Okay, let's call a meeting to order. This is the Committee on Counties and Municipalities, and let's leave a joint auditing committee. First item is to approve the minutes from the last meeting. So do I hear a motion for the approve the minutes from the last time, motion and second? in favor say aye. Any opposed? Motion carried. Okay. Next item is reports. Okay. Ms. Steele,
move into reports. The first report we're going to review today is the first one on your list. It's the city of Centerton. First, there's an investigative letter regarding the police department. And we also have the regular audit as well. Kim Williams is going to present that for us, the investigative letter.
the record, please. And you're recognized. Yes. Kim Williams, legislative audit. As Marty said, We were contacted by the 19th Judicial District Prosecuting Attorney about allegations involving the police department at the city of Centerton. So in conjunction with the Arkansas State Police, we went in and looked at some items that the allegations that had been brought to his attention. The city had also hired a consultant, and we reviewed that report as well and did some follow-up work on that to verify and confirm some of the findings of the consultant. And what was found were salary overpayments with grant funds as well as credit card transactions made by and reimbursements to both the police chief and the captain. Both of these individuals were placed on administrative leave last May with pay, and just recently they were reinstated to their jobs. What happened was we provided the information to the state police and to the prosecuting attorney who recused himself, and a circuit judge appointed a special prosecuting attorney who reviewed all the information and concluded that there was nothing in the findings that anybody had that warranted criminal charges. That's the overview of what happened. Now, there were 12 things that we've referred to the prosecutor. I'm just going to summarize them briefly. The city got a step grant, and this was to do stepped-up police procedures, but the step grant said that the police chief, people that were on salary, could not be a part of this program because it involved overtime. However, both the police chief and the captain received $14,000 of overtime on this program, and once the state police who administered the step program were made aware of this, they stopped giving the city the money. In this particular finding, the special prosecutor went ahead and referred to federal authorities. There were two problems we had with the credit card transactions. While both the police chief and the captain had use of city-authorized credit cards, they did purchase things that were personal, and they reimbursed them. They also used this credit card to purchase some food items without overnight stay, some clothing that was not suitable for law enforcement activities. And the other thing that they did, even though they had city credit cards, they used their own credit cards to purchase routine operating expenses, supplies, ammunition, postage, radios, radar guns, and other equipment. And what we didn't understand is why they would use their own credit cards when they had city credit cards. and in both transactions of city credit cards and personal credit cards a lot of this a lot of these items were shipped to their residents and the problem we had with that was the city had absolutely no procedure or process in place to ensure that anything that was ordered and paid for with city funds actually made it to the city there was no receiving reports or any kind of tracking. Another issue we had is that the city purchased ammunition and tactical gear costing over $9,000 from a vendor that didn't charge sales tax. He wasn't registered. The vendor wasn't registered. It was an individual wasn't registered secretary of state. The vendor didn't appear to have a location other than a residence on a farm acreage situation. And the invoices that were submitted by this vendor for the city to pay were exactly in the same format as those submitted by the captain for his expense reimburses. The other thing that we found odd about this, none of this was shipped to the city. The items on the invoice were marked picked up. Although small, the city did purchase a gun safe that cost around $700 and it was delivered to the department and then it was moved to the chief's residence. When this was finally made aware to the city management, the police chief returned the safe and in it were 12 of his own weapons and two of his scopes. In addition, I tried to shorten this for everybody. The city had a donation fund and people contributed to this and it was over $22,000. And management said that all the donations received were strictly to be used for department expenses. However, the police chief used some of this for holiday parties for the employees and guests around $2,000. And this violates the public purpose doctrine, we believe. We also did an equipment observation when we went on site last November, and we noted that a night scope and a battery pack costing around $700. While we're there, they were installed on a personal weapon of the police chief. The city had a policy to allow the the police department to purchase up to seven or six hundred dollars every year for uniform allowance they could purchase whatever they wanted at a particular vendor however both the police chief and the captain overspent their uniform allowance on an annual basis the city also when the police chief and the captain were placed on leave they conducted an inventory report they They listed all the weapons, all the ammunition, all the tactical gear that was on hand. They compiled the list. And what they came up with was that the department had over 40,000 rounds of ammunition. In addition, there were 7,000 more rounds of ammunition that were stored in the police chief office, and they noted that several rounds were not for weapons that the city even owned. And last, the city did not make adequate records to ensure that all the purchases of of the weapons and ammunition and gear were necessary for the operations of the city or ensure that these purchases were not commingled with the rest of the items that personally were stored at the city. That concludes my brief report on Centerton Police Department. Okay.
of Centerton. Okay, Mr. Chair, I guess, uh, first of all, I asked if the, if the mayor has a prepared statement or something that he would like to say about this,
I don't, I didn't have a prepared statement. We did respond to all of the, of the findings to legislative audit. I'm not sure if they were received to you. I will say, um, you know, after, after the findings, after the state police investigation, we did hold a special council meeting, uh, with, with myself, the city council with these two employees, and we went over these in great detail, which we have minutes of that meeting we can provide to you if needed. One thing we did learn out of the whole process, and like Ms. Williams said, you know, we're the fastest growing city in the state, and, you know, employee-wise and just infrastructure and everything, we're growing fast. So one thing that we are lacking is in our policies. You know, our policies are outdated. One thing the city did do very recent is we've just hired a human resources director to help us go through these policies and procedures to keep a lot of this from happening again. And we do have corrective action in place to make sure this don't happen again.
Okay. Thank you, Mayor, for your statement. I guess I would like to say, what have you put in place besides the human resource director? What have you put in place to ensure that the items purchased, you know, are properly checked in and in inventory? Well,
one thing that came up was the vendor that was not a, with the Secretary of State, we're now requesting W-9 forms from all new vendors because, you know, honestly, we get a lot of invoices come through, but from now on, that's what we're going to do. As far as we are taking inventory of everything that comes in now, keeping records very accurate. And I want to say something about the uniform policy. You know, they did say $600 per person. But when we get new officers, that cost will go up because we buy everything for them. We buy, you know, the belts, the guns, I mean, everything, uniform pants initially. And then the $600 is a yearly allotment so they can, you know, replace what's needed. And also, you know, we also are in the process of starting a SWAT team. So we did budget extra money for that in this year. And then also, I just wanted to say one more thing on the ammunition. You know, I know it says 40,000 rounds of ammunition. We're a police department. You know, we're a police department with 23 officers, and they qualify several times a year. Plus, also, they have the SWAT team, so they have to, you know, do specialized training too. So that's why we do have a large number of, large amount of ammunition.
Okay. All right. I guess I would just like to say, Mayor, that I was really looking for something in regards to you, I guess, because I'm assuming that the chief is, the police chief is under you. How are you going to be inventorying what they purchased and monitoring that? And so I guess I'm not saying that you didn't because I haven't read your responses. But if you have that in check, then I'll be good. But that's kind of what I was looking for, Chairman, is that a process in which, you know, they can kind of control if they purchase something, then they check it in, the inventory in it, and just keeping it all in inventory.
And so that's what I was looking for. Yes, yes. We will, you know, like I said, the lieutenant, when he was in charge, he implemented that, and we will maintain that.
Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you. So, you've got a new HR person, what did you say about the HR? You've got a new one or you've made some changes in HR, but a lot of this is financial. And what? Yeah,
but like I said, a lot of it was policy, you know, as far as like was mentioned, was credit cards. We have no credit card policy in place. The special prosecutor did review this and found, you know, no criminal activity there. But we, you know, we have what is called purchase cards, and we really want our folks to use those. So we are going to, you know, implement policies and make them use those and any other charges need to come through us.
right? Oh, yeah, that's correct. Yes, police chief and the captain. Okay. And why was that? It was a decision. Like I said, we had a meeting with the city council and the employees, went over all the findings, and at the end, the council and myself
Yes, Mr. Chairman. Mayor, I'm a little confused. Did you put these two individuals on leave? Was that your call? Yes. Well, actually we, we, we terminated
him initially and after reviewing it with, uh, our city attorney, we might've jumped the gun. So we put them on administrative leave while this investigation, uh, took place. Okay. And also the audit.
Now, all the, all the equipment that was sent to their house, I'm assuming the police chief's house was, they had the credit card that they, they bought personally. Were they, were they reimbursed by the city for this? Was this city stuff, or was this personal stuff they were buying?
This is city stuff, and the reason why some of it, because this has come out at our council meeting, the reason why some of this stuff was shipped at our house was because it went through eBay or something?
They were purchased through eBay, and what they did is they purchased on their accounts on eBay since we as a city didn't have an eBay account because you can get better deals that way, like pieces, parts, for whatever they might need, like a radio. So since they purchased it that way, they had them shipped to their house. But since then, we have told them all shipments have to come to the city. And they bought this on their personal credit card? There were some purchases that were made on the personal card, but they're also that they reimbursed. Now, did the city reimburse them? On the personal, yes, but we
did require proof of purchase on it. And y'all have everything under inventory, and you're sure the city of Centerton has it? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Representative Monty Hodges.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, for allowing me to ask a question. Going back to the ammunition, all the ammunition that was bought during that time. And she mentioned that some of it was not, it was for some weapons that were not, the city didn't have the weapons. So can you elaborate on that a little bit? Sure, I can. Yes.
What happened is one of our council members works for Academy, and during times they have unopened boxes and things that they donate to municipalities. And in the past, they've donated to larger municipalities around us. But he did ask one time, hey, can we donate this to Centerton? and all that was donated ammunition that was not for stuff that we did not have. It was not purchased. Yeah, we didn't purchase it. Ammunition, okay. But the ammunition was there for different calibers that we did not have because it just comes in a big box is what the council
member explained to me. Okay. Anybody else? Go ahead. Ma'am, what is your position with the city? financial director. You're the financial director. So you are the person that I really want to talk to. Okay. So, all right. So what are your control policies that are in place? Because I'm hearing the mayor tell me one thing, but it's a lack of controls that we're talking about here.
So it's since when, so this has been happening over, you know, a span of, I think it was like two years. I've been here since 2015, mid-15. Since then, we have added on additional employees within my department in the financial department. Part of what that is well, too, is I was overseeing the HR aspect of it, which is why we brought up we hired somebody in HR to take over policy. I'm able to take some of that workload off my plate and be able to purely look at the financial side of it and then also with the additional of the we have two more employees now under me we have um double checks to where one person will actually submit the invoice when the invoices get submitted they go through they review them and they put them in the system be processed i review them at that point and if everything looks good and we have everything in place you know um signed off on them making sure they're delivered to the city you know it's within budget then they will go ahead and they'll process the invoices and at that point if they process them I sign off on it and so does Bill but if I were to process it then they would sign off it and Bill would
So like with the with the guns um like the um the guns that are purchased over at the PD they now have the lieutenant where he um he started up a checklist to say this is what ammunition we have and then we go you know he does a check once a year to make sure what is there is there truly and then what we'll look at doing is possibly getting a second sign off on it possibly having either the police chief or the mayor sign off on it and then ask for like other departments if it's a larger purchases then we'll just do that periodic check to say is the stuff there
think we have the person that actually did the audit here would you come to the table please Would you identify for the record please and if you have anything to say about this we'd
Do you have anything you'd like to add to what you've heard? As reference to the ammunition that we talked about earlier, we weren't privy to that information prior to today as far as I'm concerned about the donations and stuff like that.
to ask this both of our staff auditors and the mayor to maybe get this clarified. Representative Gene used to be mayor. I said 40,000 rounds of him, he used to seem a little bit high, and he assured me that it was a little bit high. And, Mayor, I understand you're a growing city, but I don't think you're all as big as Magnolia yet. They really are. Oh, they are, actually. Okay, well, but I still just looked a little bit high to me, and that did not include, and Kim is ready to answer that. Yes, ma'am.
Well, something I wanted to point out, because this was in the report we did. Like I said, it was rather lengthy. We noticed that in a, during a year and a, let's see, over a year and a half period, they purchased ammunition. It was around $16,000. So all that ammunition was on hand, was bought. The 40,000 rounds were bought before these two gentlemen were placed on leave. After they were placed on leave, we didn't find that any additional ammunition has been purchased. So they went an entire year without
longer working. The last time ammunition was purchased, it's not what's happened since we left there, but they had purchased $16,000 worth of ammunition, which would have included the $40,000 that was on rounds. And they replaced on leave last May. And after they replaced on leave, we didn't find that any additional ammunition had been purchased. So I guess they lived off
what they had. Maybe they got a good price on the first $40,000 rounds. And if I could continue, Mr. Chairman, Mayor, these individual items are not deal breakers for me. I can understand how in a growing city you could have these kinds of problems. But as an aggregate, they're pretty upsetting and they're pretty worrisome, because if I were just a citizen of your community looking at this, I'd say you've got some employees and maybe the chief and then the captain that are just kind of going rogue and kind of doing what they want to. Sometimes they use the city's credit card to buy something for themselves, and sometimes they use their own credit card to buy something for the city. And you can see how problematic that can end up being, you know, in the long run. And you put all these things together. I'm just curious, you know, even in a growing city, you've got to have some kind of process and that the people, I mean, To me, this is not a breakdown of process. This is a breakdown of, you know, some staff. And, again, I don't know the gentleman. I'm just going by the information we have here. But to reinstate, you know, these two individuals after this is a little bit concerning to me. Was there some understanding with them about kind of to straighten up and fly a ride? Or did they maintain that they were doing everything to the best of their ability?
Oh, no, no. They've taken responsibility for what happened. And, you know, together with the police department and us, we'll work together to correct this. Part of the problem was it started this whole thing is, you know, some of our individual officers had some concerns with their staff, and they did not come to the city with these concerns. They went to the sheriff's office. They bypassed the city altogether. And actually, that's what caused us to hire David Williams after we were notified by the sheriff of these. We self-reported this. We hired David. We knew legislative audit was coming the following month. And in the meantime, the news media got involved with this, and that's what blew this whole thing out of proportion. But, you know, I agree with you, and together, like I said, you know, when we had our long meeting with these officers, you know, we had like three-quarters of the police department there, and, you know, and the council, and they, you know, they all just said we'll all work together and correct this. So hopefully we've learned from this, and we, like I said, with the HR person, we are going to get some, you know, stronger policies. We have been correcting things all along, and we want this to move forward. Okay. Mayor, how
during your tenure? Yes, he was. We had a long time chief, and then we had another chief we hired, and then Lafayette said we couldn't keep him because of a drop program, and I don't want to get into all that. We understand how that works. Yeah, I didn't understand it, but I didn't even know about it. But then, yeah, the other chief came from within the ranks, and that was part of the problem, too, because one thing he did identify is, like, with the personal credit cards. This was a practice that apparently was going on long before I became mayor. I'm not making excuses. I'm just saying it happened. And, you know, again, we're growing, and we want
to correct this. Well, Mayor, I can't speak to the whole committee. I'm confident you're on the right track to getting everything straightened out. But I think if we see this pop up again, we're going to have a little more serious worry about it than we would if it's just you've got it under control and everybody's trying to do it. But I appreciate your efforts on this. I appreciate you coming down here and answering our questions. And thank you both. And thank you,
Mr. Chairman. Thank you. You said a while ago that, well, somebody said a while ago. I don't know if it's you or not, but this didn't come up about the ammunition that didn't fit the calibers of firearms that you actually had, that those were donated. Why didn't you mention that early on? Why did you wait until today to bring that up? We were never asked a question.
And, again, when we've got the findings and the council seen these, that's when the council member came forward and said, hey, Bill, part of this is, you know, what
we donated. Okay. Well, I share the concerns of Senator Johnson, and one of the things that concerns me is that I don't like to hear you say it was blown out of proportion, because I don't think there's anything here that's blown out of proportion. I think these are serious matters. Oh, I agree. And the thing that concerns me is I detect a lack of commitment, and I hope that I'm hearing that wrong, but I don't know
if I am or not. Okay. Mr. Mayor, has any of the citizens of the fastest growing city in Arkansas had concerns about the decisions or lack thereof of the city council and the mayor on rehiring these two people?
i don't know i'm not sure what we're going to do with it um if you guys have suggestions that what we can do with it we'll be happy to take those or else we can look into we'll have our city attorney look into it as well too to see what can we legally do with
this ammunition since it's not for any calipers for the guns that we currently have follow-up please follow-up uh when the employees use their credit cards do they get air miles or cash back
or anything on their credit cards we asked them if there were any if they did receive any perks um you know cash back or stuff like that and they said they did not receive any um to help stop that going forward we're you know not allowing the you know we're not allowing the purchase on you know personal cards for city business and then if they do you know if it's accidentally pulled out the wrong card because they look the same, we're requesting it to be written in writing to the mayor first and letting them know what happened at the time when it happens. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
you. Go ahead. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Mr. Mayor, on page four, the last paragraph, it states that the special prosecuting attorney also stated the matter disclosed at number one, which I think, if I'm reading this right, is the STEP grant, is what they're talking about, was referred to the federal authorities. Do you have any update on that status of
that? No, I did contact the Highway Safety Office. I talked to Haley over there. Uh, you know, I asked her, how do we move forward with this? And she said they have contacted federal folks, but we have not heard nothing back. She says she'll stay in touch with me, but we haven't heard
a word. All right. Follow up, Mr. Chair. Go ahead. And so with what you have said that you've done, which I think was hired, uh, human resource officer, you're confident that you're not going to come down here again with the same
I do not know that answer. I'd like to know that answer. Okay. We actually asked that question of the police chief, he, he advised us he bought it at Sam's if it's delivered to the, he, they took it to the police department and never went to his house is what he taught us because the city
ahead. From what we understand, whenever the gun safe was bought, it was delivered to his personal residence. And then from what I understood, he then moved into a rental home and the rental place did not have a place to put the gun safe at that time. So then he brought it back to City Hall from what we were told by a couple of different people. and from what we from what we were told it did have his personal weapons and we were told that that was his personal ammunition some
of that also okay thank you representative Hodges okay thank you mr. chair I won't ask any more questions First of all, what was it? What's the population in, in, uh, central centralton? Senator, uh,
Okay. I thought it kind of odd to have a squad team for a community that size. I mean, you know, uh, is that, I mean, what's the need? How often do you utilize the squad team in your community?
Well, we are home of the Bentonville West High School, which is the fifth largest high school in the state. And we work with the Bentonville Police Department and also the Benton County Sheriff's Office. And in the event that we have a school incident, which seems to happen all over the United States now, you know, we want to be prepared. So we wanted to have, you know, that. And we work with the other two cities
guy, an ex-police officer. But anyway, we've been called out several times, yes. Secondly, on this financial sheet that they provided, the 29, 468, and 11, 521, it's a little bit over $40,000. So all that was reimbursed to the police chief, I assume, the finance, would you? Correct, Jesse. So he spent $40,000 on his credit
you looking at on that one? Page 3, total reimbursement for charges to personal credit cards, and the question charge is shipped to personal residence.
$12,000 was comprised of. So, follow up. Go ahead. So, okay, on purchases, you know, normally you have to provide a PO. I mean, you know, I know certain municipalities, they require, okay, if you purchase something that hits the service threshold, it has to be approved by the council or has to go through some type of checks and balances. Is there any type of threshold that you guys have before a person could even spend any money, any department could spend any money? So anything that is over
$1,000, they have to have mayor's approval on. And then anything, you know, above $20,000, you know, we have to put out for bid and whatnot. But to correct this going forward, I noticed you mentioned POs. Is that something that we are going to be looking into, moving into, is potentially looking at doing POs?
threshold and over the $20,000 threshold, so. It's a combination of purchases. So, I mean, if it's, it wasn't a flat, it wasn't like a flat where we're spending $15,000. No, it was
a combination of purchases. So none of this came before the council came before you, mayor, before the chief spent this money or decided he was going to buy a vault, a gun vault, buy weapons, buy ammunition. None of this was brought before you guys prior to him making these purchases?
No, we budget for ammunition and small tools and equipment and things throughout the year. So, no, the council approves the budget. And as long as they're within the budget, then it's fine. But anything over, like I said, anything over $1,000, they had to have my OK. I believe the safe was $667, what if I remember correctly. Thank
Yes, sir, I do. Okay, guys and ladies, as vice chair of this committee, Now, 26 years I was in county government. I never, ever knew of a time that we bought a piece of equipment that was delivered to any personal house. In other words, a personal shop or anything. That went directly to where that was going to be used at.
Okay. Representative Richmond. Thank you, Mr. Chair, and I won't ask any more after this. This question for State Audit, when you were in your explanation about the safe and the weapons, you were saying
you were told, who told you? We were informed by the acting lieutenant and also some of the other city officials. We were informed this from the mayor. I mean, he mentioned that the safe was a city safe, but it had not been at the city. The same thing for, like I said, the lieutenant. He said that, and also some of the other police staff said that the safe had not been at the actual police department until the police chief had changed residences. All right. Thank you
Thank you, thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. Okay, do I hear any motions from the committee? I think what we need probably is a motion to file. Okay, second. Motion and second to file. All in favor or any discussion? All in favor say aye. Any opposed? Motion carried. Thank you. I think Mayor and associated people with this city, I think you hear the sense of this committee that you've got some work to do and you need to get with it, okay? Yes, sir. Yes, thank you. Next item, Ms.
Steele. Just real quickly, since Senator Tinn is here, they were next on the list as well for their regular audit report, and they had some repeat findings, but it's my understanding these have all been corrected, and staff would recommend that we file
Motion's carried. Ms. Steele. Okay. The next on our list that we'll discuss is Pulaski County. The committee asked last month for the report to be deferred so that the county judge could be here. These findings are on page 7 and 8. The first one, the county paid $11,185 for tickets to various banquets in apparent conflict with Article 12, Section 5 of the Constitution, as interpreted by Attorney General's Opinion Number 1992-099, and the next one is on page 8. The county paid $25,000 to the Pulaski County Imagination Library, a 501c3 nonprofit organization without a contract for services in apparent conflict with the Arkansas Constitution, Article 12, Section 5, which states, in part, no county shall appropriate money for any corporation association, institution, or individual. And I believe the county judge is here to address this.
Okay. I'm seeing a lot of old friends give me the hard eye here. We don't, you know, we obviously disagreed with what the, or didn't see the infraction before it was pointed out to us at the last day of the audit when those findings were presented to us. The Imagination Library, there was an assumption in the first year that the payment was made off of an ordinance which completely described the service that was being provided and it described the amount. We're told now in this audit that that was inadequate. We can't go back to the first year and change that. We now have a, as of the second year, we have a contract in place. So we don't foresee any conflict there. Um, uh, the, uh, uh, practice of, uh, participating in, in community, uh, uh, organizations, uh, in trying to maintain that, uh, uh, that connection, um, with the business community and, and, and, uh, uh, one of which was the, um, 140th anniversary of, of the historically black, uh, college, um, Flander Smith, uh, that we were written up for. we understand that the auditor has made the point that on no circumstance any which way with any kind of document can that ever be done. So we take that as being the gospel and we don't since this audit we've not participated with any community organization whatsoever in the name of the county. Okay we thank you for
Senator Johnson, I thought you might have one. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Judge Hyde, first, for the benefit of everyone else here, you and I are both involved with the Imagination Library because of our membership in Rotary, and this is a project that's one of the best projects in this state. Chairman Raypert was at our last subcommittee meeting and was also involved in this, and We're on top of the fact that Imagination Library, which sends a book a month to children from birth to age five, and it's one of the best literacy programs in the world. It's a great program. I appreciate the county doing it. Obviously, we in government have to create a little bit of paperwork trail, Mr. Chairman, but I'm comfortable with what Judge Hyde and his staff are doing to make sure that going forward that paperwork trail exists. But I did want to point out for the benefit of the committee that the General Assembly had also provided funding to this, and the Governor, I believe, funded half a million dollars for the whole state in the last fiscal year. So this is a good program. This is nothing but an I that wasn't dotted and T wasn't crossed. But I want to thank you for coming and helping explain that and the things that you've done to move forward on that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. Judge, do you have anything you want to add to that? Not anything, sir. Okay. Thank
you. Anything else from the committee? Do I hear a motion to file? I have a motion and a second. All in favor say aye. Any opposed? Motion is carried. Thank you all
for coming in. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The next report is on page 9. Yes, sir. The City of Greenway, there are repeat findings under the mayor, the first being the budgets were not adopted by ordinance or resolution in noncompliance with 1458-202, and the second, the governing body did not review the prior report and accompanying comments at the first regularly scheduled meeting following receipt of the report in noncompliance with 10-44-18. I believe the mayor is here to address these findings. Okay. Would
You don't have? No, sir. Okay. Okay. Any questions from the committee? Have a motion to file? And second. All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? Motion is carried. Thank you. Thank
you. Thank you. The next report is on page 10, the town of Jericho. We have repeat findings under the police chief, which this is on page 11 and 12. The first is the ending balance remaining in the police bond and fine bank account was not identified with receipts issued. For cases not yet entered on the arrest report, as required by 1610-207. A similar finding was noted in the previous three reports, dating back to 2010. On page 12, the police bond and fine account was not properly reconciled, as required by 1610-207. A similar issue was noted in the previous three reports, dating back to 2010. And cash receipts and disbursements journals were prepared for the bond and fine fund, but were not properly posted and did not contain year-to-date totals in noncompliance with 1610-207. A similar finding was issued in the previous two reports, starting back in 2012. I believe the Chief is here to address this.
is Roy Hill. First, I just want to apologize for these findings here. It's been a difficult time for Jericho. So I know within the last three years, you know, we have had at least three different clerks there. We lost, like each year we will lose a clerk. And what I mean by lose a clerk, we'll lose a clerk, you know, by death there. And this year, again, you know, we lost a mayor. So one thing, what I can say, most of these findings here on the remaining bond account, Now, we've been working with the bank to help us identify these things, to set up the account books the way that the state wanted. The one on the police bond and fine account was not properly reconciled. At this point in time here, we've got a new clerk, and that process there is being taken care of at this time here. So it's being worked on. As for a receipt, the Burstman General prepared. That at this time here is being worked on here. So we should have all this wrapped up and back in compliance. Hopefully by the end of the month at that time, we will contact the legislative auditor to come in and review it to make sure that we are back
not know that until, you know, after we got involved in this and then that's when we had reached out and talked to someone. But you have now? Yes, sir. Yes, we have. And
they're helping you with the training that you talk about? Yes, sir. I do. Okay. Any questions from the committee? Representative Gonzalez. Thank you, Mr.
Well, if you don't know the border of Memphis, Tennessee there, you have a lot of stuff that's coming through there. And I had to learn that when I came from Memphis over to Arkansas. Okay. Anything else? Hear a motion. Motion to file. Thank you. Thank
Our next report is just below that, the town of Oklahoma. There's a repeat finding on the mayor that general fund expenditures exceeded budgeted appropriations by 4506 in 2017 in non-compliance with 1458-203. And I believe the mayor is here to address that finding. Okay. I'm
Because I guess it is a repeat finding. Yes, sir. I had a problem. I was appointed mayor in 16. Okay. the clerk that I had, we had run into some Alzheimer's problems. And the city council, we checked into whether she could be let go, but because she's an elected official, she couldn't. Our lawyer told us that she had to resign. And so I tried to, we budgeted and went back and amended our budget where she made mistakes. She was just not putting the correct amount of money into the budget. It was going into the bank accounts. She just wasn't putting it on the paperwork. And so she resigned as of the beginning of 18. I have a new clerk. Everything has been cleared up and centered up and we're good now. Okay. All
carried. Next item is Steele. Thank you, sir. Our next report is just below that, the city of Parkin. And if you'll go over to page 13, we have repeat findings on the Clerk-Treasurer and the District Court Clerk. On the Clerk-Treasurer, property taxes restricted for street purposes of $4,300 were not transferred from the general fund to the street fund in non-compliance with $1,459.104. Also restricted funds of $74.17 noted in previous years were not repaid, leaving a total due to the street fund of $11,737. Again, the employee state tax withholdings, again, were not paid timely, resulting in penalties in interest of 1482. IRS Forms 941 for 17 were not filed until June 7th of 18. Federal tax withholdings, again, were not remitted timely to the IRS. As of October 24th of 18, we could not determine that 16 federal taxes due of 7738 had been remitted. In addition, we cannot trace 2017 federal taxes due of $9.24 to a payment, leaving a total due of $8,662. Additional penalties and interest could be assessed by the IRS due to the late filings and unpaid balances. The city failed to withhold the proper amount of insurance costs for various city employees. That's all under the clerk-treasurer. Then under the district court clerk, the district court bank account was not properly reconciled, and the cash receipts and disbursement journals were not reconciled monthly. to bank deposits and disbursements as required by code. And then on page 14 at the top, ending balances remaining in the bank account, again, were not identified with receipts issued for cases not yet adjudicated, and the payments made on all unpaid time accounts. And I'm sorry, I thought someone from Parkin was here. I think they're stuck in traffic, is the note that I got. So, we'll move to the next one. Okay. Go ahead. The town of Russell is just below that. There's a repeat finding on the mayor. An auditor agreed upon procedures report was not obtained for the Russell Water and Sewer Department as required by 1434-119. A similar finding was noted in the previous report. The mayor is here to address this. Okay. Okay. Mayor of Russell, please.
name is Renee Gahr. I'm the mayor of Russell. And we have recently hired Turner-Williams to perform our engagements for the year 16, 17, and 18. Would you repeat that? You hired them to
the committee? Okay, what's the mind of the committee? Do I hear a motion to file? Motion to file and second. All in favor say aye. Any opposed? Motion carried. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you. The next one, the next report is on page 17, the City of Dermott. We have findings first. We have one certified to the bond board under the mayor. Unaccounted for funds totaling $17,183 were noted as follows. Cash receipts for the general, street, and water department funds exceeded cash deposits by $15,594 for the period January 1 of 2016 through April 30th of 2017. Unreceived checks were included in the bank account deposits, and the clerk made numerous adjustments to customer accounts in the water department computer system in an apparent attempt to conceal the unaccounted for cash. Receipts for the general and water department funds exceeded bank deposits by $1589 for the period May 1, 17 through December 31st of 17. The persons responsible for these unaccounted for funds could not be determined. And then if you'll go to page 19, we have another finding certified to the bond board on the district court clerk. The district judge discovered and we verified unauthorized disbursements totaling 9,449 in the district court back account during the period August 1 of 17 through August 31st of 18. These disbursements, which consisted of personal online purchases of $6,450 and utility payments of $2,999, appeared to have been made by the former district court clerk. The bank refunded certain charges totaling $672, leaving a net shortage of $8,777 in the account. In addition, a $70 cash receipt was issued by the former district court clerk on August 28th of 17. It was not entered into the computer system and was not deposited in the district court bank account. On page 20, we have a repeat finding under the police chief. The police department again made numerous posting errors in the district court virtual justice system and noncompliance was 1610-07 as follows. Amount paid to the district court per the arrest report was 896 less than the virtual justice system receipt amount, and manual receipts the amount of 3155 were not entered into the virtual system, virtual justice system. And I believe that the police chief, Mr. Evans, is here to address his
You have a statement to make concerning the findings? Yes, sir, I do. I think we have got this corrected due to us also having problems with court clerks and our virtual justice system going down quite often, and they're manually putting them – they're manually putting receipts in by hand. They're giving receipts by hand, but when the system comes back up, they're failing to enter them into the computer. But since then, I've been taking the list that they're receiving out by hand and monitoring them to make sure that they're being put in the virtual justice system. So we shouldn't have this problem anymore. So I'm not sure
We normally enter them through virtual justice through the computer, but when the system goes down, they hand out receipts by hand, written receipts. And the written ones, when the system comes back up, they're supposed to enter them back into virtual justice. That way they'll keep everything balanced out. But during the time, some of the dispatchers may forget to put it in, and that'll make it off. But what I have, what I started doing is monitoring the ones they do by hand to make
from the committee? Senator Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Chief, you mentioned you kind of had some turnover in the district clerk's office, and you're nodding like there's obviously been more than one turnover in this. Yes, sir. Is the individual or individuals that maybe are probably more responsible for some of these findings, they're gone now? Are you comfortable with the person that's in the incumbency at the moment? Yes, sir.
Definitely. And she's working with my office manager and they're matching their reports to make sure that everything balanced out. Great. That wasn't happening at first. Okay. Thank you
one? yes sir sir it just sounds like to me that you've got a system here that at one time you were trying to go over into a computerized system and then it failed at one point and you probably had to go in there by hand and fix things and then you come back in here and you try to fix it with uh with computerized equipment again and now you you got a problem but the problem you think is going to be
straight out yes sir it's basically our computer system go down and when you come to pay your fine you can't get a printed receipt so they have to write them by hands and that that's where the problem lies right there them not entering when the computer system comes back up but I think that should be taken care of. Okay. Any other
had ran into that problem before we had a judge that would order somebody to pay a certain amount of money to post a bond. And, okay, that money normally just lie in the bank because, you know, we didn't know what to do with it. But what I started doing is they were charged with anything. They had a fine. We would use that money that they owe, and then we would send them a check for the remainder, what belongs to them. And that brought down a lot of it because it used to be a lot where it was much more than what it is now. So we're still trying to get it to a zero
one? This is for staff. I'm just trying to – it just may not be on page 18. It said that the first paragraph, the money was transferred from general funds, home repairs and the Dermott City home repairs, and then I look down here and there's a nursing home, uh, which is the response that they will receive $500 a month. Is that the same account or is, I, I, I'm just, I'm kind of lost at what, what the home repairs, is that the nursing home account? That's the same account? Uh, Teresa, can you help us with
that. It's kind of confusing to me. Teresa Outlaw Legislative Audit. Those are two separate accounts. All right. What is the home repair account? That is just basically an account that they had established that's been there for years. We don't know what the original source was. I mean, it's that old, um, it could have been a number of revenues types that was going into that. So, okay. It could have been a grant money. Um, sometimes, um, there is, um, they can get federal funding for different home repairs, um, you know, for low income. And that's probably what that account was for. So there was some money in there. Yes. And
so we're recommending that they go back and put that money back in there. They couldn't provide us documentation as to why they transferred that money to General Fund. Okay. Thank you.
Representative Hodges. I guess going, thank you, Mr. Chair, I guess going back and Chief probably wouldn't know, probably have to be somebody from finance because I was just asking about, you know, oftentimes when the account is not utilized, it becomes dormant and the bank has to do something with, you know, so many years have to do something with that account. uh so i don't know if that's the case why they transferred it over or but you said they had no
explanation well what they were doing was um the accounts that had been inactive for several years they were just um transferring that money to general fund they either didn't know how to spend it or they thought the project was over and so but the bank had not done anything as far as telling them that they were going to close the account or so forth. So this was totally the city that made
transferred? Like I said, the accounts that had been enacted for several years, they were trying to close those accounts out, and they just transferred the money to general. And general fund needed the money. They needed
the funds. So, basically, it appears that they had an account sitting there with money that they weren't able to use as far as they knew, so they were trying to get it in a position to use it. Is that about where we are? Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you. Any other
questions from the committee, Senator Johnson? Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is more of a question for staff since, obviously, the mayor or someone else from The city is not here, but it says in the response to this on page 18 that city hall capital improvement and Delta Regional Authority funds will be repaid in April 2019, two months ago. And it all makes sense until I see $127,365. That kind of jumped out at me, and I don't know, Ms. Atlaw is smiling at me. Is there an explanation, Teresa?
repayment and was that done? I'm hesitant for us to go ahead and go back with this. Maybe we need to defer this one until we know an answer, but that amount of money coming from the federal
government, I'm a little bit leery of. Well, the large amount of the $127,000, that was actually sales tax money that that had been voted on by the taxpayers to fund nursing home capital improvements. So that has nothing to do with the federal government. That does not.
All they're listed in order, and I guess that's the nursing home. That's $127,000. So following that, the Delta Regional Authority, probably the $284 in there at the end. Yes, sir. Okay, then I'm not going to worry about that. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay. Thank you. Any
other questions? Seeing none, I have a motion to file. Motion to file and second. All in favor say aye. Any opposed? Motion carried. Thank you. Appreciate you coming in. Next
item, Ms. Steele. The next report is the city of Gravett, which is on page 21. The first finding was referred to the prosecuting attorney. A disbursement, this is under the mayor and clerk-treasurer, a disbursement of $1,900 for Christmas gift cards was made in apparent conflict with Article 12, Section 5 of the Constitution, as interpreted by Attorney General Opinion No. 1991-410. Then we have repeat findings under the clerk-treasurer. The Arkansas Code requires city management to maintain financial records. The financial records contained omissions and errors that were considered material. The street fund financial records contain misstatements in assets, revenues, and expenditures in the amount of $18,000, $283,000, and $28,000, respectively. These errors were due to unrecorded receivables as well as journal entry errors and posting errors. A similar finding was issued in the prior report. The effect of these omissions and errors constitutes a significant deficiency in the process of preparing financial statements. And I believe the clerk-treasurer is here to address this. Okay.
Carl Raby. I am not actually the clerk-treasurer. I'm the finance director. The clerk-treasurer is wheelchair-bound, and this trip would be very much of a hardship on him. So they sent me instead. Okay.
these findings? Yes, I can. I took over as the finance director in November of 2016. In the first year that I was there, the audit had not been done to, the last audit that had been done was in 2014. When I started, the first thing that I had to do was clean up the mess. In other words, bank wrecks had not been done for a long time. Things did not balance. So that was my priority. the first year the first thought that we did in 15 and 16 when you look at the misstatements and miss postings they were 1.6 million so even though 2017 has a forty six thousand dollar miss posting in the street fund I'm I feel much better about that than about the 1.6 million and that error was due simply to my mistake. I posted the entry and apparently got interrupted or something and I never transferred the funds. Those funds have subsequently been transferred to the proper accounts and we I currently have an Excel spreadsheet that tracks any funds that we receive that have to be split. In other words when When funds come into the general fund, such as property taxes that have to be split out to other funds, I have an Excel spreadsheet that tracks both the general ledger posting and the bank statement posting to make sure that those numbers do agree every month and that the right amounts are being properly transferred.
The $46,000 has been taken care of. That money has been transferred over to the street fund, which is where it belonged, and we currently have no variance in 17 or 18 that I'm aware of. Okay. Any
Motion to file. I'm sorry. Go ahead. Do you want me to explain the $1,900? Please. Okay. Yeah, the gift card. Okay, yes. So what happened was we talked to some contemporaries of ours and said, look, we'd like to do a Christmas party for the employees, or a business party. And we have vendors that want to make donations. We know that we can't, we don't want to take cash. they donate gift cards. So they donated gift cards, and some of them still donated cash. That money went into a bank account. It was tracked in a separate department, and those funds were then used to buy the gift cards. I have subsequently sent a letter to the prosecuting attorney with the bank statement and a detail of all the transactions and what happened
we were trying to do this benefit or this party with non-taxpayer money and we were trying to do it in a way that would be transparent to legislative audit. Once we found out that that is not the correct way to do things, we ceased doing that process. Okay. Did they give you a better way to do that? Yes. The better way to do it is not to have the money go into any accounts that are taxpayer-related. Okay. Any questions from the committee? Seeing none, do
Thank you for your information. Our next report is on page 30, the city of Tawny Town. We have a repeat finding under the mayor. City council minutes do not document the review of the findings and recommendations of the prior report, and the action taken by the city council is required by 10-4-4-18. A similar finding was issued in the prior report, and the mayor is here to address this. Okay.
mayor of the city of Tiny Town. Distinguished members, thank you for having me here today. we have shown that we have a repeat finding for notification of our audit and what we've what we've later since done is we went back I had my new assistant go back and check our records just to ensure that this was or could be a repeat finding what we've since found uh, in, um, February 7th of 2017, um, that our recorder treasurer inadvertently placed on the minutes, uh, that we discussed a water audit, which was also being conducted at the same time that we were finishing up our legislative audit, uh, but upon review of the audio tapes, which she went back and reviewed for the whole year, and each meeting lasted about an hour to an hour and a half, so it took her a little bit of time researching this, but, uh, the actual discussion was on the general fund audit so it was an inadvertent error in the recorded into the minutes at that time so in fact we don't have a repeat finding it was just inadvertently recorded upon us we've also since then took even further action and have recorded into our minutes on our audits for 15 16 and 17 with motions made by our council to approve since those dates okay Questions from the committee?
No questions? Mine to the committee. File? Motion and second? All in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion is carried. Thank you. Appreciate the information. Thank you, sir. Next item,
Ms. Steele. On the same page, we have the prosecuting attorney from the 2nd Judicial District has a repeat finding. The Poinsett County hot check complaint forms are not entered into the system timely. A similar finding was issued in the prior report, and I believe the prosecutor is
here to address this finding. Okay. Scott Ellington, Prosecuting Attorney, 2nd Judicial District. This is the second time I've been here on this matter. Judy May is my hot check coordinator for Poinsett County. She's a lovely lady. We had some corrective measures set into place. I had deputies that were to, uh, counsel with her and to, um, have meetings with her, uh, monthly and, and, and, uh, consult with her. Unfortunately, uh, when I have had young deputies in Poinsett County, both of them have taken, uh, jobs in private sector, uh, had taken jobs shortly after, uh, I was here. and I was filling in and had some other folks covering, and so some of the things got in our way of keeping up with that. She had done some better, according to the auditor, but there was some question as to whether he was going to make the reportable finding or not, and I said, it's a spade, it's a spade, report me, and I'll go to Little Rock and talk about it. And so that's where we are. We have a new crew of deputies in the office now and anticipate we'll have those meetings and we'll have a stern visit with her. And if it doesn't get better, I anticipate she'll be retiring. So one way or the other. Okay. Any questions from the committee?
What's the matter of the committee? Motion to file? Motion to file and second. All in favor say aye. Any opposed? Motion is carried. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Ellerton. Thank you,
sir. Thank you. And now if you'll go back to page 28, we have the city of Lakeview. We have repeat findings under the record of treasurer, the district court clerk, and the police chief. Under the record of treasurer, we have pre-numbered receipts were not issued for all funds received. Receipt numbers were not always indicated on deposit slips, and deposits were not always made in a timely manner. Receipt numbers were not always posted to the journals. Receipts were not issued in sequential order. Similar issues were noted in the previous two reports dating back to 2015. All disbursements were not made by pre-numbered checks, as some were made by electronic funds transfers without approval of legislative audit. Similar issues were noted in the previous three reports dating back to 2014. Cash disbursements and receipts journals were not maintained for all funds, and journals that were maintained contained numerous posting and classification errors. Cash receipts and disbursements journals were not reconciled to bank statements. A similar issue was noted in the previous report. And on page 29, bank accounts were not properly reconciled to city cash balances. Reconciliations did not contain outstanding checks. Bank fees and insufficient check charges were paid on bank accounts. Similar issues were noted in the previous two reports dating back to 2015. Invoices and supporting documentation were not always retained. Disbursements were made from statements rather than original invoices. We noted an instance where a check in the amount of 1882 did not contain any signatures, and state law requires two signatures of authorized dispersing officers. Late fees were paid on numerous invoices. Similar issues were noted in the previous three reports dating back to 2014. IRS Forms 941 were not prepared or submitted to the IRS, nor federal taxes remitted. State withholdings were not reported or remitted to the Arkansas Department of Finance and Administration. Total wages reported per the Arkansas AR-3 did not agree with total wages per IRS Form W-3. Similar issues were noted in the previous three reports dating back to 14. Authorizations for salaries and wages were not reflected in the Council minutes. A similar issue was noted in the previous report. A fixed asset listing was established. However, costs and serial numbers were not provided for all items. The listing was not updated for prior year additions. Disposed items were included in the listing. Control totals were not properly maintained. Similar issues were noted in the previous three reports, dating back to 2014. On the district court clerk, we have the district court transfer $23,200 to the general fund. The distribution report was not provided, therefore we could not determine portions that should have been distributed to the city, county, and state as required by 1610-209. Similar findings were issued in the previous two reports, dating back to 2015. Under the police chief and district court clerk, we have the balance remaining in the police bond and fine bank account of $3,504 was not identified with receipts issued but not yet entered on the arrest report in non-compliance with $16.10.207. Similar findings were issued in the previous four reports starting back to 2013. And I believe we have officials from the city here to address these findings. Okay. Could you
here, and the list is quite lengthy. Yes, sir. In reference to the police chief, the city implemented a process to maintain a settlements pending list via Excel spreadsheet with all violators that paid their fine. However, the list didn't detail the distribution of filing fees to the state in according with 1610-207. The city will provide the distribution list, which shows the amount of money sent to the state and the remaining balance in the bonds and fines account that will be transferred to the general fund in accordance with 1610-207. The city will work to identify the balance remaining in the bank with receipts issued on a monthly basis. Okay. Questions
In regards to the 940, well, first of all, I would like to state that I was elected into the position in Swarney and in 2017. This is the audit for the 2017. And I'm in transition and learning the various things that need to be done for this position. In regards to the 941-hour arrest, I wasn't aware. This is a disposition that's new to me. I wasn't aware of having to file that report. And now that I am, I am getting that report filed.
or what's the status of that I'm currently working with the IRS to setting up payments in order to become in compliance with just getting our taxes up-to-date. Okay. You know how serious
list being as long as it is? The findings, as noted, are reoccurring findings. As I stated, I just started working in 2017. I'm learning, and I'm just working on trying to get these matters resolved. And are you working, getting help, or are
I'm, yes, I'm learning that I can, uh, talk with the municipal lead to get help with the various things, and I've been working on, hopefully in 2018, some of these, uh, errors will fall off this, this audit report.
working with them for several months? What I'm saying is I haven't been working with them for several months, but I'm aware of the help that the Municipal League will give the city.
Senator Johnson. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Ma'am, there's a real nice gentleman sitting over there to your left behind you. He is former Senator Jack Critcher. He works in Municipal League. If you'll speak to him, he'll get you in touch with some folks that can help you. I appreciate that. Yes, ma'am. Thank you, and good luck on getting
this sorted out. Any other questions? Yes, sir. Thank you, Senator Cooper. Ma'am, it's real serious business. I've seen people go through this before. But now what you really need to do is you need to get with Jack Critcher. He knows as much as anyone about city government. And you need to get with the federal, and you need to break that stuff down with something realistically of what you can pay back and things that you can do. And we would like to see you do good, but, boy, ma'am, it's a serious business, and I would get on it as quick as possible. Yes, sir. Yes,
sir. Thank you. Yes, ma'am. Any other questions from the committee? Seeing none, do I hear a motion to file? Motion to file and second. All in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion is carried. Thank you. I hope you'll get this cleared up,
okay? Yes, sir. Thank you. Good luck. Okay, and now I understand that parking was able to get here, So we'll go back to page 12. Actually, the findings start on page 13. We have repeat findings on the clerk-treasurer that the property tax is restricted for street purposes. That's not me. I'm the court clerk. Okay. Well, since we've already read these findings once before they got here, I'll skip over the ones down to the district court clerk then. That's on the bottom of page 13. The district court bank account was not properly reconciled, and the cash receipts and disbursements journals were not reconciled monthly, as required by 1610-209. And on the next page, we have ending balances in the bank account. Again, we're not identified with the receipts issued for cases not yet adjudicated, and the payments made on all unpaid time accounts, in accordance with
1610-209. Okay. Would you identify yourself, and you recognize, please. Doris Jones. And you are the district court clerk? Yes, sir. Okay. Do you have a response
to the findings? Yes, sir. They've gotten me a system now that helps me reconcile, and I'm working on the bond pending. They were telling me I'd reconcile from virtual justice to the bank statement, but I had that unidentified balance. So I'm working on trying to get that narrowed down. So do
now. Okay. Pretty much, yeah. All right. All right. Thank you. Any questions from the committee? Seeing none, motion from the committee. Motion, second, file. All in favor, say aye. Any opposed? Motion is carried. Thank you. Good luck. Thank you. This only clears one of these issues. The clerk-treasurer is not here. So that motion we just made leaves the clerk-treasurer issue of this unresolved. So what's the motion? What's the mind of the committee? Do we want to defer this or file it? We want to defer this to next time? Okay. Yeah, I'll take that. Without objection, we'll do that. Next item, Ms. Steele. I'm showing
that to be all that we have visitors for. Is there anyone here who is here to address findings? Okay. Then we'll go back to the first and catch up all the others that we missed. Starting on page six, we have Ouachita County. The sheriff collector, actually on the collector's side, had a repeat finding, and he is not here. His finding had to do with uncollateralized funds. He did call and sent me a letter from the bank, but all it said was that they insured up to $250,000, and no securities were pledged. Obviously, that doesn't clear the $4.2 million that he had in the bank account. It would be up to the committee if you wanted to defer this and ask him to come next month.
next item. On page eight, we have the town of Carthage. The recorded treasurer did call and she could not get off work and she requested to defer this to the September meeting.
page 15, we had the Terrell Water and Sewer Department that we deferred last time. Since then, we did get a response to the findings and staff would recommend filing this
On page 16, we have an investigative letter on the city of Cotton Plant on the water department. They asked us to come in and look to see if manual receipts were deposited. And I think they only asked us to look at a month. And the bottom paragraph there, in summary, 2,237 was not accounted for properly. The water department employee who assisted the department secretary was placed on administrative leave with pay on August 14th of 18 and on December 11th the council voted to move this employee to administrative leave status without pay and we've gotten an update on that that pretty much at that point the the employee was let go to our knowledge no charges have been filed but we did refer this to the bond board it was certified to the bond board staff would recommend we file okay without
have the City of Flippin. This is under reports for certified to the bond board. On the City of Flippin, under the mayor and police chief, we conducted a review of selected transactions relating to the police department for the period January 1 of 15 through December 1st of 17, and issued a separate report dated January 11th of 18. This report disclosed that undocumented unauthorized disbursements holding 63,000 and 437 were made to or on behalf of the police chief and the deputy administrative assistant, respectively. Additionally, the city paid 2880 for unauthorized data usage by the police chief, who subsequently who reimbursed $2,400, leaving $480 due to the city. Ronald Smith was charged with one count of theft of property, a Class B felony on January 4th of 2018, and pled guilty on March 5th of 2019. And you can see the response there. The former police chief was terminated, and the city has implemented a stricter credit card
we'll file. Next item. On page 21, still under report certified to the bond board, we have Clay County. Under the county judge, we have the veteran service officer who works 20 hours weekly, received insurance as well as annual and sick leave benefits in violation of county policy, which states that an employee must work 37 1⁄2 to 40 hours weekly to receive these benefits. The county intends to correct this issue starting in January of 19. Under the sheriff and tax collector, the jail administrator, Rose Hancock, used the city's fuel card for personal purchases totaling $1,184 during the period November 16 through February of 17 and cashed a $1,300 commissary check on February 17 of 17. uh hancock's employment was terminated in february of 17 and on july 3rd of 17 she pled guilty to felony theft charge uh felony theft of property charges was sentenced to 60 months probation and order to pay restitution of 2484 as well as fines and costs staff would recommend we file okay
the bottom of page 22 we have Marion County under the county judge this is reports referred to the prosecuting attorney restricted road fund monies of 13,125 13,235 and 3,360 in 18 17 and 16 respectively were used to pay legal expenses related to the county judge's Ethics Commission hearing and subsequent appeal in circuit court. These payments are in apparent conflict with Hall v. Thompson 283, Arkansas 26669, SWSC, I'm not sure about the legal citation, anyway, 1984, as interpreted by Attorney General Opinion 1985-124 and 2011-110. And then on page 23, this is also referred to the prosecuting attorney under the county librarian. Marion County Library paid $100,000 of public funds to a nonprofit organization to establish a charitable fund for the benefit of the library. The agreement establishing the charitable fund states, in part, donor irrevocably gives, delivers, transfers, and assigns to the Arkansas Community Development Foundation, which is the nonprofit, all of its rights, title, and interest in and to the assets gifted. The agreement also stipulates that a minimum balance of $50,000 be maintained with a nonprofit organization for three years. The agreement appears to conflict with Arkansas Constitution Article 12, Section 5, which states in part no county shall obtain or appropriate money for any corporation, association, or individual. And you can see the response there. They did disagree regarding the investment of funds. We staff thought it was pretty clear cut with the agreement saying that they irrevocably give, deliver, and transfer the money to the nonprofit. would record when men we file. Senator Johnson. Mr. Chairman,
just, this is something I might want to learn a little bit more about. I mean, libraries have been around a long time in Arkansas, and they've been collecting fines for a long time, and we should have some kind of precedent on how those funds are properly disposed of. and I would perhaps still could just elaborate a little bit about kind of where we are on this. Again, it might be something that they can fix, but this one really bothers me primarily because of the amount of money involved.
Yes, sir. We consider the fines and fees to be county money. I mean, it's paid to the county based on the county's assets. Um, like I say, we didn't see anything really to argue about. The supervisor is here. Lance, do you have anything
to add? While he's coming up, Mr. Chairman, I've always been amused when people say that special revenues like fuel taxes aren't really tax dollars, they're user fees. And I've seen this argument before and I just would like, I'd like to hear how this, at at least what the staff received from the, in this case, Marion County, about what they said about that. Mr.
you identify yourself, please? Lance Woodworth, legislative audit. I wanted to point out the response letter was from the library director, but also involved was the board, the chair of the board, the library board, and she's an attorney and she read over our interpretation of those laws. You know, they responded that they disagree, but I believe they plan to get with the county attorney and seek more legal advice regarding the issue. It's a three-year commitment, and those funds will come back to the library. They were using it as a fundraising effort, they
That was the understanding from reading the agreement. And then also the cash is pulled together to earn different. Higher interest rate or something. Okay.
All right. Again, Mr. Chairman, I'm not wedded to one solution or another, but this is one I'm afraid we might see come back on us if we don't at least deal with it in some kind of definitive manner. So I'll defer to my chairman and our staff on the best way
the wall, so. Mr. Chairman, I'd love to have someone from the Marion County Library come at least explain to us. They may have a perfectly logical and good explanation. Maybe we need to defer it just to. Why don't
I think Lance, do you have a copy of their full response? I mean, we paraphrase them to get in here because naturally you wouldn't want a whole letter for every one of these to be included in the
Next item. Right below that we have Nevada County. This is also referred to the prosecuting attorney. The county judge disbursed $5,000 to the Nevada County Depot and Museum, which is a nonprofit without an authorizing contract in conflict with the Public Purpose Doctrine and Article 12, Section 5, which states in part, no county shall obtain or appropriate money for or on its credit to any corporation, association, institution or individual. Staff would recommend we file.
24, we have Calico Rock, an airport commissioner loan $32,000 to the Calico Rock Airport Commission on July 11th of 2016 to pay for hangar renovations and repairs. The commission repaid the loan without interest on September 1st of 2016 after receiving grant funds awarded for the project. The city did not have an authorizing ordinance allowing the airport commissioner to conduct business with the airport as required by 1442-107. If there are no questions, staff would recommend we file.
that, we have the town of Clarkdale. This is still under reports referred to the prosecuting attorney. Under the mayor and recorder treasurer, the town paid $650 for an appreciation dinner for non-employee law enforcement and fire protection individuals and their families in apparent conflict with the Public Purpose Doctrine and Article 12, Section 5. If there are no questions, staff would recommend we file. Without objection, we'll file. Next item. The City of Hamburg is right below Clarkdale. It came to our attention that on November 21st of 2018, an individual used the City bank account information to process an unauthorized withdrawal, totaling $2,313. Entity personnel discovered the unauthorized withdrawal upon reconciliation of the affected bank account, and the funds were recovered from the bank. This has to do with what you've probably seen in the news. There's been a rash of this with different government entities. Somehow someone is lifting the signature off of city and some county bank accounts, checks, and inserting it on fraudulent checks. And this has been, there's been a lot of this statewide, and this is one of those instances. We refer those to the prosecuting attorney, and they're all on top of it. I believe some other law enforcement agencies are involved as well. But we'll probably have more of
in this instance? looks like right they in all instances except one that i'm that i'm aware of the bank is making good on these and the only one that i'm aware of that the bank is not is because the entity did not reconcile their bank account timely and so it went past it was over 90 days i believe before the city discovered it and therefore the bank is saying it was past their limit of days and so that But they didn't make good on that one. But all the rest of them, though, as far as I'm aware, the bank
On the next page, page 25, we have the town of Harrell. And this is still under reports, referred to the prosecuting attorney. Under the mayor, in 2017, the town disbursed funds totaling $475 in apparent conflict with the Public Purpose Doctrine and Article 12, Section 5 as follows, $250 to Calhoun County for the Hogskin Festival sponsorship and $225 to Hampton High School for an ad. In 2018, the town disbursed funds totaling 1905 for the same Article 12, Section 5 in the Public Purpose Doctrine as interpreted by Attorney General Opinion No. 91-410 and 92-099 as follows, $250 to Calhoun County for the Hogskin Festival sponsorship, $250 to the Hampton Football Program for a sign and live stream ad, $225 to Hampton High School for an ad, $500 to the Calhoun County Park Board for an ad for the high school rodeo $180 to the Calhoun County Fair Association for an ad and $500 to Arkansas Run for the Fallen. Then we have the town passed Resolution No. 2018-16 allowing an individual to lease an abandoned street and place a mobile home on it. However, as of report date, the individual had not paid rent due to the town. This situation appears to conflict with Arkansas Constitution Article 12, Section 5, which states, in part, no county, city, town, or other municipal corporation shall loan its credit to any corporation, association, institution, or individual. And then we have, in 17, the town pays $6.50 to a town council member for entertainment at the Herald Volunteer Fire Department fundraiser without an authorizing ordinance in apparent conflict with 1442-107. And there are other findings, but those are the only ones referred to the PA. If there are no questions, staff
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. The response on this one are not satisfactory. Basically, you've got some probably deserving programs that the mayor or the council, I don't know who's involved in it, but we'll just pick on the mayor since his name is at the top. He's basically just giving city money without authority to some probably deserving organizations. I mean, I'm sure the Hogskin Festival is a wonderful thing, and certainly the school and the football team and the park board and the fair and the run. These are all wonderful things, but, you know, these are things you do out of your own pocket, not out of the taxpayer's pocket. And when he says they will not just no longer disperse to the above organizations, well, what about a new set of organizations? I'm not seeing a correction here, Ms. Steele. Are we, am I missing something? Especially on that with the bottom that you paid for the entertainment, $650,000, and in the future they'll just give each band member a check. That one was really troublesome to me.
Okay, the issue on that last one is an ethics finding, 1442-107. That would be doing business with a council member without an ordinance. So if it was a legitimate expenditure otherwise, then that might work. If each band member needed to be paid, I mean, that's another issue, whether or not the band was for a legitimate cause.
Yes, yes. Okay. And on the others, on that first one you asked about, we'll follow up on that when we go back. That's part of our procedures, is always to follow up on the prior year findings. And so we'll see what they're up to at
item. On the next page, on page 26, and this is still under reports, refer to the prosecuting attorney, the city of Hartford. We have a finding under the recorder treasurer that general fund receipts totaling $815 were not deposited for the period January 1 of 17 through December 31st of 18. Subsequent to the report date, funds totaling $269 were deposited by the recorder treasurer. And you can see her explanation down there that she had gotten some cash and paid some expenditures directly with cash not knowing that she wasn't supposed to do that and when she got finished with all that she had $269 left again that's the response we have that's if we don't have any questions staff would recommend we
Next item, please. On page 27, we're still on reports refer to the prosecuting attorney. The city of Perryville, the city paid $441 for flowers in conflict with Article 12, Section 5, and the city paid $900 for half the cost of gym memberships for five employees in conflict with Article 12, Section 5. In addition, this benefit was not included as taxable income to the employees. If there are no questions, staff would recommend we
under that, we have Johnson County. Under the sheriff, an analysis of the county sheriff's credit card account revealed $3,102 in purchases made on behalf of the Explorer program. The organization reimbursed the credit card company directly. However, these charges conflict with Arkansas Constitution Article 12, Section 5. If there are any questions about this, staff would recommend we file. Without objection, next item. St. Francis County, which is right underneath Johnson County. Under the sheriff and tax collector, the county paid $869 on behalf of the sheriff for political promotion items in conflict with Article 12, Section 5 and the Public Purpose Doctrine. The sheriff subsequently reimbursed this money on March the 6th of 19. If there aren't any questions, the staff would
On page 28 at the top, we have the City of Noble. We had repeat findings on the recorder treasurer. She called and said that she does not drive to Little Rock, and she asked to defer. If the committee would like, we could send a staff member by if it's a hardship for her to drive down here for health reasons and see if this has been
Next item when you're ready. On page 30, we have Clark County. This is under reports with repeat findings. The sheriff called and he had some issues. He called yesterday and had several issues going on at his jail, and he asked to defer this until the September
At the bottom of that page, bottom of page 30, we have the Huntington Water and Sewer Department. This is reports with findings, which means that we had not received a response. But we did get a response to this one on May the 30th, and we recommend that we file. Okay, without objection. Next item. The same thing on the top of page 31, we had the city of McNeil. This was a private audit. This is actually the city of McNeil water department that should be. Okay. And I got a response this morning actually from the accountant saying that he was to help them correct this so staff would recommend we file that one as well okay without objection next item under that we have the harrell waterworks department same thing we had not when this was printed we had not received a response but we have received one now that they are going to correct these findings and staff would recommend we file
junction city at the bottom of that page the same thing we did receive a response letter on May the 29th that addressed their findings and staff would recommend we file that as well. Okay, without objection. Next. Okay, on pages 32 to 40 we have 34 reports that have findings with responses and if anyone has any questions about any of those would be happy to talk about them Otherwise, staff would recommend that we file those. Committee need a few minutes to look through that.
to 44, there are 107 reports that have no findings. There's one exception. Arkansas County is on page 43, and we're going to have to reissue that report. But we, upon further review, we do have a finding there, and we'll present that at our next meeting. But other than that one, we would recommend that we file all those reports.
only other item I have, and this is not on the agenda. If you'll remember last month, we discussed several cities that were in noncompliance with the municipal accounting law. We got a call yesterday afternoon late from the town of Sunset that they had made some improvements and they wanted someone to come look. I guess it was the day before yesterday because we had an auditor go by yesterday. And they had made some improvements. They're still not in full compliance with municipal accounting law, and this is just going to be up to the committee as to what you want to do. Sunset has a history of being in noncompliance. They've corrected almost everything. There are still some issues in the general fund ledgers and journals. Some things are commingled that need to be pulled out. They still haven't posted a financial statement, and they did start using a debit card last month, but when we told them they couldn't do that, they've stopped that. And the committee can either vote to take them off this list, and if they do, they would start getting their term back again, or we could defer until September to see if they corrected these last few things and address it at
that point. Since we won't be having another meeting until September, that's quite a while. Uh, so, uh, uh, anybody have any thoughts on what to do about that? Uh, Senator Johnson.
Mr. Chairman, that's a long time to hold their turn back. And I, uh, if, if the staff feels they've made significant progress, even though they're not a hundred percent where they ought to be, I think perhaps we should, should maybe give them a little bit of a break. I can see Representative Rice kind of nodding on that. And so I would move that we, I guess the proper motion would be to file this. Does that, what would be the
proper motion, Ms. Steele? Actually, the proper motion would probably be to recommend to the full committee that we notify the state treasurer and city officials that the town is now in substantial compliance with the municipal accounting law. So moved.
Okay. And have a motion to that effect? Do I hear a second? I have a motion and a second. Any discussion from the committee? If not, all in favor say aye. Any opposed? Motion is carried. So that's all that we have for today, and I would say thank you to the auditing staff and the people here in the audience for sitting with us today and appreciate the work you do. Thank you for the members of the committee that sits here a long time listening to this and the work of the audit committee. So thank you all, and with nothing further, we're adjourned. Okay.