Said in CommitteeBeta

Exactly as spoken.

Public Health, Welfare and Labor Committee- House

March 12, 2019 ·15 Minutes Upon Adjournment ·Room 130 ·2:22:12
Video Transcript

Summary

Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 10, 2026

HB1177 S. Meeks TO PROTECT EMPLOYEES FROM FORCED HUMAN MICROCHIP IMPLANTATION. -1:11

Representative Stephen Meeks introduced HB 1177 to protect employees from forced human microchip implantation and opened the floor for questions, receiving none. [0:00]

The chair moved to concur on the measure, a motion was made by Rep. Payton and adopted without debate. [0:12] [0:35]

The committee then turned to HB 1220, where Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson presented an amendment that removed the standard-of-care language and substituted store-and-forward technology language, which was adopted by unanimous consent. [1:21] [1:31] [1:34] [1:37] [1:42]

Ferguson explained that the amendment allows patient visits to be established using store-and-forward technology to transfer medical records, and Rep. Karilyn Brown asked for clarification on that term, which Ferguson defined as the capability to transfer records from point A to point B. [2:24] [2:56] [3:29] [3:33] [3:43]

HB1220 Sullivan TO AMEND THE TELEMEDICINE ACT; TO ENSURE THAT TELEMEDICINE IS THE LEAST RESTRICTIVE METHOD TO DELIVER HEALTHCARE SERVICES REMOTELY; AND TO EXPA… 3:47

Representatives Karilyn Brown and Jeff Wardlaw questioned whether physicians would need access to prior medical records or patient-filled online histories to use telemedicine under HB 1220; Teladoc Vice President Claudia Duck-Tucker clarified that both sources are acceptable. [3:53] [3:58] [4:00] [4:05] [4:31] [4:39] [4:55] [5:02] [5:15] [5:36] [6:06] [6:14] [6:25] [6:36] [6:39] [6:52]

Rep. Ferguson noted that the bill eliminates the previous “standard of care” language and that the only new language is the underlined amendment, confirming that the amendment’s scope is limited. [7:17] [7:43] [7:53] [8:12]

Testimony from the ERIC organization, represented by Zonek Warisko-Files, argued that Arkansas is the only state requiring video for telemedicine and that technology-neutral legislation would improve access, urging passage of the bill. [11:49] [11:56] [12:32] [13:08] [13:38] [14:10] [14:41] [15:12] [15:48]

The Arkansas Medical Society, represented by David Roten and Scott Smith, opposed removing the video requirement for the initial patient encounter, emphasizing the need for visual assessment; after limited debate the committee voted to pass the bill. [17:51] [17:58] [18:29] [19:01] [19:33] [20:03] [20:14] [20:18] [25:06] [25:37] [25:53] [26:09] [26:39] [26:58] [27:10] [27:43]

HB1650 Ladyman TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948; AND TO REVISE THIRD- PARTY LIABILIT… 30:49

The chair, Rep. Jack Ladyman, introduced HB 1650 and explained that it would reinstate an employer’s right to reimbursement from a third-party when workers’-comp benefits are paid, and would add a six-month “inactive-claim” dismissal provision to close stagnant files. [30:58] [31:25] [31:32] [32:10] [32:41]

Opponents-including attorney Jason Hatfield, who argued the bill would unfairly shift recovery from injured workers to insurers, and attorney Paul Byrd, who warned it would jeopardize wrongful-death beneficiaries by making the compensation carrier a preferred creditor-testified against the measure. [40:47] [40:58] [41:31] [42:04] [42:36] [43:06] [43:39] [44:12] [44:47] [45:17] [45:48] [46:19] [46:52] [47:25] [47:56] [48:29] [49:06] [49:39] [50:10] [52:19] [52:32] [53:05] [53:35] [54:10] [54:41] [55:12]

A motion to pass the bill was offered by Rep. Deborah Ferguson; after brief discussion the committee voted, and the measure failed. [59:50] [1:00:06] [1:00:39] [1:01:23] [1:01:57] [1:02:14] [1:02:28]

HB1651 Ladyman TO AMEND AND UPDATE THE LAWS REGARDING TREATMENT FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH INTELLECTUAL AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; AND TO ENSURE RESPECTFUL LANG… 1:03:01

Ms. Melissa Weatherton (Director of the Division of Developmental Disability Services) presented HB 1651, noting it updates Arkansas law by replacing “mental retardation” with “intellectual and developmental disabilities” and makes other respectful-language changes. [1:03:07] [1:03:25] [1:03:38] [1:04:14] [1:04:44]

Parent advocate Jan Fortney raised concerns about the retained phrase “emotionally disturbed individuals” and the shift from “authorized to” to “may” for the Developmental Disability Services Board, prompting Rep. Ferguson and Ms. Weatherton to agree to consider further wording amendments. [1:06:19] [1:06:30] [1:07:03] [1:07:38] [1:08:12] [1:08:42] [1:08:50] [1:09:10] [1:09:16] [1:09:46] [1:10:16] [1:10:21] [1:10:25] [1:10:43] [1:10:48]

The committee moved to a motion to pass the bill, heard no further discussion, and adopted it unanimously. [1:11:28] [1:11:32] [1:12:05]

HB1691 M. Gray TO REQUIRE THE DIVISION OF DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES SERVICES OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PROMULGATE RULES FOR CLOSURE, SALE, TRANSF… 1:13:27

Rep. Michelle Gray introduced HB 1691, which requires the Division of Developmental Disabilities Services to promulgate rules governing the closure, sale, transfer, and expansion of certain facilities and services, and sets a timeline for such rulemaking. [1:13:30] [1:13:44] [1:14:17]

No committee members requested testimony, and a motion to pass the bill carried without opposition. [1:14:28] [1:14:58]

HB1687 M. Gray AN ACT TO AMEND THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES LAW; AND TO AMEND AN EXCLUSION FROM THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYMENT" WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF… 1:15:27

Rep. Michelle Gray explained HB 1687, which amends the Department of Workforce Services law to remove the exemption that allowed home-care providers to treat workers as independent contractors, thereby classifying them as employees for wage-and-hour protections. [1:15:36] [1:16:09] [1:16:40] [1:17:13]

Rep. Austin McCollum asked for clarification on why the bill would limit businesses’ ability to use independent contractors, prompting further discussion of the bill’s impact. [1:17:43] [1:17:58]

HB1707 Capp TO AMEND THE ADULT AND LONG-TERM CARE FACILITY RESIDENT MALTREATMENT ACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY. 1:18:08

Representative Michelle Gray introduced HB 1707, explaining that it would eliminate the statutory exemption that treats personal-care workers employed by third-party home-care agencies as independent contractors, thereby restoring employee status for state and federal labor-law purposes and closing the “loophole” that leaves workers without workers’ compensation, unemployment insurance, and proper tax withholding. [1:18:14] [1:18:46] [1:19:16] [1:19:29] [1:19:47] [1:20:18] [1:20:22] [1:20:34] [1:20:38] [1:20:53] [1:21:27] [1:22:00]

The committee heard extensive testimony, with industry witnesses such as Matt McClure of the Home Care Association arguing that misclassification deprives workers of benefits and creates liability risks, while Rita and Quincy Hurst of Superior Senior Care and other registries described their compliant caregiver-registry model and warned that the bill’s language could impose retroactive tax liabilities; legislators also raised concerns about Medicaid billing, travel-time pay, and the impact on for-profit and nonprofit agencies. [1:24:50] [1:25:29] [1:25:39] [1:25:52] [1:26:01] [1:26:38] [1:26:52] [1:26:54] [1:27:05] [1:27:09] [1:27:44] [1:27:57] [1:28:04] [1:28:19] [1:28:24] [1:28:52] [1:29:20] [1:29:30] [1:30:03] [1:30:12] [1:30:15] [1:30:34] [1:30:53] [1:31:06] [1:31:18] [1:31:30] [1:31:37] [1:31:40] [1:31:54] [1:32:13] [1:32:46] [1:33:19] [1:33:56] [1:34:26] [1:34:42] [1:34:46] [1:34:59] [1:35:02] [1:35:29] [1:35:50] [1:35:55] [1:36:00] [1:36:10] [1:36:31] [1:37:03] [1:38:10] [1:38:13] [1:38:20] [1:38:32] [1:38:43] [1:39:15] [1:39:52] [1:40:22] [1:40:52] [1:41:28] [1:42:08] [1:42:39]

After the discussion, Chair Rep. Jack Ladyman moved to pass the bill, and Rep. Gray indicated willingness to consider an amendment proposed by Rep. Deborah Ferguson to protect agencies from retroactive tax collection, though no final vote was recorded in that portion of the hearing. [2:07:23] [2:07:27] [2:07:36] [2:08:07] [2:08:25] [2:08:39]

The committee subsequently approved HB 1707, the amendment to the Adult and Long-Term Care Facility Resident Maltreatment Act and the emergency declaration, by voice vote after no further discussion, and Chair Ladyman announced two additional measures, with Rep. Mark Perry then introducing HB 1547-a brief, two-paragraph bill requesting Ann Purvis’s participation and noting it was not on the tablet, effectively treating the amendment as the bill itself. [2:09:09] [2:09:40] [2:09:51] [2:09:55]

HB1547 Perry TO ENSURE THAT PERSONS LICENSED TO PROVIDE EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES OR ADVANCED LIFE SUPPORT RESCUE SERVICES MAINTAIN CONTINUAL NATIONAL EMERGEN… 2:09:58

The chair introduced the amendment and Rep. Mark Perry asked for clarification; Ann Purvis, Deputy Director of the Arkansas Department of Health, explained that the amendment would require EMTs and other EMS licensees to obtain and maintain a national certification, creating reciprocity with other states. [2:10:13] [2:10:50] [2:11:20] [2:11:27] [2:11:52]

A motion to accept the amendment was made, no discussion followed, and the committee voted unanimously to adopt the amendment, so the bill was presented as amended. [2:12:10] [2:12:18] [2:12:23]

Rep. Michelle Gray queried the cost to EMS providers; Purvis said the fee is $20 per year, with about 300 existing licensees grandfathered, and the committee then closed the bill and passed it without further opposition. [2:12:46] [2:13:01] [2:13:34] [2:13:37] [2:13:44] [2:14:04]

HB1752 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; TO PROVIDE AN EXCEPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYER"; AND TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE… 2:14:33

Rep. Mary Bentley described HB 1752 as a measure to keep the $9.25 minimum wage for small businesses, nonprofits and developmental services while providing a temporary exemption as the wage schedule moves to $10-$11. [2:14:34] [2:15:06] [2:15:34]

With no members speaking for or against, a motion to pass the bill was made and carried unanimously. [2:15:48] [2:15:58]

HB1753 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; TO PROVIDE AN EXCEPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYEE"; AND TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE… 2:16:31

Rep. Mary Bentley argued that HB 1753, by allowing a $9.25 minimum wage for workers aged 16-19, would give teenagers entry-level job opportunities and let wages rise as they gain experience. [2:16:50] [2:17:23] [2:17:38] [2:17:53] [2:18:02]

Committee members debated the amendment; Rep. Justin Boyd asked whether it would disproportionately favor hiring teens, and Bentley responded that it simply provides an opportunity without creating long-term bias. [2:18:09] [2:18:23] [2:18:26] [2:18:48] [2:19:00]

After no further objections, a motion to pass the bill as amended was made and approved, and the committee reported the bill passed. [2:19:33] [2:19:35] [2:19:51] [2:20:05]

HB1751 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS. 2:20:37

Rep. Mary Bentley presented HB 1751 as a cleanup bill that updates obsolete language and adds a penalty requiring double payment if wages are not paid within seven days. [2:21:07] [2:21:31]

With no opposition, the committee moved a motion to pass the bill, which carried unanimously. [2:21:39] [2:22:03]

Bills discussed (67)

Bill Title Sponsor Status
HB1220 · 3 mentions in chapter, transcript
Matched: “HB1220 Sullivan TO AMEND THE TELEMEDICINE ACT; TO ENSURE THAT TELE…”
TO AMEND THE TELEMEDICINE ACT; TO ENSURE THAT TELEMEDICINE IS THE LEAST RESTRICTIVE METHOD TO … Sullivan Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1696 · 2 mentions in transcript, chapter
Matched: “…are you ready to present your bill? Do you want to present HB 1696?”
TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CLEAN INDOOR AIR ACT OF 2006; AND TO ALLOW PRIVATELY OWNED … Gonzales Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1060 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1060 Lynch TO ESTABLISH AND REQUIRE CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR HEA…”
TO ESTABLISH AND REQUIRE CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR HEATING, VENTILATION, AIR CONDITIONING, AND REFRIGERATION LICENSEES. Lynch Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1102 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1102 Sullivan TO ADDRESS THE UNDERSERVED STATUS OF A COUNTY AS A…”
TO ADDRESS THE UNDERSERVED STATUS OF A COUNTY AS A REQUIREMENT FOR LICENSURE AND CERTIFICATION … Sullivan Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1164 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1164 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE A PHARMACIST TO DISPENSE ORAL CONTR…”
TO AUTHORIZE A PHARMACIST TO DISPENSE ORAL CONTRACEPTIVES WITHOUT A PRESCRIPTION. Pilkington Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1177 Act 516 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1177 S. Meeks TO PROTECT EMPLOYEES FROM FORCED HUMAN MICROCHIP I…”
TO PROTECT EMPLOYEES FROM FORCED HUMAN MICROCHIP IMPLANTATION. S. Meeks Notification that HB1177 is now Act 516
HB1232 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1232 Lowery TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING AUTHORIZED PAYROLL DEDUCT…”
TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING AUTHORIZED PAYROLL DEDUCTIONS OF UNION DUES FOR PUBLIC EMPLOYEES TO … Lowery Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1252 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1252 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT…”
TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR LICENSURE OF ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANTS. Magie Recommended for study in the Interim by Joint …
HB1253 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1253 Magie TO AUTHORIZE A LICENSED DISPENSING OPTICIAN TO REFRAC…”
TO AUTHORIZE A LICENSED DISPENSING OPTICIAN TO REFRACT EYES AND DISPENSE EYEGLASSES IN CERTAIN CONDITIONS. Magie Recommended for study in the Interim by Joint …
HB1257 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1257 Boyd TO AUTHORIZE AND CLARIFY THE METHOD OF RELEASING CLAIM…”
TO AUTHORIZE AND CLARIFY THE METHOD OF RELEASING CLAIMS AND ENROLLMENT DATA BY HEALTH INSURERS … Boyd WITHDRAWN BY AUTHOR
HB1265 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1265 M. Gray TO AUTHORIZE FULL INDEPENDENT PRACTICE AUTHORITY TO…”
TO AUTHORIZE FULL INDEPENDENT PRACTICE AUTHORITY TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES WHO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS. M. Gray Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1274 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1274 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NUR…”
TO AUTHORIZE AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE WHO HAS SERVED A RURAL COMMUNITY TO PRACTICE … Pilkington Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1275 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1275 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.”
TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT. Richey Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1282 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1282 Lundstrum TO REMOVE THE REQUIREMENT FOR A MANDATORY COLLABO…”
TO REMOVE THE REQUIREMENT FOR A MANDATORY COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED … Lundstrum Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1283 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1283 Gonzales TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF CERTIFIED…”
TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHESIA"; TO CLARIFY THE SCOPE … Gonzales Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1284 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1284 Gonzales TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO RECO…”
TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO RECOGNIZE AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE AS A … Gonzales Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1289 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1289 B. Smith TO CREATE THE MEDICAL CONSCIENCE PROTECTION ACT.”
TO CREATE THE MEDICAL CONSCIENCE PROTECTION ACT. B. Smith Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1309 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1309 S. Meeks TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS NIGHTTIME ENVIRONMENT PROTE…”
TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS NIGHTTIME ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION ACT. S. Meeks Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1323 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1323 D. Douglas TO REQUIRE THE OFFICE OF LONG-TERM CARE NOT TO A…”
TO REQUIRE THE OFFICE OF LONG-TERM CARE NOT TO ADOPT RULES OR STANDARDS THAT ARE … D. Douglas Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1334 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1334 Maddox TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED UNDER THE A…”
TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED UNDER THE ASSISTED LIVING PROGRAM; TO REMOVE A … Maddox Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1433 Act 951 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1433 Rushing TO AUTHORIZE INDIVIDUALS WITH PRIOR DRUG-RELATED OF…”
TO AUTHORIZE INDIVIDUALS WITH PRIOR DRUG-RELATED OFFENSES TO WORK WITH INDIVIDUALS RECEIVING SUBSTANCE ABUSE TREATMENT … Rushing Notification that HB1433 is now Act 951
HB1435 Act 952 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1435 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO RE…”
TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO REIMBURSE FOR RIDESHARING APPLICATIONS. Pilkington Notification that HB1435 is now Act 952
HB1439 Act 493 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1439 Lundstrum TO CREATE THE CHERISH ACT; AND TO PROHIBIT ABORTI…”
TO CREATE THE CHERISH ACT; AND TO PROHIBIT ABORTIONS AFTER EIGHTEEN (18) WEEKS' GESTATION EXCEPT … Lundstrum Notification that HB1439 is now Act 493
HB1451 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1451 A. Collins TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTR…”
TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM; AND TO EXCLUDE CHILD SUPPORT … A. Collins Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1471 Act 644 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1471 C. Fite TO CREATE THE MENTAL HEALTH FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE…”
TO CREATE THE MENTAL HEALTH FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE DEAF OR HARD OF HEARING BILL … C. Fite Notification that HB1471 is now Act 644
HB1527 Act 600 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1527 Cozart TO CREATE THE RED TAPE REDUCTION SUNRISE AND SUNSET…”
TO CREATE THE RED TAPE REDUCTION SUNRISE AND SUNSET ACT OF 2019; AND TO REQUIRE … Cozart Notification that HB1527 is now Act 600
HB1528 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1528 Womack TO INCREASE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM BENEFIT LI…”
TO INCREASE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM BENEFIT LIMIT FOR DRUG TESTING AND X-RAYS. Womack Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1536 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1536 D. Douglas TO CREATE THE COMPASSIONATE CARE END-OF-LIFE OPT…”
TO CREATE THE COMPASSIONATE CARE END-OF-LIFE OPTION ACT; AND TO EXEMPT THE COMPASSIONATE CARE END-OF-LIFE … D. Douglas Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1547 Act 958 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1547 Perry TO ENSURE THAT PERSONS LICENSED TO PROVIDE EMERGENCY…”
TO ENSURE THAT PERSONS LICENSED TO PROVIDE EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES OR ADVANCED LIFE SUPPORT RESCUE … Perry Notification that HB1547 is now Act 958
HB1555 Act 959 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1555 A. Collins TO INCREASE COVERAGE FOR MEDICATIONS APPROVED BY…”
TO INCREASE COVERAGE FOR MEDICATIONS APPROVED BY THE UNITED STATES FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION FOR … A. Collins Notification that HB1555 is now Act 959
HB1568 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1568 L. Johnson TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ADVISORY COUNCIL OF HE…”
TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ADVISORY COUNCIL OF HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONS WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH. L. Johnson Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1642 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1642 Warren TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING COSMETOLOGY AND OTHER RE…”
TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING COSMETOLOGY AND OTHER RELATED OCCUPATIONS; AND TO REMOVE THE CERTIFICATION … Warren Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1649 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1649 Sullivan TO PROVIDE FOR OPPORTUNITIES FOR PATIENT CHOICE AN…”
TO PROVIDE FOR OPPORTUNITIES FOR PATIENT CHOICE AND PROMOTE QUALITY OF CARE AS A REQUIREMENT … Sullivan Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1650 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1650 Ladyman TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENS…”
TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT NO. … Ladyman Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1651 Act 1035 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1651 Ladyman TO AMEND AND UPDATE THE LAWS REGARDING TREATMENT FO…”
TO AMEND AND UPDATE THE LAWS REGARDING TREATMENT FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH INTELLECTUAL AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; … Ladyman Notification that HB1651 is now Act 1035
HB1687 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1687 M. Gray AN ACT TO AMEND THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICE…”
AN ACT TO AMEND THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES LAW; AND TO AMEND AN EXCLUSION … M. Gray Read first time, rules suspended, read second time, …
HB1688 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1688 M. Gray TO ESTABLISH COST-REPORTING FOR ASSISTED LIVING FAC…”
TO ESTABLISH COST-REPORTING FOR ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AS A … M. Gray Sine Die adjournment
HB1691 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1691 M. Gray TO REQUIRE THE DIVISION OF DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITI…”
TO REQUIRE THE DIVISION OF DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES SERVICES OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO … M. Gray Sine Die adjournment
HB1699 Act 846 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1699 Eaves TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING SALES OF RAW MILK TO AUT…”
TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING SALES OF RAW MILK TO AUTHORIZE THE SALE OF RAW … Eaves Notification that HB1699 is now Act 846
HB1707 Act 967 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1707 Capp TO AMEND THE ADULT AND LONG-TERM CARE FACILITY RESIDEN…”
TO AMEND THE ADULT AND LONG-TERM CARE FACILITY RESIDENT MALTREATMENT ACT; AND TO DECLARE AN … Capp Notification that HB1707 is now Act 967
HB1710 Act 1041 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1710 Perry TO CREATE THE TASK FORCE ON TRANSPORTATION OF NONEMER…”
TO CREATE THE TASK FORCE ON TRANSPORTATION OF NONEMERGENCY BEHAVIORAL HEALTH PATIENTS. Perry Notification that HB1710 is now Act 1041
HB1711 Act 968 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1711 Burch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING GUARDIANSHIP SUBSIDIES OF…”
TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING GUARDIANSHIP SUBSIDIES OFFERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES. Burch Notification that HB1711 is now Act 968
HB1712 Act 1042 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1712 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE LAW REQUIRING THAT INFORMATION OBTAIN…”
TO REPEAL THE LAW REQUIRING THAT INFORMATION OBTAINED ON HOME HEALTHCARE SERVICES BE CONFIDENTIAL. Wardlaw Notification that HB1712 is now Act 1042
HB1717 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1717 M. Gray TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED UNDER THE…”
TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED UNDER THE ASSISTED LIVING WAIVER PROGRAM; AND TO … M. Gray Sine Die adjournment
HB1719 Act 916 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1719 M. Gray TO UPDATE THE MEDICAID FRAUD ACT AND THE MEDICAID F…”
TO UPDATE THE MEDICAID FRAUD ACT AND THE MEDICAID FRAUD FALSE CLAIMS ACT TO ADDRESS … M. Gray Notification that HB1719 is now Act 916
HB1727 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1727 Dotson TO MANDATE COVERAGE BY AN INSURER FOR INTRAOPERATIVE…”
CONCERNING COVERAGE BY AN INSURER FOR INTRAOPERATIVE NEUROPHYSIOLOGICAL MONITORING. Dotson WITHDRAWN BY AUTHOR
HB1731 Act 1043 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1731 G. Hodges TO REQUIRE COOPERATION BETWEEN CERTAIN STATE AGEN…”
TO REQUIRE COOPERATION BETWEEN CERTAIN STATE AGENCIES REGARDING SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM ELIGIBILITY. G. Hodges Notification that HB1731 is now Act 1043
HB1743 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1743 Bentley TO PROMOTE THE PURCHASE OF HEALTHY PRODUCTS WITH SU…”
TO PROMOTE THE PURCHASE OF HEALTHY PRODUCTS WITH SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM BENEFITS. Bentley Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1745 Act 851 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1745 L. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING PRESCRIPTION ASTHMA…”
TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING PRESCRIPTION ASTHMA INHALERS IN SCHOOLS DISTRICTS AND PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS; … L. Johnson Notification that HB1745 is now Act 851
HB1751 Act 853 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1751 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARK…”
TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS. Lundstrum Notification that HB1751 is now Act 853
HB1752 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1752 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARK…”
TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; AND TO AMEND THE … Lundstrum Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1753 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1753 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARK…”
TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; AND TO AMEND THE … Lundstrum Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1771 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1771 V. Flowers TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS LITTER REDUCTION AND D…”
TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS LITTER REDUCTION AND DEPOSIT BEVERAGE CONTAINER RECYCLING ACT; TO REQUIRE THE … V. Flowers Died on House Calendar at Sine Die Adjournment
HB1775 Act 974 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1775 Bentley TO CREATE THE EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR ABLE-BOD…”
TO CREATE THE EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR ABLE-BODIED ADULTS ACT OF 2019. Bentley Notification that HB1775 is now Act 974
HB1783 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HB1783 Fielding TO MODIFY LABELING OF PRESCRIPTION DRUGS; AND TO R…”
TO MODIFY LABELING OF PRESCRIPTION DRUGS; AND TO REQUIRE PHYSICIANS TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL COUNSELING WHEN … Fielding Recommended for study in the Interim by Joint …
HCR1008 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HCR1008 Vaught TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF ORGAN DONATION TO PUB…”
TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF ORGAN DONATION TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND TO SUPPORT AND ENCOURAGE … Vaught Approved by the Governor
HR1047 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “HR1047 Watson TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE AND NEED FOR QUICK ACCES…”
TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE AND NEED FOR QUICK ACCESS TO AUTOMATED EXTERNAL DEFIBRILLATORS. Watson READ AND ADOPTED.
SB172 Act 623 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB172 G. Leding TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING SOCIAL WORK LICENSING…”
TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING SOCIAL WORK LICENSING; TO CLARIFY THE LICENSING EXEMPTION FOR STUDENTS; … G. Leding Notification that SB172 is now Act 623
SB184 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB184 G.”
TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHETISTS BY REMOVING SUPERVISION REQUIREMENTS. G. Stubblefield Sine Die adjournment
SB275 Act 688 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB275 Bledsoe TO CLARIFY LAW REGARDING OUT-OF-STATE PHYSICIANS WH…”
TO CLARIFY LAW REGARDING OUT-OF-STATE PHYSICIANS WHO PRACTICE PATIENT CARE SERVICES INITIATED IN THIS STATE … Bledsoe Notification that SB275 is now Act 688
SB3 Act 620 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB3 T. Garner TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS BY C…”
TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS BY CERTAIN PHYSICIANS AND HEALTHCARE FACILITIES FOR ABORTION COMPLICATIONS. T. Garner Notification that SB3 is now Act 620
SB339 Act 804 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB339 Irvin TO PROHIBIT THE REQUIREMENT OF, BARRING OF, AND DISCR…”
TO PROHIBIT THE REQUIREMENT OF, BARRING OF, AND DISCRIMINATION AGAINST A PHYSICIAN FOR HIS OR … Irvin Notification that SB339 is now Act 804
SB340 Act 690 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB340 Irvin TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING CONSENT TO MEDICAL TREATMENT…”
TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING CONSENT TO MEDICAL TREATMENT TO AUTHORIZE A LIAISON UNDER THE FEDERAL … Irvin Notification that SB340 is now Act 690
SB341 Act 522 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB341 Irvin TO AMEND THE WOMAN'S RIGHT-TO-KNOW ACT; AND TO PROVID…”
TO AMEND THE WOMAN'S RIGHT-TO-KNOW ACT; AND TO PROVIDE INFORMATION ON REVERSING THE EFFECTS OF … Irvin Notification that SB341 is now Act 522
SB342 Act 805 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB342 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE CONTRACTORS LICE…”
TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD; AND TO AMEND THE LICENSING REQUIREMENTS … J. Cooper Notification that SB342 is now Act 805
SB380 Act 477 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB380 G. Leding TO MODIFY COVERAGE FOR SCREENING MAMMOGRAPHY AND…”
TO MODIFY COVERAGE FOR SCREENING MAMMOGRAPHY AND BREAST ULTRASOUND FOR THE DIAGNOSIS OF BREAST DISEASE … G. Leding Notification that SB380 is now Act 477
SB446 Act 699 · 1 mention in chapter
Matched: “SB446 G. Leding CONCERNING STEP THERAPY REQUIREMENTS FOR CERTAIN…”
CONCERNING STEP THERAPY REQUIREMENTS FOR CERTAIN PRESCRIPTION DRUGS TO TREAT METASTATIC CANCER. G. Leding Notification that SB446 is now Act 699

Official video page ↗

Transcript

Transcript available Whisper ✓ SliQ live captions: not yet available Download .txt
Machine transcript

May contain errors. Verify important quotations against the official video.

About transcript accuracy
Source
Whisper
Model
ggml-large-v3-turbo.bin RTX5060
Processing date
October 10, 2026
raises, create hostile work environment, and so forth. And that's essentially what we've done. We've added a couple of co-sponsors, but otherwise, I'll be happy to take any questions. Any questions from the committee?
▶ Play
Seeing none, are you closed? I am closed, and I would appreciate a good vote. I have a motion by Representative Payton. Do pass. Motion to adopt or to concur. To concur. Okay. Motion to concur. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. Motion carries. It's been concurred. Okay, Representative Gonzalez, are you ready to present your bill? Do you want to present HB 1696? 1220? Yes. Yes, you can. You're recognized due 1220. HB 1220. All right, thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. House Bill 1220 is the... Is there an amendment? Yeah, and the amendment is the new bill, so it's on the tablet. And the amendment is
▶ Play
on your tablet, members. So I make a
▶ Play
motion to adopt the amendment. I have
▶ Play
a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your amendment's been adopted. You may present your bill as amended. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, committee. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. I mean, since
▶ Play
it is a brand new bill, is there a way I could, I want a paper copy. Does anybody else, I mean, if I could have one, that'd be great. And we got paper copies? Yes, sir. Okay. I'll be mayor. Okay. Okay.
▶ Play
there you go thank you all right you may proceed with the bill okay thank you mr chair so with the amendment we eliminated all the standard of care language that caused some issues first time we presented this and now it just says that with the use of store and forward technology technology, which is language that is already defined in code, but the use of store and forward technology and audio, you can use that to establish patient visit, establish care. Are you ready to take questions, or did you have? Yeah, I mean, it really is just that simple. Everything is struck except for we're just including the store and forward technology as a basis for establishing.
▶ Play
Okay. Representative Brown, you're recognized for a question. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Representative Gonzalez, store and forward, what is it? Is that how they transmit the medical records? Yeah, that's basically
▶ Play
all it is, is the capability to transfer medical records from point A to point B. So that the
▶ Play
Arkansas licensed physician taking the call will have that patient's medical records? Will have access
▶ Play
to the medical records just now.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. My question follows those same lines. So if they're using that, they wouldn't be able to help this patient unless they had those records from a physician that that patient had been seeing or had seen. So that way they could see that those encounters had happened. So whatever this patient's telling them, I need hydrocodone or I need whatever, they could verify that those conditions are there. Is that what you're saying?
▶ Play
Yeah, you're right, but hydrocodone would not be allowed under this anyway. No narcotics would be prescribed. Oh, I just used that for anything. Yeah, I
▶ Play
got you. But any antibiotic or anything, they can verify those conditions with the medical records that are currently there. Is that what? That is correct. I'm trying to make sure that we're on the same line. That is correct. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. I'm just trying to clarify. Are you talking about a medical record from another physician, or are you talking about the medical record the patient filled out online? I don't know the answer to that. I mean, there's
▶ Play
a big distinction. Yeah, I understand. Do you want to? If you don't mind, call somebody else up here. Please introduce yourself and who you represent.
▶ Play
Speaker 60 5:36
Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Claudia Duck-Tucker. I'm Vice President of Government Affairs for Teladoc. And to answer your question, ma'am, it's yes and yes. And so it could very well be a medical history that the patient filled out online. I can only speak for Teladoc, although there's a number of other companies that have a model similar to ours. It can also involve images, data, lab results from other places that are also on the member portal.
▶ Play
Speaker 63 6:06
okay thank you representative warlock you're recognized it
▶ Play
goes back to what i just asked so are we taking the information from the patient where they filled it in or are we taking it from a previous provider i'm sorry i
▶ Play
misunderstood your question earlier i just thought you were asking if you had to have access to the medical records so i'll i'll let her answer that and did not mean to I understand. I misinformed you there. Yes,
▶ Play
Speaker 60 6:36
you do have to have access to the medical record. The medical record source, as I think you're asking, can come from the patient just as they would in a physician's office or urgent care office. Follow up. Follow up? Yes, you recognize
▶ Play
for follow up. So what's the difference between the original bill? Because your original bill said they didn't have to have that initial visit. So if you're saying it can come from what the patient filled out, then they're still not having an original visit. And so you're using this word stored or words stored in forward to give the illusion that it's going from a provider, but you're sitting here saying that it can come straight from the patient. So, I mean, I'm a little
▶ Play
lost. Well, that in the bill is not much different than what was there before. But what we did do was eliminate the standard of care language that caused concern that on that end of being able to establish a standard of care through that first visit and overriding the medical board. It was, I guess, the big issue with that was the ability of these companies to override the medical board.
▶ Play
Speaker 45 7:43
So all that's been removed. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. I'll probably have more questions. Representative Brown, you recognize? Well, I'm just a little confused. It says delete everything after the enacting clause and substitute the following, and then we have all this text with only this small amount underlined. Is that the only thing new, the part that's underlined?
▶ Play
Yes, ma'am. That's all the new language.
▶ Play
Thank you. any other questions from the committee representative johnson you're
▶ Play
recognized just i think i understand the answer to this question but just to be clear this still allows the relationship to be established with audio only no video
▶ Play
Speaker 60 8:39
that is correct okay Well, it's not audio only. It's audio as a modality, just like video would be a modality. It still requires that that physician must have access to and review that patient's medical record first. Yeah,
▶ Play
you're recognized for a follow-up. So there's no face-to-face interaction, live, real-time, between the physician and the patient in the context of what we're doing here. Is that
▶ Play
Speaker 60 9:08
correct? What it does is give the patient choice physician discretion. It removes the requirement for an audio, for a video first. So if the patient decided to have a video and the, or the physician decided a video was needed, then video is certainly readily available. If the patient lives in an area where there's not access to broadband and a landline is all that they have, they still
▶ Play
have access to quality care. Follow-up. So you're saying that they have the option in all these cases to
▶ Play
Speaker 86 9:43
have video interaction? That's their option?
▶ Play
Speaker 60 9:46
This bill will make Arkansas technology neutral, which then they will join the other 49 states. And so, yes, it would be technology neutral. It could be interactive audio using the Storm 4 technology, or it could be video.
▶ Play
So you can choose not video in all cases, then why would you want audio only? I'm trying to understand if it's in any case. I thought part of the issue was you're having trouble with video in certain cases. If it's an either-or, why would anyone choose audio alone over audio-video? I'm trying to understand that. I
▶ Play
Speaker 60 10:17
can only speak for Teladoc, and I can tell you that at the Teladoc platform, all 50 states, We look at this, 90% of patients will choose audio. Why? Sometimes it's more convenient. Sometimes they don't have access. But that's what our data shows. Any
▶ Play
other questions from the committee? Any questions from anybody on the committee? Seeing none. Okay, we have four people signed up to speak for the bill and one to speak against the bill. So first person to speak for the bill, Alex Cody, I can't quite read that last name. Alex.
▶ Play
Speaker 99 11:22
Okay, Annette Gorisco. So you're speaking for the
▶ Play
bill, correct? I am, sir. Okay, introduce yourself and who you're representing. My
▶ Play
Speaker 108 11:49
name is Zonek Warisko-Files, and I'm the president and CEO of the ERISA Industry Committee, also known as ERIC. Thank you, Chair and members of the committee, for this opportunity. ERIC represents large employers that provide benefits to their workers and families in every state across the nation, including many companies in Arkansas. Since 2015, Eric has been working with state legislators and with medical boards all across the country regarding telemedicine legislation. The states approach it all differently, but they all want to provide access to care for the residents in their states and to help contain costs. And they've all done it virtually on a bipartisan basis. Arkansas stands alone in the nation as requiring video, and we believe that it's an unnecessary and harmful obstacle to individuals being able to receive care. So we're here to support this bill, and we urge you to pass it out of the committee. As background, the ERISA Industry Committee is the only national association that advocates exclusively for large employers on health, retirement, and compensation public policies on the federal, state, and local levels. You engage with our member companies every day when you drive a car or fill it with gas, when you use your cell phone or your computer, stay at a hotel, visit a bank, enjoy our national defense, wear makeup, enjoy a soft drink, receive, or send a package. You get my drift. These are the large companies that have workers and families in every state, and as such, they have a keen interest in policies that affect the ability of their employees to have access to quality health care. They strive to provide affordable health coverage, and they innovate by doing what they can to ensure their employees can receive it, whether that's with on-site medical clinics or wellness programs, accountable care organizations and telemedicine. They see the significant opportunity for telemedicine to modernize healthcare delivery and to improve access to care. Telemedicine minimizes the time for a provider visit, and it makes it much easier for families and caregivers and those juggling work and family demands. Importantly, it provides access to care for people who live in rural and in urban areas, caregivers, those with physical challenges, language barriers, chronic conditions, or transportation issues, individuals who may not otherwise be able to make it to see a provider. I deal directly with the corporate leaders who design the health care benefits for the largest companies in the country. They tell me loud and clear they want their employees to receive access to care when and how they need it. These are companies with tens of thousands of employees and many, many more. So we have consistently supported technology-neutral legislation and regulations regarding telemedicine. In our view, government policies cannot keep up with the pace of technological change. And most importantly, technology restrictions impede access to care. Arkansas, as I said, stands virtually alone with the video obstacle. This obstacle leaves an important and significant gap in coverage for those who live in rural areas where they don't have access to broadband, or for those who cannot afford to pay for broadband, or for those who are simply not computer savvy. This bill will help those patients and many more receive access to care and change their lives for the better. We appreciate the work that the state has done to move forward on telemedicine, and we urge you to adopt this bill. It does one thing and one thing only. It provides a choice. Someone could have a telemedicine visit with a patient located in the state by a physician licensed in the state using interactive audio with access to the patient's medical record or using video with access to the patient's medical record. It's a very straightforward and pragmatic bill. All six states surrounding Arkansas do not have this video requirement. And for my large employer members, we want the same benefits to our employees, regardless of where they live or work, without changes from border to border or across the country. I thank you for this opportunity. I'm happy to answer any questions that you
▶ Play
may have. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized
▶ Play
for a question. Thank you. I just want to clarify what organization you represent. You're with the ERISAs who are the large self-insureds who circumvent state law and do not have to comply with any insurance state laws that we develop because you are formed through federal DOL. Is that correct? We are required
▶ Play
Speaker 108 17:03
by federal law to comply with a vast majority of regulations that govern the plan and not additionally by state insurance regulation. Right. You do not have to comply with state laws
▶ Play
that we make to protect patients. I just wanted to clarify that. Any other questions?
▶ Play
Seeing none, thank you for your comments. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. To speak against the bill, David Roten and Scott Smith. Please introduce yourself
▶ Play
Speaker 116 17:51
and who you represent. I'm David Roten, representing the Arkansas Medical Society. And I'm Scott Smith with the Arkansas Medical Society. Let me start and just remind you all, we started telemedicine legislation in 2015, passed it in 2015, turned around in 2017, and passed a major amendment to that law. I can honestly tell you, during the last two and a half, four years, there have been multiple public hearings at the Medical Board regarding telemedicine rules and regulations, testimony before the House and Senate, and in spite of what I just heard, this is the first time we've ever met anyone from ERIC. So they have not been engaged in this state and working on this issue. Secondly, you're hearing, and we heard this four years ago, that Arkansas is the only state in the country that requires audio. Well, I can tell you right now, most current legislation, Oklahoma and Tennessee, two of those six states surrounding us, do not allow audio only to establish a doctor-patient relationship. Arkansas allows audio. So to say that we don't allow it is not accurate. Arkansas does allow audio. What it doesn't allow is the use of audio only to establish the initial doctor-patient, nurse-patient, chiropractor-patient, whatever patient relationship. That is the only time that the video is required, and it's required for very good reason. And I think Representative Johnson has brought this out numerous occasions, as have others on this committee. You're talking to a patient for the first time. You may have a record in front of you that may be from a physician or it may be something that the patient has completed. It may not be accurate. It may not be complete. And the only way you're going to know and really find out about that patient is to see them. So once you get past that first visit, you can use the telephone all day long and all night long for visits after that. That is what our telemedicine bill does. the amendment to this bill doesn't make any changes from a practical perspective from the original bill that was filed it still allows the use of a telephone and a document that may or may not have come from another physician to establish the relationship once you get again once you get
▶ Play
Speaker 118 20:14
past that you're in the clear if i
▶ Play
Speaker 117 20:18
might add one of the best illustrations that that i've heard of is that it would be somewhat like you going to your physician for the first time and you being in the room, the patient room, with the door closed and the physician coming to the door and knocking on the door and saying, I'm here, but I'm going to stay out in the hall while you talk to me. I'll slide my sheet of information that I filled out. I'll slide it under the door, doctor, so you can look at it outside in the hall as we talk and you do your
▶ Play
Speaker 116 20:54
diagnosis. It's not much different than that. I would add that in the last legislative session, working up to the legislation that was ultimately filed, Representative Ferguson and Senator Bledsoe worked with several of our state's largest employers, including J.B. Hunt, to come up with the language that we have in the statute today. And they were happy with it, and we have not heard from them that they are unhappy with it. So it's working. Telemedicine is across the state. Teladoc, the company that's here today, is working in Arkansas. So to say that they can't do it is disingenuous. They can do it. They are doing it. Employers are using telemedicine across the state. And I would also have to point out the other telemedicine vendors are not here asking for this change because most of them do not utilize this type
▶ Play
of a business model. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Brown, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Is it possible that I understand that the patient has the discretion of whether to just use audio only and that the doctor who receives the call, they have the medical records for this individual. If a person calling in has something relatively minor, easy to diagnose, would you necessarily need to have a video? I mean, there are some things that are pretty, I don't know, standard problems, like, you know, a virus or a cold, something like that. What kind of situations, I mean, wouldn't, this is a licensed Arkansas doctor, would he not know when seeing the patient, a visual of that patient would be necessary and then say, well, I'm sorry, I can't address that with a phone call, only you do need to go to a clinic. I mean, I would think that between the patient and the doctor, they could work that out.
▶ Play
Speaker 116 23:03
Remember that this is a patient that the doctor has never spoken to before, knows nothing about their history other than a possible medical questionnaire that the patient has filled out, which may or may not be accurate, may or may not be up to date. So yes, once you have that relationship, there are lots of situations where a phone call is all you need to do. But in establishing that relationship, the physicians in this state, and I think most of the other health care providers in this state, including the dentists and the nurses and everybody else who supported this bill in the last session, firmly believe that that initial visit with the doctor needs to be using audiovisual at least. Prior to that, it was in person. So they came a long way backing off from that and going to a video only. And then the video, the audio-visual, can only be used if in the situation of that particular patient you can get the kind of information that you need to diagnose the patient. If you can't, then you should tell the patient you're going to have to come in for a visit. And the problem is the bill isn't
▶ Play
limited to those simple situations. It applies to everything. But, I mean, if it's a licensed Arkansas physician, they're going to know that they can't properly address or diagnose a situation just with a phone call.
▶ Play
Speaker 116 24:35
Arkansas physicians would prefer to have legislation that says the initial visit must be face-to-face in person. But they compromised and said, okay, we'll accept audio-visual as a compromise to that as long as we can meet the standard of care in doing so. So Arkansas physicians, this is the current bill, the current statute is what they want. Thank you. Representative McGee, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Motion, Mr. Chair. Motion. What's your motion? Motion to end debate. I have a motion. That's a valid motion. Motion is to end debate. It's non-debatable. All in favor? Signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Nay. Motion carries. What's the pleasure of the committee? Representative Bentley, you're recognized. I have a motion of due pass by Representative Bentley. Any discussion on the motion? As amended, yes. Representative Johnson, you're recognized. Yeah,
▶ Play
I just want to say to the committee, you know, this doesn't change anything for me. I still feel like that in this day and age to rely solely on audio as your initial means of evaluating a patient is a mistake. I think you're setting yourself up for mistakes clinically. The idea that we're going to allow an industry to be technology neutral. If you could imagine if medicine had been practiced technology neutral over the last decade, two decades, three decades, the idea that you're not going to roll with improvements in technology and how you progress seems like a poorly thought out process for patient care. Additionally, this idea that there's not access, every hospital in the state of Arkansas, no matter how rural, has telemedicine. I'm not against telemedicine. These hospitals utilize it in their emergency departments, but it's a landline. The ability is there to landline to any place you want to landline to in Arkansas. Now, is it going to cost money? Sure. But for the quality of care that you provide with visual versus audio, I think that technology is there and available. And that's the only comments I'm going to make. Thank you. Thank you,
▶ Play
Representative Johnson. I gave you some latitude there. There is no discussion because we ended the debate. So we have to vote immediately. Well, that was really no debate at all. It was just comments. You got a free one. We have a motion on the floor. Do pass. All in favor of the motion signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed nay. No. I'm going to say the ayes have it. Call the roll. Representative Johnson
▶ Play
Speaker 142 27:43
Representative Perry Representative Penzo Representative Coleman Representative McCollum Representative McCollum Representative Brown? Yes. Representative Kenneth Ferguson? Representative Kenneth Ferguson? Representative Gonzalez? Yes. Representative Gray? No. Representative Bentley? Yes. Representative Payton? No. Representative Womack? Representative Miller? Representative McGee? Representative Ritchie? Representative Ritchie? Representative Wardlaw? Representative Wardlaw representative love representative love vice chair Ferguson cheer ladyman yes
▶ Play
Where did he go? Representative Gonzales, your bill has passed, congratulations. Representative Warren, is Representative Warren in the room? No. REPRESENTATIVE SULLIVAN
▶ Play
REPRESENTATIVE LIGHTYMAN IS GOING TO RUN BILL 1650 50, if y'all want to pull it up on your pads.
▶ Play
Thank you, Madam Chair. Okay, Bill HB 1650 talks about certain provisions of the workers' compensation law. I'll try to introduce that, and then I have a guest here, if you would
▶ Play
Speaker 172 31:25
introduce yourself. Carol Worley. I'm with Asia, the Arkansas Self-Insured Association.
▶ Play
So, I'll try to hit a couple of bullets here, just some background information. Workers' comp is what we're talking about. It's a no-fault insurance. There are situations where an employee is injured on the job as a result of a third-party fault, like a car accident, vehicle accident. In these instances, while the employer or carrier pays benefits and expenses resulting from the injury, the employee can also pursue a third-party claim at an at-fault party. The employee is allowed to present those medical bills and compensate the employer as has been paid to establish their damages in a suit against the third party. When there's a judgment or a settlement with a third party, the employer may recover what they have already paid on behalf of the employee through the workers' compensation insurance. While the act was originally passed to provide for such recovery, this right has been altered by the courts that makes it somewhat ineffective. The proposed language in this bill would reinstate an employer's right to reimbursement from an at-fault party for benefits paid in a workers' compensation claim. So that's kind of the background for what this bill does. And then there's a second part to it, which is 11-9-7-14 prohibits the filing of groundless claims. There have been numerous Form C's filed with the Commission on claims that have no issues to be litigated or that simply are not pursued. Benefits are being or have been afforded to claimant in the majority of these claims, but the claims are not being litigated. Self-insured employers and carriers cannot close their claim files as long as a Form C is active. This bill will require claims to be dismissed by the commission without prejudice to the refiling of the same if there has been no formal hearing request within six months. So if there's no action in six months, these old claims could be closed. The dismissal is without prejudice to the claim being refiled within the structure of limitation period. So I'd like to let my guest elaborate on that, if you
▶ Play
Speaker 171 34:09
would. Yeah, so what it is is what we're trying to do. You want to introduce yourself? I'm
▶ Play
Speaker 172 34:15
sorry, Carol Worley again. Sorry. What we're trying to do is return the statutory right to reimbursement and workers' compensation claims where a carrier or a self-insured pays benefits associated with a work-related injury. If they file a third-party claim against the actual tortfeasor, the person or parties that caused the accident. then we want to be the workers' comp carrier or self-insured wants to be reimbursed if they get a settlement or a judgment. In 1993, the act was set out a formula that was two-thirds of the net proceeds, so the plaintiff's attorney takes their fee off the top of a third-party settlement, their third or 40%, whatever they have. And then up to two-thirds of the net proceeds of the remainder is what the carrier or the self-insured would be entitled to re-recover in the third-party action. The claimant would always get at least a third of the net proceeds. The second part of it is the dismissal bill, and this is kind of a cleanup thing. We have claims that are filed over there all the time that say we're seeking every available benefit under the act, and they do that because the Court of Appeals said that unless you claim every benefit under the act, the statute of limitations won't run so just they they do it every single time well there are claims that are filed and they just sit over there and nothing ever happens to them because benefits are being paid or they just don't want to pursue benefits so what we're we have is I've worked with a commission to come up with language so that claims that are not being pursued if after six months of inactivity from a litigation perspective we can request that they be dismissed They can refile them within the statutory time frame. It's free to refile a workers' comp claim. There's no filing fee or anything. So it would simply be so the insurance company or then self-insured can close their file and know that at some point in the future, the statute of limitations will actually run.
▶ Play
If anybody has questions, I'll be glad to answer them. Are there questions from the
▶ Play
committee? Representative Brown, you're recognized. I don't understand that. Could you put it in like, this is what
▶ Play
Speaker 172 36:30
it looks like in everyday words? Okay, both parts of it. Because one is Section 410, 119-410, and that's the right to reimbursement in third-party claims. And what we're trying to do is shift the burden of paying benefits or bills to whoever caused it, to the third-party at fault. So if it's a car accident, for instance, and your Blue Cross Blue Shield pays for your medical bills, When you collect in that car wreck, you pay Blue Cross Blue Shield back. We're trying to get, that was written into the act in 1993 as part of the grand bargain, is that we got it back. The courts have since diluted that by saying a claimant has to be made whole before you can get any money back. And so, in essence, you can never get any money back. You never get that right to reimbursement. So what I did is I went through and tracked the language of the public employee claims because their act has a 100% right to reimbursement. So they get all of their money back in the event there's a third-party claim. So I just tracked that so that we could have that same right with the self-insured employers or carriers here in Arkansas. The second part that's the cleanup is the dismissals. A claim for benefits is like filing a complaint in circuit court. And generally, if you don't pursue, you file a claim in circuit court or a complaint. After six months or so, it's dismissed administratively because you haven't done anything with it. And you can't just clog up the courts with filing complaints and not doing anything. And we used to have what we called an administrative dismissal in workers' comp. And then somewhere down the road, and Judge Greenbaum, no one can really figure out where down the road it happened. But somewhere down the road, they just quit doing it. And so now there are claims in there from 1999 that nothing's happening on, benefits aren't being paid, but the statute of limitations is told, and they could come back at any point in time and request benefits, even 20 years later. Now, we can argue reasonable and necessary. You know, we have defenses we can argue, but we still have to pay, you know, they have to pay an attorney to go and invite it, to address it. So what we're trying to do in that one is simply to administratively close claims that are stagnant, that aren't, there's no litigation pending. They're being paid because claims are paid all the time without a formal claim pending at the commission. But because they file the claim with the commission, then we have to get it dismissed before the self-insured or the carrier or the third-party administrator can close their file. Does that help? You're looking at me like, uh-uh. Yeah, I worked with the commissioners at the Workers' Comp Commission to come up with that language on the dismissal so that, you know, because we wanted several types of claims dismissed, and we agreed to
▶ Play
just address the ones that are stagnant. So you're just making this same for self-insured as well as you're saying you're representing a certain type of employer, like a self-insured employer.
▶ Play
Speaker 172 39:53
Is that what you're saying? So I am here. I sit on the board of the Arkansas Self-Insured Association, and I am on their legislative committee. I'm the chair of that. So that's who I'm speaking on behalf of. Although I represent self-insureds, insureds, unfortunately uninsureds, you know, the whole gamut of employers in the state of Arkansas. That's who all that is. Thank you. Sure. Okay. Seeing
▶ Play
no further questions, we have two people to speak against the bill. Jason Hatfield, am I saying that correctly? Yes. You're recognized. Thank you. introduce yourself and say who you're with turn your mic on can you
▶ Play
hear me okay my name is jason hatfield i'm an attorney in springdale arkansas through school i've worked every job in a poultry plant every job on a construction site. I worked in warehouses and loaded trucks through law school. I've dedicated my career to injured workers, okay? I've seen lots of injuries on the site, and I represent injured workers. I wasn't going to say much about this dismissal, but really quickly, last week I had four new clients come into my office that the insurance company was denying their surgery. The doctor had recommended surgery. The insurance company was denying it. They were like, I don't know what to do. I don't want to be here in your office, but I need this surgery and I need to get back to work. And so I filed a claim and on three of those within 24 hours, the surgery was scheduled. So I don't need to ask for a hearing at that point. I filed the claim. They're wanting to dismiss this, but what happens with this injured worker who gets his surgery and then he gets back to work, but maybe he re-tears that rotator cuff and he needs to go back to the doctor or he re-injures himself. They're wanting that future medical to be cut off and they're wanting the statute of limitations to run on it. And that's extremely unfair to the worker because they're going to have additional complications. And that's one of the things that they rely on is after they've been injured at work, that they can go back and get medical treatment for that injury without having to get it dismissed every six months and refile it. But the main reason I came here today was to talk about this made whole. Injured workers, by definition, are not made whole. They only get two-thirds of their wages, and that's capped at $695 a week. So if you're making $50,000 a year or more, you're not even getting two-thirds of your wages. Injured workers are not entitled to pain and suffering or quality of life. I've represented diesel mechanics that maybe tore their rotator cuff. They love to hunt. A result of that torn rotator cuff cannot climb. They cannot climb in their deer stand. They cannot pull a bow to deer hunt anymore. They're not compensated for that in workers' comp. Injured workers don't get to pick their doctor. The insurance companies pick their doctor, and the insurance companies send case managers to the appointments that bully the doctor and tell the doctor to do what they want them to do. So there are lots and lots of things that injured workers don't get. it is a very small percentage that can say hey there was somebody else that was at fault and let's make a claim against that other party. That could be a defective piece of equipment that maybe it is a car wreck and they hire an attorney and we go after whoever that wrongdoer is. They always defend by saying well that worker was injured because they weren't properly trained Or, well, that employer didn't properly maintain the equipment, and that's why it didn't work. And so their damages are cut by a percentage. And so that's why a lot of times the recovery is not as much. Right now, the way the law works is when we get a recovery, and let's just say from a third party, 90% of the time I'm talking with the insurance lawyer and saying, can we work out a deal? We'll pay you back this much. This much goes to the worker. And we usually work out a deal most of the time. But if we cannot work out that deal, if everybody's being unreasonable, the way this process works is we ask for a hearing in front of an administrative workers' comp law judge. Those judges are appointed by the governor of the state of Arkansas. And we can go in front of the judge. I can put on evidence. The insurance company can put on evidence and the judges can decide this is what's fair out of the settlement. I'm going to give this much to the worker. I'm going to give this much back to the insurance company. And whoever, if anybody doesn't like it, has the right, an absolute right to appeal that judge's decision to the Workers' Compensation Commission, which is a member of three commissioners appointed by the governor and it's a do-over. That workers' comp commission can look at the facts and decide what's fair. What is the fair distribution of this settlement? And if somebody's unhappy with that, they have the right to appeal that decision to the Arkansas Court of Appeals and the Court of Appeals can evaluate it. And if they don't like that, they have the right to ask the Arkansas Supreme Court to decide and that's how it works. and it's a court of equity and fairness and that's the way it works today and what this bill does is it flips it on its head and it ensures that the insurance company gets paid back at the expense of the injured worker and whether it's an insurance company or self-insured the injured worker didn't choose it the injured worker didn't choose whether you want to be self-insured or whether you just want to pay an insurance premium like my firm does and if somebody on my staff gets hurt, I turn it over to my insurance company and they take care of it. And I want my clients, my people that work for me to be taken care of. And if they can recover from somebody else, I hope that they're made whole. And I've got one example that I wanted to do just the math. If you are fatally injured on the job, your spouse is entitled to 35% of your wages, your average weekly wage. So let's just say I make $12 an hour. Let's say there was a shortage of the construction job and they're like, hey, we need you up on the roof. We haven't really trained you, but I need you up on the roof. And you have a defective product and you forgot to put on your harness and you fall off and you die. Well, you might have a claim for that defective product, but there's a lot of arguments that they shouldn't have put you on that roof. But back to, so your average weekly wage is $480. You've died and your wife, your spouse is entitled to 35%. Well, she's certainly not made whole by 35%. That's $168 a week. I just came up with a number of 450 weeks. That number comes up in workers comp. So if she's paid $168 a week. That totals $75,600. That's $8,700 a year that she gets paid until she remarries. And I'm not even talking about if they had children. Let's just leave it at that. So there's $140,000. The other 65% that workers comp didn't pay, there's $140,000 that she didn't get paid. You cannot live on $168 a week. You're going to be applying for government help. So she makes a claim against this defective product. And let's just say that she gets $140,000 in a settlement. She's made whole by that settlement. She does have to pay an attorney. Attorneys have to get paid. She doesn't have the money to pay them $250 an hour like an insurance company. She's got to pay a contingency. So after the cost of collection, we could argue, is she still made whole with the $93,600 that's left? She wouldn't be made whole, but we could argue with the insurance company. We could put it in front of a workers' comp judge, and the judge could decide it. Under this law, we can't put it in front of a workers' comp judge. we can't take it to the Workers' Comp Commission. The insurance company gets $62,000, and she only gets $31,000. It's totally flipped the script, and so this injured Arkansan didn't even get half of their damages, but the insurance company got almost everything back, plus they're keeping the insurance premiums that they were paid to take on this risk. So at the end, I mean, I'm certainly willing to answer any questions. I've spent 23 years of my life. This is what I do all day, every day. This bill is extremely unfair to the injured worker. I ask that you vote no. um we we've got it absolutely right right now that we've got these workers comp judges that can make the decision um typically we work them out anyway um but i'm certainly willing to answer any questions that anybody
▶ Play
has um i have any questions but uh representative perry you're recognized thank you
▶ Play
madam chairman in that particular scenario if if you had sued for the additional amount, would your client receive the full amount, or would your fee be 30 to 50 percent
▶ Play
of that? The fee typically would be one-third. In a product liability case, let's use product liability, and I'll give you an example. I recently was in litigation with a foreign company. They brought a zero-turn mower, and they wanted to compete with John Deere and compete with some other companies. And they didn't put a seatbelt and rollover protection on that zero turn. And I had a client that was severely hurt because of that. And we went into litigation. I spent $50,000 of my own money on engineers, on human factors experts, on medical experts. This foreign company flew me to New York City taking depositions, Atlanta. I spent all that money just to prove the case. It ultimately did settle, and I did get paid a fee. But ladies and gentlemen of this committee, this is hard work. These companies don't roll over and pay thousands of dollars without lots and lots of effort.
▶ Play
I hope that answered your question. Seeing no further questions, thank you. We have one other person to speak against, Paul Byrd. Is he in the room? You're recognized. If you'll introduce yourself and say
▶ Play
Speaker 196 52:19
who you're with. Hello, I'm Paul Byrd. I'm an attorney here in Little Rock. Like Mr. Hatfield, I represent people who've been injured or families who have lost a loved one. And one concern I have about this particular bill is particularly in the situation where someone has died, a family has lost a father, a spouse has lost a breadwinner, children don't have a daddy. when under Arkansas Wrongful Death Act, as passed by this body, in Arkansas Code 16-62-102, you can recover for your mental anguish, the loss of the consortium of your parent. In other words, we try to help the children get somewhere back to as normal as you can make them, to make them get through life. Well, what we have in that act, in Part E, is that no part of the recovery in this section is subject to the debts of the deceased or in any way becomes assets of the deceased person. So the father who has died, if he has debts or medical bills that maybe he lingered in the hospital for a week and a half before he died, those debts don't become part of his estate because we want the spouse and the children to be able to recover for what has happened to their loved one. But under this bill, that damage that they get will now be subjected to having to pay back the comp carrier. And the comp carrier becomes higher and special to every other creditor out there in the world that that father may have owed money to. So it's drastically changing that point over and above what he's talking about with the spouse that didn't get all their wages back because she had to pay some back to the comp carrier. So I think if you just focus on the Wrongful Death Act itself, we're totally changing the game here in a way that puts the comp carrier in a better position than any of you that may have loaned money to that particular person that died and gives them a special place under the law that I don't think they ought to have the right to be better than another creditor. And the public policy in this is to get that family back to where they can be as made as whole as they can and get by without having their dad. That's all. I have any questions. I'll
▶ Play
be glad to answer. I see no questions for the committee. Representative Lightingman, do you want to close
▶ Play
for your bill? Yes, I do, Madam Chair. Thank you very much. Well, I didn't quite follow all the last two presentations or how it relates to this bill. So let me try to simplify what we're talking about here. You know, I heard statements like the insurance company would be paid back at the expense of the injured employee. I don't see where they get that from, because all this bill does, it just asks for the recovery of the medical cost involved in this injury. That's all it asks for. It doesn't talk about the wages. it just talks about workers comp or the insurer can recover from a third party who pays because they were at fault they would pay those medical bills that are paid, that's all and those bills would be paid, those medical bills I don't know whether you noticed but in both of the people that spoke against this they get 100% of their cost and their profit off the top. Both of them said that they get their money off the top. So why wouldn't the insurance company get back what they paid for the medical bills? And that's all it is. The thing about the income and all, that's not related to this bill. I'll tell you, from working many years with workers' comp cases, it's a bad thing when someone gets seriously hurt. It's a very bad thing. I wish they could get 100% of their salary, but they don't. It's just not possible. So we're not even talking about that here. That's totally different. What we're talking about is workers' comp being able to get money from a third party. The car wreck is a good example of that other company being sued, paying money because they might be at fault, and workers' comp would take out of that payment and pay whatever medical bills there were. Now, why are they interested in that? And I hear them talk about large companies. Small companies pay workers' comp insurance, small businesses, and that raises the cost of workers' comp. So if these medical bills can be paid by a third party who's at fault, that keeps our workers' comp costs down. It helps our businesses, our small businesses. And all they're doing is paying the bills. That's all they're doing. They're not taking extra money. If there's extra money that comes from that third party for pain, suffering, or whatever, that still goes to that person. But a third of it off the top goes to the attorneys. You've heard that twice. So all this bill does is pay for the medical bills. So these other things that were talked about, that's not in this bill. The second part of it, I think there's some confusion about that. What it talks about are cases where there's no activity for six months. Maybe they've been there for a while, and there's been no activity, but it's open. Those could be closed, and then there was an example, well, they might need medical treatment later on, but the cases can be reopened. There's a process to reopen that case. if there's other medical bills that come up later on. So all that's doing is closing some of these cases. And some of these cases, I've seen cases, in my own personal experience, have been out there for 10 years that were not closed for whatever various reasons. But if there's no activity over a six-month period, the case could be closed. It can be reopened if there's additional medical costs involved in that. So I think it's a good bill. I think it would help businesses keep their costs down. They insure their employees, and they try to cover them. I think this bill would help keep that cost reasonable so that our workers' costs would be reasonable in this state. So I would ask for a good vote, and I make a
▶ Play
motion do pass. We have a motion do pass. Is there any discussion on the motion? um if not um all in favor say aye aye all opposed i i i say let's call the roll i i don't know
▶ Play
Speaker 142 1:00:06
representative johnson Representative Johnson Representative Perry Representative Penzo Representative Coleman Representative McCollum Representative Boyd Representative Brown representative Kenneth Ferguson representative Kenneth Ferguson representative Representative Gonzales, Representative Gray, Representative Bentley, Representative Payton, Representative Womack, Representative Miller, Representative Miller, Representative McGee, Representative Ritchie, Representative Ritchie representative Ward long representative Ward long representative
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:01:57
love representative love okay since she's the presider I call your name next Chair Ladyman? Yes. Vice Chair Ferguson? Yes? I'll pass. I'll
▶ Play
Speaker 215 1:02:14
pass. Okay. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6.
▶ Play
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. 8 to 6, the bill has failed. Sorry, would you like to run 1651? Thank you, committee. Yes. House Bill 1651
▶ Play
committee, sorry. House Bill 651. I'd like to ask DHS, if she's here, to come to the table.
▶ Play
Present your bill. Thank you. Do you want her to introduce herself? Yes, please. Hi, Melissa Stone,
▶ Play
Director for the Division of Developmental Disability Services with DHS. Okay, committee, this bill is 35 pages. I brought this to you last week. And I think some folks on the committee needed more time to look at it. the bill was originally filed, and then we had a lot of vetting of that bill, and I pulled that bill down, and a new bill was issued. It's basically the same bill, but there was a lot of word changes within the bill, so that's the reason for reissuing that. We had a lot of input from parents and other groups related to folks with disabilities, but what bill HB 651 does, it amends the laws regarding the treatment for individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities to ensure respectful language is used. So basically what it does, it changes the term mental retardation to intellectual and developmental disabilities multiple times. So if you'll look through that bill, it's maybe 100 times it's changed in there. It just changes two words over to those four words. There is a definition of intellectual and developmental disabilities. It's on line 13 through 24 on page 2, if you want to look that up. So it does define what that term means. But basically, that's it. There are a few other word changes throughout the document, but that's all it is. The purpose of the bill is to change that language to respectful language. And this has been worked on for a very long time, not just recently. They've tried to run this bill some other times, but we're not prepared to do that. So I would be open to questions, or did you want to add anything to that, Ms. Stone? You did
▶ Play
great. Okay. We'd be open for questions. i don't see any questions from the committee is that everyone get okay with your questions from last time um seeing no questions there's no one to speak for and against the bill oh i'm
▶ Play
Speaker 157 1:05:46
sorry are you signed up oh i don't see okay sorry jan
▶ Play
fortney i'm sorry i didn't see you on the list you're you're recognized us to, and you don't know if you're for or against, is that the, oh, okay, it said concerned, it didn't say for or against, okay, introduce yourself and tell who you're
▶ Play
with. My name is Jan Fortney, I am a mother and guardian of an adult child that's fixing to be 44 next week with intellectual and developmental disabilities. She lives at the Conway Human Development Center, and I'm also a guardian of another 78-year-old woman that lives in the same unit that she lives in. I was following this bill early on, the first bill, and I really appreciate these two helping us try to vet this and make sure the bill was right. I'm all about the respectful language. I mean, since nationally rose as a bill, that's something that's been needed. That does not change the diagnosis of my daughter. She still has microcephaly, mental retardation, and I'm okay with that. But there's a section on page 18 that I have a couple of concerns. Section 28, the first line says, emotionally disturbed individuals. That has been added back in. The first bill, it took it out and it replaced it with residents of Arkansas with then the diagnosis or intellectual disabilities. I really almost feel emotionally disturbed is one of those things that needs to be respectful as well. Our folks are not emotionally disturbed necessarily. You can treat an emotional disturbance a mental illness with medication you cannot, and people will get better and be able to function on a daily basis. But a person that has intellectual cognitive disabilities, they're not going to get better with medication and so that I think that wording needs to come back out and then also my second concern was throughout the bill that it says that the developmental disability services board in many many places and there's been a change that says is authorized too and they're changing everywhere to may um i don't know what the purpose of that was for my understanding is that board's going to continue to have its authority and powers so i'm not really sure what the reasoning was behind that part those are my only two concerns thank
▶ Play
you very much thank you and melissa maybe you could address these concerns i i guess the way I was explaining the bill is that it's really, it's updating it to current medical terminology as much as anything else. And you might address her other
▶ Play
concerns. Yes, Representative Ferguson. So DDS is grateful for Representative Laineyman for running this bill. We intended it to be a cleanup bill, but really there's no such thing, I don't think. We've done several versions and thought we were in a good spot. So on the last thing that Ms. Fortney, who I do highly respect her opinion on, is authorized to, changing that to May. It's my understanding that's a code revision cleanup piece. That was not anything that we specifically asked for. It's throughout the bill. On line 20, section 28, as we stated, there were several versions. That language was in the initial bill. It wasn't removed because, as Representative Ladyman said, we were trying to take out the words and use more respectful language and change out those words from mental retardation to intellectual and developmentally disabled. And where I understand Ms. Fortney's concern, it wasn't meant to be disrespectful to anyone to leave the language in there that
▶ Play
was there previously. I guess, is that acceptable current
▶ Play
medical terminology? Emotionally disturbed individuals. I'd have to go back and look. It's more of a behavioral health term, and I'm more of the DD side of the house at DHS, but I can definitely take it back and
▶ Play
ask. Okay. Any other questions from the committee? Do you have input?
▶ Play
Can I make a comment on that? Sure. If it's okay with Ms. Stone, we could go back and look at that term, Emotionally Disturbed Individuals. And, you know, if that could be changed to something more respectful, is the right word, we would be happy to do that on the Senate side, make an amendment over there if we can find a term that's better. Would that be acceptable? I think we got figured out. We'll just take those two words out. Okay. We'll just take them out on the Senate side.
▶ Play
Okay. You're recognized closed. There's no more for or against. I'm closed.
▶ Play
Speaker 235 1:11:28
I make a motion do pass. Okay. I have
▶ Play
a motion do pass. Is there any discussion on the motion? Seeing no discussion, all in favor say aye. Aye. All opposed? Your bill is passed. I don't think anybody else, I mean, if you go straight down, I don't think anybody else is here. I guess Michelle's ready
▶ Play
Speaker 238 1:12:07
to win a list. Well, if you go straight
▶ Play
down the list. Okay, we're going to keep going down the list. Yeah, she's, I mean, I don't think any of these people are here, you can ask, but I think it would get to her. Okay, we're
▶ Play
going to keep going down the list, and Representative Vaught is not here. Senator Irvin's not here. Senator Letting is not here. So, Representative Gray, are you ready to present? You've got two
▶ Play
Speaker 240 1:12:57
bills there. Which one do
▶ Play
you want to present first? 1687 or 1691? Let's do 1687. Okay.
▶ Play
actually let's you said 1691 if i could that'll be a fast one we could
▶ Play
get that one out of the way okay okay committee hb 1691 you're recognized
▶ Play
all right thank you mr chair so house bill 1691 is i think hopefully at the beginning of session we all heard representative sullivan's bill that dealt with EIDT or early intervention day treatment. Um, and I had made the comment in debate on the motion that I agreed with most of the bill. I just did not agree with removing the underserved requirement. So this bill is exactly the section four is word for word. What representative Sullivan's bill was that he brought before us. Um, just, I did not put any of the first part where we remove the underserved requirement out. So essentially this provides a rule that says that DHS has to promulgate rules for closure, sale, transfer, and expansion of certain facilities and services, and it puts a time frame on there. And I have the Craig Cloud is here with DHS if there are any questions for
▶ Play
him. Okay, committee, are there any questions? I'm seeing no questions. Did we have anybody signed up to speak? That is 16 minutes. All right, we have no one signed up to speak for or against. So, Representative Gonzalez, you had a motion? Have a motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your bill is passed. Thank you. Do you want to do your other bill, or do you want to wait on
▶ Play
that one? I can. No, I'd like to. 1687. Okay. You may proceed. Thank you, Mr. Chair. All right, committee. this bill, essentially what I'm doing is striking current law. So back in 2013, this statute was written that exempted health service providers from meeting the term employment. And so what this allowed to happen was it allowed home care providers to pay by 1099 or treat their employees as contract labor instead of as employees. And so I actually had a constituent call me last summer wanting to know why her travel wasn't covered. We went through the whole RUW-2, RU1099. So I kind of started researching it a little bit. And what I found was in 2013, the U.S., well, the Department of Labor passed a rule, a final rule that became effective, and it ended up going through the whole judicial process through the Supreme Court. So it became effective on October 13, 2015, that essentially says it gave protections to about 2 million home care employees that says that they have to be paid overtime and put a whole lot of essentially classified them as employees. So there had been a lot of ambiguity up until that point as how employees should be classified. So literally all I'm doing, and most of the, I say most of the providers, most of the home care providers in the state already treat their employees as employees. There are a select few. I haven't heard from any of them directly. I've heard from one business in the state indirectly that is opposed to my striking this language. but essentially all this says in the legislative intent is pretty clear that on and after the effective date of this act personal care services performed by an individual for a home and community-based service provider are no longer excluded from the definition of employment and then an individual performing personal care services for a home and community-based service provider is an employee of that of that business so that's essentially what this bill does i'd be glad to take any questions and i'm sure there'll probably be some for and against
▶ Play
on this one Any questions? Senator McCollum, you're recognized.
▶ Play
I'm just trying to understand why it seems like we're not allowing businesses to use independent contractors. If the independent contractors want to be considered independent contractors, and if the businesses think that works out well. Well, and that's just it. They're not independent
▶ Play
contractors, in my opinion. And so my thing is this. If I strike this language in the businesses that continue, if they want to continue to pay them as independent contractors, then they can work that out with the state. They can look at state law. They can look at federal law. If they still deem that they think they're independent contractors, then they're more than willing to go ahead and pay them as independent contractors. I just don't want to solidify it in code and essentially exempt them. So what we have is we have employees who, when you look at the IRS, you know, essentially the litmus test here, have got employees or people that are working for these home care organizations that I feel meet most of the criteria to be employees. So we're not paying in workers' comp on them. We're not paying in unemployment insurance on them. I mean, they're not paying in Medicare. Nothing is getting paid in on these employees. and these employees are essentially having to pay both the employer and the employee taxes when they file their taxes each year. So my thing is, essentially, if these businesses still feel that they are legal and doing 1099 or providing them as contract labor or presenting them as contract labor, then they can go ahead and do that, and they can work that out with Arkansas or the IRS at that point.
▶ Play
Follow-up? Yeah, you can have a follow-up. So you're saying you feel like that they're not following the criteria. Isn't that between the employee and the company to go through that
▶ Play
list of criteria? Absolutely, and I don't think state law should give them an exemption to federal labor law. I think you're absolutely right. I think by removing this exemption, it's totally at their discretion, and I'm not giving them a loophole to do that. I completely agree with you.
▶ Play
Representative Brown, you're recognized for a question. Thank you. Please tell me what it is that these companies do that indicate to you that the independent contractors are indeed employees. Do they tell them when they have to be at work? I mean, do they regulate them like an employee, what's considered an employee? Yeah, let me get it right here. Or do they just give them referrals? Well, I
▶ Play
mean, when you're, like, going into a home and doing personal care, they have to tell them who their patients are that they're going to go see. They have to follow certain state and federal guidelines as to what they can and can't do. There's a whole list of,
▶ Play
let me find it right here. Okay, but who's they? I need
▶ Play
to know who the players are that you're referring to. The business owner. The business owner. So the home care provider, so we'll call them the third party. So the third party tells these, we'll call them contractors, tells the contractors who it is, what patients it is that they are supposed to go out to the home and work with. So they tell them who they are. They may not specify you have to be there at 10 o'clock, but they specify how many hours they're approved for each week. So, you know, when you look at IRS, they go through pay basis, benefits, which most of the ones that are doing this are not paying benefits. Most in the state are paying benefits. Importance of the worker services. If the worker provides services that are integral to the success of your business, the worker is likely your employee. I'm pretty sure that actually following through and going to see the patients is integral to their business model. personal performance of services an independent contractor should have the freedom to hire assistants or subcontract work to other workers i don't think that they are allowed to subcontract their personal care to other personal care workers they have to perform the service themselves so they don't meet that setting the order or sequence of the work if you determine what gets done when it indicates you control how the work is performed allowing an independent to decide his or her schedule, both day-to-day and for the longer term. They don't get to dictate their schedule outside very small latitude. So this is my thing. If they want to continue to pay as independent contractors and they feel that that meets federal statute, federal law, federal IRS guidelines, then they have the freedom to do that. Me removing this language doesn't say they can't do that. I'm just not giving them the sole exclusion to do that. can i have a follow-up you have one
▶ Play
follow-up are these are these clients that are being serviced are they um are they clients of uh are being served by dhs um well they would be
▶ Play
like personal care services well i i know
▶ Play
but if you have a long-term care policy you can you'll have personal services in your home and you may not need dhs to get involved now that's completely different So if you're talking
▶ Play
about like someone that's a household employee or that is hired directly by the person themselves, then there are different guidelines, and they can be treated as contract labor. This is just when you bring a third party in to do it. So say my dad needs personal care at home. He doesn't have Medicaid, and he just wants to hire someone independently to come in and help give him a bath, you know, four times a week. He can do that, and he can still pay his independent contractor. There are some criteria. It's actually rather lengthy in the IRS code, but there are some criteria that he has to meet in order to do that. This doesn't affect that at all. That still is within the same parameters of how it – my bill does not affect that at all. My bill just affects if essentially the third-party companies that hire these employees to go out. So if my dad contacted a company, and I'm going to use AAA because I'm getting started saying company in my district, and I believe they pay by W-2, so they're not involved in this. But if my dad contacts the AAA provider and says, or White River Area Agency on Aging, and he works out with them to send someone, whoever it is they send, There are a few companies in Arkansas that still pay them as contract labor, even though they are dictating where they go. And most of what that employee does is integral to that business. But it does not affect if you want to hire personal yourself, if that makes sense. It does. Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And Representative Gray, finally, something before this committee I'm familiar with. So, well, in my other life, I hire contract auctioneers. Now, they work for other companies other than mine. They work for my company on this day and another company on another day. And they're professionally licensed auctioneers. But the IRS has taken a very close look at my business model, and it qualifies under all their code. I don't need anything written in the Arkansas code to give me an exemption. So can you give me a little, make me familiar with this company we're talking about. Do their independent contractors work for other companies, or are they sole providers for this company?
▶ Play
I think that other company might be here, and they might get answered that at some point, but it's my understanding that a large majority of them only work for this one company. And do you know if they
▶ Play
have any professional licensure status? That I do not know. Okay. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Representative Coleman, you're recognized for a question. Do any of these subcontractors or contractors, do they have a problem with this? Do they not happy with this relation?
▶ Play
I've been contacted by a few, and that's one that I have been contacted by, essentially. Why was she not getting paid for her travel time? Well, technically, I mean, if you look at this, the DOL rule that they passed in 2013, she should have, A, been, if she's under contract, or if she's an employee, she should have been paid. So they're saying you have to pay for travel time either by the hour or by the mile. You have to pay for something to cover travel time. So her being treated as a contract employee, they were not required to pay her for travel time to or from. and then I've heard from a couple that were hit they didn't realize that that's how it they were being paid until it came tax time and they were responsible for more taxes than what they had
▶ Play
Speaker 265 1:26:52
originally thought yeah you can have one
▶ Play
following okay and are the 1099s filed on them so that everything is that they're that they're paying their their taxes or at least the government's aware of
▶ Play
it well the the employee or the contractor that the company the company files their part just to show and then the employee or contractor would have to file their part of the 1099 so as long as everyone files their forms yes the taxes are being paid just in this particular situation everything's being paid twice by the contractor and not at all by the company where if you pay as a w-2 you have to put in employment taxes as a company you put in workers comp unemployment insurance and none of that's being paid by the company the company's not paying any benefits with contract labor representative mccullum you're
▶ Play
recognized for a question thank you so when you're saying they have the solo exclusion or they're they're using a loop or they have a loop who is who is the they
▶ Play
that we're talking about of a couple of in-home providers in the
▶ Play
state of Arkansas. So how is it a loophole if everyone in the business, everyone that's considered providing personal care services for a certified home, how is that a loophole if it's, if it's available for everyone? So it's because
▶ Play
most of the people that deem their employees as employees, don't feel that it's legal. They don't feel that they meet that litmus test for them to be contractors. And so, and that's, it took me a while to get here as well. And that was, I've talked to several people about, well, why did we exempt, if we exempt it on the state side, how are they doing it legally on the federal side? And so most of the people, most of the companies that do pay by W-2 feel that it's not legal to do it on the federal side. So they go ahead and do W-2 and treat them as employees across the spectrum. If the other company is here and is going to testify, they could probably answer to how they came to be, where they are. I think they might. Well, I'll let them testify to that, and I think it's pretty specific to just one company. If they're not here in closing, I will try
▶ Play
and tell you more. Representative Brown, you recognize. One quick question. Who pays these personal care providers, the person getting the care or the agency that sends them out?
▶ Play
The agency that sends them out. Thank you. Representative Johnson, you're recognized for a question. So is the intent here to just remove this exclusionary language and the intent then to allow whoever's paying these people to make the decision to treat them based on their own criteria, whether it's independent contractor or employment labor, W-2 labor? That's correct. It's just right now there's this exclusionary language that we're trying to remove. Okay. Okay, because part of this text makes me think it looks like we're trying to mandate that we pay them as an employee. And I put that
▶ Play
in my legislative intent. It's not in the codified section. Because that's
▶ Play
not in the codified. That's just the intent. I just want to clarify that point. That's my intent. In fact, if I may have a follow-up. Yes, you recognize. So we're not about to codify that we're mandating that these people are employees. We're just saying it's the intent of the legislative body. This is not part of the codification. The only part we're actually changing is we're removing this exclusion that says, by definition of employment according to the Department of Workforce Services, if you're doing personal care, that's not employment. We're just removing that exclusion. Is that correct? That's the only legislative thing we're doing. That's correct. And that's one of my concerns
▶ Play
was I didn't want to just strike this language and then somehow it be retroactive because then you have a law that's no longer on the books. I didn't want it to hurt anyone in arrears. So we essentially said from the effective date of this act, just try to put some legislative intent that moving forward this change
▶ Play
is to take place. Any other questions? Seeing none, we do have three people signed up, two to speak for
▶ Play
Speaker 99 1:31:30
the bill and one against. let's do it
▶ Play
for okay first to speak for the bill matt mcclure please introduce yourself and who you're
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:31:54
representing mr chairman members of the committee thank you for allowing me to speak i'm matt mcclure I serve on the Home Care Association of Arkansas board, but I am here speaking independently as the owner of Homestead Senior Care with offices in Little Rock, Hot Springs, and Searcy. Just to touch a little bit on what Representative Gray touched on, under our IRS guidelines, independent contractors, the agency can't control their work, how they do their job, when they show up. or they can't supervise them without appearing like their employer. The agencies that are doing all of these things not only do that, but they do pay directly to the contractor. And I think there's two big things that maybe haven't been touched on, and that is the misclassification of the employees. Some of the things that that employee is missing out is family and medical leave, health insurance, overtime, unemployment insurance, workman's comp, social security and medicare payments that are being made and then I think the biggest issue comes back to and we've taken on several patients in my offices of employees that I mean contractors that were hurt in a senior's home, and they were under the understanding that the agency was responsible because, and I can't speak for any agency directly, I can just tell you that the ones that we've come in behind have said that they were bonded and insured, and the agency is, but the independent contractor that goes in the home is not. And so if that independent contractor then is injured in any way, that liability falls back on the patient. And like I said, a couple of times we've been in a position where we've had to come back behind that and deal with the aftermath. Now, a senior that is trying to get help at home, that's not really fair to them because they don't know the right questions to ask. Making it to where everyone is a W-2 employee coming in the home it just kind of levels the playing field and it doesn't put a senior or their family member in a position where they have to ask the right questions to get the right answers and if they don't do that then and i'm not saying they're knowingly misled but they can be misled down a path that is different than what they perceive it to be and with that i'll be happy to answer any questions
▶ Play
that you have any questions from the committee representative brown You're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So do you provide services for DHS clients or just people who hire you? All of the above. Thank you.
▶ Play
Any other questions? Representative Ward-Long, you're recognized. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Matt, you and I have met before. When you look at this and you look at the ones that are doing it under independent contractor, it creates an unfair advantage when it comes to you guys because they're not paying that tax. When those guys go and file their taxes in January, they're not getting any checks back. They're having to pay that match and the taxes that they carried home at 1099. So it really puts a hindrance on these employees that are making minimum wage. Would you agree to that?
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:35:29
Absolutely. And I think as far as the industry goes, it would allow someone to offer a higher wage than maybe we can because we're providing health insurance. We're providing dental and vision and unemployment and workman's comp, and so it's really uneven, that playing field. Thank you,
▶ Play
Mr. Chair. Thank you, Matt. Any other
▶ Play
questions? Oh, Representative Ferguson, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Other than the salary, though, those additional benefits you're providing, they're not required benefits. You're just providing those. Is that right? I would
▶ Play
Chair Unverified 1:36:10
say some are required and some aren't. Unemployment insurance, pain, Social Security benefits, actually the health insurance because of the size of my company, we are required to do that. So I would say it's a combination of, you know what I mean, both of those things. Some are that we elect to do that because we think it's the right thing to do, and some are because we're required to. I think about the, I was just reading, I think it was last week, a situation where a person in another state was involved in this same situation, and they ended up going back and suing the family for Social Security benefits that they didn't pay in on them because they were an independent contractor. And, you know, I just look at it and say we're taking our most vulnerable population and we're putting them at a disadvantage of really knowing what is going on when it comes to the industry. They're concerned about one thing. They're concerned about that person that's coming in and taking care of them. And that's their only concern. And the truth is they shouldn't have to worry about this other side of the coin. Any
▶ Play
other questions? Representative Brown, you're recognized. I presume that
▶ Play
you do background checks. Yes, ma'am. Federal FBI. Are background checks required of independent contractors? Yes.
▶ Play
Thank you. Any other questions? Seeing none, thank you for your comments. Thank you. To speak against the bill, Rita Hurst and Quincy Hurst. Please identify yourself and who you're representing.
▶ Play
Speaker 295 1:38:10
Thank you, Mr. Chair and committee. My name is
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:38:13
Rita Hurst, and I'm speaking on behalf of my company, Superior Senior Care. I'm Quincy
▶ Play
Speaker 347 1:38:20
Hurst, speaking on behalf of Superior Senior Care. I'm really just here for questions. She's doing
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:38:32
the speaking. You may proceed. My company, Superior Senior Care, has been in business for 34 years, since 1985, and we have been a Medicaid provider for 27 years. There are several different models of in-home care. The business model that my company uses is that of a caregiver registry, which refers self-employed caregivers to individuals, seniors, to provide personal care to them. We are the oldest registry in the state, and we are one of the three largest Medicaid providers in the state and one of the most reputable providers. My company has 24 offices around the state. We have 160 administrative staff, and we are currently referring around 2,000 caregivers to approximately 1,700 Medicaid clients in all 75 counties of the state. And I mention Medicaid because I thought that this bill was only directed toward the caregivers who work for home and community-based providers. And I'm not sure if that's the case or not. If it's not, we refer many more caregivers to many more clients, which are private pay. And a little bit about the registry model. The registry model allows caregivers the freedom to set their own rate of pay. and this is usually based on their individual client's needs or the travel. They may live in a remote area. The travel time to get there may determine the rate they set. They have the freedom to work as much or as little as they choose. Their clients have the freedom to choose the caregivers that they think best fit their needs And likewise, the caregiver can choose the clients that they wish to work for. All of these caregivers are trained and certified. They all have background checks, drug testing, credential certifying, pretty much everything you can check for. and everything that's required by the state or by Medicaid. These caregivers are proud to be self-employed. They enjoy having the freedom of free enterprise, and I believe this bill is a government intrusion into free enterprise. Many of the caregivers on our registry have been on our registry for years. They want to be self-employed. this is how they want to work. They like having a flexible schedule, working around their family schedules or their own schedules. Many of these caregivers, if they were told had to become employees, would probably leave the caregiving industry rather than take a cut in pay. we know there are providers that are operating uh that are not operating properly and they are misclassifying workers we are not one of those companies superior senior care's business model has been tested legally and has been approved by the arkansas department of workforce services the IRS, and the U.S. Department of Labor. And all three agencies have issued rulings that we are operating properly as a bona fide registry. I'm definitely for eliminating the bad actors, and I believe there are ways that that can be done without destroying companies like mine who have a long-standing reputation for excellence in providing quality care um i'm not opposed to the repeal of this bill it's the language the non-codified language after the um the repeal and i feel like this uh and i don't have the bill i don't have it in front of me.
▶ Play
Speaker 303 1:43:19
Is there a copy? Just the repeal
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:43:29
itself with an amendment would take care of all the problems with it, I believe. Because it not only repeals it, it goes from calling, in the original bill, calling caregivers independent contractors to, in the non-codified language, saying that they cannot be independent contractors, that they have to be employees. So I would just urge you to
▶ Play
Speaker 304 1:44:02
vote against this bill for this reason. Okay, we
▶ Play
have some questions. Would you be willing to take questions? Of course. Representative Payton, you're
▶ Play
recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So you mentioned, I think you said, 160 administrative positions? Yes. Are they independent contractors or employees? They
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:44:27
are mainly employees. There are a few on administrative staff that are contractors, but the majority, over 100, are employees. Can I have some follow-ups? You
▶ Play
Speaker 308 1:44:36
can have one. I don't know which one I
▶ Play
want to go first. So earlier I asked whether these independent contractors work for other companies or are they exclusive to your company. Can you answer that? They can work for anyone they
▶ Play
Speaker 309 1:44:50
wish. Do they? And they do. Okay.
▶ Play
You want to put you at the bottom of the list? Thank you.
▶ Play
Representative Ferguson, you're recognized. Thank you. And as we all know, the 2013 DOL rule is what significantly changed everything in the state for us. Were you in the personal care business before the 2013 DOL ruling? Yes, since 1985. And you were, I'm sorry, you were working, they were working as independent contractors prior to that? Yes, they were, and we have been audited by the Department of Labor since then
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:45:29
and have the ruling that they are independent contractors. Okay, thank you. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. You indicated that this legislative intent paragraph is your problem. I just read through it for the fourth or fifth time sitting here. Is your problem the definition it gives of employment? Because it looked like to me reading that, it would be very difficult for you to pay them as contract labor without that in this bill. So can you explain why you want
▶ Play
Speaker 312 1:46:05
that taken out and what that does
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:46:13
to your employees? Um, well, where it says they are no longer excluded from the definition of employment and individual performing personal care services for a home and community-based service provider is an employee of the home and community-based provider and not an independent contractor.
▶ Play
Okay. Follow-up. Yeah. She didn't answer my question. You read it to me. I've already read it. I want to know why you want that taken out and what it does to you. So, I mean, I
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:46:48
can't even get my follow-up now because I needed this answer. We have been cleared by the Arkansas Department of Workforce Services to use independent contractors. We are using them properly. I believe this language could take that away.
▶ Play
Well, that's the whole point in the bill, is
▶ Play
it not? I think it is, yes. Thank
▶ Play
you. Representative Payton, you're recognized for a question. Thank you again, Mr. Chair. So you said that the people that you're classifying as independent contractors work for other companies are they professionally licensed in some way they're uh
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:47:36
certified nurses assistants okay and or personal care
▶ Play
assistants you have following okay so the u.s department of labor and irs has said that you can qualify them as independent contractors i don't see how us eliminating this section of code changes that i mean i have independent contractors that work for me and i don't have a section of code that says that they're independent contractors i have all of the irs and department of labor rules and everything else if they are happy and you're happy and your customers are happy there's nothing being done here that would force you to change your business model can you can you show me where i'm wrong
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:48:15
there well it's i mean i know this language at the end is not codified but i still think it might do away with the ruling that we have from department of workforce i'm not positive but i don't think it would thank you thank you mr
▶ Play
chair representative penzo you recognize for a
▶ Play
question thank you mr chair um you mentioned that you're a registry. Can you explain that and also answer if you schedule the people that work for you? Explain what a registry is?
▶ Play
Speaker 327 1:48:59
You said you're a registry. I'm wanting
▶ Play
clarification on what you mean by you're a registry and then I'd also like to know if you schedule your employees or the laborers? Okay, well, a registry,
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:49:19
we're licensed by the Department of Labor as an employment agency, which is also known as a caregiver registry. And a registry refers self-employed or independent contractors to others for employment and no we do not schedule the schedules are arranged between the clients and the caregivers follow-up is that you can have one
▶ Play
follow-up thank you um do you do you accept
▶ Play
Medicaid? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. Yes. I'll give the committee a little background. In 2013, I actually passed this bill that Representative Gray is trying to overturn. And at that time, the personal care agency in my town, I'm going to ask a question, but the personal care agency in my town came because the new 2013 DOL rule would have prohibited contract labor, and we passed this rule to protect those agencies that were doing contract labor because the Department of Labor was coming back on them and going to require them to pay several million dollars in unemployment taxes. I guess my question is, did you have that situation as well since you were in business before 13? And if this passes, is DOL now going to come back and say we want these millions of dollars
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:51:02
back in unemployment taxes? We did not have that problem in 2013. We have a ruling prior to that, and I can't remember the year, but we were audited. I don't remember how many years ago. And the Department of Workforce gave us the ruling that the caregivers are independent contractors and we did not have to pay any back taxes, no.
▶ Play
What happened at the time, there was a conflict between what the Department of Health was saying and what the Department of Labor was saying. And this language was passed to clear that up and allow contract labor so we didn't lose a lot of personal care workers. I mean, how would this affect your business? Would you lose personal care workers, or is that
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:52:00
still an issue? We would definitely lose some if they have to become employees, yes, a lot of them, yes.
▶ Play
Representative Brown, you're recognized for a question.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Pardon me for beating this drum. I'm just trying to get the concept. When these people that you refer go out and meet with a potential client, and they decide, the two of them decide whether that's going to be a compatible working relationship, which I'm sure they can change at some point in time, Does that client then pay the independent contractor, or do they pay you? And if they pay you, is that a convenience thing, or how does
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:52:52
that work? Well, yes. They can pay the caregiver direct, and the caregiver, in turn, pays us a referral fee. They can also pay into an escrow account, and we disperse the funds out to the caregiver and also take our referral fee from that.
▶ Play
Thank you. Representative Perry, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Okay, I'm going back to my insurance hat. If they're independent contractors, do they supply you with a certificate of liability and or work comp or a
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:53:33
work comp waiver? uh not typically they some carry their own liability insurance so that would we also carry you with that certificate yes we also carry liability insurance and work comp and we carry
▶ Play
workers comp and the certificate or the does the contractor provide you a certificate of work comp Uh, not
▶ Play
Speaker 330 1:53:58
usually. Occasionally, but no. Okay. Representative Warlaw, did you have a
▶ Play
question? I do, Mr. Chair. I'm lost. I actually have several questions, but I'll stick it to two as much as I can. You made a statement a while ago that you put this money in an escrow account, and then you pay. Do these people have Medicaid numbers? Are they Medicaid providers that you're paying out of this escrow account? Uh, we are a
▶ Play
Speaker 316 1:54:26
Medicaid provider. I'm not talking about you. I'm talking about the people you're
▶ Play
paying out of this escrow account. Are they Medicaid providers? The, the caregivers? These independent contractors. No, they're not Medicaid
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:54:41
providers. I mean, they provide services for Medicaid clients. Okay. My follow-up? One follow-up, yep. So, you're just right because I don't give one of them,
▶ Play
and I'll sit here for 30 minutes to wait on another one.
▶ Play
I'll get back in the queue, Mr. Chair. Representative Penzo, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Wardlaw kind of touched on what my thoughts were. If it is Medicaid payments coming in, um how how do you handle not scheduling and billing medicaid how do you i'm i'm i've got a background in uh physical therapy and i'm real familiar with home care and home health services so i'm kind of confused how um you're you just said you had insurance but they're independent contractors, and then you're billing Medicaid through an independent contractor, how do you make sure that, I mean, they're not employees, so how do you track what they're doing, and there's got to be some kind of a scheduling component. I don't see how you can bill Medicaid and not ensure that those people are on a schedule, and seeing the clients or patients they're supposed to be seeing at the appropriate times. Can you elaborate on that for me, please? Yeah. You want to take that one.
▶ Play
Speaker 347 1:56:20
Any of our clients who are on a Medicaid program, they have a plan of care through DHS. That lays out their basic schedule as far as how many hours a week, how many hours a month, how many hours even a year. The client works with the caregiver to determine specifics with that, such as what days of the week they want, what times of the day they work. That's the client direction component. But as far as how many hours, the overall schedule, that's laid out in the plan of care for Medicaid clients.
▶ Play
Representative Johnson, do you have a question? Yes, thank you, Mr.
▶ Play
Chair. So I'm still trying to understand this. This is back to the question Representative Payton had asked. I also work with employed physicians and care providers and also work with independent contractors, depending on, you know, how, whether they're working for us as their sole source of income or whether they have other sources of income. And, again, in my experience, that's been dictated by the IRS. They're the ones that control this. I'm having trouble understanding how this bill would affect your business model if there's nothing in here that codifies it. And it's my understanding this is really defined by the federal government and the
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:57:49
IRS and not at a state level. Well, again, I think it's the non-codified language that I have a problem with. If there was just an amendment put in there that, you know, referred to, you know, unless there has been, you know, that these workers would be employees and not independent contractors unless there has been a determination by the Department of Workforce Services or the Department of Labor. because I think the Department of Labor or Department of Workforce Services could look at this language and rely on that and say, well, I guess they're not independent contractors then if this says they're employees, if that's the legislative intent. You
▶ Play
Speaker 349 1:58:40
need to follow up? Okay. Would
▶ Play
you agree that the legislative intent is not codified in a statute? This is not something that's becoming law. This is just... I understand that. And also, would you agree that it's the IRS that really determines whether you're actually using people as independent contractors and employers appropriately, not the Department of
▶ Play
Speaker 296 1:59:06
Workforce Labor? Well, the IRS is looking at one aspect of it. The Department of Labor looks at whether a worker has been misclassified for wage and hour and overtime. And so, you know, different agencies are looking at different
▶ Play
components. Representative Gray, did you have a comment? It's unusual that you would ask a question of someone opposing your bill, but I will allow it, so go ahead. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
▶ Play
My question was, essentially, if they're being paid as contractors, you don't dictate their time, how do you bill Medicaid? Because you have to bill Medicaid in 15-minute increments for this service. So if they're not under your direction or control, how do you know what to bill Medicaid? That was my question as just a follow-up on what had already
▶ Play
Speaker 296 2:00:00
been asked. Okay, because the client and the caregiver are verifying the time to be billed under their plan of care. okay seeing no more
▶ Play
questions thank you for your comments we have one more person signed up to speak for the bill luke mattingly hello and i've been with you
▶ Play
Speaker 356 2:00:29
since nine so thank you very much for for seeing me please introduce yourself and who you're representing i'm luke mattingly with care LINC, and I represent the Area Agency on Aging Association. So we represent about 2,000 employees statewide, too, and so Superior Care would be my direct competition, so you can take that in the back of your mind as I'm talking here today. And I have a great deal of respect for Superior Care and the work that they do. But when we talk about employees versus contractors, um once we get our license we have exactly the same rules to follow we have all the same policies and procedures when we're in medicaid we have to do everything by the book and so we all have to obey those laws and regulations independent contractors were never established ever to be a close to minimum wage employee this was always for professional employees or skilled trades Literally, the IRS definition is people such as doctors, dentists, veterinarians, auctioneers for the gentleman known right, lawyers, accountants, independent skilled trades, business or professions. The very definition of this service is unskilled home health. So that's what we're talking about here is an unskilled home health person. We all have the same rates that we get paid for what we deliver. one of the things that has changed since 2013 was last year 2018 the DOL came out with further clarification about who makes an employer versus an employee clarifying language from 2013 some of the indicators of you are an employer include setting policies that require a caregiver to provide services in a particular way if you're a Medicaid provider in Arkansas you meet that definition.
▶ Play
Speaker 362 2:02:21
You're visiting a home to monitor a caregiver's
▶ Play
Speaker 356 2:02:25
behavior. By policy in the state of Arkansas, if you're a Medicaid provider, you have to assess and attend every 62 days your nurse has to go to that home at least a minimum once a year. You have to be there to assess the caregiver's behavior. Also, conducting performance evaluations of the caregiver. Again, Arkansas policy requires that as an agency, you conduct a performance evaluation on that employee or contractor every year. So by definition, these people are employees. As a result of this finding in 2018, the California Supreme Court just recently ruled that unskilled home health employees, in addition to some other contractors, are actually employees, not independent contractors for the entire state of California. If you want to hire someone, and Representative Gray used her dad as an example, you can hire an independent contractor to come in and take care of your father as long as you don't spend more than $2,100. Once you reach that $2,100 threshold, you are now an employer and you have to withhold FICA taxes and you're a household employer. So why does these other agencies have a special provision that excludes them from all these requirements? Again, you've heard it, but they don't pay workers' compensation. So when an If employees are injured in that home, they are driving up your hospital's uninsured cost, or they're out there on your Arkansas work program, driving up the cost of your Arkansas work program that should be covered by workers' compensation. They're not withholding that FICA or unemployment. If a client is injured, that client, by the contractor, they have fewer options of what they do about going back trying to get some restitution for the injury that they've sustained. and superior care just said they are one of the largest medicaid providers of home health in the state of arkansas so i just ask you as a legislator you have the largest medicaid provider in the state of arkansas that doesn't pay workers compensation they do not play unemployment they don't play fica that's medicaid money out there providing these services and you're allowing someone not to do those basic statutory benefits when the rules and regulations are exactly the same. I'm not an expert in this field. I do have some expertise in this field. And I have also consulted with labor attorneys at length, and they don't understand themselves how this model continues to sustain. But I think the 2018 clarification is what's creating a lot more concern about the 2013 bill. But also, Superior Care has been in business since the 80s. By eliminating this, they were in business before this 2013 bill came in. They can continue doing what they're doing and see if the federal DOL catches up with them. Thank you, sir. Representative Payton, you're recognized.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Sir, are you aware of any other business model in any other industry in this state that is afforded this type of privilege? I'm not aware of any, sir. Thank you. Thank
▶ Play
you, Mr. Chair. Any other questions? Seeing none, thank you for your comments. Thank you for the ability to speak. Okay. Representative, are you ready to close for your bill? I'm ready.
▶ Play
Thank you, Mr. Chair and colleagues. I know we're ready to go home. I'll try and make this quick. Essentially, all I'm doing is striking this state-sponsored loophole that we have here and saying if they believe that they can pay through independent contractors, they're more than welcome to do that. It simply falls back to what state labor law and federal labor law will allow them to do or not do. One of the other things I just wanted to say was, I mean, either they have some control and they should be treating them as employees, or they don't, and if they don't have the control, then maybe we need to look at it from a Medicaid perspective that they're not actually taking care of the patients the way Medicaid dictates in statute and reg that they actually take care of the patients. I mean, they did mention that they have liability in workers' comp. They do have liabilities in workers' comp that applies to their employees, but not to their contractors. I just wanted to clarify that those contractors are totally independent from the workers' comp and liability that they mentioned before. So, anyhow, committee, I just thank you for listening to this debate, and I would appreciate a good vote on this and just helping. Essentially, this takes care of some of our lowest paid workers in the state. It will make sure that they have the full benefits that are afforded to everyone else in the state of Arkansas when it comes to unemployment, workers' comp, and all the benefits that the companies have to offer. So,
▶ Play
with that, I make a motion. Do pass. We've got
▶ Play
a question. for you, Representative Ferguson? Actually, I have a request. I guess after talking to the Attorney General's office, my concern is exactly what I expressed earlier. When we passed this bill, the Arkansas Department of Labor was going to come back and retroactively charge these personal care people millions of dollars because in unemployment and Medicare and employee taxes. I guess I would like to see you add an amendment that protects them from retroactive collection of taxes that they have considered to be functioning legally under the contract labor law. That's my biggest concern. That's the reason we passed the bill in 2013 was for protection from retroactive collection of taxes when people thought they were functioning legally. And that's, so I will answer with this. I'll be glad to
▶ Play
talk with BLR. I actually specifically asked that of BLR, which is where we didn't have a do not codify section originally, and we added the do not codify section that specifically says on and after the effective date of this act so that it could not be done retroactively. But I will be glad to get with AG's office or BLR, And if there's something else we need to add in here to make sure that, because that's not my intent, it's to be retroactive, that we will add that. And we could add it on the Senate side, if that's agreeable to the committee. Okay, thank you. Did you have
▶ Play
any more comments, Representative Gray? No, sir, I'm done. You're closed? Yes. You have a motion? Motion do pass. I have a motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing no discussion. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Nay. Ayes have it. Your bill is passed. Thank you, Chair. Committee. Okay, Committee, we've got two more. We're not done. We're not done. Representative Perry has a small bill, and Representative Lundstrom has some bills that she's been waiting to present, so I'm going to let her do that. Representative Perry, go ahead.
▶ Play
You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Simple bill, real easy bill. I'd actually ask for Ann Purvis to join
▶ Play
me. Okay, and this is HB
▶ Play
1547? Yes, HB 1547. Actually, it's just today. I asked Mr. Price to please pass those out. It's not on the tablet. So you have an amendment? The amendment is the bill. Okay. It's a one-page, two paragraphs.
▶ Play
It is on the tablet. It is? Yes, it is. 1547, yes. That's not the right amendment. That's not the right amendment. The one today is the right amendment. Okay, we'll pass that out. Bear with us here. We've got to find it in the stack here.
▶ Play
If it was complicated, I wouldn't ask the members to. It's late. Can you explain the amendment a little bit while we're handing this out? I'd be glad to. The amendment has to do with the license for EMTs. It's brought to us by the Ambulance Association. Ms. Purvis can explain it more in detail for me, because it's Ambulance Association and the Department of Health work together on it. Please
▶ Play
introduce yourself. Thank you, Mr. Chair. My name is Ann Purvis. I'm Deputy Director of the Arkansas Department of Health. What this amendment does and what the bill does is require for the EMTs, the EMS licensees, to get national certification and maintain that national certification. That national certification is the same standards that we do have in Arkansas. However, this would allow that reciprocity and also for them to go to other states. It really dovetails nicely with our emergency preparedness efforts. If we have to go to another state or somebody comes into our state, we'd like them to have that national certification so we're sure that everybody has the same standards. And that's the purpose of this bill.
▶ Play
Speaker 382 2:12:10
Any motion on the amendment? I'll make a motion.
▶ Play
Okay. I have a motion to accept the amendment. Any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries your amendment has been adopted. You may present the bill as amended. The amendment is the bill. Any questions on the bill as amended? We're making it
▶ Play
easy on y'all. Any questions from the committee? Representative Gray, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Just a quick question. So I'm on the EMS board up in my county. This national certification, will this cost the EMS businesses additional money?
▶ Play
The national certification fee is $20 a year, and most of the EMSs pay that fee already as part of that national certification. There are going to be two provisions. There are about 300 that did not have the national certification at the time of licensure, and they're kind of grandfathered in. So they don't have to get that national certification. But for everybody else that became licensed in Arkansas, they had that national certification at the time of licensure. They might have let it lapse, but they need to keep it current. So it's $20 a year. Okay, thank you. Representative Gray, the reason we didn't
▶ Play
add the amount of the fee in here is because if the fee changes, you've got to go back to rules. Any other questions? Seeing none, are you
▶ Play
ready to close for your bill? No one's here to speak for or against the bill. I'm closed, Mr. Chairman. Do you have a motion? Motion do pass. I have a motion do pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. Your bill is passed. Representative Lundstrom, are you ready? which bill do you want
▶ Play
to present I'll start with 1752 and colleagues I've been with you since 9 o'clock this morning so I'm extremely grateful to be here you may proceed thank you this bill is a minimum wage Act. It's a very controlled, tightly done bill. It directly impacts the minimum wage in Arkansas. The voters passed a 925 wage increase. This is going to impact our small businesses, nonprofits, and it will impact our developmental services. This keeps it at the 925, but when the increases come to 10 and 11, that's going to be a hard time for our small businesses and our nonprofits under a million dollars. This adds a structured and tightly reserved way of helping those catch their breath, and hopefully they will catch up quickly. They're going to have to compete for workers. This will give them a few years to do that, and then competition will take over after that, and those wages will go up. With that, I will entertain a few
▶ Play
questions. Any questions from the committee. Seeing none, we have no one signed up to speak for or against the bill. Are you ready
▶ Play
to close for your bill? Yes, sir. I had included a long speech, but due to the length of the day, I
▶ Play
would just appreciate a good vote. What's the will of the committee? Representative Bentley? I have a motion of due pass. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. All opposed, nay. Motion carries. The ayes have it. Motion carries. Thank you
▶ Play
for your kindness, colleagues. This next one is very passionate to me. This is about teenagers. This is House Bill 1753. There is an amendment on it. Actually, it involves, we need to adopt that first. The amendment is on the tablet. All right. This has two changes on it. It drops it down to below, from 20 to below. So basically this impacts teens, 16, 17, 18, and 19-year-olds. Removes the age, or excuse me, education component. So it's much easier, much better, much more structured. So I appreciate the input from folks. So it made a good bill much better and much easier to digest. I'm extremely worried about teens not having a chance to get their soft skills, learn that the boss is right, learn to work with the public, be on time. Once you get a good teen that's willing to work, their wages are going to go up. But when those wages are $10 and $11, they're not going to get those first-time jobs. This will give those employers a break that are willing to hire teenagers at that $9.25, find out they're great kids, and their wages will go up after that.
▶ Play
Representative Gray, did you have a motion? Have a motion to adopt the amendment. Any discussion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. The amendment is adopted. You may discuss the bill
▶ Play
as amended. Thank you, colleagues. All of you remember your first-time jobs and what all you learned. I'd like for teenagers to have that opportunity. When those wages go up to $10 and $11, they're not going to get that opportunity. Nobody's going to hire a 16-year-old at $11 an hour. And I'd like for them to have that shot, get to know those kids, and then their wages will go up.
▶ Play
With that, I'll entertain any questions. Any questions from the
▶ Play
committee? Representative Boyd, you're recognized. I know it's like you and I talked. I've got to ask this. Yes, please. Is this going to somehow disproportionately encourage hiring of teenagers versus 20 and up? That's the concern that I've had that I just want you to
▶ Play
address. First of all, I don't think it will disproportionately hire teenagers. I think it will give people an opportunity to hire teenagers. And I think once they get to know these teenagers and find out that they're great hard workers, those wages will go up. I'm hoping that people will hire teenagers. But over time, they're going to have to compete for the wage force just like everybody else. One follow-up. Very quickly. And
▶ Play
just so I'm crystal clear. Once you hit 20 years old, then you all of a sudden. You're out there with everybody else. So you would have to, if you were making 9 1⁄4, you'd automatically have to go up.
▶ Play
You're automatically going to go up. But let's be clear. Anybody that's 9 1⁄4 is a starting wage. Anybody that can fog a mirror, show up on time, understand how to work with the public, their wages are going to go up, and they're going to go up quickly. This is a place, $9.25 or a minimum wage is a starting wage, a training wage. If you do a good job, your employer is going to keep you and they're going to pay you more. That's a reality because you want good people and you've got to keep good people.
▶ Play
Representative Ferguson, you're recognized for a question. Will this
▶ Play
require 66 votes in the House? Yes, this will retire two-thirds. Any other questions? Seeing none, we have no one signed
▶ Play
up to speak for or against the bill. Are you ready to close for your bill? I would appreciate a good vote. What's the will of the committee? Representative Bentley, do you have a motion? I have a motion of due pass as amended by Representative Bentley. Any discussion on the motion? Seeing none, all in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. Aye. All opposed, nay? Aye. Motion carries. Congratulations. Your bill is passed. Thank you, colleagues. My
▶ Play
last one is just a cleanup bill. There's a couple of things in here that I will call your... Oh, I'm sorry.
▶ Play
Speaker 248 2:20:31
I know we're all tired. Is this HB 1751? Yes. Okay.
▶ Play
You may proceed. We're all going to get silly, I know. 1751 is a cleanup. up. It cleans up some old language, including a, believe it or not, people used to pay 30 cents for employees that engaged in boarding, lodging, apparel, that type of thing. And then it adds a correction, employees that want to get their paychecks in a card or debit card. I'm showing my age here, but I can't imagine that. I like a paycheck, but you got to get with it these days. um so there's some corrective language and then also the very last one an employer that fails to make payment under a certain subject subject i'm tired anyway um they would have to pay double after seven days so you got to you got to pay people what they're due and you got to pay it within seven days and that's the rest of the corrective language and i appreciate a good vote how's that for fast any
▶ Play
questions from the committee seeing none no one signed up to speak for or against the bill you ready to close for your bill I'll answer it are you closed yes sir what's the will of the committee Representative Bentley you're recognized have a due pass from Representative Bentley any discussion on the motion seeing none all in favor signify by saying aye all opposed nay motion carries your
▶ Play
bill has passed congratulations. Thank you colleagues and thank you for being here since 9 o'clock in
▶ Play
the morning and your indulgence. Members thank you for staying with us we got through a lot of bills we are adjourned
▶ Play

Agenda

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1177 S. Meeks TO PROTECT EMPLOYEES FROM FORCED HUMAN MICROCHIP IMPLANTATION.

-1:11 - 2:09:58 420 segments 50 speakers

Representative Stephen Meeks introduced HB 1177 to protect employees from forced human microchip implantation and opened the floor for questions, receiving none. [0:00]

The chair moved to concur on the measure, a motion was made by Rep. Payton and adopted without debate. [0:12] [0:35]

The committee then turned to HB 1220, where Rep. Kenneth B. Ferguson presented an amendment that removed the standard-of-care language and substituted store-and-forward technology language, which was adopted by unanimous consent. [1:21] [1:31] [1:34] [1:37] [1:42]

Ferguson explained that the amendment allows patient visits to be established using store-and-forward technology to transfer medical records, and Rep. Karilyn Brown asked for clarification on that term, which Ferguson defined as the capability to transfer records from point A to point B. [2:24] [2:56] [3:29] [3:33] [3:43]

HB1439 Lundstrum TO CREATE THE CHERISH ACT; AND TO PROHIBIT ABORTIONS AFTER EIGHTEEN(18) WEEKS' GESTATION EXCEPT IN A MEDICAL EMERGENCY.

REGULAR AGENDA

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1433 Rushing TO AUTHORIZE INDIVIDUALS WITH PRIOR DRUG-RELATED OFFENSES TO WORK WITH INDIVIDUALS RECEIVING SUBSTANCE ABUSE TREATMENT AS PEER SUPPORT SPECIALISTS OR SIMILAR POSITIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1536 D. Douglas TO CREATE THE COMPASSIONATE CARE END-OF-LIFE OPTION ACT; AND TO EXEMPT THE COMPASSIONATE CARE END-OF-LIFE OPTION ACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF" PHYSICIAN-ASSISTED SUICIDE".

HB1527 Cozart TO CREATE THE RED TAPE REDUCTION SUNRISE AND SUNSET ACT OF 2019; AND TO REQUIRE LEGISLATIVE REVIEW OF OCCUPATIONAL AUTHORIZATIONS AND OCCUPATIONAL ENTITIES.

HB1547 Perry TO ENSURE THAT PERSONS LICENSED TO PROVIDE EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES OR ADVANCED LIFE SUPPORT RESCUE SERVICES MAINTAIN CONTINUAL NATIONAL EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES CERTIFICATION.

2:09:58 - 30:49

The chair introduced the amendment and Rep. Mark Perry asked for clarification; Ann Purvis, Deputy Director of the Arkansas Department of Health, explained that the amendment would require EMTs and other EMS licensees to obtain and maintain a national certification, creating reciprocity with other states. [2:10:13] [2:10:50] [2:11:20] [2:11:27] [2:11:52]

A motion to accept the amendment was made, no discussion followed, and the committee voted unanimously to adopt the amendment, so the bill was presented as amended. [2:12:10] [2:12:18] [2:12:23]

Rep. Michelle Gray queried the cost to EMS providers; Purvis said the fee is $20 per year, with about 300 existing licensees grandfathered, and the committee then closed the bill and passed it without further opposition. [2:12:46] [2:13:01] [2:13:34] [2:13:37] [2:13:44] [2:14:04]

SB275 Bledsoe TO CLARIFY LAW REGARDING OUT-OF-STATE PHYSICIANS WHO PRACTICE PATIENT CARE SERVICES INITIATED IN THIS STATE THROUGH THE USE OF ANY MEDIUM.

SB340 Irvin TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING CONSENT TO MEDICAL TREATMENT TO AUTHORIZE A LIAISON UNDER THE FEDERAL MCKINNEY-VENTO HOMELESS ASSISTANCE ACT TO CONSENT TO MEDICAL TREATMENT FOR A HOMELESS MINOR; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1555 A. Collins TO INCREASE COVERAGE FOR MEDICATIONS APPROVED BY THE UNITED STATES FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION FOR TOBACCO CESSATION IN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM.

HB1435 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO REIMBURSE FOR RIDE SHARING APPLICATIONS.

SB380 G. Leding TO MODIFY COVERAGE FOR SCREENING MAMMOGRAPHY AND BREAST ULTRASOUND FOR THE DIAGNOSIS OF BREAST DISEASE SUCH AS CANCER AND FOR THE EVALUATION OF DENSE BREAST TISSUE AS AN ESSENTIAL HEALTH BENEFIT.

HB1568 L. Johnson TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ADVISORY COUNCIL OF HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONS WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH.

SB341 Irvin TO AMEND THE WOMAN'S RIGHT-TO-KNOW ACT; AND TO PROVIDEING FORMATION ON REVERSING THE EFFECTS OF ABORTION-INDUCING DRUGS.

HB1642 Warren TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING COSMETOLOGY AND OTHER RELATED OCCUPATIONS; AND TO REMOVE THE CERTIFICATION FOR NATURAL HAIR BRAIDING.

HB1649 Sullivan TO PROVIDE FOR OPPORTUNITIES FOR PATIENT CHOICE AND PROMOT EQUALITY OF CARE AS A REQUIREMENT FOR LICENSURE AND CERTIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROVIDERS.

HB1650 Ladyman TO AMEND CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW THAT RESULTED FROM INITIATED ACT NO. 4 OF 1948; AND TO REVISE THIRD- PARTY LIABILITY IN THE WORKERS' COMPENSATION LAW.

30:49 - 1:15:27 118 segments 17 speakers

The chair, Rep. Jack Ladyman, introduced HB 1650 and explained that it would reinstate an employer’s right to reimbursement from a third-party when workers’-comp benefits are paid, and would add a six-month “inactive-claim” dismissal provision to close stagnant files. [30:58] [31:25] [31:32] [32:10] [32:41]

Opponents-including attorney Jason Hatfield, who argued the bill would unfairly shift recovery from injured workers to insurers, and attorney Paul Byrd, who warned it would jeopardize wrongful-death beneficiaries by making the compensation carrier a preferred creditor-testified against the measure. [40:47] [40:58] [41:31] [42:04] [42:36] [43:06] [43:39] [44:12] [44:47] [45:17] [45:48] [46:19] [46:52] [47:25] [47:56] [48:29] [49:06] [49:39] [50:10] [52:19] [52:32] [53:05] [53:35] [54:10] [54:41] [55:12]

A motion to pass the bill was offered by Rep. Deborah Ferguson; after brief discussion the committee voted, and the measure failed. [59:50] [1:00:06] [1:00:39] [1:01:23] [1:01:57] [1:02:14] [1:02:28]

HCR1008 Vaught TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF ORGAN DONATION TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND TO SUPPORT AND ENCOURAGE ORGAN DONATION AND AWARENESS.

SB339 Irvin TO PROHIBIT THE REQUIREMENT OF, BARRING OF, AND DISCRIMINATION AGAINST A PHYSICIAN FOR HIS OR HER DECISION TO NOT PARTICIPATE IN MAINTENANCE OF CERTIFICATION.

SB446 G. Leding CONCERNING STEP THERAPY REQUIREMENTS FOR CERTAIN PRESCRIPTION DRUGS TO TREAT METASTATIC CANCER.

HB1687 M. Gray AN ACT TO AMEND THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES LAW; AND TO AMEND AN EXCLUSION FROM THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYMENT" WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES LAW.

1:15:27 - 1:13:27

Rep. Michelle Gray explained HB 1687, which amends the Department of Workforce Services law to remove the exemption that allowed home-care providers to treat workers as independent contractors, thereby classifying them as employees for wage-and-hour protections. [1:15:36] [1:16:09] [1:16:40] [1:17:13]

Rep. Austin McCollum asked for clarification on why the bill would limit businesses’ ability to use independent contractors, prompting further discussion of the bill’s impact. [1:17:43] [1:17:58]

HB1688 M. Gray TO ESTABLISH COST-REPORTING FOR ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES TO THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES AS A CONDITION OF PARTICIPATION IN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM.

HB1691 M. Gray TO REQUIRE THE DIVISION OF DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES SERVICES OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES TO PROMULGATE RULES FOR CLOSURE, SALE, TRANSFER, AND EXPANSION OF CERTAIN FACILITIES AND SERVICES.

1:13:27 - 1:18:08 13 segments 3 speakers

Rep. Michelle Gray introduced HB 1691, which requires the Division of Developmental Disabilities Services to promulgate rules governing the closure, sale, transfer, and expansion of certain facilities and services, and sets a timeline for such rulemaking. [1:13:30] [1:13:44] [1:14:17]

No committee members requested testimony, and a motion to pass the bill carried without opposition. [1:14:28] [1:14:58]

HB1696 Gonzales TO AMEND THE ARKANSAS CLEAN INDOOR AIR ACT OF 2006; AND TO ALLOW PRIVATELY OWNED BUSINESSES THE OPTION TO PROHIBIT SMOKING.

HB1699 Eaves TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING SALES OF RAW MILK TO AUTHORIZE THE SALE OF RAW SHEEP MILK.

HB1707 Capp TO AMEND THE ADULT AND LONG-TERM CARE FACILITY RESIDENT MALTREATMENT ACT; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

1:18:08 - 1:03:01

Representative Michelle Gray introduced HB 1707, explaining that it would eliminate the statutory exemption that treats personal-care workers employed by third-party home-care agencies as independent contractors, thereby restoring employee status for state and federal labor-law purposes and closing the “loophole” that leaves workers without workers’ compensation, unemployment insurance, and proper tax withholding. [1:18:14] [1:18:46] [1:19:16] [1:19:29] [1:19:47] [1:20:18] [1:20:22] [1:20:34] [1:20:38] [1:20:53] [1:21:27] [1:22:00]

The committee heard extensive testimony, with industry witnesses such as Matt McClure of the Home Care Association arguing that misclassification deprives workers of benefits and creates liability risks, while Rita and Quincy Hurst of Superior Senior Care and other registries described their compliant caregiver-registry model and warned that the bill’s language could impose retroactive tax liabilities; legislators also raised concerns about Medicaid billing, travel-time pay, and the impact on for-profit and nonprofit agencies. [1:24:50] [1:25:29] [1:25:39] [1:25:52] [1:26:01] [1:26:38] [1:26:52] [1:26:54] [1:27:05] [1:27:09] [1:27:44] [1:27:57] [1:28:04] [1:28:19] [1:28:24] [1:28:52] [1:29:20] [1:29:30] [1:30:03] [1:30:12] [1:30:15] [1:30:34] [1:30:53] [1:31:06] [1:31:18] [1:31:30] [1:31:37] [1:31:40] [1:31:54] [1:32:13] [1:32:46] [1:33:19] [1:33:56] [1:34:26] [1:34:42] [1:34:46] [1:34:59] [1:35:02] [1:35:29] [1:35:50] [1:35:55] [1:36:00] [1:36:10] [1:36:31] [1:37:03] [1:38:10] [1:38:13] [1:38:20] [1:38:32] [1:38:43] [1:39:15] [1:39:52] [1:40:22] [1:40:52] [1:41:28] [1:42:08] [1:42:39]

After the discussion, Chair Rep. Jack Ladyman moved to pass the bill, and Rep. Gray indicated willingness to consider an amendment proposed by Rep. Deborah Ferguson to protect agencies from retroactive tax collection, though no final vote was recorded in that portion of the hearing. [2:07:23] [2:07:27] [2:07:36] [2:08:07] [2:08:25] [2:08:39]

The committee subsequently approved HB 1707, the amendment to the Adult and Long-Term Care Facility Resident Maltreatment Act and the emergency declaration, by voice vote after no further discussion, and Chair Ladyman announced two additional measures, with Rep. Mark Perry then introducing HB 1547-a brief, two-paragraph bill requesting Ann Purvis’s participation and noting it was not on the tablet, effectively treating the amendment as the bill itself. [2:09:09] [2:09:40] [2:09:51] [2:09:55]

SB342 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD; AND TO AMEND THE LICENSING REQUIREMENTS OF CONTRACTORS.

HB1451 A. Collins TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM; AND TO EXCLUDE CHILD SUPPORT PAYMENTS FROM GROSS INCOME USED FOR ELIGIBILITY DETERMINATION.

SB172 G. Leding TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING SOCIAL WORK LICENSING; TO CLARIFY HE LICENSING EXEMPTION FOR STUDENTS; AND TO CHANGE THE TERM "RECIPROCITY" TO "ENDORSEMENT".

HB1471 C. Fite TO CREATE THE MENTAL HEALTH FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE DEAF OR HARD OF HEARING BILL OF RIGHTS ACT.

HB1651 Ladyman TO AMEND AND UPDATE THE LAWS REGARDING TREATMENT FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH INTELLECTUAL AND DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; AND TO ENSURE RESPECTFUL LANGUAGE IS USED WITHIN THE ARKANSAS CODE.

1:03:01 - 2:20:37 281 segments 39 speakers

Ms. Melissa Weatherton (Director of the Division of Developmental Disability Services) presented HB 1651, noting it updates Arkansas law by replacing “mental retardation” with “intellectual and developmental disabilities” and makes other respectful-language changes. [1:03:07] [1:03:25] [1:03:38] [1:04:14] [1:04:44]

Parent advocate Jan Fortney raised concerns about the retained phrase “emotionally disturbed individuals” and the shift from “authorized to” to “may” for the Developmental Disability Services Board, prompting Rep. Ferguson and Ms. Weatherton to agree to consider further wording amendments. [1:06:19] [1:06:30] [1:07:03] [1:07:38] [1:08:12] [1:08:42] [1:08:50] [1:09:10] [1:09:16] [1:09:46] [1:10:16] [1:10:21] [1:10:25] [1:10:43] [1:10:48]

The committee moved to a motion to pass the bill, heard no further discussion, and adopted it unanimously. [1:11:28] [1:11:32] [1:12:05]

HB1265 M. Gray TO AUTHORIZE FULL INDEPENDENT PRACTICE AUTHORITY TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES WHO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS.

HB1710 Perry TO CREATE THE TASK FORCE ON TRANSPORTATION OF NONEMERGENCY BEHAVIORAL HEALTH PATIENTS.

HB1711 Burch TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING GUARDIANSHIP SUBSIDIES OFFERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES; TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "CASH ASSISTANCE"; AND TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING COURT- ORDERED CHILD PLACEMENTS.

HB1712 Wardlaw TO REPEAL THE LAW REQUIRING THAT INFORMATION OBTAINED ON HOME HEALTHCARE SERVICES BE CONFIDENTIAL.

HB1717 M. Gray TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED UNDER THE ASSISTED LIVING WAIVER PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1719 M. Gray TO UPDATE THE MEDICAID FRAUD ACT AND THE MEDICAID FRAUD FALSE CLAIMS ACT TO ADDRESS FLAWS IDENTIFIED IN RECENT INVESTIGATIONS AND CHANGES RELATED TO THE IMPLEMENTATION OF MANAGED CARE; AND TO UPDATE THE ADULT ABUSE PENALTIES.

HB1727 Dotson TO MANDATE COVERAGE BY AN INSURER FOR INTRAOPERATIVENEUROPHYSIOLOGICAL MONITORING.

HB1060 Lynch TO ESTABLISH AND REQUIRE CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR HEATING, VENTILATION, AIR CONDITIONING, AND REFRIGERATION LICENSEES.

SB3 T. Garner TO REQUIRE ADDITIONAL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS BY CERTAIN PHYSICIANS AND HEALTHCARE FACILITIES FOR ABORTION COMPLICATIONS.

HB1731 G. Hodges TO REQUIRE COOPERATION BETWEEN CERTAIN STATE AGENCIES REGARDING SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM ELIGIBILITY.

HB1743 Bentley TO PROMOTE THE PURCHASE OF HEALTHY PRODUCTS WITH SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM BENEFITS.

HB1745 L. Johnson TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING PRESCRIPTION ASTHMA INHALERS IN SCHOOLS DISTRICTS AND PUBLIC CHARTER SCHOOLS; AND TO AUTHORIZE ACQUIRING AND STOCKING ALBUTEROL FOR ADMINISTRATION IN CERTAIN SITUATIONS.

HB1751 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS.

2:20:37 - 2:14:33

Rep. Mary Bentley presented HB 1751 as a cleanup bill that updates obsolete language and adds a penalty requiring double payment if wages are not paid within seven days. [2:21:07] [2:21:31]

With no opposition, the committee moved a motion to pass the bill, which carried unanimously. [2:21:39] [2:22:03]

HB1752 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; TO PROVIDE AN EXCEPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYER"; AND TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 5 OF 2018.

2:14:33 - 2:16:31 7 segments 2 speakers

Rep. Mary Bentley described HB 1752 as a measure to keep the $9.25 minimum wage for small businesses, nonprofits and developmental services while providing a temporary exemption as the wage schedule moves to $10-$11. [2:14:34] [2:15:06] [2:15:34]

With no members speaking for or against, a motion to pass the bill was made and carried unanimously. [2:15:48] [2:15:58]

HB1753 Lundstrum TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS; TO PROVIDE AN EXCEPTION TO THE DEFINITION OF "EMPLOYEE"; AND TO AMEND THE MINIMUM WAGE ACT OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS RESULTING FROM INITIATED ACT 5 OF 2018.

2:16:31 - 3:47

Rep. Mary Bentley argued that HB 1753, by allowing a $9.25 minimum wage for workers aged 16-19, would give teenagers entry-level job opportunities and let wages rise as they gain experience. [2:16:50] [2:17:23] [2:17:38] [2:17:53] [2:18:02]

Committee members debated the amendment; Rep. Justin Boyd asked whether it would disproportionately favor hiring teens, and Bentley responded that it simply provides an opportunity without creating long-term bias. [2:18:09] [2:18:23] [2:18:26] [2:18:48] [2:19:00]

After no further objections, a motion to pass the bill as amended was made and approved, and the committee reported the bill passed. [2:19:33] [2:19:35] [2:19:51] [2:20:05]

HB1771 V. Flowers TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS LITTER REDUCTION AND DEPOSIT BEVERAGE CONTAINER RECYCLING ACT; TO REQUIRE THE LABELING OF DEPOSIT BEVERAGE CONTAINERS SOLD IN ARKANSAS; TO ESTABLISH THE DEPOSIT BEVERAGE CONTAINER RECYCLING PROGRAM.

HB1775 Bentley TO CREATE THE EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES FOR ABLE-BODIED ADULTS ACT OF 2019.

HB1783 Fielding TO MODIFY LABELING OF PRESCRIPTION DRUGS; AND TO REQUIRE PHYSICIANS TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL COUNSELING WHEN PRESCRIBING MEDICATIONS.

HR1047 Watson TO RECOGNIZE THE IMPORTANCE AND NEED FOR QUICK ACCESS TO AUTO MATEDEXTERNAL DEFIBRILLATORS.

SCOPE OF PRACTICE BILLS

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1275 Richey TO CREATE THE COMMUNITY HEALTH WORKER ACT.

HB1289 B. Smith TO CREATE THE MEDICAL CONSCIENCE PROTECTION ACT.

HB1282 Lundstrum TO REMOVE THE REQUIREMENT FOR A MANDATORY COLLABORATIVE PRACTICEAGREEMENT FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO HAVE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY.

SB184 G.

Stubblefield TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHETISTS BY REMOVING SUPERVISION REQUIREMENTS.

HB1220 Sullivan TO AMEND THE TELEMEDICINE ACT; TO ENSURE THAT TELEMEDICINE IS THE LEAST RESTRICTIVE METHOD TO DELIVER HEALTHCARE SERVICES REMOTELY; AND TO EXPAND THE DEFINITION OF "PROFESSIONAL RELATIONSHIP".

3:47 - 2:22:12 449 segments 54 speakers

Representatives Karilyn Brown and Jeff Wardlaw questioned whether physicians would need access to prior medical records or patient-filled online histories to use telemedicine under HB 1220; Teladoc Vice President Claudia Duck-Tucker clarified that both sources are acceptable. [3:53] [3:58] [4:00] [4:05] [4:31] [4:39] [4:55] [5:02] [5:15] [5:36] [6:06] [6:14] [6:25] [6:36] [6:39] [6:52]

Rep. Ferguson noted that the bill eliminates the previous “standard of care” language and that the only new language is the underlined amendment, confirming that the amendment’s scope is limited. [7:17] [7:43] [7:53] [8:12]

Testimony from the ERIC organization, represented by Zonek Warisko-Files, argued that Arkansas is the only state requiring video for telemedicine and that technology-neutral legislation would improve access, urging passage of the bill. [11:49] [11:56] [12:32] [13:08] [13:38] [14:10] [14:41] [15:12] [15:48]

The Arkansas Medical Society, represented by David Roten and Scott Smith, opposed removing the video requirement for the initial patient encounter, emphasizing the need for visual assessment; after limited debate the committee voted to pass the bill. [17:51] [17:58] [18:29] [19:01] [19:33] [20:03] [20:14] [20:18] [25:06] [25:37] [25:53] [26:09] [26:39] [26:58] [27:10] [27:43]

DEFERRED BILLS

Number Sponsor Subtitle

HB1323 D. Douglas TO REQUIRE THE OFFICE OF LONG-TERM CARE NOT TO ADOPT RULES OR STANDARDS THAT ARE STRICTER THAN THE FEDERAL MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR CERTIFIED NURSING AIDES OR ASSISTANTS AND CERTIFIED NURSING AIDE OR ASSISTANT INSTRUCTORS.

HB1334 Maddox TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED UNDER THE ASSISTED LIVING PROGRAM; TO REMOVE A LIMITATION ON THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED AT A TIME IN THE ASSISTED LIVING PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.

HB1232 Lowery TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING AUTHORIZED PAYROLL DEDUCTIONS OF UNION DUES FOR PUBLIC EMPLOYEES TO ALLOW DEDUCTIONS ONLY FOR FIREFIGHTERS, POLICE OFFICERS, AND EMERGENCY FIRST RESPONDERS; AND TO PROHIBIT DEDUCTIONS FOR TEACHERS.

HB1309 S. Meeks TO CREATE THE ARKANSAS NIGHTTIME ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION ACT.

HB1102 Sullivan TO ADDRESS THE UNDERSERVED STATUS OF A COUNTY AS A REQUIREMENT FOR LICENSURE AND CERTIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROVIDERS.

HB1528 Womack TO INCREASE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM BENEFIT LIMIT FOR DRUG TESTING AND X-RAYS.

HB1164 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE A PHARMACIST TO DISPENSE ORAL CONTRACEPTIVES WITHOUT A PRESCRIPTION.

HB1252 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR LICENSURE OF ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANTS.

HB1253 Magie TO AUTHORIZE A LICENSED DISPENSING OPTICIAN TO REFRACT EYES AND DISPENSE EYEGLASSES IN CERTAIN CONDITIONS.

HB1283 Gonzales TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHESIA"; TO CLARIFY THE SCOPE OF PRACTICE OF A CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHETIST; AND TO REMOVE SUPERVISION REQUIREMENTS.

HB1284 Gonzales TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO RECOGNIZE AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE AS A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.

HB1257 Boyd TO AUTHORIZE AND CLARIFY THE METHOD OF RELEASING CLAIMS AND ENROLLMENT DATA BY HEALTH INSURERS THAT PROVIDE HEALTHCARE COVERAGE TO ELIGIBLE INDIVIDUALS IN THE ARKANSAS WORKS PROGRAM.

HB1274 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE WHO HAS

SERVED A RURAL COMMUNITY TO PRACTICE WITHOUT A COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT.

Documents

No documents posted.

Speakers

Representative Stephen Meeks Unverified
1 segment
Representative Jack Ladyman Chair Unverified
85 segments
Representative Kenneth B. Ferguson Unverified
11 segments
Representative Deborah Ferguson Unverified
34 segments
Representative Karilyn Brown Unverified
20 segments
Representative Jeff Wardlaw Unverified
15 segments
Speaker 60
11 segments
Speaker 63
1 segment
Speaker 45
1 segment
Representative Lee Johnson Unverified
16 segments
Speaker 86
1 segment
Speaker 99
2 segments
Speaker 108
11 segments
Speaker 116
13 segments
Speaker 118
1 segment
Speaker 117
2 segments
Chair Unverified
11 segments
Speaker 142
6 segments
Speaker 172
13 segments
Speaker 171
1 segment
Jason Hatfield Unverified
22 segments
Representative Mark Perry Unverified
9 segments
Speaker 196
7 segments
Speaker 157
2 segments
Speaker 215
1 segment
Melissa Weatherton Unverified
6 segments
Jan Fortney Unverified
6 segments
Speaker 235
1 segment
Speaker 238
1 segment
Speaker 240
1 segment
Representative Michelle Gray Unverified
44 segments
Representative Austin McCollum Unverified
5 segments
Representative John Payton Unverified
11 segments
Representative Bruce Coleman Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 265
1 segment
Speaker 295
1 segment
Speaker 296
32 segments
Speaker 347
3 segments
Speaker 303
1 segment
Speaker 304
1 segment
Speaker 308
1 segment
Speaker 309
1 segment
Speaker 312
1 segment
Representative Clint Penzo Unverified
8 segments
Speaker 327
1 segment
Speaker 330
1 segment
Speaker 316
1 segment
Speaker 349
1 segment
Speaker 356
11 segments
Speaker 362
1 segment
Dallas Green Unverified
4 segments
Speaker 382
1 segment
Representative Mary Bentley Unverified
16 segments
Representative Justin Boyd Unverified
2 segments
Speaker 248
1 segment