The committee first adopted a motion to limit debate to two minutes per speaker (which passed), later reversed it back to five minutes, and ultimately voted the bill down, resulting in its failure.
[18:46][18:50][18:54][18:58][19:03][22:25][22:47][23:01][52:27]
HB1278 Gazaway TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF PHARMACY" TO ALLOW VACCINES AND IMMUNIZATIONS TO BE GIVEN TO A PERSON FROM SEVEN (7) YEARS OF AGE TO EIG… 54:25
Representative Jimmy Gazaway opened the hearing by outlining Arkansas’s alarmingly low childhood vaccination rates-citing CDC data that the state trails neighboring states on measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, pertussis, hepatitis B, polio, varicella and HPV coverage-and explained that HB 1278 would expand pharmacist access in the 16 counties lacking any physician-provided immunizations, thereby addressing recent outbreaks of hepatitis A, mumps and other vaccine-preventable diseases.
[54:41][55:15][55:47][56:21][56:55][57:26][57:59]
Committee members questioned the bill’s context and mechanics, including possible federal action on low rates (Rep. Boyd to Scott Pace), how a “general written protocol” would be created and reported (Rep. Johnson and Pace), whether any additional fees would apply (Rep. Ferguson and Pace), and concerns about parental consent for minors (Rep. Gray and subsequent discussion); Pace clarified that protocols remain physician-controlled, doses are reported to the statewide WebIZ system, and vaccines are generally covered with no extra charge.
[58:42][58:59][59:03][59:20][59:31][59:36][1:01:23][1:01:50][1:02:24][1:02:36][1:03:21][1:03:32][1:03:57][1:04:05][1:04:20][1:04:42][1:05:13]
The chair sees a quorum in the vicinity, so we're going to get started. We're going to pick up right where we left off on Senate Bill 184. And members, we were down to questions, and everyone that was on our list for questions, we got through that list. So are there any additional questions from the committee?
Representative Ritchie you're recognized thank you Mr. Chair I thought I was on the list before we left I guess I'll jump in trying to remember what I was going to ask previously I got a letter I got a call from my hospital back in Helena about this issue and working with the Chamber of Commerce down there, I've tried to help recruit surgeons down there before, and so I know kind of what the issue they're dealing with. But, you know, I think being here, serving on this committee, as Representative Wardlaw said earlier, serve on this committee a number of times, after a while you become a bit skeptical. And so, you know, y'all have stated repeatedly that, you know, this is about legal liability for the docs and so forth. And, of course, you know, I guess the question that's been asked but not been asked directly several times is what's in this for you? What's in this for you guys? Because I think if we can know exactly how you guys benefit from this, that will clear up some questions. I mean, the pain centers and all that's been thrown out there. And so I think for the clarity for us, we just need to know how do you guys benefit from this, and why are you all bringing this to the table?
If you want to take that, go ahead. Absolutely. First, I want to apologize because, honestly, I've done this a couple times, but I get a little nervous, and so I start listening, and then I couldn't follow where we were going with the pain clinic component, which has not ever been brought up in the discussions that we talk about about anything like that. So what do CRNAs get out of this, doing the deal? Well, we're working in rural America. We live in rural America. Our job is there. We want to have surgeons come to rural America. We don't want to have that liability imposed on them that makes them not want to work with us. And in other factors, what do we get out of it? well, if I'm working in another location, I want those guys. I want a level competitive playing field that lets me work with the podiatrist or the surgeon who wants to do cases in his office or the plastic surgeon or whoever. We want that level playing field to be able to do that. And then finally, I mean, I think it's, for us, it's obvious because we're at it year after year after year and sometimes we don't make it clear perhaps to y'all but there you know cms is allowed now elimination of supervision language across the cms rules and certainly this would be an excellent stepping stone to get us there so we want to work in the rural sector we want people to work with us in the rural sector without having issues we want a competitive market that's level on the playing field and in the future we want to be able to move arkansas to the opt-out state component
So I think I can give a pretty simple basic answer to that. Right now you have physicians operating in these rural areas that are a little bit concerned about supervising a CRNA because they feel like that, and I'm not speaking for all of them because I know there's a lot of them behind me here that are going to speak differently, but you also have a stack of letters on your desk, Some from hospital CEOs, some from physicians. There's, I don't know, approximately 40 letters here. Some physicians are not comfortable with that language of supervision in there because they feel like that makes them somewhat liable. So if we remove that and they can work in coordination with and they are not liable for that CRNA, who they feel like is more educated in anesthesia than they are, then they are more likely to come to these rural areas and work with them. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have two questions, Mr. Chair. I've got a question and a follow-up if I'm recognized for a follow-up. My first question is, I messed up this morning, and I didn't ask this question because this is very important to me as a health care provider. What about the patient in this, and how does a patient fit in this, and are we keeping patient care first and foremost and making sure they get the best available care to that patient in these particular situations?
question is, and you and I had a discussion about this earlier, how does this tie into the APRN bills that have been tried in here so far where they do away with the collaborative agreement and we open up Schedule 2s, which I know that's been taken care of and an amendment's been done and all that. But does it all flow into that so that these pain clinics that we keep hearing about could be opened if those bills was to pass along with this?
There was no intent of that ever. CRNAs and APRNs have not come to any type of collaboration to say, hey, let's get all these things done so we can open up pain clinics I think probably this session is the first session that they have even remotely worked together on any type of legislation. So, no, that has not ever been the intent. Thank you. Any
Thank you, Mr. Chair. And with regard to how this benefits a patient, although nothing will really change in your relationship with other professionals, by removing this requirement that the physicians in these rural areas say that they are supervising you in order for you to be able to function in that setting, by removing that liability from them, that would probably bring, in my opinion, I'm asking, would that not encourage more physicians to serve those areas so that health care would be improved for people in rural areas because they would have more access to care by these other physicians? Not that it's going to benefit you specifically, but it's going to benefit the patients in these rural areas we would definitely hope
other questions seeing none we have a number of people signed up to speak against and for the bill and currently what was we have a time limit of five minutes per person per speaker and 10 minutes to close so keep that in mind as you come up to the table. First person to speak against the bill is Josh Dilley. Please introduce yourself and who
you represent. Yes sir, my name is Josh Dilley. I'm an anesthesiologist. I'm representing the Arkansas Society of Anesthesiology. Thank you for the opportunity for letting me come here and speak with you guys today. I really appreciate all the hard work that you guys do. You guys are pulled in a lot of directions. It's not easy. You guys are asked to cover a lot of stuff, and we just appreciate you taking the time to consider everything that's put before you. So, you know, this is, for us, this is about patient care and safety. What we are talking about today, the outcomes, the consequences, is literally a matter of life and death. We are urging you to vote no to SB 184. Proponents claim it will increase patient access and will not have effect on patient outcomes. This is unequivocally false. They're also saying that it will reduce the liability. If you're coordinating with somebody, you're still liable for the outcomes. As a physician, if I put an order in for something, I'm liable for that outcome of that order. my job is as an anesthesiologist is a little bit mysterious to a lot of people even people in health care my wife is a physician she doesn't even fully understand the full scope of what i do the period of time when a patient is in surgery is only a small part of what we're actually doing as physicians we coordinate we we plan care with other physicians prior to surgery i'm working with the cardiologist right now we have a patient coming in a month from now that we're working together with to make sure that that patient has the best outcome. We prescribe plans to the nurse anesthetists that are in the room. We give them autonomy. We allow them to function in the room without us constantly being in the room because we develop a relationship. They do have a skill set and we trust them. Their skill set is in monitoring and reporting to us. It's not in diagnosing and prescribing what we're looking at doing here is fundamentally changing their role this is absolutely a scope of practice issue it's no different than a nurse working on a surgical floor and taking orders from a surgeon for a long period of time you get to know that surgeon and their preferences just because you know the surgeon and their preferences doesn't mean that you're able to go do surgery and take care of the patient write their prescriptions and make their own plans on those patients. Anesthesiology is the practice of medicine. CRNA is no doubt playing an important role. Physicians lead and direct the care, though. When someone is dying, there's no time or reason to debate who's in charge and what needs to be done. The physicians in charge are uniquely prepared to deal with these situations, and the physicians are trained to be leaders. Confusing this role can have devastating outcomes. This is also not a rural access bill. This bill will affect everybody in the state. I have heard your concerns that rural communities are disadvantaged by the current law. I grew up in Arkadelphia. My parents still live in Arkadelphia. We have Baptist Hospital down there. It's been staffed by CRNAs for a long time. I also know the surgeons in that area. I know the surgeons in Clarksville. I know the surgeons in Bentonville. I know the surgeons in Hot Springs. They would rather supervise the CRNAs than have them practice independently. Dr. Frederick Bentley, the president of the Arkansas chapter of the American College of Surgeons, released a letter yesterday, I believe. He sent it out to everybody on the committee representing all 450 practicing surgeons in this state strongly opposing this bill. The term coordination is vague and undefined. There's no legal principle or precedent set for what coordination means. This is the only state that will have this language in the bill. No other states use this language. It's going to create a lot of red tape. It's going to create a lot of headaches for hospitals trying to figure out what this means. It's going to impede care, and it's going to cause a lot of issues in court. It's going to lead to a lot of delays in taking care of patients. The VA examined removing supervision from patient care with CRNAs. Access of care was also used as an argument. After extensive research, the federal government decided the risk was too high. The care team led by a physician was determined to be the best model, and that was the model that they currently implement. We have received many letters, emails, phone calls, and texts. We have surgeons, dentists, people of all other medical specialties here in the room supporting us. I've gotten a number of texts and emails today. They're still coming in. I've never had this many people agree on one thing. I could offer everybody in the room cake right now, and they would probably have more disagreement about whether or not
Yes. My name is Lance Ogle. I'm a nurse anesthetist. Um, I, uh, am representing the, uh, Arkansas Association of Nurse Anesthetists. Um, I'm a nurse anesthetist. I'm originally from El Dorado. I lived most of my life in Rogers and practiced anesthesia there for 16 years. And I have done locum tenums work all over Arkansas, anywhere from Fort Smith, Conway, Mountain Home, Batesville, Little Rock, and Benton. And I currently, for the past 10 years, have been doing anesthesia in a rural care hospital in Forest City, Arkansas. I became a CRNA to be able to take care of people. As the doctor previously mentioned, he mistakenly admitted that, said that we have to report to an anesthesiologist. I have not seen an anesthesiologist in the last 10 years. And I do surgery every day. I do epidurals for OB patients. Our education is that we have to have a four-year degree in nursing. We have to have critical care experience at the minimum of a year. Most nurses that go to anesthesia school have three years at least of critical care experience working in an ICU-type setting before they ever go to anesthesia school. And then the programs run from 28 to 32 months in length. Currently, the CRN programs are master and doctorate level. They get full-time clinical experience ranging up to 9,000 hours plus, 9,600 hours. By the year 2022, all CRNA programs will be doctorate prepared. 100% of the CRNAs are board certified in the United States. 73% of the anesthesiologists are certified. CRNA recertification occurs every four years and requires 100 years of continuing education credit. CRNAs have long been the primary professionals in rural America enabling health care facilities in these medically underserved areas to offer obstetrical, surgical, and trauma stabilization services. In Arkansas, CRNAs are the sole providers in 100% of our critical access hospitals in our state, 90% of the rural hospitals in the state, and 75% of all the anesthetics in the state of Arkansas are done by CRNAs. And one of those CRNAs in a rural hospital, as I said, our group serves the people of the least healthy half-dozen counties in the state, being St. Francis and the surrounding counties, ranging down to Phillips and as far up as Cross and above there. Um, we consider these people to be some of the sickest ones in the state and, uh, and, but at the same time, uh, we work with, uh, we work as I worked, uh, in contrast in, in Rogers, Arkansas, where I worked before, uh, we worked in the healthiest county in the state. I was responsible even up there for treating trauma and anything that came through the door, day or night, weekends and holidays, obstetrics, and other surgical specialties. My past 10 years, like I said, has been in Forest City, and we do trauma support in the emergency department and ICU along with the surgical patients and women in labor. All surgical anesthetics are done with a surgeon present, and labor epidurals are done with the coordination of the admitting OB physician. We also provide anesthesia for ophthalmology, dentistry, and podiatry. Senate Bill will not change how CRNAs or our physician counterparts operate. It simply changes the statute under the supervision of a physician requirement and replaces it in coordination with, but thereby accurately describing what actually happens where CRNAs administer anesthesia all over the state of Arkansas. Thank you for allowing me to speak, and I ask that you vote for Senate Bill 184. Thank you.
Any questions? Seeing none, thank you for your comments. Oh, you had a question? Thank you for your comments. Representative Wardlaw, you're recognized for a motion.
close. And five minutes to close. It's non-debatable. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. Nay. Motion carries. so next to speak against the bill is josh chance good afternoon thank
you uh chairman legum and uh the members of the committee uh two minutes obviously is not very much i am joshua chance i'm an anesthesiologist here i'm also the president of the arkansas society of anesthesiology uh and so i represent uh that membership uh as well as indicate that our surgical colleagues across the state have written many letters, of which I think you have received somewhere between 80 or 90 probably, in support of saying no to this bill. It was an interesting, Mr. Ogle mentioned just a moment ago that all anesthetics done in his area, surgical anesthetics done in his area are supervised by the surgeon. Well, that's true. 100% of all anesthetics in the state are currently supervised. We have very, very strong statute in place right now, and that statute, Liz, sets a very high precedent on patient safety and patient care. And I urge each of you to maintain that. Our members want, our citizens want that. A recent survey in our state indicated that 86% of the voting members in our state want physician involvement in their anesthesia care. And so I just urge all of you to take that into consideration. Vote no against this and, you know, leave our care as high as it is currently. So if anyone has any questions, I'm happy to answer.
Yeah, I have a question for you. You mentioned the letters. I have two packets of letters here, one pro, one con. I have twice as many letters for this bill as I do against the bill. Can you speak to that or why that
might be the case? It was our impression we had a packet of that. It's actually a bound packet. I don't have that here with me. All of those letters are in against this bill 184. So I think it looks like that. So all of those are surgeons that have indicated they wish for you to vote no against this bill, along with, like I said, the letter from Dr. Bentley, who is the current president of the chapter of insurgents. Yeah, members, he's talking about the one
that was given to us individually before the meeting, so I apologize I didn't remember that. Your time is up. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Yes, sir. Representative Penzo, you're recognized.
Can I make a motion? Yes, you may. I'd like to reconsider. If there's just nine more people speaking, I think two minutes is inadequate. Then it's pretty serious. I'd like to consider taking this back to five minutes for
each speaker. Okay, that's a valid motion. So the motion is to limit the discussion to five minutes per speaker from the current two minutes. No debate. All in favor, signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. Ayes have it. We're back to five minutes. You're lucky. Go ahead and introduce yourself.
Okay. Here we go. Thank you guys for this opportunity. First off, my name is Brad Pitts. I'm a CRNA here locally. I live in Bryant. I got out of anesthesia school in 2012. In 2015, I started working independently on a part-time basis, independent meaning independent from physician anesthesiologists. Since then, we've put together a team of independent CRNAs that work around the state, mostly locally. approximately four are staffed on our team day to day in a pool of about 10 to 12 that work as needed. We cover sites from Hot Springs up to Bentonville over to Searcy and everywhere in between including the metro area here in Little Rock and many specialties. Pediatric dentistry specifically is one that we focus on. Oral surgery, plastic surgery, outpatient surgery, you name it gastroenterology we do all this without a physician anesthesiologist supervising us the yes the point is practicing independently there's questions on our safety okay our safety dates back from when we started this 150 years ago there's no bodies piling up anywhere okay, that would obviously be something that is evident that we would all see. For instance, we also work in conjunction with every other specialty. If we have a patient that comes in that needs a cardiac clearance because they've had numerous heart issues or lung issues or COPD, we'll pursue that. We don't make the decision as a nurse anesthetist individually without looking for further advice from people who know things. especially along those lines for instance in pediatric dentistry we we have five clinics hot springs bentonville six clinics searcy cabot bryant little rock with needs in conway pine bluff a harrison that we can't quite open up yet because of this uh you know there's this underlying tone of we don't know what the liability is it's perceived liability it's not true. We've found that. There's been one case, they said so far, where a surgeon's been liable for what we've done, and we don't know the details of that, but it's the perception. Our safety record doing pediatric dental is very high. There's a very low complication rate, for instance. We talk to the patients a week ahead of time, talk to the family members, troubleshoot anything that may come up at that point in time and if they need further evaluation we'll send them to their pediatrician and have a letter to come in and say they're ready for anesthesia. The day of the procedure we do assessment heart lungs liver I mean heart lungs airway and then when we decide it's time to proceed we will proceed in coordination with the dentist currently. This is increased care to patients who have a hard time getting into the hospital. These are mostly Medicaid patients. We all know how hard it is to get Medicaid, specifically pediatric dental Medicaid patients, into the operating room because it's not financially beneficial for ORs. They'd rather do a gallbladder surgery. So we go to their town, we do the procedure there. The biggest complication we may have is nausea after the procedure because the kid's been on nitrous. Other than that, very safe. We've already reached last year probably 750 to 800 kids and we plan to continue to try to reach that. I think changing the supervision language would help us increase our reach, increase some more areas of the state such as Harrison, Pine Bluff, Conway, Fort Smith, Jonesboro. And, you know, that's basically it from me. I'll take any questions if you like. Any questions? Representative Bentley, you're recognized. So
more care? If we can remove that, we'll remove some hesitancy from some providers out there that are hesitant with that one word, supervisor, especially a dentist that's not been to any type of anesthesia school or any of that. I do, absolutely. So we have also a lot of patients out there. Would you agree that a lot of young Medicaid constituents out there that really need some care that without this
will not get it? 100%. All right, thank you. Any other questions? Seeing none, thank you for your comments. Next person to speak against the bill is Christian Lenhart. Please identify yourself and who you
represent. My name is Kristen Lindhart. I'm a board-certified physician anesthesiologist. I'm representing the Arkansas Society of Anesthesia. Thank you, Chairman Ladyman and Vice Chairman Ferguson. I was born and raised in Arkansas. I'm not going anywhere. You're stuck with me for the rest of my life anyway. I've been practicing medicine for over a decade. And I just want to simply provide one example of the many examples that I have of why our current law regarding the physician-led anesthesia care team works and why it's vital for our patient care. While supervising a nurse anesthetist, which I often do, and caring for a patient having a minor procedure, we're talking a minor procedure, she reported to me that the EKG alarm was going off. And so I immediately go to the room as I'm supposed to, and I notice the patient's EKG is not normal, which it was normal before surgery. So I suspected that the patient was having a heart attack, treated it as such. I alerted the surgeons, asked them to speed along, let's take care of this sweet patient, and we delivered that patient safely to the recovery room. So the patient is safely there. I continue to examine, work up the patient, confirm a heart attack. I consult an interventional cardiologist, and we immediately take that patient to the cath lab, and they withdraw a huge clot from this person's heart. Okay, this is what we do every day. The patient went home the very next day with no heart damage, okay? But if we had not had this dedicated, concerted care, this patient could have had irreversible heart damage. He could have died. This very example is why medical education is irreplaceable. To have the breadth and depth of medical knowledge required to make life or death decisions in a split second. We're not talking about taking a blood pressure, monitoring blood sugar in patients. We're talking about life or death. This requires a physician-led team of individuals, all with unique experiences, unique education, but we're working together to provide exceptional, organized, and efficient care for our patients.
I urge you to vote no for this bill. Yes, ma'am. Representative Boyd, you're recognized for a question. Sure. Thank you. I just want a little clarification. I have a health care background, but not a lot of time in the operating room. So when you're in the operating room or around the operating room, I know you roam around and go between surgeries. So at the end of the day, who's really in charge? Is it the surgeon? Is it the anesthesiologist? Is it the nurse? Who is in charge, and how does it work if you're both physicians?
I love your question. I love it because I tell the people I work with and that I train. The surgeon thinks that they're the head of the OR. Oh, everyone's recording this. But I am the neck, okay? I get that from my big fat Greek wedding. And I turn that neck or that head, whichever way is safest for the patient. The surgeon is my colleague and my peer, and they depend on me. I had surgeons calling me today asking me, what do I do about this patient? How do I get this person taken care of every day? And this is applicable in the rural areas. You take me out of the equation, it's still the physician, it's still the surgeon who's responsible for this patient. Representative Brown, you're recognized
you. Representative Payton, you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. So you just said that the surgeon calls you for advice. Is there a requirement in Arkansas statute that he call you or that you're a supervision? No, it's because he trusts me. In the other scenario you gave where you detected the heart attack, do you think that this change in the law would stop that nurse, CNA, from contacting somebody when she saw an irregular EKG or the alarm went off? I mean, it shouldn't. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Please identify yourself and who you represent. My name is Harold Simpson. I'm the attorney for the Arkansas Association of Nursing Ethicists. You all have already heard me talk to some of the legal issues, so I'm going to be extremely brief and answer your questions. One of the things that I think is being, that's critical to understand here as you look at this situation is we get a lot of things that are mish-mashed together. There is a difference between ordering a procedure to be done in order to administering the care that's required by that order and with regard to prescribing medication. One of the things that you all talked about was whether this is trying to encourage pain management facilities. And I think, again, that's being mishmashed together. You have to understand that in a pain clinic, if there were a pain clinic that a CRNA operated in, you have to narrow it down to whether you're talking about order, administration, or prescription. If you're talking about order, CRNAs don't have the ability to order the anesthesia. If you're talking about administer, they do have the authority to administer under this statute. However, it's modified or not modified by this committee. If you're talking about prescriptive authority, that is prescribing a medication to fill at the pharmacy and for the patient to take home, you're talking about something that's governed by the laws relating to prescriptive authority for advanced registered practice nurses. So when you look at it, you have to ask yourself the question, what law applies to the particular circumstance that you're dealing with? But with that, I'll stop and take any questions you have on the legal issues of this.
Committee, are there any questions? Seeing none, thank you for your comments. Thank you all. Okay, next person to speak against the bill is Kyle Staniford. Staniford? Please introduce yourself and who you're representing. Yes, thank you all for being here today.
I know we've spent a lot of time. I will try and be brief and to the point. My name is Kyle Standiford. I am a second-year medical student here in the state of Arkansas from Pocahontas, Arkansas, so also a rural area and small town. I do believe that I offer somewhat of a unique perspective to what's being discussed today. I believe I'm the only one in the room who has attended a CRNA program who has then transitioned into medical school. So I would be happy to address any questions related to that. I do think, however, that both sides here, no matter what we decide today, I do believe we all should have the best interest of our patients and heart and mind moving forward and continuing on with these discussions today. Are there any questions from
okay next speaking for the bill Cassia Pabin I may have mispronounced that there's no one else speaking for the bill if you want. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Speaking against the bill, Jeff Flagenhoff? David Roten. David Roten. Please identify yourself and who you're here
representing. David Roten representing the Arkansas Medical Society. Members of the committee, I've been in here all day and I've listened to the testimony on both sides of this. We're obviously opposed to the bill, but I want to zero in on a couple of really fine points that keep seeming to get confused. We have anesthesiologists and CRNAs across the state. What you typically see is anesthesiologists in your larger cities, Little Rock, Fort Smith, Jonesboro, Northwest, places like that, and in those large hospitals, they work with CRNAs, And in those situations, the anesthesiologists are supervising the CRNAs. In your more rural areas where there are not anesthesiologists, the CRNAs are there. They're working with your surgeons, with your local doctors. And in those cases, the surgeons are supervising the CRNAs. What they're asking you to do is to remove that supervision requirement so it doesn't just apply in those areas in the rural parts of Arkansas. It also would apply in places like St. Vincent's, Baptist, UAMS, St. Mary's, Washington Regional, all of those hospitals where right now the anesthesiologists are in fact supervising CRNAs. And it would remove that requirement. The closest thing I've heard to an argument for this bill today is we want to remove the liability from our surgeons. And that's going to help encourage them to go to rural Arkansas. you all know how hard it is to get people into rural Arkansas, whether it's practicing medicine or nursing or anything else. There's not one hospital, and they've already testified that every single critical access hospital has a CRNA. That also means they have people there that are doing surgery. People don't go to rural Arkansas to practice because there's a CRNA there, and they're going to have to, quote, supervise them. We've got letters from doctors across the state in rural Arkansas that are opposed to this bill. They accept their responsibility for supervision. Regardless of what you do with this bill, it's not going to change that liability, and I think that has come out, and I just wanted to make those fine
points. Thank you very much. I'm Jeff Plaganoff. I'm an anesthesiologist from Dallas, Texas. I thank you very much for the effort that you've put forth here to digest a very difficult subject, and I'm very empathetic with the confusion that was expressed earlier because for lay people and even for people who work in health care that don't work in the operating room, this is all very confusing. And added to the confusion are the terms that are used in billing and payment rules that kind of muddy the waters. While I was the president of the American Society of Anesthesiologists in 2017, I was not sent here by them, nor was I paid by them to come here. I would be best defined as a patient advocate. I've fought for patient safety and quality of care my entire career, and part of the reason I agreed to come was that when I watched the Senate testimony, some of the things that I heard were very disingenuous, some were downright false, and it bothered me because this is an extremely important issue for the citizens of your state. And I really respect the representative, Penzo, for asking that the time be increased because giving two minutes to this is very, very difficult. Now, I would rather have an exchange with you. I'm happy to answer any questions on any subject and help alleviate some of the confusion. So please interrupt me at any time. I'll welcome an interruption. Just say, hey, I've practiced in the anesthesia care team for 30 years with nurse anesthetist and anesthesiologist assistants. And somebody did ask earlier why we're against this. Like somebody said, if it reduces liability, why wouldn't we be for it? We're against it simply because we stand for safety and quality. That's the way we're trained. Anesthesiologists have been recognized by the Institute of Medicine for being the single specialty in the House of Medicine that has totally transformed patient safety and quality of care through our Patient Safety Foundation. The Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation has been the model for the National Patient Safety Foundation, which all other specialties have used. So that's why we care about this. It's somewhat offensive to suggest that this is about competition. There isn't any competition. It's about safety and quality. I think it's really important to talk about the terms direction, supervision, collaboration, and consultation, and the new one that's thrown out here, coordination. It's extremely disingenuous, misleading, and errant to say in testimony, which it was in the Senate, that 41 states have already approved this. It was also said earlier here, I believe, by the director of the nurse anesthetist organization that coordination is commonly used. Let it be known, if you're not clear on this, It is the very first time it has been suggested to be used in statute, the very first time. Right now, Arkansas is among the top 20 states for the verbiage used in its scope of practice legislation addressing nurse anesthetist's scope of practice. Eight states require medical direction. There are two states that use the term supervision and direction, and another 12 that say supervision. And then beyond that, there are 20 that say collaboration and consultation. So to say that there are all these states that don't require any physician involvement is inaccurate. There are only four states in this country where nurse anesthetists practice totally independently. They are New Hampshire, Montana, Oregon, and Alaska. Because to practice completely independently, the state must have, A, opted out of the Medicare medical direction rule, and B, past language similar to what you're considering. Without both of those, it's not complete independent practice. So if you're one of the safest states, one must ask why you're doing this. Now, the access to care wagon, I believe, has been ridden a bit too far. We have four studies, two published in 2016 and two published in 2017, that show that access to care in the opt-out states was not increased. Okay, I know that people have thought, you're thinking along the right tracks, you want to increase access to care. I would maintain that increasing care in a way that's less safe is not that admirable. We must maintain a safety bar. And especially to those people who are the most vulnerable, who may not know that the bar was lowered so that they don't have to drive as far. So this will not improve access. I've got the studies that have been done. They've been published in good journals. You have to be careful about the references to studies. Some of the studies referenced here today were paid for by the American Association of Nurse Anesthetists, and the one that was mentioned specifically actually acknowledged the person who referenced it, thanking him for being on the technical expert committee. There were no physicians on that committee. It won't make care cheaper. You should not reduce physician involvement in the operating room. Surgeons, good surgeons, have already responded to you. Their state society has responded to you and their national association, the American College of Surgeons, a letter from David Hoyt, M.D., their director. They believe physicians in the surgical role should maintain supervisory capacity. It's even more important in rural settings for that to happen, as it is in offices, as it is in dentist offices. And as a matter of fact, I want you to know I was handed a note here after the previous testimony about dental offices. This is from Dr. Bietstra, head of dentistry at the Arkansas Children's Hospital. He says he sent all committee members a no letter and also wants you to know that there have been many dental deaths in Texas. There have been many dental deaths or kids all over this country, and that's why we had Caleb's Law in California. It is not a time to lower the bar there. You don't push the 911 button when the doo-doo hits the fan in an office or a surgery center. You don't have the layers of safety that you have in a hospital where you can call a code and a bunch of different people with different skill sets show up. You're it. And while in this state, dentist and podiatrist can order anesthesia, I think you need to think twice about whether or not those people should hold some responsibility to assist in resuscitation during an untoward event. I've had nurse anesthetists call me and tell me that I'm right about this. I say that I stand for physician supervision always to protect not just the patient, but also the nurse anesthetist. I've been there. I've been in a cardiac arrest in the OR. It's a very lonely place to be when the only person assisting you is the circulating nurse. I will proudly say right here, if I had a cardiac arrest on one of the many cardiac anesthetics I delivered, I would much rather have Mr. Juan Quintana assist me in resuscitating the patient than the circulating nurse. I want an extra set of well-trained hands, a strong brain who knows a lot. It improves safety and quality. If you can't get one of the three different categories of anesthesia providers to be your assistant, you better hope it's somebody with significant postgraduate education like a dentist or a podiatrist or the surgeon. They should be involved. I've had many surgeons assist me with airway management on lost airways. Sorry, but your time is up. Okay. Thanks for
Please identify yourself and who you represent. Mr. Chairman, thank you and members of the committee. I'm Billy Tarpley with the Arkansas State Dental Association. Mr. Chair, with your indulgence, I'd like to ask Dr. Jana Barfield to
that motion. It's not in the bed. So we have a motion for immediate consideration. All in favor? Signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed, nay. No. Ayes have it. Motion carries. What's the pleasure of the committee? I have a motion due pass by Representative Gonzalez. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing no discussion, Representative Johnson, you're recognized. Sorry, I'll keep it brief.
you know in looking at this statute to me i will concede that i think there's room to improve this statute what i don't think we're doing by changing the word coordination from supervision is improving it to me it's just confusing the issue i mean if the main point of this is to create a situation where we're creating less liability for providers to work with our crnas moving to a word that no Whether state uses where there's no statute to reflect what it means in a situation where everyone involved that there's a problem is going to be called to task. So just because you have the word coordination in there as opposed to supervision, I think that gives no real relief to any of the providers in the room for liability. I don't really see how this changes or improves our situation. Again, I think there's room for improvement. I just don't think this is the way to do it, and I think this just confuses the issue more. Just wanted to make those few brief comments before I
you, Mr. Chair. I'd just like to remind everybody that you do have a stack of letters from physicians and hospital administrators from all over the state that are asking for this language to be changed, specifically to coordination. We heard testimony on dental deaths in Texas as well. Well, there was not, as far as I know, there was not CRNA care involved in those deaths. It was deaths due to dental practices without the use of CRNA or anesthesiology because they have the ability to do that on their own. And that's when the deaths were caused. I think this is a good bill, good compromise.
I'd appreciate a yes vote. Thank you. Representative Brown, you're recognized. Representative Gonzalez covered it. Representative McGee. You're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Well, I looked at the stacks of the letters, and if you look through it real close, some of them came all from one group, all from one hospital or from one group of individuals. So I don't think this is the general consensus of all the physicians that practice in the state of Arkansas.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Any other discussion? Seeing none. The motion for the committee is due pass. All in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed nay. No. The ayes have it. Roll call. Roll call. Call the roll.
Thank you. Okay, members, we do have one other small bill that I'd like to run, take just a few minutes. It should be a quick bill. You'll bear with me just a second here. Representative Gassaway, bill number HB-1278, you're recognized to present your bill.
Please have your yes introduce yourself. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Scott Pace with Impact Management Group. We represent the National Association of Chain Drug Stores, which represents the large box pharmacies in Arkansas as well as half of the independent pharmacies in Arkansas.
Representative Gasway, you're recognized to present your bill. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Good afternoon, committee. I know it's late in the day, and so I want to be respectful of your time. as the chairman said I think this is a pretty simple bill this bill is intended to help move our state from the very bottom in the rankings of the nation of the rates of immunization for children ages 7 through 17 this bill will allow children ages 7 through 17 to be able to receive vaccinations at their local pharmacies so long as the pharmacy has a written working protocol with the doctor on file, which will increase access to vaccinations for those children. And so to just start out, to give you an idea of where we are in Arkansas compared to other states with regard to vaccination rates, the 2017 and 2018 CDC statistics with regard to school-age vaccinations are pretty shocking with respect to the state of affairs with Arkansas, Specifically with measles, mumps, and rubella, Arkansas has the lowest rate of all of our surrounding states at 91.9%. To put that in perspective, Mississippi, for example, has a 99.4%. We have a 91.9%. And with respect to measles, in order to prevent an outbreak, it's recommended that the vaccination level be at 95%. So we are dangerously low. diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis, which is whooping cough, Arkansas has the lowest rate of all of our surrounding states, 93.1%, which puts us in the bottom 10 in the country. Hepatitis B, Arkansas has the lowest rate of all of our surrounding states at 93.7%, Mississippi 99.4%. Polio, Arkansas, the lowest rate of all of our surrounding states, 91.3%, bottom 10 in the country. Mississippi, 99.4%. Varicella, which is chickenpox, Arkansas has the lowest rate of all the surrounding states at 91.6%. Mississippi, 99.4%. And the HPV vaccine, only 61% of kids received the first dose of this vaccine. Less than 35% complete the series, and this is the only vaccine in the world, of course, that's been proven to prevent cancer. These are very important issues that present themselves with regard to the public health of our state. And so the issue, one of the issues, of course, then is access. And so what this bill is designed to do is to increase that access. And where we are as a state, out of the 75 counties, there are 16 counties where there are zero physician practices that can administer these vaccines to children. and the only provider in the county who can give those vaccines currently would be the local health department. And so there are, of course, pharmacies around the state in some of the more rural areas of the state that may be the only health care provider there, and this will make it quicker, easier, and more efficient for parents to take their children and get them the vaccines that they need. again this is the exact same method that every other state that touches Arkansas permits for kids every other state that touches Arkansas allows for a working protocol but in Arkansas currently it requires a patient specific prescription and so this bill seeks to change that and the last thing that I would say is that many of us and and some of you who sit on this committee have been in areas of the state that have seen outbreaks of diseases that have been virtually dead for decades in the United States. And we're beginning to see, I know in northeast Arkansas, there were outbreaks in Perigold, Jonesboro, Walnut Ridge of hepatitis A. In northwest Arkansas, there have been outbreaks of hepatitis A. And just within the last week, many of you may have seen that there was a mumps outbreak in Northwest Arkansas at the University of Arkansas, which was chronicled in an international journal as being the second largest outbreak of mumps in the United States in the last 30 years. So we have a serious issue in Arkansas, and I think improving access can only help with that issue. And with that, I'm happy to entertain any questions. Of course, I have Scott Pace here who can help me, hopefully. So thank you. Representative Boyd, you're recognized
for a question. Dr. Pace, this question's for you, and maybe you covered it. Representative Gasway, I apologize if I didn't hear it. Is the federal government, is there a discussion about the federal government taking over the way we do immunizations because of the failure of states to immunize people
appropriately? Well, there was actually an article last week, Representative Boyd, in the national media about the head of the, I believe it was Food and Drug Administration, Dr. Gottlieb, saying that exact thing, that if the states didn't turn around their low vaccination rates, that the feds would be looking to put a federal solution in place. Can
I have one follow-up? Yes, you can. Are you aware of any other efforts that have been made, you know, with this legislature to help with this besides just expanding access via pharmacy? Well, I
can tell you that you have for the last two years been working with the Department of Human Services to address vaccination payment for physicians and for pharmacists and any other providers that administer vaccines to try to make sure that these rates have multiple different ways of getting up. Representative
Brown, you're recognized for a question. Thank you, Mr. Chair. You may or may not know, Mr. Gassaway, I don't think you were here at the time, but I filed a bill to eliminate the discretion parents have for just personal convictions against immunizations and was clobbered, the way we get clobbered, but very clobbered for even filing the bill. I didn't even get to run it. I think this is an extremely important issue. I think we have to do something. If we can't mandate it, then by providing access, do you have any numbers on other states who have simply increased access this way? Have they had a higher immunization rate? Well,
it's a multifactorial question, really. And so there are certainly access issues that come into play to the immunization rates going up, but there are also the exemptions that have been discussed at the federal level too. So there's not any studies that demonstrate that that one factor moves the needle any more than one other factor moving the needle. It's kind of the totality of all of the different activities moving the needle upward.
by saying that I'm in favor of this. I think this is a good policy change. My question is really just a point of clarification. I'm sorry I haven't gotten to you all earlier to ask the question. Under where it says general written protocol, who will be responsible for generating that protocol? And it in following says reporting to the administration of the prescribing physician. Help me understand that language and what that means for the physician.
Yep. So the protocols are actually physician controlled. This is how it's been with the adult vaccinations for 22 years in Arkansas. A physician for each individual location will decide what vaccines they're comfortable having under their name and what are the conditions that would allow them for age, et cetera. And so the other language would be reporting back to the statewide WebIZ database and to the primary care provider to make sure that the loop is closed is how that has worked in the adult population, and this language is intended to
mirror that. Okay. Thank you. Representative Brown, you're recognized. I'll be brief. I see that we're talking about immunizations in the more youthful phase of life. Is there anything in this that would prohibit or encourage adults to go ahead and get their immunizations? I know I got my boosters, so I want all the adults to know they need to be getting their boosters.
and I sort of have the same question I had about the smoking cessation and oral contraceptives. Other than the charge for the immunization, is there an administrative or consulting charge?
There generally is not at all in the vaccination world as it pertains to the kids or adults since 1997. Insurance coverage generally covers the totality of those immunizations and under the Affordable Care Act, most of these recommended vaccines are covered at $0 copay to the patient. So there's, just like at any place that they would get that, there's usually zero out of pocket. Can I ask a follow-up?
Yes, you can. And I know, you know, of course, always the pediatrician's concern is that the child won't come in for a visit and be seen. And sometimes when they come to get immunizations, it's their only time to be seen. what kind of protocol is typical in other states to assure that, you know, it's fine that they get their immunizations, but you also want to assure that they
get back to the pediatrician? Great question. And I talked with Dr. Chad Rogers about this earlier this morning. So two answers. First of all, we didn't push the age down below seven for the exact reason that you're talking about. There are four states around us that allow vaccinations at age zero for kids, And we thought that it was very important to be thoughtful about not disrupting that physician-patient relationship during those first seven years of life when those early vaccines are being given. And so those will still continue to be given as they have been in the primary care provider. And then there's a screening tool that we use in the pharmacies whenever people come in, adult vaccinations come in, to query have they been ill, what other concomitant conditions they have. And it's our anticipation that we will include on that when's the last time you've been to visit your primary care provider to make sure that there is a good mechanism for triaging back to the dot.
Chair. Just a motion at the proper time. Okay. Any other questions? No. Okay. Seeing none, we do have two people signed up to speak for this bill. We have nobody signed up to speak against
No, that's all right. We'll get you. We need to know the bill that's coming up. Oh, okay. Okay. Well, I tell you, you want to speak against the bill? You go ahead and go first then.
please identify yourself david roten with the medical society i'm sorry guys i know y'all are tired of seeing me today uh my objections are really procedural as much as anything else i've been asking mr pace for the last two days if this bill was going to come up and the answer i've been getting is no not yet i haven't talked to the sponsor we don't know We had, he mentioned Dr. Chad Rogers. Dr. Rogers was here this morning. So was Amy Olinghouse, the director of the Arkansas chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics. The pediatricians, unless something has changed during the day that Scott knows that I don't, are opposed to this bill. And they were here this morning thinking it would come up. They were told it wasn't going to come up, so obviously they're not here this afternoon. I would simply ask that you hold this bill to give them an opportunity to be here to share their concerns with you. And one of the things that I think you all ought to think about is if these are, this is coming from the Walmarts and the large Walgreens, the chain pharmacies. This is not coming from your local community pharmacist. And I would encourage you that if they are that concerned about public health, and they should be, that you limit this bill to those pharmacies that do not sell tobacco products. Now, that would be a blow for helping public health. And other than that, I would just ask that you hold this bill until they
Thank you, Mr. Chair, Chair, members of the committee. john vinson chief operating officer for the arkansas pharmacists association and we represent over 2500 pharmacists and student pharmacists in arkansas the pharmacists themselves across all practice settings including local smaller pharmacies as well as pharmacy pharmacists that work for the chain drug stores and retail grocery retail settings and i just would like to say that we are in support of this bill today and think it will be great you know to help provide more access there are certain counties like franklin county you know where i've had calls from pharmacists and even the local physician community that you know have challenges of delivering vaccines union county craighead county and we're in support and we'll be happy to take any questions any questions from the
since this morning we've all been here sir I was able to stick around and to be able to offer my testimony. My name is Eric Crumball. I'm a pharmacist and currently a director of clinical business development with ExpressRx Pharmacy. ExpressRx is a small, locally-owned drugstore with a total of eight locations, four here in Arkansas. Previously, I served as the executive director of the Arkansas Immunization Action Coalition, and prior to that was a community clinical pharmacist at Kroger. Throughout my practice as a pharmacist, I've been recommending and administering immunizations to protect my patients and the public from vaccine-preventable disease. Today I'm speaking in support of House Bill 1278, which would allow Arkansas pharmacists to administer immunizations pursuant to a protocol for people aged 7 to 17 years of age. Currently, Arkansas pharmacists can only provide flu immunizations pursuant to protocol for this age range of patients. For all other routine immunizations for people aged 7 to 17 years of age, pharmacists must get a patient-specific prescription from the pediatrician or primary care provider. A physician protocol or standing order allows a pharmacist to administer immunizations to patients who meet predetermined criteria that has been established by that prescriber. The protocol serves as a prescription and authorizes the pharmacist to give the immunization. These protocols are reviewed and re-signed by the physician annually per Arkansas State Board of Pharmacy regulations. Recently, our pharmacies have become providers in the Vaccines for Children program, or VFC. VFC is a federally funded program that provides vaccines to people under the age of 18 whose families are uninsured, underinsured, or cannot afford them. This program also funds all routine immunizations for children covered by Arkansas Medicaid. Last summer, we had a father come into our location on Cantrell to get his son a meningococcal immunization, which was required for school in the fall. The pharmacy determined that his son did need this vaccine and was eligible for the VFC program. We had the appropriate dose on hand. However, per the current age restrictions on immunization practices, our pharmacy needed a prescription from the provider for the recommended vaccination. We then called the child's primary care provider's office, who was not enrolled in the VFC program to get a verbal prescription, and were told no. The physician refused to authorize a prescription and instructed us to refer the patient to the local health unit. The father called the local health unit and was told there were not any immunization appointments available until after school started. If House Bill 1278 had been in place or there had not been any age restrictions and regulations last summer, our pharmacy would have been able to provide this patient and many more with their routine immunizations. Another area where House Bill 1278 could have positive impacts across Arkansas is in regards to uptake and series completion of the hemopapilloman virus vaccine, which prevents cervical and oral cancers. This vaccine prevents life-altering cancers that tend to be more prevalent in young adults in their 20s and 30s. In order for this vaccine to be most effective, the series must be completed in the teenage years. According to a 2016 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and Centers for Disease Control report, Arkansas joined Louisiana, Mississippi, and West Virginia as states with the highest rates for HPV-associated cancers. Most of these cancers can be prevented by the HPV vaccination. However, only about 35% of Arkansas youths have completed this series. Recently, our state has made vast improvements in uptake of this vaccine. However, the state has a lot of work to do to meet the healthy people goal of 80%. When I further examined our pharmacy records of the last 10 adolescents who received the flu vaccination at one of our stores, we found that seven of the ten needed at least one dose of HPV vaccination, according to the Arkansas Immunization Information System, or WebIZ. The Centers for Disease Control and the American Association of Pediatrics recommends simultaneously administering all vaccines for which a person is eligible at the time of a visit. If HB1278 had been in place last flu season, our pharmacy would have been able to recommend and administer the appropriate HPV and other recommended vaccines to these patients. In order to ensure a patient is receiving the highest quality care, our pharmacy has several standards in place. First, we assess vaccination status of all patients receiving immunizations and recommend any additional needed immunizations. Second, all of our patients, regardless of age, are asked if they have a primary care provider and if they are up-to-date on their wellness appointments. Lastly, in an effort to improve continuity of care and prevent duplication of immunizations, ExpressRx reports all doses administered to the state's immunization information system called WebIZ. Currently, Arkansas law requires that any immunization given to a person less than 22 years of age must be reported to the state immunization information system. Many Arkansas health care providers have access to this registry and some of the large health systems' electronic health records are integrated with this registry. Therefore, once immunization doses are reported to the registry, the patient's health care providers can see what was administered by other providers, such as pharmacies, and can update their records. Even though the law only requires immunizations to children, adolescents, and young adults, our pharmacy currently reports all vaccination doses administered at their location, regardless of the patient's age to WebIZ. Regardless of new legislation, our pharmacy plans to continue to pay for this service because it is considered a best practice per the CDC and other advisory bodies. Also, we want all health care providers to be up to date on what immunizations and services our pharmacy has provided for their patients. In conclusion, pharmacists have been serving as an easily accessible and convenient location for Arkansans to receive flu and other adult routine immunizations for the past 20 plus years. Currently immunization services are incorporated into the daily routine of most community pharmacies. Arkansas continues to be at risk for vaccine preventable diseases which is evident by recent outbreaks of mumps and measles. House Bill 1278 would remove any age restrictions on pharmacist-administered immunizations and allow for more of our most vulnerable population, children and adolescents, to be protected from these diseases and even cancers. Immunizations continue to be one of the greatest advancements in medicine. Please vote for House Bill 1278 to improve access to immunizations and to protect public health in Arkansas. Thank you for allowing me to speak.
Representative Payton, did you have a question? Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair. So what type of parental consent is going to be required if they're coming into a pharmacy, and are we going to require any
identification to know that this is the parent? So that's a great question. Currently, if we have a child who comes in to get a flu shot, But most of the time that patient is known, so we know that patient or they've been to our pharmacy before and have filled prescriptions before. And so a lot of times we don't ask for any proof of parentship or anything like that. But with other immunizations or any other service that we would offer in our pharmacy, Obviously, we would follow whatever guidelines, regulations are in place for other health care providers, such as pediatricians. You recognize for a follow-up. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
So, I mean, you recognize that other pharmacies other than your own is going to be authorized to do this. And is there any standard protocol, or does the language in the code or in this bill require any type of parental consent or identification before a 16- or a 15-year-old walks
in and gets these immunizations? So, you know, the question of parental consent is one that's not specifically laid out or mentioned in the bill or in any of the protocols that are established. I think for my practice, for my pharmacy, we follow what other local health care providers, whatever burden of proof that is met for them to be able to provide care for a patient consent. I'm just not sure Walgreens and
close for your bill? Hey, Mr. Chair, thank you. Again, I just want to say that every other state that borders Arkansas has this type of model in place that allows immunizations to be given by pharmacists under a written working protocol with a doctor. And as I stated with those statistics earlier, we are lower than every other state with regard to the diseases that were once dead or nearly dead and the immunization rates of our children. This is a very serious issue, and increasing access can only help. And with that, I would ask for a good vote. Thank you. What's the will
of the committee? Representative Brown, you're recognized. Motion due passed. I have a motion due passed by Representative Brown. Any discussion on the motion? Representative Gray,
you're recognized. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I'm for this bill. I'll just preface that with that. I think Representative Payton brings up a very good point in that, like in physicians' offices, you have to have a parent or legal guardian there unless you're 18, until you reach the age of 18. So in order for, I would like to see this amended. I don't know if you'd be amenable to that. Just to add that piece. on the Senate side, I would trust you to do that if that's something you were willing to look at. I would like to vote yes for it. I kind of need that
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Colleagues, we've all been here a long time. It's been a long day. It's been a long week. and I fully support this bill. One thing I would like to add very briefly is I don't believe that this committee needs somebody who represents some other association to come to the table complaining about our process and how we go about doing our business. We handle our business the way we handle our business. We don't go to them and tell them how to handle theirs.
other discussion Representative Payton thank you Mr. Chair members I'm going to vote yes based on the assumption that we will put some protocol in there to require parental
consent thank you any further discussion seeing none the motion that we're considering is do pass all in favor signify by saying aye aye all opposed nay motion carries congratulations representative your bill has passed thank you Mr. Chairman thank you committee committee before you leave committee before you leave it's been a long day and I want to thank you all for coming back we had 100% show up that is saying something it showed your commitment that is really good and I appreciate very much what you've done today it's been some good work so we are adjourned
HB1263 Eaves TO AUTHORIZE A PHARMACIST TO INITIATE THERAPY AND ADMINISTER OR DISPENSE, OR BOTH, CERTAIN TYPES OF TOBACCO CESSATION; TO AUTHORIZE A PHYSICIAN TO ADMINISTER OR DISPENSE, OR BOTH, CERTAIN TYPES OF TOBACCO CESSATION.
HB1290 Pilkington TO AMEND THE PROVISIONS OF THE ARKANSAS CODE CONCERNING THE PRACTICE OF PHARMACY; AND TO AUTHORIZE PHARMACISTS TO PROVIDE ACCESS TO AND ADMINISTRATION OF ORAL CONTRACEPTIVES.
SB184 G.Stubblefield TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHETISTS BY REMOVING SUPERVISION REQUIREMENTS.
The committee first adopted a motion to limit debate to two minutes per speaker (which passed), later reversed it back to five minutes, and ultimately voted the bill down, resulting in its failure.
[18:46][18:50][18:54][18:58][19:03][22:25][22:47][23:01][52:27]
HB1433 Rushing TO AUTHORIZE INDIVIDUALS WITH PRIOR DRUG-RELATED OFFENSES TO WORK WITH INDIVIDUALS RECEIVING SUBSTANCE ABUSE TREATMENT AS PEER SUPPORT SPECIALISTS OR SIMILAR POSITIONS; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1451 A. Collins TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING THE SUPPLEMENTAL NUTRITION ASSISTANCE PROGRAM; AND TO EXCLUDE CHILD SUPPORT PAYMENTS FROM GROSS INCOME USED FOR ELIGIBILITY DETERMINATION.
HB1471 C. Fite TO CREATE THE MENTAL HEALTH FOR INDIVIDUALS WHO ARE DEAF OR HARD OF HEARING BILL OF RIGHTS ACT.
HB1473 J. Mayberry TO REQUIRE HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS OF MAMMOGRAPHY SERVICES TO NOTIFY AND INFORM PATIENTS ABOUT BREAST DENSITY.
HB1484 Watson TO CLARIFY THE PROCEDURE FOR DISPOSITION OF UNCLAIMED BODIES IN TH ESTATE OF ARKANSAS.
SB172 G. Leding TO AMEND THE LAWS REGARDING SOCIAL WORK LICENSING; TO CLARIFY
THE LICENSING EXEMPTION FOR STUDENTS; AND TO CHANGE THE TERM "RECIPROCITY" TO "ENDORSEMENT".
Notice: Silence your cell phones. Keep your personal conversations to a minimum. Observe restrictionsdesignating areas as 'Members and Staff Only'.
SB273 Bledsoe TO CLARIFY THAT AN EXPERT WITNESS ACTING ON BEHALF OF A BOARD OF ANY PROFESSION OR OCCUPATION CLASSIFIED UNDER THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF ARKANSAS AS A PROFESSION OF THE HEALING ARTS HAS IMMUNITY; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
SB301 K. Hammer TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING CRIMINAL BACKGROUND CHECKS FOR NURSING LICENSURE.
HB1060 Lynch TO ESTABLISH AND REQUIRE CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR HEATING, VENTILATION, AIR CONDITIONING, AND REFRIGERATION LICENSEES.
HB1536 D. Douglas TO CREATE THE COMPASSIONATE CARE END-OF-LIFE OPTION ACT; AND TO EXEMPT THE COMPASSIONATE CARE END-OF-LIFE OPTION ACT FROM THE DEFINITION OF"PHYSICIAN-ASSISTED SUICIDE".
HB1527 Cozart TO CREATE THE RED TAPE REDUCTION SUNRISE AND SUNSET ACT OF 2019; AND TO REQUIRE LEGISLATIVE REVIEW OF OCCUPATIONAL AUTHORIZATIONS AND OCCUPATIONAL ENTITIES.
HB1547 Perry TO ENSURE THAT PERSONS LICENSED TO PROVIDE EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES OR ADVANCED LIFE SUPPORT RESCUE SERVICES MAINTAIN CONTINUAL NATIONAL EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES CERTIFICATION.
SB275 Bledsoe TO CLARIFY LAW REGARDING OUT-OF-STATE PHYSICIANS WHO PRACTICE PATIENT CARE SERVICES INITIATED IN THIS STATE THROUGH THE USE OF ANY MEDIUM.
SB340 Irvin TO AMEND LAWS CONCERNING CONSENT TO MEDICAL TREATMENT TO AUTHORIZE A LIAISON UNDER THE FEDERAL MCKINNEY-VENTO HOMELESS ASSISTANCE ACT TO CONSENT TO MEDICAL TREATMENT FOR A HOMELESS MINOR; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1555 A. Collins TO INCREASE COVERAGE FOR MEDICATIONS APPROVED BY THE UNITED STATES FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION FOR TOBACCO CESSATION IN THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM.
HB1435 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO REIMBURSE FOR RIDESHARING APPLICATIONS.
SB380 G. Leding TO MODIFY COVERAGE FOR SCREENING MAMMOGRAPHY AND BREASTULTR A SOUND FOR THE DIAGNOSIS OF BREAST DISEASE SUCH AS CANCER AND FOR THE EVALUATION OF DENSE BREAST TISSUE AS AN ESSENTIAL HEALTH BENEFIT.
HB1568 L. Johnson TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ADVISORY COUNCIL OF HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONS WITHIN THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH.
HB1572 Ladyman TO AMEND THE LAW CONCERNING STATE AGENCY CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT CONTRACTS FOR PURPOSES OF UNIFORMITY.
SB298 K. Hammer TO AMEND THE TAXABLE WAGE BASE UNDER THE DEPARTMENT OF WORKFORCE SERVICES LAW.
HB1164 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE A PHARMACIST TO DISPENSE ORAL CONTRACEPTIVES WITHOUT A PRESCRIPTION.
HB1252 Magie TO ESTABLISH THE ARKANSAS ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANT ACT; AND TO PROVIDE FOR LICENSURE OF ANESTHESIOLOGIST ASSISTANTS.
HB1253 Magie TO AUTHORIZE A LICENSED DISPENSING OPTICIAN TO REFRACT EYES AND DISPENSE EYEGLASSES IN CERTAIN CONDITIONS.
HB1284 Gonzales TO AUTHORIZE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM TO RECOGNIZE AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE AS A PRIMARY CARE PROVIDER.
HB1265 M. Gray TO AUTHORIZE FULL INDEPENDENT PRACTICE AUTHORITY TO ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSES WHO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS.
HB1274 Pilkington TO AUTHORIZE AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE WHO HAS SERVED A RURAL COMMUNITY TO PRACTICE WITHOUT A COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT.
HB1278 Gazaway TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF PHARMACY" TO ALLOW VACCINES AND IMMUNIZATIONS TO BE GIVEN TO A PERSON FROM SEVEN (7) YEARS OF AGE TO EIGHTEEN (18) YEARS OF AGE UNDER A GENERAL WRITTEN PROTOCOL.
54:25 - 1:22:1884 segments17 speakers
Representative Jimmy Gazaway opened the hearing by outlining Arkansas’s alarmingly low childhood vaccination rates-citing CDC data that the state trails neighboring states on measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, pertussis, hepatitis B, polio, varicella and HPV coverage-and explained that HB 1278 would expand pharmacist access in the 16 counties lacking any physician-provided immunizations, thereby addressing recent outbreaks of hepatitis A, mumps and other vaccine-preventable diseases.
[54:41][55:15][55:47][56:21][56:55][57:26][57:59]
Committee members questioned the bill’s context and mechanics, including possible federal action on low rates (Rep. Boyd to Scott Pace), how a “general written protocol” would be created and reported (Rep. Johnson and Pace), whether any additional fees would apply (Rep. Ferguson and Pace), and concerns about parental consent for minors (Rep. Gray and subsequent discussion); Pace clarified that protocols remain physician-controlled, doses are reported to the statewide WebIZ system, and vaccines are generally covered with no extra charge.
[58:42][58:59][59:03][59:20][59:31][59:36][1:01:23][1:01:50][1:02:24][1:02:36][1:03:21][1:03:32][1:03:57][1:04:05][1:04:20][1:04:42][1:05:13]
HB1254 Magie TO MODIFY THE DEFINITION OF "OPHTHALMIC DISPENSING" TO INCLUDE THE PREPARATION AND DISPENSING OF CONTACT LENSES.
HB1251 Eubanks TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF OPTOMETRY"; TO EXPAND THE TYPES OF OPHTHALMIC SURGERY THAT MAY BE PERFORMED BY OPTOMETRISTS; AND TO MODERNIZE THE PRACTICE OF OPTOMETRY.
HB1220 Sullivan TO AMEND THE TELEMEDICINE ACT; TO ENSURE THAT TELEMEDICINE IS THE LEAST RESTRICTIVE METHOD TO DELIVER HEALTHCARE SERVICES REMOTELY; AND TO EXPAND THE DEFINITION OF "PROFESSIONAL RELATIONSHIP".
HB1282 Lundstrum TO REMOVE THE REQUIREMENT FOR A MANDATORY COLLABORATIVE PRACTICE AGREEMENT FOR AN ADVANCED PRACTICE REGISTERED NURSE TO HAVE PRESCRIPTIVE AUTHORITY.
HB1283 Gonzales TO AMEND THE DEFINITION OF "PRACTICE OF CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHESIA"; TO CLARIFY THE SCOPE OF PRACTICE OF A CERTIFIED REGISTERED NURSE ANESTHETIST; AND TO REMOVE SUPERVISION REQUIREMENTS.
HB1226 M. Gray CONCERNING THE PURSUIT OF A NATIONAL CANCER INSTITUTE-DESIGNATED CANCER CENTER AT THE WINTHROP P. ROCKEFELLER CANCER INSTITUTE AT THE UNIVERSITY OF ARKANSAS FOR MEDICAL SCIENCES.
HB1281 Ladyman TO AMEND AND UPDATE THE LAWS REGARDING TREATMENT FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES; AND TO ENSURE RESPECTFUL LANGUAGE IS USED REGARDING INDIVIDUALS WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES.
HB1257 Boyd TO AUTHORIZE AND CLARIFY THE METHOD OF RELEASING CLAIMS AND ENROLLMENT DATA BY HEALTH INSURERS THAT PROVIDE HEALTHCARE COVERAGE TO ELIGIBLE INDIVIDUALS IN THE ARKANSAS WORKS PROGRAM.
HB1323 D. Douglas TO REQUIRE THE OFFICE OF LONG-TERM CARE NOT TO ADOPT RULES OR STANDARDS THAT ARE STRICTER THAN THE FEDERAL MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR CERTIFIED NURSING AIDES OR ASSISTANTS AND
HB1334 Maddox TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED UNDER THE ASSISTED LIVING PROGRAM; TO REMOVE A LIMITATION ON THE NUMBER OF PERSONS SERVED AT A TIME IN THE ASSISTED LIVING PROGRAM; AND TO DECLARE AN EMERGENCY.
HB1232 Lowery TO AMEND THE LAW REGARDING AUTHORIZED PAYROLL DEDUCTIONS OF UNION DUES FOR PUBLIC EMPLOYEES TO ALLOW DEDUCTIONS ONLY FOR FIREFIGHTERS, POLICE OFFICERS, AND EMERGENCY FIRST RESPONDERS; AND TO PROHIBIT DEDUCTIONS FOR TEACHERS.
HB1102 Sullivan TO ADDRESS THE UNDERSERVED STATUS OF A COUNTY AS A REQUIREMENT FOR LICENSURE AND CERTIFICATION OF CERTAIN PROVIDERS.
HB1528 Womack TO INCREASE THE ARKANSAS MEDICAID PROGRAM BENEFIT LIMIT FOR DRUG TESTING AND X-RAYS.
SB342 J. Cooper TO AMEND THE LAWS CONCERNING THE CONTRACTORS LICENSING BOARD; AND TO AMEND THE LICENSING REQUIREMENTS OF CONTRACTORS.