finance and determined by the appropriated title, and they are not set by statute. Act 1088 of 2013 clearly states that the State Board of Finance sets the standards and minimum qualifications. This gentleman is in a Treasury Division Director position, not the Senior Investment Manager position. We followed the guidelines and practices as they were set out. We have not and did not do anything to violate any rules or laws. For example, this is the same as we did when we hired Ed Garner. His business cards have said Deputy Chief Investment Officer and Senior Investment Manager, while he has been in the positions of the appropriated positions of Investment Manager, Director, Chief Investment Officer, and Senior Investment Manager, which he is currently in right now. DF&A and the State Board of Finance reviewed the recent hire's resume, and no one raised any objections. Bottom line is he has over 30 years of experience in the industry, multiple securities license, 91 college credit hours, and is in the Treasury Division Director position, which only prefers a college degree. I would just kind of look at from the business operational aspect. This is not just placing a CEO, but an entire operational division under a board of directors. Good business is having a backup and someone who knows how to do a person's job in case they are injured, incapacitated, or even die. We are an integral part of the functioning of state government, and since the Treasurer took office, we have ensured we have backups and even in some cases backups to the backup. Ed Garner is currently the only one who knows certain securities that we are investing in, and that's an unacceptable risk. When we had the opening created by the retirement of our Chief of Staff, we made it a priority to hire someone to back up Ed Garner in the investment division. So we hired someone with double the years of experience for him to back him up. We've also added to the workload of the investment division, and we just need individuals with with investment experience to assist in managing the increased workload. When everyone is in charge, no one is in charge. Having the State Board of Finance employ these individuals will only increase risk, make the investments of the state more political than they currently are, and really opens up that no one will take any responsibility for this. This bill is looking for a solution to a problem that simply does not exist, and it doesn't solve any problems that have been raised. This does not create any efficiencies, nor good government, but in our opinion, it does create the exact opposite. With that, we'd be glad to answer any questions. Any questions from the
▶ Play
committee? Representative House, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
First of all, I am very pleased on behalf of the taxpayers the way the Treasurer's office has been running your investment program. I'm just very, very proud of you, Mr. Treasurer. Let me give you another way to look at this and tell me why it's wrong. I don't have any investment experience, but let's just say I had $7,500, $100 maybe I wanted to try to invest. So I go down to someplace like Schwab or one of the banks and contact one of their investment teams, and I hire them to come and invest my money. And I expect them to act with professionalism and to make me money and to manage my investments for me. But if I'm not happy with their services, I can say, this is not working, fellas. I'm going to Edward Jones or something. Now, one of the, and this is leading up to a question, one of the, I always like to use the church example. You've got some folks that go around, and they have the offering plates, and they collect money. They give it to a second person who counts it, and perhaps a third person who deposits it, and the deposit slip goes back to the person writing the check so they can keep their checkbook. but you have a diversification of people who handle the money and handle the finances and the paperwork, and you separate those functions in order to have a good accountability structure. Now, with my treasurer, our treasurer in charge of all of these operations, why is not splitting off this investment function as somebody you would like to hire, and if you're not satisfied with them, letting them go, and getting somebody else, this guy's not working out, I want another investor, and also provides that diversification for accountability purposes, not responsibility, but accountability purposes to the treasurer. So if something goes bad, he's not getting all the blame whether he had anything to do with it or not. Now he's got an investment group. What's wrong with my thinking there as far as y'all are concerned? Why do you need to control everything, and what checks and balances are there that your investment people are doing the very best they can. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative House, if I can start in on that and Grant may weigh in as well. From a legal perspective, I don't think what you're saying is a bad thing, but this bill doesn't do any of that. All this bill does is takes four employees of the Treasury, leaves them inside the Treasury, continues to make the Treasurer pay for them out of their appropriation but calls them employees of some board that doesn't have its own appropriation, isn't its own agency. So essentially, everything is still happening inside the Treasury. It's the exact same for people. There's no difference. All you have is this legal morass that we can't figure out who's employed by who, who's responsible to who. You've got the Treasurer who's criminally liable for things they do, but he doesn't technically employ these people. So if the bill were to say let's take investments completely away from the Treasury and make it a function of the State Board of Finance, That may be something worth talking about someday in the future, if there were some reason to do that. But that's not what this bill does. This bill just creates this new dual employment public employee that isn't anticipated by any employment law in the books in the state of Arkansas. And the only
▶ Play
Speaker 15 9:50
thing I would add is this actually would we currently have that check and balance with the CIO position being an employee of the State Board of Finance. There is that check and balance that if there was ever a problem with the investments that the treasurer's office was doing, there's somebody that can go and raise a flag and cause and bring some light on it. What this bill would do is actually put all of the investments in the dark where it's in this no man's land that no one's responsible, no one's really keeping a check on what's going on, and you're breaking down some of that separation of duties, especially with the positions that are being moved over. Right now, we've got a position, two positions that are in this middle office role that don't necessarily, they don't buy it and they don't work with the broker, but they don't work with the money end of it as well. They just make sure everything in the middle is kind of taken care of and in line and all the boxes are checked as they need to be. And those are legitimate things between the working with the broker and the money being actually sent to the brokerage house. So all that would collapse, and you're putting this behind closed doors. I would say currently the State Board of Finance has the ability to hire an investment consultant to examine the policies and practices of the State Treasurer's Office and make recommendations to the board. This bill actually would negate that function because that operation is actually under the State Board of Finance. Why would the State Board of Finance investigate itself? So, you lose that additional check and balance in it that 1088 appropriately sets up. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Representative Hendren, you're recognized for
▶ Play
a question. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I'll make a little bit of introduction like Representative House did. You know, as I understand it, Dennis Milligan, the state treasurer, is responsible for this deal. And as I've come back down here after being down here off and on a few times, more and more I'm learning there are folks that get elected down here, and then all of a sudden they think they know how to decide what everybody else ought to be doing because they've been here maybe two years, four years at the most until these term limits got changed recently. and they determine your skill sets. They determine where you ought to be and then they're going to assign you. And frankly, that ain't working. It's not working in my opinion. We're voting on bills over and over. We send a bill to the governor. He signs it and then we come back and start amending it. And in this member's opinion, we've just got a mess. And what I'm thinking, this may be some of the same stuff here. It bothers me. And what I've always thought is that the ultimate decider of my skill sets and Dennis Milligan's skill set are the voters. with whom we're all going to face next May and March and so forth. Thank the Lord for that, I would say, for all of us. But my question is, is that why don't, I thought, and I know the sponsor mentioned, these people aren't qualified or perhaps don't have the qualifications or don't have a degree. That bothers me just a bit because when I ran for office, I've never been said, well, you got a degree or don't have a degree. And my dad didn't have a degree. He had a six-year education, but he did pretty well. and so forth. So my question is this, what is Dennis Milligan screwing up here that needs to get fixed? I'd ask that if you all, maybe you're going to defend it the other way, and then the sponsor. What is getting screwed up that needs to get fixed that the voters can't fix with Dennis Milligan in the
▶ Play
Speaker 15 13:34
next election? Sir, the only way I know how to answer that question is that he has doubled the returns in his first physical year in office, reaching numbers not seen since 2008. He has secured nearly $80 million in returns in the investment since taking office, and this was not done by the CIO, but by his hires and selections that he made as he came into office, and his challenge to not accept the way things have been always done. There's not a problem in the investment division, and the only thing I probably would add is to hitch yourself to one wagon is not acceptable when you're dealing with $3.8 billion of the people's money. Follow-up, Mr. Chair. You're recognized. Could I ask them
▶ Play
to sponsor the bill to respond to that? When he closes, I'm
▶ Play
sure you'll have an opportunity to respond to that. You mean I can't ask him a question? No, that's what I'm saying. You can ask him a question. In fact, even though in closing, we don't usually do that, but I'll definitely let you ask a question during close. Right now, we have two gentlemen who are testifying, and if we have no other further questions for them, I'm going to let them get out of the way, Representative Hendren. Are there any other questions for these witnesses who are testifying? All right. Seeing none, you guys are dismissed. Appreciate your testimony. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right. There's nobody else signed to speak for or against. Representative Gonzalez, you're recognized and
▶ Play
closed for your bill. Thank you. I'll start by answering Representative Hendricks' question, I suppose. I don't know that there is anything that's screwed up right now, but this is about preventing things from getting screwed up and creating a little bit of accountability. That's what's going on here. As far as the qualifications, that's what's set forth. You know, whether it's set by statute or by this board, regardless, we have qualifications that aren't being met. I'm not saying that he doesn't have the experience. But the fact is that the qualifications are not met. So does that answer your question in any way?
▶ Play
I'm sorry, I can't ask questions. No, you guys feel free. We've got liberty. So, Representative Hendren, if that works for you or if you have another question, you're welcome to ask it. All right. Seeing no other
▶ Play
questions. Are you closed for your bill? Well, I'll just continue on by saying that this doesn't create a different board that has more. This is already a board that exists. It is adding more people to that board. But they work with, and this is in the bill, they work with and at the direction of the treasurer. but consistent with the policies and directives of the board. And I think that's where the problem is right now. And as far as the new employee that we're talking about here, right here is the memo where he was hired in with the title of senior investment manager that requires a college degree to fill that position. So with that, I'll close.
▶ Play
Thank you. Do you have a motion? Motion do pass. All right, so we have a motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Okay. Hearing none, all
▶ Play
Speaker 38 17:02
in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. Nay. Ayes have it. Okay, call the roll. Representative Wardlaw, Representative Wardlaw, Representative Hammer, Representative Hammer, Representative Eubanks, Representative Eubanks, Representative House, Representative House, Representative Douglas, Representative Douglas, Representative Dodson, Representative Miller, Representative Miller, Representative Womack, Representative Womack, Representative Davis, Representative Davis, Representative Saban, Representative Hendren, Representative Drown, Representative Gray, Representative Gray. Representative Tosh. No. Representative Gonzalez. Yes. Representative Ferguson. No. Representative Sternch. Representative Sternch. Representative Smith. No. Representative Ladiman. No. Sorry, Representative Gonzalez, your bill fails. Okay. Representative
▶ Play
Vladyman, are you going to pick up and run SB 633? Yes, I will. I appreciate you doing that. And I think this may close out business, depending on what we get from the Senate. If we need to meet tomorrow in order to get something in particular taken care of, then I'd be happy to do that. But as of now, I think this will
▶ Play
probably take care of everything that we have on our agenda. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is Senate Bill 633, an act to amend the law regarding the State Marketing Board for recyclables and the Compliance Advisory Panel and for other purposes. This bill does four things. It merges two existing boards into one for financial and operational efficiency. It allows the new panel to assist businesses in meeting state and federal environmental requirements. He continues to assist businesses with the identification of potential recyclable materials to divert away from waste streams. And it requires no additional resources because adequate funding already exists. So I'd be happy to take any questions.
▶ Play
Any questions from the committee? I appreciate that presentation, seeing that you just picked it up. That was actually, it seemed like you did a pretty adequate job of that. I'm a little familiar with that subject, but anyway. Well, that was meant for you then. All right. No questions from the committee? All right. You're
▶ Play
recognized and closed for your bill then. I'm closed. Appreciate a good vote. Make a motion to do
▶ Play
pass. All right. We have a motion to do pass. Any discussion on the motion? All right. No discussion. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. Congratulations. You passed your bill. Thank you, sir. Does any members have any other business? Anything else we need to take care of? Email me then. All right. I appreciate you. I assume that we're going to probably meet at least one more time. And so just listen for a call. We are adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

SB425 Rice CONCERNING THE DUTIES OF THE STATE BOARD OF FINANCE; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

0:18 - 15:28 39 segments 6 speakers

Representative Justin Gonzales introduced Senate Bill 425, arguing that the State Board of Finance needs qualified oversight for managing $3 billion and noting a current appointee lacks a required college degree. [0:45] [1:03]

Treasury officials, including Chief Deputy Treasurer Grant Wallace and legal counsel TJ Fowler, testified that the qualifications are set by the Board, not statute, and that the hired Treasury Division Director meets the Board’s standards and possesses extensive experience. [1:34] [2:06] [2:10] [2:40] [3:12] [3:16] [3:47] [4:19] [4:49]

Representative Douglas House and the Treasury witnesses countered that the bill would create an unconstitutional dual-employment scheme, undermine existing checks and balances, and shift responsibility without clear legal authority. [2:10] [2:40] [3:12] [8:43] [9:04] [9:39] [9:50] [10:12] [10:45]

After a brief question period, Chairman Ballinger dismissed the witnesses and Representative Gonzales closed the bill without a motion or vote, leaving SB 425 without passage. [14:31] [14:58] [15:03]

SB627 J. Hutchinson CONCERNING MEETING TO CONSIDER APPEALS OF DECISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS STATE CLAIMS COMMISSION, INCLUDING MEETINGS OF THE CLAIMS REVIEW SUBCOMMITTEE OF THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL.

15:28 - 17:49 7 segments 3 speakers

Representative Justin Gonzales explained that SB 627 would add members to the existing claims-review board who would work under the treasurer’s direction, citing the bill’s language on the senior investment manager position requiring a degree. [15:53] [16:09]

Chairman Ballinger called for a motion, the committee moved to pass the bill, and after a voice vote the motion was recorded as opposed, resulting in the bill’s failure. [16:34] [16:39] [17:02] [17:37]

SB633 E. Williams TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE STATE MARKETING BOARD FOR RECYCLABLES AND THE COMPLIANCE ADVISORY PANEL.

17:49 - 19:56 8 segments 2 speakers

Representative Jack Ladyman presented SB 633, outlining that it merges two boards, creates a compliance advisory panel to aid businesses with environmental requirements, and requires no new funding. [18:40]

With no committee questions, Chairman Ballinger moved to pass the bill, the motion carried unanimously, and the committee reported SB 633 as passed. [19:30] [19:33] [19:42]

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
14 segments
Representative Justin Gonzales Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 15
13 segments
Representative Douglas House Chair Unverified
11 segments
Representative Kim Hendren Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 38
2 segments
Representative Jack Ladyman Unverified
3 segments