Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

State Agencies & Govermental Affairs

March 31, 2017 ·Committee Room 149 ·34:42
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026

HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE ARKANSAS STATE LIBRARY; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE ACT. 0:13

The committee considered a motion to concur in Amendment 1 to HB 1386, which added a co-sponsor and deleted section 2, and the motion was adopted unanimously. [0:36] [0:49]

Representative Richard Womack then presented an amendment to HB 1440 that clarifies canvasser reporting requirements and adds an additional week for submitting lists, and a motion to concur in that amendment was also moved and passed. [1:12] [1:18]

HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ELECTION RUNOFFS, INTIATIVES, AND REFERENDA 1:19

A motion to concur in Representative Gray’s amendment to HB 1440 was made and carried without opposition. [1:44]

Representative Robin Lundstrum offered a concurrence on HB 1866, proposing the addition of a second supervisory signature and a two-year sunset for the exemption, and the amendment was approved. [2:27]

HB1866 Lundstrum TO EXEMPT CERTAIN INFORMATION PERTAINING TO A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; AND CONCERNING PUBLIC RECOR… 2:34

Representative Robin Lundstrum introduced HB 1866, seeking to exempt certain personal information of law-enforcement officers from FOIA on public-record websites, limiting the exemption to a website-only scope, a two-year sunset, and adding a focus group and second-signature requirement, citing similar practices in several other states. [2:58] [4:12] [4:35]

Committee members raised concerns about the impact on title searches, potential costs to counties (estimated up to $15,000 for software upgrades), and the need for clear procedures, with Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson and others questioning how the exemption would affect real-property transactions and budgeting. [4:50] [7:29] [18:53] [19:36] [19:54]

A motion to limit debate to five minutes per side was offered by Representative Dwight Tosh, carried unanimously, and subsequently a motion to concur in the amendment was put to a vote, passing with all ayes and no nays. [25:04] [25:18] [32:15]

Despite the approvals, the chair announced that the bill failed to pass, recommending that the sponsor table the measure or place it in interim study for further work with stakeholders. [33:16] [33:46] [34:15]

Bills discussed (3)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1386 · 3 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “If you wanted to represent Drown, will you be able to do HB 1386? That's one for Representative Lemons. Can we do the amendm…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1440 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE IN THE ARK…”
Pre-2017 bill
HB1866 · 2 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1866 Lundstrum TO EXEMPT CERTAIN INFORMATION PERTAINING TO A LAW…”
Pre-2017 bill

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 12, 2026
If you wanted to represent Drown, will you be able to do HB 1386? That's one for Representative Lemons. Can we do the amendment? Yeah, the amendment, concurring the amendment. I think that one is the adding a co-sponsor and deleting section two. Okay, we're concurring in amendment number one.
▶ Play
Speaker 5 0:36
Thank you, Mr. Chair. As he said, concurring amendment number one, it just adds a co-sponsor and deletes section two. Okay, we have a motion. Motion do pass. All right,
▶ Play
we have a motion to concur in Amendment 1 to HB 1386. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed, say nay. All right. Passes. And Representative Womack, do you want to handle the one for Representative Gray?
▶ Play
Speaker 12 1:12
That's HB 1440. Thank you, Mr. Chair. This amendment simply clarifies that in addition to the initial and updated
▶ Play
canvasser list, sponsors will provide a final list of paid canvassers and signature cards to the Secretary of State when they turn in their petitions, and it adds an extra week for that time to be done. Okay. And I would appreciate whatever motion I need to add to this amendment. Concurring the amendment? Yes, sir. Okay. You have a motion to concur in the amendment.
▶ Play
Representative Gray, this is your amendment. All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right. It is concurred in. Thank you. All right. Representative Womack, do you want to pop out and see if Representative Lundstrom wants to come in and run her concurrence? Or we can adjourn. That's the last one. That's the last one. You're up, Representative Lundstrom, if you're ready for it.
▶ Play
Thank you, colleagues. This is a concurrence on House Bill 1866. We have added a number of things to allay some concerns and fears. I don't think we've allayed them all, but it's a place to start. We added a second signature so that not only does the officer have to have their supervisor's signature, but also their highest ranking officer's signature. So this is not an all skate. It is only for two years. And finally, it is the website only. This will not stop title work or real estate, that type of thing. It has the full backing of the Fraternal Order of Police. And also, Texas, Florida, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Missouri, Illinois, South Carolina, and Ohio all do this on a large-scale basis. We only want to do this on a small-scale basis because, frankly, we need time to implement it. And that's the other thing that we have added. Instead of having this due August 1st or January 1st, we've moved the date out to May simply because clerks and all the process involved need the time to think this through. And those were the amendments that we changed. And with that, I would ask for
▶ Play
a good vote. On this, and I wish I would have studied this more, but on this, the personal contact information, real property records, personal that are admitted for two years. Yes. How is that functioning? I mean, does that information come out while, I mean, like if they bought a home and the documents were recorded and then two years later, is that made
▶ Play
public? It goes back on. It simply sunsets. If that officer wants to continue, he needs to go back that process again. Then they have to go every two years. This is not a forever deal. It's only a limited time. Okay. And also, because there are a lot of moving parts, we added to this a focus group to bring all the stakeholders to the table, because I do think this is going to be a bumpy process, and I think they need to be a part of that process.
▶ Play
Speaker 33 4:43
So we've added those stakeholders. Okay, any questions
▶ Play
from the committee? Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. One quick question, Representative Lundstrom. If that police officer desires to, after a year of having his or her house, and he desires to sell that house again, how does that work with the title company doing an accurate title search? We're
▶ Play
not going to be removing and stopping title searches. This is for website only. Website only. No, we simply can't. Land records, you can't redact, you can't change that. What I want to do is only work on this specific area. And if that officer feels like that needs to be on that, he can call and ask for a request. We can do the documentation to make that possible as well if they need it. But officers need to realize if their stuff is not on there, it's going to slow down the process some but not make it completely difficult to do. I did talk to an attorney with the highway department that all they do is title searches. They said, this is not a problem. You're only doing the website. So that's basically it. We're just addressing that website issue. There is no way we can go back and redact or stop title searches
▶ Play
or anything like that. You are addressing the real estate records on
▶ Play
the website, though. Yes. If you're agent, if you are Bob Ballinger, a lot of states just put a post office or a courthouse address, something that tells the title company, clue in, you're going to have to go maybe a step further. With computers these days, surely we can, with a year and three months to work on this, we can find a solution to keep the wheels rolling and still protect police officers. All right. Any other
▶ Play
questions? Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I may have missed it, so I apologize. But are there any other states that are doing this currently? Do you know how
▶ Play
it's working for them? Yes. Texas, Florida require all officers. We're not doing that at all. Oregon, Pennsylvania, Missouri, Illinois, South Carolina, and Ohio, and they're still getting divorced and selling houses and going down the road in those states. What I would like to see us do instead of recreating the wheel and stressing our people out is in this time frame, get that information and apply that. Plus, there are major computer companies that do this, and I spoke to one of the gentlemen that's in charge of that, and he said other states are doing this too. It's just going to be a process. We've got, I'm not saying it's going to happen overnight.
▶ Play
It's just got to start. Any other questions from the committee? I have one I'm not, I hate to even ask because I should have asked it to you before, but
▶ Play
do you have any idea what it will cost? No, right now we don't because we are just starting
▶ Play
the process. We'll see. Okay. Representative Hammer, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I was trying to read through the amendment real quick. So after two years, it would automatically go back to a matter of public record? Yes. So is the intent to give a police officer coverage for just two years? and what's the rationale behind not making it permanent if the intent is to protect the police officer? Not every police officer needs this. This was
▶ Play
brought to us by the FBI. They are dealing with some very specific things. Things are getting difficult out there. But all the time, it's just not possible. Police officers move. Life happens. Not all police officers need this. It's only for a limited time, for a limited scope. And the two years was brought to me as a request from stakeholders at the table that they did not want a lifetime. They needed a short something with a sunset, so I put that in there. Everything that's been brought to me, except for not do it, has been added. And I will continue with that attitude. I very much think we can do this.
▶ Play
It's just going to take some time. That was a hammer. You're recognized. Thank you. If this was brought to you by the FBI, is there any reason we wouldn't limit it to just the group that requested it then instead of for everybody if this is going to be kind of a trial
▶ Play
and error period moving forward? No, because they're very concerned in general about some issues. I don't know. I'm not an FBI agent, nor am I in law enforcement. I understand that there are some DEA agents who also need a little bit of help. But again, this is a limited scope. And in the process and in the instructions, we're going to make that very clear, that this is for a limited scope for a small number of officers that need some help. Evidently, things are getting rougher out there, as we've all heard. Officers are being targeted. And this is, imagine you're an FBI agent and you're working a very difficult case. The bad guys know where your family is. They know where your spouse and children sleep at night. They need a little bit of protection on those websites. Will it be 100%? No. I wish it could be, but I am confident if we work with these. There's incredible clerks and folks out there that once we get started, they all feel the same way that I do. They all want to help police officers. They have the same concerns that I do. The process is going to be bumpy, but we have to start somewhere. Thank you, thank you, Madam
▶ Play
Chair. Any other questions from the committee? Okay, seeing none, we do have individuals who are signed to speak against. Represent lunchroom, if you don't mind making room at the end of the table. Come on down. What I would say is that if you guys are pretty much together, go ahead and take the end of the table together and then you can introduce yourself for the record. So it's Josh Curtis. Thank you, Rob. Yeah. . Bentley House, Sharon Baker. Where do you want us? And Robbie, I don't know your last name, but your routing is as bad as mine. So if you
▶ Play
Speaker 42 11:01
all don't mind introducing yourself for the record, I'd appreciate it. Josh Curtis, Association of Arkansas Counties.
▶ Play
Speaker 62 11:09
Debbie Wise, Circuit Clerk from Randolph County, Legislative Chair for the Association of Arkansas
▶ Play
Counties. Sharon Blount-Baker, Crawford County. And I'm the Legislative Chair for the Circuit Clerks Association. Bentley
▶ Play
Speaker 67 11:20
Hovist, Chief Deputy of Plaski County Treasurer, Collector's Office. Okay. All
▶ Play
right. You all are recognized. Thank
▶ Play
Speaker 63 11:29
you, Mr. Chair and committee. This is tough because Robin and I are close friends, and we've been working on this for a couple weeks now. I wrote some stuff down last night, so I'm just going to read from this, and we'll ask questions. I've got the technical experts here with me. This bill is well-intended, and the sponsor's heart is in the right place. Law enforcement does so much for our communities, and we should take every reasonable step to protect these individuals. Representative Lundstrom has been great to work with in this process, but I think we need more time to get a good bill that will actually do what she is wanting it to do. This amendment is completely different from what the committee passed out a couple weeks ago. Representative Lundstrom testified in the committee that she wanted to protect FBI agents, DEA agents, and undercover officers. And we agree with that premise, but however, this amendment does not take care of that. Mr. Chairman, you asked Representative Lundstrom to amend the regional bill to make it a little bit more narrow in scope. We believe this amendment makes this a lot more broader in scope. This amendment expands the sponsor's intent of the original bill to include all law enforcement officers, not just undercover FBI agents. The bill that passed out of committee only exempted real property. this amendment expands that to real property, personal property, and tax records. So from the first bill, we had just the circuit clerks opposing it. Now we have the assessors and the tax collectors as well opposing the bill. Of course, everyone uses the internet these days, whether that's good or bad. This amendment would completely disrupt the operations for title companies doing title searches. Because in today's world, title companies use the internet for everything. It was said on the Senate floor yesterday that these title companies would have to go back into the courthouse to do these searches, and they could do that with this bill. However, I've seen all session bills trying to streamline government and use technology in the best way possible. Why would we take that option away from the private sector? This would increase the price of doing business and would be passed on to the taxpayers. What we would like to see with this bill is in the last part of the bill, But it does set up a review committee. This committee would be smart to set up, and Representative Lundstrom said she'd work with us on that. But our position is, if we're going to set this committee up, let's set this committee up and get all the stakeholders involved before we pass a law that really doesn't address the problems and the concerns that Representative Lundstrom's brought to us, and they're valid concerns and valid problems. We don't want to tear down the house and figure out how to rebuild it. But I'm asking for a no vote on this bill and let all of our stakeholders get together and work with Representative Lundstrom because she said that other states do this. And I'm sure other states worked hard with all the stakeholders involved to make a good piece of legislation instead of just a piece of legislation. Let's work out the details after this passes. So that's kind of my thoughts. I'll be happy to answer any questions. But I'd also like to recognize the circuit clerk from Randolph County, Debbie Wise, to speak against the bill as well, if
▶ Play
that's okay, Mr. Chairman. Yeah, and Representative Douglas has a question for you, so probably you
▶ Play
Speaker 73 14:52
can go ahead. You're recognized, Representative Douglas. Help me understand, if this is not implemented for a year and a month or so, do you have enough wiggle room within that year and a half to make the implementations that you feel like are necessary because you're going to have this working group? You don't have to do it for a year. Is the bill broad enough for you to write the rules that would satisfy what your concerns are right now? You've got a year to do that. Nothing has to be implemented until May of next year, maybe, yes. I'm wondering if that is your task group time to get this right, and then that way we don't have to come back in a special session. I don't know, and my circuit clerk, Sharon Blount, is down there too, and if she could weigh in on that as well. So whoever has the answer. Well,
▶ Play
Speaker 63 15:55
I'll start off, but thank you for the question. Representative Douglas. Yes, that sounds great, but I don't think this body can change laws in the interim. I mean, I get that I've heard that this could go on a special session if we need to clean it up, but you all know as well as I do how hard it is to get things on the call at a special session. We would like to set up the working group and then pass a good law that addresses all the problems. Because in this right here, one thing, one question this got brought up today was these forms that we're wanting law enforcement officers to fill out, they're going to have to stay in the Surrey Clerk's Office. So somebody, a bad guy, could come in there and FOI these forms and have one stack of paper that has all these police officers' records. So basically the Surrey Clerk's Office comes into a one-stop shop for all police officer records that address the forms. So I would argue that that makes it easier for the bad guys to have this information and to put this information out on a website rather than this bill. Follow up, if I could. You're recognized. But none of this has to be implemented for a year. Is that correct? I think it's May
▶ Play
Speaker 73 17:09
of 2018. May of 2018, yes, ma'am. 18. We'll have a couple of special sessions, and we may have a fiscal session. And if it deals with law enforcement and people losing their lives, you can get a majority of us to put that on a call. I'm trying to look for a way to protect the police officers and move this forward without making you uncomfortable to see if we can still salvage this without pushing you into doing something that's not going to be good. So, you know, I'm just all about compromise at this point, trying to get us there, but you guys answer that. Sorry, I'm rambling too much sleep. One of
▶ Play
Speaker 63 17:55
the things that Representative Lundstrom has been excellent to work with and she has adopted a few of our ideas. We would like to push the date back to 2019. So there is an opportunity there for the 2019 session when we have problems with this bill. Thank you. Yes, ma'am. Representative Hammer,
▶ Play
you recognize? I think you just spoke to it, but so just real briefly. If this law went in effect, and there are bad guys that are wanting to get information on the police, are they still going to be able to get it with or without this law? That's correct. Specifically, how would they be able to do that? Quickly, please. They would just
▶ Play
Speaker 63 18:37
FOI all these forms on the exemption and they'll have all those records and one stack of paper from the clerk's office. Or they can show up at the courthouse,
▶ Play
and now we have them in our courthouse. And that's a little personal to me, being the county that was, you know, shot, had shooting not too long ago. So now they're coming to the courthouse and actually searching the records there. And, you know, that's a concern of mine. And back to Representative Douglas' question, you know, going back to the website, we haven't had a chance to talk to some of the software providers to determine the cost of having this change. And then we have to go through the budget proceedings to get that money from the quorum court to implement it. Even if it's, you know, $15,000 to make this change, I mean, some counties don't have that additional $15,000 to make an upgrade to their software. So that's something that we would have to look at also. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. To anyone down at the end of the table, I heard someone say something about $15,000. Are you saying that there is an additional cost if this bill passes in the current form that it's in now? I think there could be. I haven't been able to call my software provider to see if there's a cost to that, but I would assume that that's an upgrade, and I would think that there would be some cost. And I would think that it could be
▶ Play
Speaker 68 20:06
up to that. I'm not saying it's actually
▶ Play
$15,000 at this point. But there would be some cost. Just a quick follow-up, Mr. Chair. Would that be the only cost? That I can think of right here, Representative, I would think that that would be an upgrade cost or to turn something on in your software. Some software doesn't have a redaction or, so to speak, a hidden feature to hide this document online like that. So we would have to research that. So I really can't just
▶ Play
Speaker 62 20:36
answer you straightforward. May I follow up on that question? Yes, you may. Another cost could be to the law enforcement officer. Once these records are sealed or omitted or redacted, in order, the law does not provide a way for those to be open for the law enforcement officer. The only way that I know that they would be able to do that would be to hire an attorney, go to court, and get a court order to have those records opened. Another problem could be once we redact these orders, say a deed, for example, Say a law enforcement officer with his father or grandfather or family goes and buys properties, say to Hunnam, just for an example. If you redact that document, that means that the other person that's involved in that deed, their deed's redacted also. And that could cause a problem for them, which could also be a cost. There's no one that wants to support law enforcement more than circuit clerks do. We work with them every day. I have law enforcement in my family. We've had an officer's shot in Randolph County. We are actually sitting here to help them because we are concerned what this may do to them with their land records. And there's other records in the courthouse besides the land records where someone could come in and get a law enforcement officer's address. There's also the court records. But all of this could cause a problem for them, for the title companies. The title companies have said that they will not write title insurance. And I find that to be a huge concern for law enforcement once they get ready to sell their homes, for example.
▶ Play
I guess one question. I just want to make sure, I mean, I totally understand everybody's problems. In fact, I visited with Representative Lundstrom about this prior to and when she first brought the bill to me and explained it to. In fact, I even reached out to some interested groups to get with Robin to try to fix these problems from the very beginning. What I don't want to do is overstate it. you know, as a person who ran a title company for a long time, people will still write title insurance. They will do it because that's how they make their money and that's, they're not going to go out of business. They're going to do everything they can to do it. I definitely see that if you are a title company that is not located in the county, but yet you have access to a title plan, usually those are online accesses that you would, it would be a struggle for you to be able to write that title insurance. But my guess is the system will find a way to make it work, it just, the question is how cumbersome is that and how expensive is that? But I think to make, if a title company told you that they wouldn't write title insurance anymore, I don't know if you mean an underwriter or an agent, but either way, they're full of it. They're going to write title insurance. It just, how expensive is it for them to do
▶ Play
that? Exactly. That's my understanding. Representative Tosh, you're recognized for a question. Just help me understand one thing. I walked in a little late and I apologize for that. We were over in a rules meeting, but if this is exempt, and maybe y'all just covered this before I got in here, but if this is passed and this information is exempt from FOI, then how can it be FOI? I'm having a little problem understanding that.
▶ Play
Speaker 67 23:44
Sir, it's not exempt from FOI. It's exempted from the tax records that are made available online by the county, but you can still FOI the information. Well,
▶ Play
it says here in the title, an act to exempt certain information pertaining to a law enforcement officer from the Freedom of Information Act of 1967 concerning public record websites and for other purposes. I
▶ Play
Speaker 67 24:07
agree, but I think that when they amended the bill, the actual body of the bill does not say that. And our interpretation is that you can still FOI. Is that? Yeah.
▶ Play
That actually is, and this will be something that when Representative Lundstrom will have her address, is that that actually would be a little bit of a concern, is that it is that the bill, I think that points out a problem, is that the bill is different than the title because it doesn't actually exempt anything from FOI. But I guess that's something we need to talk about.
▶ Play
Speaker 12 24:46
Representative Gonzalez, you have a motion. Do you have a follow-up, Representative Tosh? No, I was going to make a
▶ Play
motion for a limited debate or anything specific. Okay. I think it was going to be Representative Gonzalez's, so I'll take your motion,
▶ Play
Representative Tosh. Let me just make a motion for limited debate. Okay, to what?
▶ Play
Five minutes. Okay, we have a motion to limit debate to five minutes per side, I would guess, which what that will do is give five minutes for Representative Lundstrom to close. Is that your motion? Yes, sir, it is. Okay, so motion to limit debate to five minutes per side. Any discussion on the motion? All in favor, say aye. Aye. Opposed? All right, so the motion carries. Another thing I would
▶ Play
Speaker 63 25:32
like to point out, Mr. Chairman and committee, is I don't know how much the land commissioner's office has been involved in the process of this bill. But I would say that there may, I worked in the land commissioner's office, Because I would say that there may be some problems in this bill that hinders the Land Commissioner's Office selling property the way they sell tax delinquent property. The two years, somebody asked why the two-year sunset was on there. That was a recommendation we did make to Representative Lundstrom, because property goes delinquent after two years, then it's certified to the Land Commissioner's Office. So this may enable or it may prohibit the land commissioner's office from filling all their statutory requirements in a public land sale as well. Sure.
▶ Play
All right. Any other comments? Yeah. Ms. Baker. Thank you. I
▶ Play
just want to state that we agree with the intent of this bill, and I'm a wife of a former law enforcement officer officer and the current wife of a judge who has been threatened recently. So I understand the intent of this bill. But from the recorder standpoint, I want to encourage you that these are live documents and that they can ask to have a mortgage covered, sealed, whatever we want to call it. But that doesn't change what's going to happen in the next five minutes. A lien can be filed, a fraudulent deed can be filed. He would have to constantly fill these forms out to have all that stuff covered. And I also just kind of want to mention that it's a little bit concerning that it's not just limited to their family because Debbie and I can own property together, and she's the law enforcement officer. So if you look up her name, the deed is hidden. But if you look at my name, you're still going to get Debbie's information because I'm not hidden. So that's just something to think about. There's a lot of repercussions to this bill. I think it has wonderful intent. And as a wife of a law enforcement officer, I agree with it. But there's a lot of repercussions to
▶ Play
Speaker 101 27:32
land records. They're that important. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? All right. Seeing
▶ Play
none, I appreciate your testimony today. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. In the, I don't think, yeah, okay. I'm sorry, I think we had somebody else sign up. So we don't have anyone else signed up to speak against the bill or speak for the bill. So Representative Lundstrom, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Close for your bill. Thank you. First of all, I realize there are concerns, and I've heard those concerns. And I think they are valid concerns. That's the reason we wanted to wait a year. That's the reason we had a focus group, so we could answer those concerns. I do not wish to cause things to stop, and I don't think it will. It hasn't stopped in a lot of other states that do it on a much larger scale. We need to streamline. They're exactly correct. And thankfully, in this day and age, we can do that. We have computer companies that are doing this for other states. We simply need to copy those models and adapt them to Arkansas. I think law enforcement, like we've all agreed, is worth the effort. And I think you've seen that there are enough passionate people that care about law enforcement that if we move forward together, we can get this done. Um, we have to start somewhere. We will not be able to redact. We don't want to. We simply want to block the bad guys from going on the website and finding that officer's home address. I want to remind you of the states that have already done this. Texas, Florida, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Missouri, Illinois, and South Carolina and Ohio. All of these states use computer software that allow them to do this. We can do this too. We're just taking a little more time and we're putting all the stakeholders at the table. I spoke to a title company yesterday, or excuse me, a title attorney that handles all the title searches for highway departments. Everywhere they go, right-of-ways are checked. And I said, is this going to cause a problem? She said, no, you're doing the website only. This can get done. We can do it. And with that, I would ask for your help and moving this forward. The one thing that
▶ Play
was brought up, and I don't know how much of a concern it is for you, is that the title does specifically say that it does exempt the information from the Freedom of Information Act. No, well, the title says from Freedom of Information Act, right? Is that
▶ Play
what it says? Yes, and when we promulgate the rules for this one sheet of paper that we're going to do, we can put the information in an appropriate place and
▶ Play
Speaker 29 30:23
handle that, too. Well, but the title, so the
▶ Play
title of it itself, I mean, you run into the constitutional requirement that the title be, but, you know, in the end, it'll revise the code. So somebody had to sue on it to be able to rule it unconstitutional. But I would say that there is a concern that the title didn't match up. Whoever your bill drafter is did you disservice in not amending that part of the code or the We have amended
▶ Play
this because I've taken suggestions from every single stakeholder to put in this, and I want to continue that. I think it's important that we move together as a team, and that's why we amended it so much, to add the focus group, to add the extended time, to add the second signature, because these are things that were asked for,
▶ Play
and I want to keep that going. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? What is the will of the committee? We have a motion to concur in the amendment. Any discussion on the motion? One thing I'd like to say is I appreciate Representative Lindstrom's tenacity. I think that a lot of us have concerns about the bill. I don't think any of us have any concerns about the purpose of the bill. So I don't think anybody in here has any heartache of it. One thing that I have said, though, to people is, you know, there was an opportunity to do the work that it takes to amend this. And typically what we're dealing with here is just the concurrence in the amendment. So I don't, I mean, from my standpoint, I still have some reservations about how the bill will work and what will need to be done. But at the same time, I also know that all we're doing is concurring an amendment. So just to put things in perspective for the committee. Any other discussion on the motion? Okay, motion on the table is to concur in the amendment. All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed say nay. No. Ayes have it.
▶ Play
Speaker 112 32:39
All right, we have two hands for roll call. Representative Wardlaw? No. Representative Hammer? No. Representative Eubanks? Representative Eubanks? Representative House, Representative House, Representative Douglas, Representative Douglas, Representative Dotson, Representative Miller, Representative Miller, Representative Womack, Representative Womack, Representative Davis, Representative Davis, Representative Saban, Representative Hendren, Representative Hendren, Representative Drown, Representative Gray, Representative Taj, Representative Representative Gonzales? Yes. Representative Ferguson? No. Representative Sterch? Yes. Representative Smith? Representative Smith? Representative Leidyman? Representative Leidyman? Yes. Representative Leidyman? Yes. Representative Leidyman? Yes. I'm sorry, your bill failed. Thank you for your time. What I would
▶ Play
say, Representative Lindstrom, since you're still at the end of the table, is I think that you have very broad support for a great idea that you brought. And to some extent, I'll tell, say, my committee, I've told them all the time that a good idea is necessarily a good bill. I think you're on your way to a very good bill. I think you now have the attention of every stakeholder and they know that this is a problem. And what I would support you in doing is if you can get all of them together and can put together your great idea, make it into a really great bill, that we'll have a couple of special sessions, and we can lobby to see if we can get it included in one of those. Thank you. Do
▶ Play
I need to table it or put it in interim study at this point, or just bring it back?
▶ Play
You can put them in interim study, but you have to do that on the floor. I'll do that on the floor. I'll start to work today. I think that's probably a good idea. Thank you, Rep. Thank you. All right, committee. We are actually done with business. I appreciate you guys. I think you've been a good, hardworking committee, and I'm very proud of you. We are adjourned.
▶ Play

Agenda

HB1386 Lemons TO REQUIRE THE FILING OF FINAL AGENCY RULES WITH THE ARKANSAS STATE LIBRARY; AND TO AMEND PROVISIONS OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE ACT.

0:13 - 1:19 4 segments 4 speakers

The committee considered a motion to concur in Amendment 1 to HB 1386, which added a co-sponsor and deleted section 2, and the motion was adopted unanimously. [0:36] [0:49]

Representative Richard Womack then presented an amendment to HB 1440 that clarifies canvasser reporting requirements and adds an additional week for submitting lists, and a motion to concur in that amendment was also moved and passed. [1:12] [1:18]

HB1440 M. Gray TO AMEND PROVISIONS IN THE ARKANSAS CODE IN THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING ELECTION RUNOFFS, INTIATIVES, AND REFERENDA

1:19 - 2:34 2 segments 2 speakers

A motion to concur in Representative Gray’s amendment to HB 1440 was made and carried without opposition. [1:44]

Representative Robin Lundstrum offered a concurrence on HB 1866, proposing the addition of a second supervisory signature and a two-year sunset for the exemption, and the amendment was approved. [2:27]

HB1866 Lundstrum TO EXEMPT CERTAIN INFORMATION PERTAINING TO A LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER FROM THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT OF 1967; AND CONCERNING PUBLIC RECORD WEBSITES.

2:34 - 34:38 116 segments 18 speakers

Representative Robin Lundstrum introduced HB 1866, seeking to exempt certain personal information of law-enforcement officers from FOIA on public-record websites, limiting the exemption to a website-only scope, a two-year sunset, and adding a focus group and second-signature requirement, citing similar practices in several other states. [2:58] [4:12] [4:35]

Committee members raised concerns about the impact on title searches, potential costs to counties (estimated up to $15,000 for software upgrades), and the need for clear procedures, with Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson and others questioning how the exemption would affect real-property transactions and budgeting. [4:50] [7:29] [18:53] [19:36] [19:54]

A motion to limit debate to five minutes per side was offered by Representative Dwight Tosh, carried unanimously, and subsequently a motion to concur in the amendment was put to a vote, passing with all ayes and no nays. [25:04] [25:18] [32:15]

Despite the approvals, the chair announced that the bill failed to pass, recommending that the sponsor table the measure or place it in interim study for further work with stakeholders. [33:16] [33:46] [34:15]

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Bob Ballinger Chair Unverified
32 segments
Speaker 5
1 segment
Speaker 12
2 segments
Representative Richard Womack Unverified
1 segment
Representative Robin Lundstrum Unverified
26 segments
Speaker 33
1 segment
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Chair Unverified
15 segments
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
1 segment
Representative Kim Hammer Unverified
5 segments
Speaker 42
2 segments
Speaker 62
4 segments
Speaker 67
4 segments
Speaker 63
14 segments
Speaker 73
6 segments
Speaker 68
1 segment
Representative Dwight Tosh Unverified
3 segments
Speaker 101
1 segment
Speaker 29
1 segment
Speaker 112
3 segments